Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Len Rogers — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 13:40:33 GMT

I agree Michael was robbed! Why Jason is still there amazes me. Guess the popularity driven voters of young-young teens explains it all. The only reason I can find for the under-performing Jason to still be there. I think Michael will do well, and maybe was even done a afvor with the vote-off.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Chip — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 13:51:35 GMT

Whynatte? I was a little skeptical, but I just checked out their website. I can see why Michael is a fan - it looks like a fun time, and Michael seems like a fun guy. Good to see that he's supporting the friends of his back home!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Lori — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 14:16:13 GMT

I agree--Michael Johns should not have been voted off this soon--although I don't think he would've made first place, but he is definately in the top 5 contestants this year! I can't understand why Kristy Lee Cook and Brooke White and Jason Castro are still there since their performances are mediocre at best, yet Ramielle was voted off, which is very sad because she has a wonderful bluesy/R&B voice and she should've been in the top 6.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Audrey MAtis Elk Rive, Mn — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 15:10:37 GMT

Michael Johns was robbed, there is no way he should of been voted off before a few others that come to mind, Kristi Lee, Brooke etc. He was robbed big time.I was sad to see him go.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Julie, Rochester, Illinois — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 15:13:26 GMT

Kristi Lee Cook - a no talent. Short sweet and to the point, he was robbed.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Ben, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 15:18:43 GMT

I don't think he should have been voted off before a few other choice contestants (why are you still here kristy lee!?!?), but he was inconsistent. Great performances like his Dolly Parton number were followed by less than stellar peices like his Day In The Life cover, or his Queen medley from last week. In the end, he was only ousted a week, maybe two early.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Maria C., NYC — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 15:22:39 GMT

I would like to comment on the awful way Ryan Seacrest gave Michael Johns the boot last week. He started off by saying that last year after "Idol Gives Back", no one was voted off. He then proceeded to tell him he was leaving. Why even mention last year if it wasn't going to follow suit? I think it was terrible. Shame on you.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Audrey Elk River, Mn — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 15:34:01 GMT

Michael Johns was robbed, there is no way he should of been voted off this early especially before a few others that come to mind such as Kristi Lee, Brooke, Jason etc. I was sad to see him go. he will get some offers I am sure of.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

E. PEREZ SA TX — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 15:36:56 GMT

ABSOLUTELY, MICHAEL JOHNS WAS ROBBED BIG TIME!!
MAKES ME NOT WANT TO WATCH THE SHOW ANYMORE!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Cristal Taylor, Paris KY — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 15:37:48 GMT

I hated to see him go, actually I think he was the best one. Just like Chris Daughtry was the best in my opinion as well. I love Chris's songs!!!!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Star, Silverdale, Washington — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 15:41:31 GMT

I don't even want to watch the show after Michael Johns being voted off. He should have ended up in the top 2. There are too many left with far less talent. Plus he has the most charisma. He will do well though and I look forward to that.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Iris Wadkins Garden City MI — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 15:48:03 GMT

With Michael Johns voted off the show and given the boot so unmercifully, you have lost a viewer...

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Cali Peach — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 15:50:31 GMT

Gone, but NOT forgotten. There's no question he has a promising career ahead of him if he wants it.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Rose Baumgardner, Latrobe, PA — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 16:16:45 GMT

Jason and David Cook should've gone long before Michael. I can't believe that they booted him off when he should've stayed until the end. I'm sure some record company will believe in his incredible talent and sign him up quickly.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Phyllis Stephenson — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 16:18:18 GMT

What are these people thinking, (probably not thinking). Time for Kristy Lee & Jason to hit the road. Michael Johns will be missed.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Joe Schmie, San Diego, CA — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 16:31:43 GMT

This just goes to show that allowing people to vote 'Chicago Style' (early and often) will bring poor results every time. As Simon alluded to on an earlier episode if Idol is a 'talent contest rather than a popularity contest' then Michael, David Archuletta and Cook are the front runners along with Kylie. But since the people who can text the fastest get the most votes in, it's anyone's guess who will win. How else do you explain Chris Daughtry getting booted last year? And why don't the producers make the actual results public? Why ins this age of information technology cant they limit the votes to 1 per text id and one per ip address. At least that would limit viral voting!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Jackie, Boise ID — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 16:34:08 GMT

I have to say that Ryan Seacrest should have been kicked off for how he handled that elimination. Michael was in my top 3. I agree with the other comments in relation to Daughtry...Michael will be another Chris. We will miss you!!!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Donna, Anderson SC — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 16:55:30 GMT

I know a whole week has gone by since Michael Johns was voted off - I am still very disappointed that he will no longer be competing...he should be. I have to agree with other bloggers - Ryan handled the announcement all wrong. Not only did he mislead Michael into thinking he might be staying - he disappointed everyone watching! Not too cool - Ryan!!!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

jeannie hedges — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 16:59:16 GMT

I am so sad about Michael Johns leaving. Hw is very talented and seems like a really sweet guy. I am looking forward to the day when his CD comes out.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Medford, Oregon — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:01:42 GMT

I was very sad to see Michael go. I figured he would have been one of the top two. He always seemed to have more class and charisma than the others, and I loved the way he sang. I don't think the show is going to be as exciting to watch. I usually look forward to Tuesday night, but I'm not sure if I'm even going to watch it tonight.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Deb, Pittsburgh, PA — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:04:03 GMT

You all sound like you are blaming the show. Have you forgotten that the FANS voted him off????

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Diane Porter, Godfrey, IL — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:08:06 GMT

I agree 100%- Michael should have been in the top 3. I won't watch it anymore because I don't like the contestants that are remaining. They need to change the program to be a real talent program and not a popularity contest. They should have judges not voters calling in. And the pit with the little girls screaming.....what a joke. If David Archuleta or Brooke wins I definately won't ever watch the program again.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Mike, Fort Wayne Indiana — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:11:32 GMT

American Idol is the only show I watch as I am a small business owner with kids and have a very busy schedule. I still find time to put in my 1-10 votes for Michael. I watched the show and loved "Dream On". I was busy the night after and did not get to vote. If you are listening Michael, I hope you can forgive me, I wish you the best of luck. Everything happens for a reason, and with the outpouring of attention maybe this is better than getting 2nd-7th place! Start now!!!!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Amy, Coeur d alene, ID — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:11:52 GMT

I have to agree that Michael Johns was robbed. That was horrible, I have to say it is time to see Kristy Lee go or Brooke White go. I wasn't a big fan of Michael Johns but he still should have stayed a little longer. As for Seacrest they way he put it say they didn't vote anyone off last year but this year we say good bye was BULLS***. That was cruel and mean

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Marcyne, New Castle, PA — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:12:15 GMT

Michael was robbed. Jason needs to go. Ryan literally kicked him in the stomach. I don't know how he sleeps at night. Good luck Michael! I will buy your cd.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Beth, Madison — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:38:39 GMT

Michael had a great voice, but a penchant for picking boring songs and some annoying mannerisms. I honestly was not at all surprised to see him go after giving another forgettable performance. He's like Carly -- talent, but no "it" factor. Doesn't matter, really. This year's idol will be named David.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Judy Johnson, Elizabeth City, North Carolina — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:39:19 GMT

I love the way Kristy Lee Cook sings. Everyone has an opinion and everyone likes a different kind of music. That's what makes the world go around. As long as little children and young groupies are allowed to vote, you will see great talent booted off for no good explaination.
PS I loved the opening song. We should always Praise the Lord!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Mel L. Fargo — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:46:45 GMT

HE wasn't robbed. We just didn't vote for him. Who should you blame? Every one of the top ten have the potential to be great on their own. Don't Sas Kristy Lee she did a good job. I don't think he would have lasted more than 2 more weeks anyway. This week the bottom three will be Kristi, Jason, and Brooke. I won't see any surprises until we get to the top 4.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Jan, Somerset, NJ — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:54:23 GMT

Although David Archuleta has a wonderful voice and is obviously a very talented musician, why has no one ever mentioned his rather obvious speech impediment (than sounds horrible, but I'm not being rude - just honest)? He does no form the letter "s" properly, and it just grates on my nerves. With a little bit of speech therapy, this could be corrected so easily. I had the same problem when I was in school, and although it wasn't a "lisp" they still caught that I wasn't saying it properly. Problem fixed in a few weeks. Perhaps why I may be more sensitive to this issue than the public in general. Otherwise, talented but I don't think ready to be the #1 pick.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

chrystie,wichita,kansas — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:55:47 GMT

i also believe michael was robbed. he was my favorite on the show and he's so cute. i was stunned when i saw him get dumped by idol. i have a feeling he will make a career of singing. he has a wonderful singing voice and love his accent.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Nellie, New York, NY — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:58:54 GMT

Michael, I am really disappointed I would not get to hear you this week (and many weeks to come)!! I can not wait for your CD!!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Kathy Charleston, SC — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:03:35 GMT

I think Michael Johns is an awesome singer and I would definitely buy his cd! I also agree he was robbed, but I believe he is going on to bigger & definitely better things. Ryan Secrest has become so arrogant, and the way Michael was dismissed was just very tacky! Real classy, Secrest!! I'm not sure I care to watch anymore!!!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Edgar, Los Angeles, California — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:17:04 GMT

Michael was robbed by the powers that be at American Idol. With all the talks - wrong choice of song, not be a rocker cause David is already a rocker - these are all from the powers behind American Idol. Fans will be fans. It does not matter to them whether he picked up the wrong song, whether it is inspirational or not, whether there is already a rocker. Fans will not shift their vote to another contender until their idol is booted off. I am sure American Idol booted Michael out, not the fans. He should have stayed at least the top 4 or 5. Why is Kristy still there? Is her flirting with Simon working? Why is Jason still there? He has a nice voice but he looks so flat on TV. He is just young and goodlooking. Why is Syesha still there? I believe that Kristy Lee Cook, Syesha, Carly Smithson and Jason should have gone first before Michael.

American Idol is very unfair. I am sure there will be a lot of people not watching AI after this.

Why can't American Idol have an independent accounting firm count the votes and make it public? With all the commercials, they have the means.

It is time for American Idol to be fair. Let the people decide who should be American Idol and not who the American Idol powers.

American Idol sucks and so is Ryan Seacrest.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Joe Detroit — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:25:06 GMT

I for one am not sad Michael is gone.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Mary, Everett, WA — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:27:03 GMT

Many posts seem to blame American Idol for the unfair results for Michael Johns - remember, it is the viewers who are the voting (or not voting). I felt the same shock as we all saw on Paula's face. I know we will hear from MJ in the near future.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Dawn, Mpls, MN — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:28:40 GMT

I really hope American Idol says something about how Michael Johns was treated last week. I was so sad about him leaving but know that this was just a stepping stone for him. Can't wait for his 1st CD---Ryan please give Michael an apology, publically

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

D. Tracy, Clifton, Arizona — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:31:33 GMT

I was sure hoping to hear Michael sing something like "Mustang Sally" or "Dark End Of The Street". Perhaps he will consider making an album with some of those songs...soon!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Brit, Knoxville, TN — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:41:37 GMT

I put in 7 votes for Michael Johns the night he sang Dream On but I guess I should have voted more! I will buy his CD (and David Cook's) before I buy anyone else's on this season of American Idol. I agree with what everyone is saying about Ryan, but I would also like to direct this towards Simon. He gave Michael a hard time and kept saying he didn't know why Micheal chose Dream On as an inspirational song. Simon was still talking about it when Micheal was in the bottom 3 on wednesday. Sometimes Simon forgets that some people in America do not make their own decisions and actually listens to what he says! (Shame on you both!). Who is Simon to say what song does and does not inspire Micheal Johns, then to go on and say he was impersonating Aerosmith. Well if he was, then he should get props for his excellent performance! I felt like Micheal Johns, David Cook, and Carly Smithson should have been the top 3 this season. I am terrible shocked and upset that Micheal Johns was eliminated so early but at least he has a lead now on getting his CD (that i know he will get on offer to do) out before the other idols who get kicked off!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Cindy North Branch, Michigan — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:44:03 GMT

Nice job Michael. We will being seeing more of your talent.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Medford, Oregon — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:55:23 GMT

It may be the public who votes, but I for one think the way the public gets to vote is not fair. I am not going to stay up for two hours and put in thousands of votes. I put in about five votes for my favorite, but then I go to bed because I have to work the next day. It's too bad they can't figure out a way to let people only vote a few times, like Dancing with the Stars does or other shows that get voted on. It doesn't seem fair when someone can text message and call in votes as many times as they like. Some people have lives and don't have the time to put in vote after vote after vote. I find it frustrating and think it would be much fairer if they had a different voting system. I do enjoy AI, but am getting to the point that I am not going to vote, because my one or two measly little votes can't even compete when there are all these kids and others who will vote millions of times. It just seems there should be a better and more fairer way. More people would probably vote if they knew they could vote for that person five times and that was it.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Carlile, Dulcie — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:59:25 GMT

After Michael Johns was voted off, I just turned off the TV. I get so tired of America voting off some of the best and keeping on those that aren't so good. I'm sorry Michael. You deserved to be there until at least the top 4. Hope you do well. You deserve to.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

James, Houston — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 19:12:21 GMT

So sad MJ is gone. What a shocker. Like others, I had him pegged as a top 5 finalist, but probably not the winner. Just checked out this Whynatte thing. Pretty cool site. Whoever writes the posts is hilarious.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Andrea — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 19:14:22 GMT

This is the first time I ever watched American Idol. Michael Johns was my first choice from the beginning and made me watch the show. I was deeply shocked and angry that he was voted off. I couldn't even sleep that night. It is completely unfair, and makes absolutely no sense. I also think Ryan Seacrest was incredibly rude and disgusting when he announced that last season, they decided not to have an elimination...., but this season, Michael Johns was leaving. For a second, it gave Michael false hope and all his fans false hope. That was totally uncalled for. Everyone on this show wants to do their best and for Ryan Seacrest to play with a person's emotions and dreams is mean-spirited and cruel. Ryan has his high paying job and seems to have lost his sense of compassion for others who are trying to earn their dream under the scrutiny of a TV audience judging their every move. He should be eliminated off the show! Michael, I will buy every one of your CD's because you are an awesome talent!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Ben, Houston TX — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 19:19:59 GMT

Phenomenal interview. I have also wondered about the t-shirt from that idol episode, and my questions were finally answered. After checking out the website, I have purchased several t-shirts and plan to speak at local Houston civic gathering about the virtues of the whynatte. I can only imagine how delicious a whynatte would go down while watching a late season fantasy basketball collapse of epic proportions.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

michaelene gon, westerville,oihio — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 19:35:24 GMT

the voting method is a travesty.

The "babies" vote a jazillion times. MUST be limited in number by each voter.....and judge scores must count also....as with Dancing with the Stars.

There is no super star quality in any of those remaining.

Archuleta has been pre-chosen as the winner by AI. Yes, he does have that speech immpediment....and is not built "normally" either. I am no longer interested in Idol, since they have so arrogantly neglected to "cover" their tracks.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

JudyK. Atlanta Ga — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 20:22:41 GMT

Michael Johns and WHYNATTE are a great team!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Debbie, Concord, NC — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 20:38:31 GMT

I am still so shocked about Michael leaving that I'm not even looking forward to watching AI tonight--and that's a first for me, for I have loved this show since day one! This season, Michael was the one I found myself looking so forward to his preformance. Why Jason is still there is a joke. What bothers me is Simon, for some odd reason, wanting him off the show and Ryan could'nt have been more heartless. I read that Michael was to be eliminated that week and the tiny-bopper Acheletta was going to win. And sure enough, Michael was eliminated. Wow, why do we vote if it's all decided upon? It now isn't much to look forward to if that's the case. The best talent was between Michael, David Cook and Carly. I'm finding it very hard to believe that Michael was "voted off" and am hoping they do bring back the "wild card", or whatever it is, so Michael will be back where he belongs. Between Simon's remarks to the public and Ryan, especially Ryan's coldness---this is absolutely shameful!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

C J, Illinois — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 20:48:34 GMT

What a shocker! I would have bought one of Michael's CDs as I really liked his style and loved listening to him sing. AI is really going down hill. I only started watching AI because my wife likes it but now we are both turned off by Ryan's rudeness every week and the way it has turned out to be more of a popularity contest with the "kids". Too bad a good thing has gone bad. Good luck to you Michael....we will be watching for your CD and you can count on us to buy it!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Rosie Hernandez, Burbank, CA. — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 20:55:40 GMT

UNFORTUNATELY, I DIDN'T GET TO SEE AMERICAN IDOL WHEN MICHAEL JOHNS LEFT. WHEN I FOUND OUT, I MADE THE DECISION NOT TO WATCH AMERICAN IDOL AGAIN!!! IT MAKES NO SENSE WITHOUT MICHAEL JOHNS. HE WAS DEFINITELY THE BEST, BY FAR. WHAT IS JASON STILL DOING IN THE COMPETITION, ANYWAY?

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Tom, Chicago, IL — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 21:15:49 GMT

It was another mistake by Idol - not the voters, but Idol itself. Insiders have already said the Clay Akon actually beat Ruben. It was a technical error, but Idol naturally didn't admit it. If you recall, Clay was up 4 to 1 over Ruben the previous week, but "lost." Michael, I imagine is in the same boat. But, it may be better for him anyway.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Vickie, MN — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 21:17:26 GMT

All you people can complain that MJ got booted off to early, but isn't it left up to us to vote to keep him in????

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Janice Vanderpool, Castle Rock, Colorado — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 21:38:11 GMT

I think Michael Johns is awesome, and thank you to the Today Show for having him on. I wish he would have sang for us, though. I am so dissapointed with AI for the way Ryan Seacrest treated Michael. This was the first season I really had a favorite and now he is off the show. I did vote but obviously not enough to make a difference. I have pre-recorded all Ellen Degeneres shows so I don't miss his performance. Unfortunate for AI because Michael Johns was the whole package. Can't wait to buy his CDs.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Jane, Brantford Canada — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 21:39:18 GMT

and here is the thing with Chicago style voting, whether or not you think AI is manipulating the votes

just because David A has for example 10 million votes and David C has 5 million votes doesn't necessarily mean David A is going to sell more records than David C if David A's fans are voting thousands of times in the voting period and David C fans are voting once or 10 or 100 times, one fan may be able to vote 2000 times but they can only buy one CD and one concert ticket, now when you have the AI machine behind you as the winner, you can reach the non AI audience and I suppose that AI fans will buy the winner's album or clearly a good portion of them do even if that person was not their favourite and with the Idol tour featuring the Top 10, you get the fans for all Top 10 contestants buying concert tickets anyway.

I confess however never having bought the album of an AI winner or a Canadian Idol winner, though I do like Kelly Clarkson and thought about getting her album once and I've seen Daughtry in concert with Nickelback and I was more interested in seeing Daughtry but I will buy Michael John's album regardless and maybe David Cook as it stands and I might even buy a Hedley album, the lead singer, Jacob Hoggard, who was a Canadian Idol runner up and told his fans to vote him out on purpose before the finale, he is already stacking up to be the most successful Canadian Idol contestant of all.........

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

KC HANSEN, SPOAKNE WASHINGTON — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 21:42:06 GMT

HOW AWFUL RYAN SEACREST HANDLED MICHAELS DEPARTURE...HIS ARROGANCE ON THE SHOW HAS REALLY DAMPENED OUR TUESDAY NIGHTS.......I AM SURE MICAHEL WILL FIND SUCCESS.........HE SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN THE ONE TO GO........WHO ACTUALLY SEES THE VOTES? AND WHY ARE PEOPLE ALLOWED SO MANY...KEEP IT REAL!!! KC

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Sunflower Lady, Lower Alabama — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 21:54:31 GMT

When will the judges wake up and realize that this is just merely a popularity contest. It's no longer the talent contest that they thought it was. The only reason Archuleta is still in there is because of teenage girls voting for him.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Jacob, Los Angeles CA — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 21:55:40 GMT

Travesty. Johns is a latter day Otis Redding/Solomon Burke.

Whynatte is hilarious. My friends and I were curious about it after checking out the website. The drink is phenomenal.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Jeanine mcNail, Hamshire, TX — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 22:22:13 GMT

I was speechless when Michael Johns was voted off. I recall Simon's remarks earlier in this competition that he thought Michael had the capability of becoming a SuperStar. Let it be so! and let Ryan Seacrest be sent to the woodshed. He is becoming so self-interested that I find him to be a distraction.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Maria, London, UK — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 22:54:02 GMT

I absolutely LOVE Michael and think he has a brilliant carrer ahead of him. He is a star and should have won AI!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Michael Todd, Chicago — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 22:56:09 GMT

People, this is a TV show. If you all cared as much about the general election and voted as feverishly this country would be a very different place.

American Idol is a popularity contest, and Michael Johns didn't win it. Even though I agree that there are others that should have gone first (Brooke, Jason Castro, Kristy Lee) Michael Johns didn't have a chance in winning the competition unless a freak act of nature claimed the lives or vocal cords of David Archuleta or David Cook. It's going to come down to the Davids.

I didn't enjoy how Michael Johns' facial expressions made it look like he was smelling an egg fart every time he sang, and that (or other reasons) kept me (and, apparently, lots of other people) from voting for him. He was lackluster overall until about 3 weeks ago, so it's not shocking that he wasn't able to build up a huge fan base in such a short amount of time.

Stop crying, you and FOX both know that you'll keep watching.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

geri spohn — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 23:24:30 GMT

Not watching AI, after this elimination...cannot imagine the rest of the season without Michael Johns...
some of the others are just so mediocre.......
AI needs to revamp voting method it is not working...

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

C. Cruz, Tampa, FL — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 23:54:31 GMT

I still haven't gotten over that Michael Johns was voted off. He didn't deserve it at this stage of the competition. I'm sure he'll do better outside the American Idol just like Chris Daughtry. Move on, Michael! You'll do just fine. On a separate note, Michael Johns is HOT.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Kathy, New Jersey — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 00:03:15 GMT

Ok, I cried like a baby when Michael was eliminated. He's got the charisma, voice and looks to do very well for himself. I will definitely buy his music and I think I may have to see him live too.

I hated that he was eliminated and how it was done. But, in a wierd way it's been good for him. The too soon exit has really upped his profile even more and has generated alot of good will and support for him.

I'll miss seeing him perform every week. But now I have lots of time to do other things on tues and wed nights, since I won't be watching American Idol anymore.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

KATARINA CANTON, OHIO — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 02:09:13 GMT

MICHAEL WAS THE BRIGHT SPOT OF MY WEEK AND NOW THAT HE'S GONE, I'M NOT LOOKING FORWARD TO AI, I WILL WATCH ONLY IF I HAVE NOTHING ELSE TO DO AND WILL NEVER VOTE AGAIN.(I VOTED MANY TIMES FOR MICHAEL)....FROM WHAT I'M READING, IT SEEMS THAT THE VOTING MAY BE FIXED ANYWAY. MICHAEL BEING ELIMINATED IN SUCH A CRUEL WAY AHS MADE ME LOSE ALL MY FAITH. I CAN'T WAIT FOR MICHAEL'S CD AND TO SEE HIM WHEN HE COMES TO CLEVELAND ON HIS TOUR. HE IS BY FAR THE BEST ALL AROUND IDOL CONTESTANT THAT THEY HAVE EVER HAD.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Louiseann Boston, Mass. — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 02:35:15 GMT

When Ryan announced Michael would be going home, his head dropped and he looked like a beautiful sad angel. And we all felt heartbroken- WE would be robbed of his talent, his looks and his expressive sensuality. What was so unnerving to so many women was his raw sexuality --yet it was that block of four women, who kept him distanced from the top. So we blame those women and the judges, who slighted against him and those texting teens. Now everyone is heartbroken. It's like going to a class on the first day and seeking out the cutest guys. Then after a week, you realize the cutest guy transfered to another class. Now there is nothing to anticipate. There is a deadness.
Dear Michael, we will look to the future for your bright star, for surely this surging heartfelt disappointment of your exit will only raise you higher in our collective hearts. WE CAN'T WAIT FOR YOUR SUCCESS!!!!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Marie, Phoenix, AZ — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 02:45:44 GMT

I was shocked when Michael was voted off. He is so good. But no worry, he's going places. I like when I see Daughtry opening for Bon Jovi and actually singing with him on stage. Fantastic! I think Michael is going to the same "places". My best to you Michael.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Barbra Snooke Canada — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 04:11:33 GMT

The voting on this show is wrong and it must change so a mistake like last week won't repeat itself again
Micheal Johns was robbed but never fear I think somehow he will be the last man standing sorry Brooke Carly Syesha Kristy and Jason

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Jan Michele, Lexington, KY — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 04:29:50 GMT

Michael has a nice singing voice (a few voice lessons would make it fabulous), but OH, I'm going to miss that beautiful face!, those eyes!, that smile!, and that tall handsome bod! Michael has all the charisma of a super star! AI fans BLEW IT!
My interest in the show dropped 80% after Michael left.
(By the way, is it a coincidence that the one voted off had picked a song reflecting that? If so, then, look for Brooke to be going this week. The song she sang tonight was appropriate for the one to go).

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Rob, Atlanta GA — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 04:48:04 GMT

Tonight was the first time since the show's inception that I didn't watch AI. I just couldn't-there was no Michael Johns. The rest of the "singers" just pale in comparison. You Tube has some great vintage MJ when he was lead singer in the band The Rising. The song "Cradle" is phenomenal!!!Y'all should check it out!http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WquoHxNMo0Y
Also, I heard that Ryan had Michael on his radio show and apologized to Michael for the "knife twisting" way he announced that he was leaving. Yeah well....he blamed it on Nigel (the show's producer). If Ryan had any class or b**** he would have refused to do it that way. Whatever. Michael is gone and I can't wait to buy his CD!! Please people-I beg of you-if you still watch that mediocre excuse for a "singing competition" don't vote for the awww shucks teeny bopper!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Alexis, San Diego, California — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 04:59:08 GMT

I love michael and I LOVE WHYNATTES. They are better than liquid gold. I had 42 over the past 7 days and I already won a a scratch lottery ticket worth over 1,500 dollars. They are right, life really does get better. Great job Michael! Can't wait for your first single!!!!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Diane Getz, Coplay, PA — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 05:05:44 GMT

Michael Johns was the only reason I watched the show. I have been a viewer since the first season. Sad to say, I will no longer watch the show. I could care less who wins now. You go Michael...show 'em how it's done!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

JANE S. RALEIGH, NC — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 05:11:41 GMT

REALLY THE QUESTION IS WHO WILL SELL CDS....I JUST CAN'T SEE MYSELF BUYING DAVID A.S CD. HE IS A GOOD SINGER BUT NOT REALLY COMMERCIAL.
MICHAEL JOHNS WAS THE ONE I WAS LOOKING FORWARD TO BUYING.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Nita, Valdosta, GA — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 06:16:33 GMT

How rude of AI and SeacrestNOT TO APOLOGIZE AND NOT to BRING BACK MICHAEL JOHNS TUESDAY NIGHT! Clearly, he would have won hands down beating out David Archuforgetyourlyrics can do no wrong in AI's and judges minds. Archuletta is robotic and creepy with those puppy dog eyes (like Melinda Doolittle) and perfectly sculpted hair singing the same type of songs week after week. Boring! Bottom three, Jason "pothead-like" Castro, White, Syesha. Ideally, Idol should trade-up two of these and GIVE BACK MICHAEL JOHNS. SHAME ON AMERICAN IDOL, SIMON COWELL, AND RYAN SEACREST.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Al M. — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 07:26:38 GMT

In past years, I noticed that when it's down to the final 8, it gets harder to register a vote for a favorite. This happened when I tried to vote for Elliott Yamin, and kept getting a dead connection. It happened before that with other candidates. So, it finally hit me that the final 2 had already been chosen. How else could I explain it happening every year?

I stopped watching now that Michael Johns has been cast off. I totally agree that Ryan Seacrest was cold and cruel when he did what he did to Michael.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Linda Jensen, Kansas City, MO — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 11:36:19 GMT

Michael Johns was one of the best on the show. How can this happen...his fans apparently didn't vote. He clearly was better than the other guys (David Cook perhaps the exception) and all the women! I hope to see and hear from him again...The show sucks!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

chris williams, North, SC — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 13:08:15 GMT

I hate that michael is going because I was looking forward to a final between him and the two davids. This is surely a guys year. I have found that when they want someone off, for some reason you can't get through to vote for that person - it was that way with Amanda Overmyer the week she was voted off - I tried and tried to vote with her but I didn't get a busy signal or through - the phone did something very weird. It was the same way with Michael which is why I knew he was going. I am disillusioned by American Idol and the voting process. I agree they should do like Dancing with the Stars and limit the number of votes from any one number and even limit text voting as well. This "contest" will never be fair until they do.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

chris williams, North, SC — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 14:08:13 GMT

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Lori, Roanoke Virginia — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 14:09:46 GMT

Michael Johns should still be in the top 7. Unlike most...David A. needs to go...he only sings ballads Where is the versatility...I would never buy a CD of his because he is BORING..(snooze, snooze). I don't like rock but I throughly enjoyed watching Michael perform. I think we will see a CD forthcoming.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Susan, Washington, IA — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 15:09:02 GMT

It is absolutely mind-boggling to think that Michael Johns was voted off Idol. He easily should have made the final three, along with David Cook and David Archuleta. Jason Castro should have been voted off LONG ago! He appears to be a nice young man and his voice is pleasant enough, but his vocal range and strength are very limited and he is quite frequently "pitchy," as Randy Jackson would say, yet none of the judges seem to acknowledge it. I agree there should be (and easily could be) a system developed to limit the number of votes by an individual caller or "texter" for each of the contestants to help prevent teeny-boppers from skewing the voting results. And the number of votes per contestant should be made public! I also did not like the way Michael John's elimination was handled; i.e., briefly giving him the false hope that he would be spared during Idol Gives Back week.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Kathy, Columbia, SC — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 15:59:54 GMT

David Archuleta the "American Idol"! I don't think so yet. I agree that the voting is a joke! Believe it or not, us 30, 40 and 50ish fans of American Idol would like to think we still know talent and would like our vote to count. But, as mentioned, we also have lives, and better things to do than stay up for 2 hours casting votes......give us a break!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Carolyn Heaslip — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 16:17:29 GMT

"American Idol" should be a package deal. The talent is definitely with David A, Carly S. and David Cook, but who has the "stage presence"? After Michael John's untimely dismissal, there is only one left with a real stage presence and that is David Cook. Also, what is it that makes the AI producers think that rudeness is the key to success? It's okay for the judges to be critical. That sometimes is helpful to the contestants, but where does Seacrest get off thinking it is his place to be cruel and demeaning to the contestants. That's totally out of line, is not entertaining and very distasteful. Surely, they could come up with someone more suitable and pleasant to watch.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Opal, Sioux City, IA — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 16:28:48 GMT

I still say the show is rigged. What a complete surprise that Michael Johns was voted off. The show was pretty "cut and dry" up until this point. They had to do something for some attention. Michael was clearly one of the top two, the other being David Cook. I'm sure that David Archuleta is going to win...his dad is in show business and all the younger audience (who do most text messaging) will put him over the top. He's a cute young guy but he is just to bland and safe in his song choices...all his songs sound the same. His youth sells and that's what Simon is seeing $$$$. David A. will win even though David Cook will go the furthest in his career.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Lee Peterson — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 16:52:28 GMT

The show is sooooo boring now. At least we had a little "eye candy" and talent with MJ. Not much left to watch or hear now. Good bye Idol until you come up with something new.....

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Donna, New Jersey — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 16:58:07 GMT

I agree with the ranks.. what are Kristy Lee, Brooke and Jason still doing there?!?! Each are flat, without real charisma and 2 dimensional. The only consolation I can offer Michael is to look at what getting voted off did for Chris Daughtry...........(whose cd I have worn out from play!)

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Larry, North Royalton, OH — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 17:05:23 GMT

First, Michael Johns is NOT better than David Cook. Let's not fool ourselves there. And, secondly, look out for Kristy Lee Cook. I wasn't a fan of hers at first. But look at her progression in choice of songs, performance and actual singing prowess. She won't win - but she could easily be Top Three material with her improvement AND good looks!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Allen, FL — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 17:17:12 GMT

Michael is so amazing and I love him so much!! I was heartbroken when he was voted off and I have sworn never to watch the show again. I'm sure he'll have a great career. I'm so excited for his next album! Go Michael!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Tricia, San Angelo, TX — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 17:38:32 GMT

Concerning Michael Johns being voted off: Yeah, I liked him better than a couple of others on the show now. But to all of you are screaming "He was robbed!", please remember it's the people calling in that decide. It's the VIEWERS who booted him off, not American Idol. Remember when Melinda was voted off last year? She was - by far - the most talented of the whole group. If you love your guy, you'd better call in your vote!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

LaVerne, Okeechobee, Florida — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 18:17:21 GMT

OMGosh, I can't believe MJ was voted off, but it's time we older people realize the majority of voters are pre-teens and teens. MJ is/was my choice to win, he had looks and talent, not to mention he seemed like a genuine good person. I'm to the point where I wish Ryan Seacrest would get voted off. I'm tired of the way he tries to ake Simon look bad, he always has negative things to say to Simon but Randy has been bad mouthing people a lot lately and Ryan doesn't say anything about it. I would love it if Ryan was voted off as the announcer, he was just plain cruel with the way he told Michael he was leaving. For the life of me I can't figure out what people like about Ryan. Oh well, I hope we hear some music from Michael Johns real soon.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

lisa, texas — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 18:18:21 GMT

CANNOT BELIEVE MICHAEL JOHNS GOT ELIMINATED!!!! THAT IS JUST NOT RIGHT!!! MICHAEL JOHNS AND DAVID COOK ARE THE BEST TALENTS THIS YEAR! TO SEE MICHAEL SENT HOME AND DURING THE IDOL GIVES BACK EPISODE IS REALLY NOT FAIR! HOPE HE DOES GREAT WITH HIS CD! THE NEXT CHRIS DAUGHTRY! DEFINITELY LOOKING FORWARD TO MICHAEL'S AND DAVID COOK'S CDs! THE SHOW HAS BECOME BORING WITHOUT MJ! THE ONLY INTERESTING PERFORMANCES ARE BY DAVID COOK! WOULD HAVE LOVED TO SEE A FINALE WITH DAVID COOK AND MICHAEL JOHNS!!!!!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Sandra Brightman Dunkirk New York — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 18:24:56 GMT

Michael is overated. He sings in a band for a living like millions of other people whom never make it in the industry. He came to America to become famous which is what he accomplished. He was over confident and over rated. This is a good season and only one can win. Cook, castor and Brook deserve to be the top three.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

LUCY GEORGIA — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 18:40:15 GMT

I THINK MICHEAL JOHN ,WAS DONE A FAVOR BY BEING VOTED OFF ,FOR THAT YOUNG MAN IS GOING PLACES ,JUST WATCH AND SEE ,AND YOU DID NOT HAVE SOME VOTED OFF .CANNOT UNDERSTAND THAT ,FOR MICHEAL JOHN ,HAS ALL IT TAKES TO DO GREAT

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Diane, Texarkana, Tx. — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 19:57:43 GMT

I started watching AI last year for the first time. I thought last year's singers were better than this year--Jordin and Melinda especially. I voted for Jordin every week because she had "star" quality to me. This year, I'm not sure anyone has. I don't think that Jason or Carly should still be on when Michael was voted off. My opinion is that Michael Johns should have been in the top 3.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Missie, Buckhannon, WV — Thu, 17 Apr 2008 03:13:24 GMT

I totally agree with Tom from Chicago. It is the same situation as with Clay Aiken. Clay was the real winner of AI. Michael should not have gone home. He sould have been in the top 3 and possibly the top 2. I loved his voice from the moment I heard him sing the Otis Redding song. Michael WILL be better off not being tied down to AI. I haven't been this discusted with Idol since Clay didn't "win".

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Brandy Arnold, Texas — Thu, 17 Apr 2008 12:14:29 GMT

It is obvious that Michael Johns is a great singer and a good performer. He definitely has some fans out there...but he failed to connect with everyone. Personally, I thought he was too serious on stage and I kept waiting for something amazing that never came out of him....it was no surprise to me to find out that he was such an endearing, funny person, with a great personality and a such a connection to the other contestants---that is what was missing on stage!! Good luck to him in the future and I hope his fans stay loyal (my husband is one of them).

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Patty O -- CT — Thu, 17 Apr 2008 14:04:46 GMT

Michael Johns was robbed. Simon always complains about it being a poularity contest instead of a singing contest....well, the problem is the voting system that the show uses. If Simon wants the show to have credibility, he needs to tell the producers that unless they change the system of voting that he is out.....the show couldn't survive without him....it should be one vote per phone line for the person who performed the worst.

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Pat Cochran, Brandon, MS — Thu, 17 Apr 2008 14:47:50 GMT

Michael Johns and David Cook by far the best in this year's competition. it's becoming increasingly apparent that contest may be rigged - many people stated they could not get through on Michael's line -myself included. I agree votes need to be handled more efficiently - limit votes per person as well as judge's votes counting toward the overall score.

Ryan came off as arrogant and rude which is becoming the norm for him.

I for one am weary of what American Idol has become.

Michael Johns is greatly missed, but his star will continue to rise. I applaud him for following his DREAM!!!

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

k Illinois — Tue, 22 Apr 2008 21:34:24 GMT

Michael Johns should still be on Idol....I was completely surprised when he left.....but not being the Idol winner, he will win in other ways....Chris Daughtry did.....He's great.... and his band members, they all seem to be very nice men. What is with Jasons hair!!!!!!!looks very unclean..Elliot Yamin sure looks good now, and still has a great voice..was nice to see him on Idol Gives Back.. Really tired of Ryan's banter to Simon, give it up.. Good luck Michael Johns..............

Michael Johns Finds Attention 'Surreal,' Loves Whynattes

Bernice Policastro Union, NJ — Tue, 22 Apr 2008 23:13:56 GMT

It's ALL WRONG, but it's ALRIGHT, because Michael John's will be another Chris Daughtry!

Loved that performance Michael! I think everyone was surprised you got voted off.