LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jennifer Suter, Keyser WV — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:15:08 GMT

It's the comments that have been made that fuels the racism in this country. I could have looked at that cover and never once even considered the "King Kong" shot but now since it has been made an issue I can't look at it without thinking of it. He is a strong beautiful, talented man who just happens to be of color. How dare anyone compare him to an ape.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Columbus, Ohio — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:16:15 GMT

I cant express how appalled I was by Ann's behavior this morning while reporting on this segment. The Today Show invited "experts" on to give their opinion, then not only refused to allow them to express their thoughts, but went so far as to talk over them anytime they began to speak. The cover is an expression of art and, in my opinion, give a very accurate interpretation of LeBron's personality. It seems to me that the people who are making these comparisons to gorillas are black people themselves, and it would have likely gone unnoticed by everyone without their outbursts of criticism.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Shannon — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:18:56 GMT

This story made me chuckle. Part of the reason racism still exists is because black people want it to. It gives them a crutch and an excuse to complain. It also provides them with a get out of jail free card to play. I never would've read into this what others have. King Kong? Black man wanting black woman? Come on....really?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Alice Wernersville, PA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:21:48 GMT

I think LeBron and Giselle look wonderful! Their pictures are awesome! People need to get a grip!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Robin — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:27:19 GMT

This all seems a little silly. Annie Liebowitz is a well respected and professional photographer. I think this image was chosen because it captures the essence of what these two people are : A strong, muscular athlete who is fierce on the court, and a beautiful feminine goddess, a supermodel. This issue is about shape and beautiful bodies and this image shows that about both of them.
I don't think Lebron's stance is offensive. I doubt anyone said to him "stand like a gorilla". I think he was trying to stand in a pose that best showed off his physique and his sport. This is a pose that a lot of body builders use. And if Giselle is supposed to be so "afaid" of him, then why is she smiling with a grin bigger than Julia Roberts'?
I agree that there were more artsy photos with a more flowing composition in the collection. But I dont think they captured the essence of being in action. That is, after all, how you get in shape and get on the cover for having a great bod isn't it?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

mcn Bedford, TX — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:27:47 GMT

I am a 54 year old white woman, married to a 54 year
old white man. Why does a great photo like this
have to be considered racist?
I think LeBron James looks HOT! I love the photo
chosen for the cover.
I would never think he looks like a gorilla.
People get over it! It is only racist if you are!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Heather — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:29:31 GMT

I have a couple of questions to pose. If LeBron was photographed with an black model, how would people react? If Gisele was photographed with a white athlete, how would people react? What if a female black athlete, like Laila Ali, was photographed with a slender, white, male athlete, how would people react? Does Gisele look threatened in this photo? Quite the contrary. She looks like she is having a blast. Finally, as we live in the 21st century, should we not be looking beyond the colour of people's skin? As they say, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and there is great beauty in this cover shoot. I congratulate Vogue for their ability to capture beauty in many forms.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Deborah Shaughnessy, Jonesboro, Arkansas — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:33:58 GMT

Unless you are a racist this is just a photograph of
two people, nothing more!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Shelly Roberts, Whitehouse, Texas — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:40:14 GMT

When I viewed this cover all I thought was athlete and supermodel. I NEVER even thougt black man, white woman. I'm so sick of african americans looking for reasons to label white people racists. I feel like white people in America are under attack. It's like the african american community looks for reasons to stir conflict. I fully expect Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson to speak out on this cover in the days to come.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Wesley Grant, New Bedford Mass — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:49:36 GMT

The issue of racisim has jumped into the headlines recently. it seems that everyone has "re stirred" this hornets nest recently. Vouge is a RESPECTABLE magazine and put a picture of a african american and a beautiful woman on the cover and the race card is thrown into the mix again. the world needs to see all races in a better light this is a picture nothing more. people in this world need to let more things just be what they are and not dig up un nessecary issues a famous pychiatrist once said "sometimes a cigar is just a cigar" this picture is just a picture period

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

g.eglesias`pennsylvania`` — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:49:48 GMT

He looks more like a football player than a basketball player to me. Anyway, why does he need a woman on his arm "black or white" with a look on his face like that?? The picture is just screaming controversy.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

debbie, decatur, il. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:51:53 GMT

Please- critics let it go. It is what it is-a great cover and a great photograph.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Christy Rolas, Morgan City, Louisiana — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:53:04 GMT

When the word "controversial" preceded the unveiling of this picture, I imagined nudity, not two notorious people depicting fun and humor; my initial response was not "King Kong and damsel in distress"! Those whose feathers were ruffled were likely those who love to stir racial tension, who are actually racist themselves and despise seeing a man of color in the same setting as a caucasian woman. Rather than viewing this as races uniting with smiles some had to turn it into a race issue...can't help but wonder if a white man with the same expression and pose would have been okay to grace Ebony or Jet's covers...

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jerry Lisiecki, Charlotte, Michigan — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:55:51 GMT

Why has no mentioned the picture of LeBron in a three piece suit on the cover of a financial magazine recently? Or the fact that Buffett has given LeBron his personal cell phone number and says they often discuss business? Wait a minute, that is not an image that offends so the politically correct ignore it. Covers are intended to attract the eye. This one did. Get over it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lumberton, TX — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 13:56:43 GMT

Who says that LeBron is standing like a gorilla? Isn't he dribbling a basketball? Duh!!!! I believe that only the racists themselves are seeing this as racial. Who cares what the guests think...what does LeBron think? He did the shot. I'm sure that he didn't feel that he was being shot as a gorilla, but as the fierce, hot man that he is.Leave it alone and get a real life. Ann Currie needs to get a grip. A few of her interviews lately, especially concerning this issue and when she interviewed Omarosa, have been down right rude. Talking over her guests and rolling her eyes at them. Wow! If I wanted to watch controversial and uncomfortable interviews I would watch another show.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Brian — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:05:02 GMT

This picture did not evoke thoughts of King Kong until it was pointed out to me. I see no stereotyping in this picture at all. It's a star athlete and a supermodel, raw masculine power and true feminine beauty.It's quite a clever picture.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Cathy Thomas, Vancleave, MS — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:06:00 GMT

It's a good picture people need to get over the whole race issue, and just enjoy seeing 2 beautiful people on the cover of a magazine.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Leon Haven Denton Texas — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:07:02 GMT

If you find something wrong with this cover their is something definately wrong with you as a person!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

B.REAL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:12:19 GMT

This is the way of the world.Everything throws up a red flag due to people being naive.He is a basketball player,she is a model.Thats it!! Anyone reading anything else into this has nothing better to do with their lives.King Kong,please!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tracy, Boston area, Mass. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:13:10 GMT

Most people so far have indicated my thoughts on this. It is a nice photo and anyone who views it in a different light has issues. I too would never have viewed LeBron as looking like a gorilla - LETS BE REAL!!! Everyone needs to step back and get into reality. I too am tired of everyone picking apart everything and claiming racism. The past is the past and unless we stop claiming racism, then we will not progress into a society with no racism. We cannot be held responsible for what our ancestors may have done or not done! I'm quite sure that Sharpton and/or Jackson will be getting on this ban wagon - they live for this garbage! (Yes, I am a 41 y/o married white woman, with children and have friends and family of many backgrounds. I do not judge anyone by their color, sex, religion or anything else but how they treat others!)

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Wendy Hoekstra — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:13:24 GMT

God help us that this has become a news worthy story. What has become of us when we have nothing better to do with our time then to turn a beautiful picture ugly. There are so many good things we could talk about yet we continue to drag the uglyness to the front. It's as if we enjoy being miserable.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kerry,Durham,NC — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:14:56 GMT

Not sure about the monkey issue. As a black male I would have liked to seen him in better pic showing some style. That pic sucks for a man of his money and status.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Atlanta, GA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:25:35 GMT

Although I did not see the racism in the picture, I can see how some would look at it a different way. However, I do see racism in the comments online. Black people, me, don't need a crutch some white people have made sure to place that in our lives. Your inability to see someone's side SHANNON is the very heart of racism. People like you keep it alive.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Abraham — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:25:54 GMT

This is just a great cover, nothing more. There is no need to bring race issues were there are none. Leave the "I'm so sick of african americans looking for reasons to label white people racists." out of this. Racism is real in the US, there's no denying it (even though many try to).Unfortunately for people like that there is no controversy on this cover. It is an image of a famous athlete and a beautiful model, nothing more.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tampa, FL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:27:01 GMT

It's not fair to say that "racism exists because black people want it to". It's ignornant and not true. Racism exists because...it exists! There are still racist people in this world. No one wants it to exist. How do black people benefit from racism? How does society in general? As far as the cover is concerned, as a black woman, I'm more ashamed of Lebron than I am upset with the magazine. When black athletes or public figures are portrayed in "racist" or unfavorable lights, it's their own fault. As one of the previous posters commented, the photographer probably didn't ask him to pose like Godzilla but he sure does look like he's trying to. Lebron must not have taken into consideration the past of blacks being compared to monkeys and the effect it would have on the community. It's not about anything being taken out of proportion or taken the wrong way. In reality, you can't look at that picture and not see a black man striking a pose similiar to one made famous by Godzilla and holding a beautiful white woman. So, racism exists in the real life because stereotypes sitll exist and many people still believe them. Not to support Affirmative Action or to give us a get out of jail free card. 85% of all jails are filled with black men...did we run out of cards or something? Not to blame "the white man" or society for that either.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Linda McCoy, Syracuse, NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:27:43 GMT

The Vogue cover is a beautiful representation of two beautiful human beings. Period. You can disagree about that because, indeed, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but racist? Give me a break!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tom Hughes — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:30:16 GMT

Good grief!!!! What "may have" been viewed as inappropriate or racial by a select few people who will never change their views will now be the topic of racial discussions and sterotypes. Thanks to this reporting and intreptation of taking an innocent, yet celebrating photo and turning it into some type of political grandstanding you are now the leading the racist and sterotypical reporter. Well done. NOT!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Angela, Richmond, VA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:32:42 GMT

I think it's still difficult for some black and white persons to see a black man and white woman together period. And I think this was fueled by the comment(s) from the Vogue spokesperson who stated that King James was the first black man to grace the cover of their mag. "And how dare they put him on there with a white woman!" Whatever sells, honey. I'm sure Vogue will notice a spike in sales on this one. Everyone just needs to calm down. It's a picture. That's all. Can we move on? Hello? We're still in Iraq and Afghanistan, gas prices are quickly rising, disposable income (whatever that is) is shrinking and we have yet to begin the clean-up of the subprime mortgage debacle!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Laura Klinger — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:34:27 GMT

How much better it would have been to photograph LeBron with a beautiful black lady, a model or a singer, and there are many out there. It seems Vogue was looking for controversy to sell a few more magazines. Shame on them! One more thing, young black men need role models, and to allow himself to become embroiled in this, LeBron loses credibility where it is so badly needed.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

C Clark, Pittsburgh, PA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:34:45 GMT

The way I see it is the only way one could be offended by this is if they WANTED to be offended. There is nothing even remotely racial about that picture.
And I can't believe that fact that people being offended by this is news-worthy. There are way more important things going on in this country that deserves this type of attention.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Charity Meyers, Baltimore, MD — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:36:01 GMT

This is ridiculous! This cover is about as controversial as my morning bowl of oatmeal! To me, LeBron merely looks as if he is psyched up before a game, giving a battle cry not unlike they do in martial arts, and Gisele is laughing amicably at his enthusiasm. He does not, in any way, shape, or form, resemble King Kong, and those who think so are only showing their own insecurities. Political correctness in this country has gone insane, reading racism/sexism into things where it doesn't exist! And the ones I hear the most disparaging remarks for black people is from other black people; it's very rare I hear anything from a white person. And I'm a woman, and have hardly ever faced any disparagement/action I believe was made due to my sex. Grow up and get a life, people! It seems only those who have a stake in keeping the races and sexes at each other's throats coughcough the media cough see anything controversial about this cover.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Melissa, Biloxi, MS — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:38:02 GMT

I wish the media would stop stirring up racial controversy. From the presidential election to this picture we are so focused on the color of people's skin that we forget about what is really important. I think the media should be responsible and stop inventing things to rile up racial tension. Hopefully this is the last we will hear about this picture.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

JCM, Denver, CO. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:38:18 GMT

When are people going to get past the race issue. This great picture of "King James" with the hottist model on the planet is a celabration of just how far we really have come on the issue of race. I'm happy to see Vogue push themselfs to new levels of understanding our socieity. Both black and white people need to knock the chip off their shoulders and get on with the business of being "Americans"

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Paula — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:39:37 GMT

Is the picture racist? No. Is the picture stupid? Yes.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tracy, Missouri — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:39:38 GMT

I don't see anything wrong with it. It says the top in their fields. I think people are making too much of it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Frustrated, Cleveland, Ohio — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:42:48 GMT

What frustrates me the most, is everyone looks too much into things. Who even thought of this image portraying King Kong in the first place? That did not come to my mind when I saw the cover. Lets face it, if the cover depicted a femine, smiling, and gentle LeBron James (the King of Basketball) and a masculine and intimidating Gisele (one of the most renown models known for her beauty) there would have been controversy. It would have been.... "Shouldn't they have LeBron James looking more like a Basketball Player instead of a Ballerina and Gisele like the image she is known for?" Secondly, LeBron James was completely aware of his face, stance, and the girl in his arms. I'm sure if he had seen an issue with it, it would not have been printed. And lastly, Gisele looks like she is having a blast, not like she is being wisked away by King Kong. Maybe the King of Basketball....Who wouldn't want to be in his protective arms?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Cindy — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:43:05 GMT

I cant believe people are actually making a big deal about this.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jody Beeler , Sedona, Az — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:43:48 GMT

Controversey sells magazines!! We have all been duped by this one!! A great photo, by a great photographer and shame on the Today show for resorting to low brow cheesy journalism.Thanks for showing two beautiful people in the prime of life all in the name of art!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

e smith — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:47:12 GMT

I wasn't impressed with the photo when I saw it first before all the contraversy. I think they could have done better. They definately could have done better. And yes I do believe their is something racist about it. But that's how the media is. Sneaky as usual.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Deborah Pedata, Deland Fl — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:49:05 GMT

Is this a joke! Lebron looks nothing like an ape and Giselle is hardly a damsel in distress. Someone is bored and wants to start a controvery. We have more important issues to deal with in this world than trying to find trouble where none was meant. Is this a great picture,no. Is it racist,also no.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Denise Olsen, Eagan, Minnesota — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:49:47 GMT

WHAT??? I would never have even considered this cover to be anything other than LeBron and Giselle having fun while doing a cover shoot. Why does it always have to come down to race - honestly, let it go!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ed J — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:49:55 GMT

The picture helps reinforce negative stereotypes about blacks. All Blackmen love to play basketball and be uncivilized. While the Attractive white woman stands there quite civilized!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Brian, Pasadena, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:50:34 GMT

Here is the thing. Racism continues to get perpetuated in our society strongly due stories like this. The only reason this cover is being discussed as possibly racist it because you and other news groups are doing a story about it maybe being racist. I gaurentee that if you did no story, no would think this. No person with common sense would look at this cover and think anything other than it's a big tough basketball player and a pretty model on the cover. If we want racism to stop in, one of the first things that needs to happen is for the media to stop making everything out to be racist. You are a huge part of the problem. Stop making everything racist and racism will die. We are more evolved than this.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Chris, Mt. Pocono, PA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:50:56 GMT

It seems to me that the racists are the ones who dubbed Lebron as "King Kong". If Lebron were white, would he be portrayed as "The Abominable Snowman"???? The pic is great and I'm quite sure that if King James had a problem with it, it wouldn't be on the cover. Rock on, Lebron!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

David, Greensboro, NC — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:51:10 GMT

Please! All I see is two attractive people having fun at a photo op! The folks who are making a big deal out of this are just nuts.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lisa, Jenks America — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:54:28 GMT

When i first saw this cover i thought nothing. LeBron looks like himself. That is the way he is. People need to watch a game! I feel like they're insulting LeBron and should be ashamed of themselves. When is the time going to come that everyone would look at this cover and see an exuberant athlete and a beautiful model. It is people that criticize this cover that keep racism alive. WHEN ARE WE GOING TO QUIT SEEING BLACK AND WHITE!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

James, Canon City, Colorado — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 14:54:35 GMT

Its things like this that just fuel the issue of racism. How will people ever get along if we keep fueling the fire with such stupid issues like a magazine cover. Wake up and grow up. Lets learn to get along as one, and solve some real problems such as our failing economy, poverty, global warming, affordable health insurance, or education. WAKE UP AMERICA !

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jared, San Diego, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:02:36 GMT

I think it is so crazy that people must read racially into this. Annie Liebovitz, a fabulous photographer who also could say that her jewish life has been persecuted took this photograph. If some can see that he is a mad man on his way to enslave the black man....couldn't we also say he is the image of Hitler carrying a beautiful white jewish girl to the gas chamber? Come on!! People see what they want to see and interpret things obvioulsly very differently. This is a photograph that shows him as an excited and pumped up basketball star and her a beautiful model. We are all Americans. I was born here...I'm American. Lebron was born here...he is American. My family is French/Italian...yet I consider myself just American. Let's stop using these names to set us apart. African American? Were you born in Africa? The majority will have to say no. Just call yourself American for Pete's sake!! Stop all of the racial separation and unite.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Adrienne, Cleveland, Oh — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:03:05 GMT

This is so frustrating..how this is racist is beyond me, people will always find a way to see something for what IT ISNT. Two talented young people whether they be black, white, yellow purple etc...should be celebrated for their accomplishments not looked down upon for their color or what someone protrays as a racist photograph...i also congratulate vogue for taking a stand and seeing no color just two wonderful young people in their prime...bravo!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sandie G., Seattle, Washington — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:03:13 GMT

This is just a photo of a black man and a white woman chosen by people who are professionals working for a magazine that has been very successful for many, many years. Why do blacks always make everything a racial issue?? They should be celebrating the fact that LeBron made the cover and is being recognized. Instead they (blacks) are making it an issue, again. LeBron is an amazingly talented basketball player who just happens to be big, black and georgous and who does not show any resemblence to King Kong (a black woman's words). He plays with passion and I think passion is what is portrayed in this photo. HE seems to be just fine with the choice of the cover photo. Again, why is this a racial issue??? This whole thing is not worth the air it is getting. I hope Al Sharpton and Jessie Jackson don't subscribe to Vogue...God help us if they do.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

S. Lacey, Los Angeles, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:07:52 GMT

I can not believe that A) People are even suggesting this Vogue cover is a racial issue B) the Today Show spent one second on this so called 'controversy'. Photography is art and I really think the anyone who is considering this offensive, needs to find a hobby.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

New Mexico — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:08:31 GMT

I don't really care for the picture, but not because of racism. I just think it looks stupid. Just because Leibowitz is an acclaimed photographer doesn't mean I think every one of her pictures is amazing. I don't really understand the purpose of having Giselle there other than to have a woman in the picture. If James had been by himself, how impressed with the picture would you have been? It would have looked like something you see on Sports Illustrated. It must be a slow news week for this to be getting this much attention.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Andrew, Cleveland, Ohio — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:11:04 GMT

I think the cover leaves a lot to be desired. I don't know anything about fashion or it's media (mostly because I don't take them seriously at all), but it seems like they are running out of ideas and this usually means we get crap. I'm sure they had a plethora of pics to choose from, but how many would stir a meaningless controversy like this?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

lorenzo — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:14:27 GMT

typical white people not taking responsibility for what goes on in america. lol The first black man to be on the cover of vogue and he is with a white woman who looks so calm and sweet, where as he looks like a wild man. Wow, what a great picture for the first black man to be on the cover of vogue. White people for whatever reason just cant get over what they did and keep doing to black people overtly.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jonah, New York, NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:20:59 GMT

Typical white people Lorenzo? Are you running for office by any chance?

"Maybe it's just me, but aren't most of the people begging for a "new conversation" on race the same folks who shouted "racist!" at anyone who disagreed with them during all the previous conversations?

Why do voluptuaries of racial argy-bargy want yet another such dialogue? For some, it's to avoid actually dealing with unpleasant facts. But for others when they say we need more conversation, they really mean their version of reality should win the day.

Replace "conversation" with "instruction" and you'll have a better sense of where these people are coming from and where they want their "dialogue" to take us."

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Leeds, Alabama — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:22:07 GMT

You can't change how everyone else feels about anything, if some people choose to believe he looks like "King Kong" then so be it, they have their own voice. Stop worrying about what everyone else is doing and saying and get yourself straight. It's a picture of two people, if you want to buy the magazine, buy it...if you don't, don't!!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Wm — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:23:14 GMT

Speaking as black american; this stupid controversy reinforces an old saying: "The past is always in front of us." I think the Vogue cover is harmless. What if the model was black?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Patti Tucker, Kalamazoo,MI. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:24:18 GMT

Boy, if it's not one thing to complain about; it's another. I say HURRAY for the cover of Vogue and if people read the small writing on the bottom of the cover, they'd see this issue was about "Shape." Gisele and LeBron definately have beautiful shapes. Doesn't matter if you're white, black, pokadotted....(got the picture?) if you are what a magazine is looking for, then congrats to you. You see, if it was just a white person on the front, some people would say that the people that subscribe to Vogue are racist. Seems like someone's got to complain about something and there are much more needed subjects that we should worry about and talk about and get solved. AMEN!
Sincerely,
Patti Tucker
p.s. the girls in the segment that Matt did "Mistaken Identity" are from our state and we watched the news nightly on what was going on and it truly is a sad story that did come out with some good.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

tired — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:31:43 GMT

In response to lorenzo, what exactly are white people doing (other than helping to put the first biracial president in office)? Do you think there are secret meetings being held to determine how to keep the black man down? To me, this is just the media continuing to stir the pot so that people will focus on this cr** instead of on real issues (the economy, the war, gas prices, etc.)

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Susan, Washington, PA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:33:00 GMT

When I heard controversy I was leary of my 10 year old daughter watching. I couldn't believe it...an ape?! I would have never thought that if it hadn't been stated. He just looks like a basketball player moving to the hoop and she just looks fabulous as always! I think the cover was fine and I do feel there are African Americans who love to feed off of this and keep it all stirred up. I don't think any typical caucasian person seeing this cover for the first time would ever have thought: "King Kong and Faye Wray!" Give me a break!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

A. Smith — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:34:34 GMT

This picture was made to be controversial and is. I myself would rather see him with a beautiful black model. This is like I'm a successful black basketball player and now I can get a white woman.
His tatooes make him look like a street gang thug.
This only reminds me of all the white girls I see with half white, half black babies that are on welfare because the black dad is no where to be found.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Duncan, New Jersey — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:41:28 GMT

The picture was unfortunate. When a magazine that does not depict black people chooses to use a photo that does indeed enforce stereotypes, it’s a clear indication of the nonchalant, have-a- good-day racism of the people in charge of that magazine. I did not think of the picture as King Kong, but I did think it was typical, savage black man and delicate white woman shot.
I'm sure white people are sick of being called racist, tired of hearing about racism and reminded of its impact in this country since the Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s. Black people on the other hand, have lived with state sponsored racism and its affects since before the 1660s. Think about it.
Lastly, I am always amused and irritated by people who remain steadfast in their belief that the racial divide will be cured by ignoring it. Comments like 'get over it,' are code for willful ignorance, and that is dangerous. Remember, if you bury your head in the sand, you won't see what's coming up behind you.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Pae, US — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:46:48 GMT

Gosh anything that's said anymore is racist. And it's not white people complaining about this either. It's a cover for Vogue and I don't see the point of complaining and crying over it. I guess certain black people see themselves as apes then because that's more racist if you ask me (comparing Lebron to an ape). I'm not going censor myself because someone is too emotional. I thought people would talk about the fact that Lebron is on the cover but this is just nuts.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

David W — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:47:43 GMT

Yeah, it's a shame people look at him and think race.. How about 2 people who probably are happy about getting a chance to work with the other on the cover of a popular magazine??.. It's 2008 people.. I see 2 successful individuals on the cover of a magazine.. People who make negative comments like that are usually broke

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lynda, Hartfield, PA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:48:12 GMT

He looks like a gorilla? I didn't know gorillas could dribble basketballs.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Traci Reeves, Chicago, IL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:49:06 GMT

"Oh it's just art, oh it's just beauty, oh it's just, just, just"...what people don't understand is that it is not THE OBVIOUS that is the problem. OBVIOUSLY, the picture is a stunning work of art. However, there IS something to be said of why certain artistic choices were made...why the picture that everyone considers beautiful just happens to conjure up a history in the American past in which black men were understood to be beastly, aggressive, deviant especially as that aggression relates to desiring white women. And that was considered art too! No, of course, no one is saying (at least I'm not) that Vogue, the photographers, the photographed are racist...but it just shows how the seeds of racism planted long ago have captured the minds of people even in unexpected, unconcious and yes even artistic ways. When you go back and look at films like King Kong, or Birth of a Nation you may begin to understand why this picture and subtext behind could be considered controversial. It's not about black people trying to always cry racism it is about never forgetting history so that the same mistakes are not made in the future...if a magazine cover causes alarm then yes, someone needs to say so. Just so that we are always insuring a positive, more tolerant, progressive future for everyone. If we all act blindly as if nothing is ever a problem, nothing is ever controversial then we are liable to re-hash mistakes of the past. If it just so happens to be a black person that recognizes what might be offensive why are they criticized for being touchy, or belligerent and not merely observant of something other than what is just obvious to everyone else? It is a truly beautiful thing when we can all appreciate the experience and opinions of people from all different races and accept that what we may love for art, they may fear for subtext.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jay D, Wallkill, NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:51:23 GMT

The only people who see this are racists. For a black woman to say Lebron looks like a gorilla putting her hands at her waist like an ape... She is a racist against her own. Very ugly.

The image is outstanding.... As a 37 yr. old white graphic designer, I see two people who are the top of their profession. Lebron poses in an aggressive basketball stance and Giselle is posing as a beautiful supermodel. "Two superstars at the top of their game." Anyone who sees anything different is looking through racist eyes hoping to see what is not there.

My 5 year old son was getting dressed while the story was airing and asked what is a racist. I had to explain this to my son that the people on your show think the black man looks like a monkey. MY 5 YEAR OLD SON SAID " THAT IS SILLY DADDY, HE LOOKS LIKE A BASKETBALL PLAYER WITH A PRETTY GIRL"

A racist can see racism in anything they look at.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

alex, Cartersville, Georgia — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:53:47 GMT

Enough already.
Race is not the be all end all that people make it out to be. On 1 hand the media's job is to report on facts as they pertain to the world we live in, but on the other hand the media--Fox News in particular-- make it a point to slant the coverage so that almost all stories come back to the race card. Lebron and Gisele are both in the rarified air that Tiger, Jordon, and Gretzky enjoy. Aealm I might mention that doesn't see black and white, they see green for dollars. They are both beyond the realm of normalcy that average people can expect. Holding this magazine cover up as testement to racial malfesance is a farce, and much worse an exercise in futility. As a 30 year old black American, I have been called racial epithets myself and brought into the good ol' boy joke system as the 3rd wheel in countless "Dirty Mexican" jokes. Race should not be the undoing of civility, and neither should common sense be the undoing of the mass media. This is no more racially tinged than any Victoria Secret ad I have ever seen. What of the countless millions of people who neither take time nor give thought to the subtle messages President Bush spews out of his mouth? Messages about global warming, illegal immigration, or America's current economic position within the world......it's these same people who find the time to see fault in this ad, who make the discussions about this ad useless. 2 weeks from now Lebron will still be 'Bron', Giselle will still be a super model and we'll all still be stuck in reccession, and hated throughout the world, but we will have wasted a few days of our lives talking about such things as this.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Darin McFadden, Annapolis, Maryland — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:54:31 GMT

As a black person, I am not offended by this at all. I think it's ridiculous that someone would cause up such a stir over this cover. Obviously they were okay with taking the photograph, so it's not really a big deal. I think we as a nation need to stop pulling the race card for EVERYTHING. In response to Shannons comment, "Part of the reason racism still exists is because black people want it to. It gives them a crutch and an excuse to complain. It also provides them with a get out of jail free card to play." Please understand that that only applies to SOME black people, not all. Please do not form an opinion based on the ignorance of SOME people.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

William R. Shepherd, Salt Lake City, Utah — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:55:06 GMT

This photo is barely noteworthy if not taken by the highly overrated, (Annie Liebovitz). She has taken some fairly decent photo's during her reign, however this is not one of them. It is two people having fun during an otherwise boring photo shoot. Nothing more!! Give me a break! Artistic value?????

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Mike, NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 15:59:51 GMT

Has anyone stopped to think that its the people who are still racist at heart that look at that image and say its protraying LeBron in a negative light? Someone blind to race will look at that image and see a model striking a pose and a basketball player acting intense as if in the middle of a game. Only a racist, or at least someone still focusing way to much attention on race will see something more in that image.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rose — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:01:20 GMT

It's only a cover shoot. Nothing more, nothing less.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ron Kirby — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:03:48 GMT

I didn't see the arrow in federal expess until someone pointed it out,now that's all I see.Many
people didn't relate the picture in Vogue to King Kong,but now that's all they see.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sharon Raine, New York City, NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:04:42 GMT

I would never have assumed the "King Kong, Gorilla" stereo-type theme here! It's a picture, a suggestive one,but nonetheless a picture. However, Lebron & Giselle posed in other photos together that represent Vogue's classiness, style & elegance - which could've been used on the cover. This photo of Lebron's mouth wide opened was better served inside the Magazine. It's just not a typical Vogue Magazine Photo Cover!So it is weird to see! Had Lebron been by himself - this type of pose would not have been a big controversey. But throw in a White Woman & you have a recipe for disaster! Also remember, the month before the 2007 Oscars were presented - Vogue put Jennifer Hudson on the cover in the exact same "aggressive" POSE! Another young Black person, up & coming, star in her own right who was destined to win the Oscar for her role in DreamGirls. Jennifer Hudson like Lebron is a beautiful African-American who should've looked demure & sophisticated on the Cover - but had more of a "Wild" look to her. The shot was still beautiful but should've been classier.......

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Adam Stevens, Richmond, Virginia — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:04:47 GMT

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder and racism is in the eye of the beholder.

When I first saw this picture, I thought nothing of it until the racism drums started up.

One day this nation will evolve into higher thinking individuals; until then, we will have to deal with this type of elementary thinking…

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

J, Oly, WA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:16:10 GMT

People finding negativity in this cover of Vogue have enslaved themselves in a self-created world of experiencing nothing but another race and other people as their enemy or the oppressor of some sorts. We are all one - the same. Period. But people still choose to live without the freedom that's given by knowing that. They are choosing to see stereotypes or whatever negatives they continue to look for. They actually seek this by their own choice. By choosing to remain in this state, they are only enslaving themselves. They could move on to the freedom and world they think they are seeking at any second, but it's their choice to make, not a race's. Racism is a personal choice and in this instance with the people finding negativity in this cover of Vogue, the negativity was sought out and brought upon them by their own choice. It was not placed upon them by anyone else's doing.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Greg Birdsall, Roseville, California — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:16:39 GMT

The problem I see here is that our press perpetuates this type of controversy. It is unfortunate that people have to take a simple picture and put their political spin on it for whatever cause they feel it will help or infuriate. I see a picture of a fine athlete dipicting the core of his athleticism when he has to reach deep into his physical abilities to perform at his best and the opposite a delicate beautiful woman of simple beauty and grace. Its that simple folks, nothing more nothing less. To compare it to King Kong is that persons own racial bias. Not that of the photographer, Vogue, or anyone else. These issues take up way to much of Americas time, we need to quit whining about the little things and look at the bigger picture. It would help by not giving these people press time to which perpetuates the problem.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Gigi, New Orleans, Louisiana — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:20:58 GMT

My only thought on seeing this cover was that it's a good photograph of a basketball player doing what he's famous for (playing a competitive sport aggressively and enthusiastically) and a supermodel doing what she's famous for (looking great in clothes and makeup). I never even thought about the fact that he's black and she's white.
We will never be free from racism unless we free ourselves from it. Individuals must stop defining people by their race, and the media must stop giving racist comments a forum (surely the media can find a real controversy in this world if they try).
I was astounded and appalled that anyone would look at that cover and think "gorilla" or "King Kong". The individuals who make such comparisons are the ones who are perpetuating racist stereotypes.
I don't know whether some individuals are afraid to move past their race-based world view, or if they just enjoy being the focus of controversy. But there are many others who look at a person and see an individual, not a race.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

A. James Tennessee — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:21:11 GMT

I don't expect whites to see the stereotype perpetuated in this photo. You don't have to ever think about the black experience in America, and you certainly do not have to live it. This photo epitomizes the tendency to depict black men in quintessential extremes. They are either good Remus or primal proctector, on the one hand, or evil, on the other-- but rarely complex, e.g. Places in the Heart, Fried Green Tomatoes, even modern movies with Morgan Freeman(Dri Miss) and Denzel W. Imagine how V. arrived at the decision to pair him with Giselle.
They needed a counterpoint to the white,delicate, beauty. Aaahhh,yes. The beast. The big,powerful, raging, black man. So overdone. So tired.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

B.H., Atanta, GA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:26:13 GMT

I am a black man. I know racism when I see it. This is not racism. This is a top basketball player posing with a top model. He looks like he does when he plays basketball. She looks like she does on the runway. To even insinuate King Kong is absurd... I think the real issue is him with a Brazilian woman that is upsetting so many. We have real issues in the world. This isn't one of them. Let's choose our battles wisely.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Charles O., Gastonia, NC — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:29:57 GMT

It seems that some of both races seem to plant these negative thoughts into anyone they can to stir up controversy.

I agree that thoughts and comments like this are just causing more dissention among races.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Zach — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:33:04 GMT

I'd like to second what someone else said earlier-"the inability to see someone else's side is the heart of racism". I'm a black man. In a vacuum, I don't find anything particularly wrong with the photo. However, since it's been pointed out, I see the King Kong, damsel in distress comparison. My question-why does this photo evoke so much finger pointing? People are entitled to react to this photo however their life experience dictates. As uncomfortable as it may be for some to accept, our country's history of race relations is not resolved. Acting as if they are perpetuates the problem. Open dialogue, such as this format, is part of the solution.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Grace, Houston, Texas — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:34:16 GMT

"Black man wanting white woman"?! Gisele Bundchen is only part white. She's from BRAZIL with SOME German heritage tracing back six generations, according to Wikipedia. This photo is beautiful. Stop playing the race card, people. I am bi-racial, by the way.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

C. A, Bay Area, California — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:34:43 GMT

I think this photo is stunning! Catching two gorgeous people in movement and having the ball and her hair in action as well rounds out the shot. To capture the divine moment that symbolizes them both while they interact with eachother is amazing.

Anyone who sees racist images needs to examine themselves and what baggage they are projecting onto a gorgeous photo.

It is truly an instant classic with Anne's aesthetic eye for magic. Hopefully this controversy doesn't steal from it, or at the very least raises the dialogue.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

CharlesG, Gaithersburg, MD — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:35:06 GMT

I saw this story this a.m. on the Today show. Truly, I have no idea who either of the people are as I am not interested in sports or fashion. The teaser lead-in to the story asked if the photo was racist. I paused the TiVo, examined the photo at length, and it was not until the segment aired that I heard the comparison to King Kong and Fay Wrey.

Really, people! Is that a stretch or what? I could have looked at that photo all day long and NEVER has arrived at that conclusion! To me, it was a photo of a sports star and a fashion model, period.

As long as people keep dragging up the race issue, racism will continue. That's a hint to the Democrats if they have any plans to succeed in November.

Let's get beyond this!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

CG, Washington, DC — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:43:09 GMT

Notice how almost all the people from the South (and Texas) are dismissing the claims of the cover reinforcing racial stereotypes........ (Which it does, PS)

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Typical White Guy — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:43:22 GMT

"Please understand that that only applies to SOME black people, not all. Please do not form an opinion based on the ignorance of SOME people."

Thanks Darin! Generalizing about groups of people is wrong. Some people will see racism everywhere. Others won't. We now have lots of role models for people of all races. We have made strides in this country, like nowhere else. I believe that every group has within it a small group of racists. No one is exempt.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Scott B. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:51:47 GMT

The only people offended by this are the ones looking for a reason to be.They had to try pretty hard here.Lebron is a well conditioned athlete and it shows.Maybe that made some people have some self esteem issues and this is the only way they can vent.Give me a break with all this racist non-sense if this is this is the best they can come up with.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

David Hubbard, Scottsdale, AZ — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:53:17 GMT

People need to get over it. This is a beautiful photograph of an athlete and a model. It is doing what Vogue wants it to do, call attention to the magazine. I am sure thay had many poses to choose from and this one was the most energetic. People need to get off their PC wagons and get past their own personal bias. It is the 21st century; when are we all going to start getting along as a people? Seems like we will have flying cars long before we have true racial unity and equality.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Paul A. Wahl Steubenville,Ohio. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:53:49 GMT

I Honor and respect all people.Why the Action Pose of a Sport Professional is thought to be simiular to the the "Savage on Building Top."If another Professional Athlete was caught in the same view, would it be reminding of the Movie?
Yes this Movie Did Impact Society.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Keri Cohen, Los Angeles, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:55:05 GMT

RACISM STILL EXISTS AS MUCH AS YOU THINK IT DOESN'T. IT'S FUNNY HOW WHITE PEOPLE THINK IT WAS SO LONG AGO THAT BLACK FOLKS HAVE BEEN GIVEN EQUAL RIGHTS, BUT REMEMBER IT JUST HAPPENED IT THE 60'S. THE COORDINATORS OF THE PHOTOSHOOT MADE IT AN ISSUE WHEN THEY PRODUCED IT TO REPLICATE THE MOVIE KING KONG! IF YOU LOOKED AT THE MOVIE STILL FRAME, YOU'LL SEE IT'S THE SAME COLOR DRESS AND THE SAME POSITION. black peole bring up the issue that white people keep wanting to get away with.

It is ridiculous to me how white people can easily say to a black person to let it go, when racism is previlant. Maybe if the white editor of the magazine had some tack she wouldn't have produced this photoshoot to make an image such as King Kong out of Lebron. Guess this one didn't slip past the black people as I'm sure they thought it would. So if no one realized the issue that it's portraying Lebron as an ape, then it's okay? WOW!!! So if someone portrayed white people as trailer trash and no one realized it, then it's okay too? Or we should portray them as slave drivers and "blond and dumb", but be subtle enough so people can't really notice, and it will be okay. White people want to brush racism under the rug, when it's still clearly an issue here. Ignorance is bliss, isn't it?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lou Who, Detroit, MI — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:55:32 GMT

People who look for racism will find it. Never even entered my mind...LeBron looks like the superstar athlete he is...Giselle looks like the gorgeous supermodel she is...King Kong and Fey Wrey? Yeah - she looks terrified.....Come on people - there is more to worry about than this!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

YVETTE DETROIT, MI — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 16:56:35 GMT

IN RESPONSE TO SANDIE G SEATTLE WASHINGTON IT IS NOT BLACKS WHO MAKE RACE AN ISSUE IT IS WHITE PEOPLE WHO MAKE RACE AN ISSUE EVERYDAY FOR THE LAST 4 OR 5 CENTRIES WE (BLACKS) ARE ALWAYS LABELED AND HAVE BEEN SINCE I BEEN LIVING (51 YEARS) THE TERM AFRICAN AMERICAN IS A TERM I DISLIKE DUE TO THE FACT I WAS NOT BORN AFRICA I WAS BORN IN AMERICA IT SHOULD BE NATIONALITY NOT SKIN COLOR MY SON IS GERMAN/AMERICAN HE WAS BORN IN GERMANY BUT BECAUSE HE IS BLACK HE IS LABELED THAT. RACE IS THE GROUP FOR PEOPLE (HUMAN RACE) NOT COLOR WE ARE ALL THE SAME, PEOPLE BUT WHITE AMERICA MAKE THE DIFFERENCES NOT BLACK AMERICANS WE ARE JUDGED BY OUR SKIN COLOR INSTEAD OF OUR ABILTIES AND THE FACT THAT WE ARE HUMAN ALSO. THIS THE ONLY COUNTRY IN THE WORLD WHERE SKIN COLOR MATTERS IT IS IGNORANT/AND CRUEL TO THINK THAT WAY,WHITE AMERICA NEED TO CHANGE IN THEIR HEARTS, THOUGHTS, AND THE WAY THEY VIEW OTHER PEOPLE IN THE WORLD. LABRON JAMES IS AN EXCELLANT PLAYER BUT HE IS A KING NOR A GOD SO WE NEED TO STOP PUTTING THESE PEOPLE ON HI PEDSTALS AND ABOVE REPROACH THEY ARE HUMAN BEINGS ALSO. ALL THE SO CALLED CHRISTIANS NEED TO PRACTICE WHAT YOU PREACH AND TREAT EVERYONE THE SAME WE ARE ALL STARS IN THE EYES OF GOD THE CREATOR.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

ACTerry,Pine Knot, KY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:03:04 GMT

I think the expression on his face could be from pain if she were standing on his foot with a high heel. People "LET IT GO". There is much more important things to be worried about.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Almyra Hornberger Sullivan, Maine — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:03:50 GMT

Nancy Giles sounded hypersensitive to the cover. If every action, picture and words must be filtered through a black sensitivity censor won't we be experiencing another form of racism and prejudice? This is a photo of the bold and the beautiful and nothing else. Haven't atheltes been doing their macho image for years? Why this outcry of racism? Save your outrage for important things like the mortgage crisis and our economic woes. ARH

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sarah, Indiana — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:04:37 GMT

Just a note on LeBron's pose. . .if you look at all of the other photos in this collection, the athletes are being photographed as they are performing their specific sports, Shaun White on a snow board and Michael Phelps under water, just as LeBron is shown dribbling a basketball. While some may see that as stereotypical, a black man with a basketball, or even racist (due to his pose and the look on his face) I see it as nothing more that a photograph to accompany a profile on top athletes. I can perhaps see controversy if this were a profile on LeBron's incredible business sense, but it is not, it is all about his athletic prowess and impressive physique.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

JP, Cleveland, Ohio — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:04:40 GMT

I think it's easy for white people to say racism exists only because black people want it to because they have never been on the other end of racism. They don't know what it's like to be discriminated against. Or to be constantly be judged by skin color. It does exist, unfortunately. And to SANDIE G. it's ignorant to say "They should be celebrating the fact that LeBron made the cover and is being recognized." Why exactly? It's SAD that it took until 2008 to put a non-white on the cover. That is not a reason to celebrate. GET OVER YOURSELF! Anyway, I think Lebron is just trying to show the passion he has when he plays, I am a huge fan and this is a face I see every night he plays. I think it's a great cover!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

DB, Austin, TX — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:05:06 GMT

To me this is a picture of 2 beautiful famous people who look like they are having fun, not all "posey" like the usual Vogue cover photos. Controversy? I don't get it and I still don't see it. Sorry Debbie Downers.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ken A., Las Vegas, Nevada — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:06:50 GMT

If there's one thing I've learned over the years about racism it's this: If you're always looking for racism you're always going to find it... whether it's there or not. This cover (perhaps I should say this "contoversy") is a picture perfect example of that sad and outdated mentality.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

HuMan, Richmond Va — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:08:14 GMT

OK lets be real and civilized about this. racism will NEVER die in this country because such ignorance like racism, sexist, classism and other "ISMS" are selling like pancakes here in THIS country. I am a black man and when I see this cover there is nothing racist about it. just the thoughts and misconceptions behind a picture. it's a picture for god sakes!!! this is why we as black get mad at dumb conceptions like this. Everything is considered racist ONLY to racists. Soon as a real situation comes along dealing with racism, and prejudice; it will probably be swept under the rug because of the previous "cry wolf" comments about this magazine cover. USA is the only country that loves the HATE.

Just like Obama and Bill Clinton- Obama is considered not black enough; but Bill is classed as the first black president- Sorry to say but we have morally sodomized ourselves to the piont that now we don't feel right if we are not considered animals, beasts, ignorant, or dumb. Lebron James is not a dumb man and Gisele is NOT the most beautiful woman no matter what you think so chill out people get a grip on reality. I bet if Gisele had sex with Lebron you would probably hate her too for being with him...then what... will she be the most beautiful?

All you holier than thou so called "righteous" black leaders are just wrong for thinking about every little thing is a racial issue. stop it! you are the cause of much distress and YOU are the imbalance of what is and what isn't .....punks! fight and stand up for REAL injustice and stop worrying about a damn picture and what you precieve as this or that- get your facts straight!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Dave, Whitehall, PA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:14:29 GMT

You know I'm so tired of black people throwing down the racist card all the time. And I say black people because how can they call themselves African-Amercans if they're not even from Africa? I'm of German descent but I don't call myself German-American. Blacks call whites white so what's wrong with calling blacks black? Racism still exists, unfortunately, because blacks and other ethnicities want it to. But I digress. The Vogue cover is simply of two human beings posing and the photographer trying to capture their respective personas. NOTHING MORE. If you found it offensive, then you 're the racist....and a little ignorant.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

khadijah W. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:14:45 GMT

It amazes me that people who have never been denied a job, a promotion, a grade or seat in a class on the basis of race can expound in such detail on its non-existence. Isn't that kind of like an atheist with no religious background explaining, without any research, how the Pentecostal experience works? How can any of you people talk about race -- or feel priveleged to do so? Have you ever been called a coon? Had your brother called an N*#&#*? Watched as a roomate referred to another as "Aunt Jemima?"

I'm sick to death of all these comments about how we as Black people are somehow making up racism. That it somehow helps us to point out how a photograph is reminiscent of an allegory about colonialism and slavery (yes, if you know anything about either colonialism or slavery you should take another look at King Kong).

Here's a quick tutorial for all of you who seem to think you know so much about a topic that I doubt you ever took a class in, read a book about, or had more than a passing conversation with an INFORMED person of color about.

RACIALISM is bringing up the topic of race-- which matters all the time for people of color in this country even if white people can manage to NEVER have to think about it.

RACISM is discriminating systemically against a person in a way that supports the current race hierarchy (i.e., not hiring someone because he or she is not white).

DISCRIMINATION is a way of behaving towards someone that is premised on their race, gender, age, etc (and, not always negative-- I carry babies who can't walk, but rarely carry my 9 year old brother. -- that's discrimination).

Fine, you can't see a race issue-- I'm sure you didn't catch remember that Jesus (or Mary or anyone else mentioned in the New Testament besides the Romans) wasn't actually White when you saw the famed Gibson movie "Passions" (and this in a movie where the director studied detail so scrupulously).

This country has been built according to racial stratification-- if that has officially ended, I'd really like you to tell me the exact day and time when all racism in this country ceased to exist. THAT should be in the history books.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

R.Branch, Omaha,Nebraska — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:16:22 GMT

As a Black Man, I too am tired of Blacks trying to find someone to be racist. The first thing I noticed about the cover was how huge he seemed to be compared to her...mot that he looked like Kong.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Manuel, Brooklyn NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:19:09 GMT

I'm a black male, and I don't think the cover was racist, I think it was insensitive if not thoroughly thought out. It is simply unfortunate that the first time a black male gets on the cover of Vogue, he is depicted in this way, aggresively hulking over a beautiful white woman...(eye roll). Of course white people would not see it this way! It is not an indictment on you or your believes it simply not something you have to deal with on a societal level: black athlete + beautiful white woman (check), black man aggressive, brash, hulking, white woman elegantly dress, slim and beautiful (check).
Many of you are right, we would not be having this conversation if black men were a mainstay on a the Vogue cover; we would not be having this conversation if this was one of many vogue covers where black men were involved, no it is the first, and it sucks for us that the first brings up shades of so many stereo types...as a black male you can't help to look and it and say typical...and roll your eyes.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

shay taylor grand rapids michigan — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:19:28 GMT

you know, i had to read the article to see what the controversy was about, even after looking at the cover. i am a black female and i didn't see anything wrong with the picture. LeBron appears to be a very respectful, talented young man. Gisele appears to be a very strong and beautiful woman. it's sad when some people add negative things to other people's character. i would have choosen the other picture with LeBron sittings on the chair holding Gesele at the waist,only to show how handsome Lebron is from a woman's perspective.photographers see beauty in all things. So, please stop reading between the lines, "nothing is there".

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Edward B. NY,NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:20:16 GMT

As a person of mixed black heritage, I still took one look at this photo and felt uneasy. I also don't understand comments which suggest we are in racially sensitive times. In America this state seems chronic not acute. While not wholly offended by this photo, I must say it is certainly evocative of a less than positive image. The dress, her hair, her skin, his grimace and baring of teeth, his grip on her side. All iconic references, isn't that Annie Liebowitz' specialty?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sharon, Pennsylvania — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:21:16 GMT

Did anyone notice the basketball in the photo? How about the beaming smile on Gisele's face? These two celebs were photographed expressing their passion and beauty, each representing their individuality and excitement for their very different professions. Nothing more, nothing less.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rod Heffern, Madison, FL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:21:49 GMT

if there is no current controversy...then I guess it is time for the stirrers of the racism/sexism pot to serve one up, albeit lame. It must be a slow day or laziness that is driving this one. Where is the shame and/or blame that should be turned on these dim-witted people??

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

K.M. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:23:57 GMT

Personally, this reminds me of the freaks that believe they see the virgin Mary in potato chips and what not. If you are implying that the photo depicts racism, then you are implying the photographer took the photo this way intentionally thus implying she is racist. I think we can all agree, this is most likely not true. So stop trying to see what isn't there. Besides, I think the real chatter about this pic is that Gizelle totally looks like crap. It looks more like Lebron is holding a mannequin.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rhiannon, Minneapolis, MN — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:24:07 GMT

There are many people who study the effects of images within our society, most of whom are educated white people. Even if we do not realize what we are doing we convey ideas or beliefs about others with out having to say a word, i,e images. They are often subconscious things that we have been learned living a society where these ideas are so permiated into the fabric of everyday life. I don't believe that these things are done on pupose, but when the issues are not dealt with, they continue, and thats what we are seeing.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

j, chicago — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:25:28 GMT

Um, racism causes racism, not well-intended people perhaps misinterpreting images. And, Dan? No one is color blind. Why perpetuate that myth? It's OK to notice differences. (It cannot be avoided.) It's merely wrong to judge people by those differences.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Katherine — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:26:10 GMT

I am so tired of racial issues being brought about in circumstances that are purely innocent - the cover of Vogue shows 2 beautiful people in a pose that truly highlights both of their beauty. Comparing it to King Kong is just ludicrous! There is Black Entertainment Televion channel, awards shows for African American Films and talk of a Grammy-type awards show focusing on African Americans - can you imagine the outcry if it was anounced that there would be a White Entertainment Television channel???? Or a White-Only Awards show? Yet, white people are the racist ones? I think racism needs to be reexamined and it needs to be realized that it is instances like the outcry over the Vogue cover that just make some members of the African American community look ridiculous, oversensitive and starved for a reason to complain!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Pat, Camden,NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:37:05 GMT

How silly! Aren't there more important things in this world to worry about then weather LeBron James looks like King Kong in the picture? Give me a break. He is a talented athlete, and Gisele is a talented model. To me this picture depicts nothing more than that. As for racist, I don't see it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jessica S., Naples, FL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:39:32 GMT

"KING KONG"?

Like the resulting interpretations of an inkblot test, it is the viewer who sees "King King" on the Vogue cover, who is the racist! He is reflecting his own prejuduce by his interpretation of the cover picture. It is what he sees.

While this is an unusually beautiful picture series, I find it to be disturbingly SEXIST!

Go ahead - have a field day with MY interpretation!

Reasons?

The male (as usual) is the person actively doing something; the female (as usual), strikes a pose and looks pretty (beautiful in this case), but otherwise useless.

Despite the varied evoked psychological responses of the viewers, I find the contrasting pictures of these two individuals truly exquisite. The pictures selected and printed make up one of the best picture series I've ever seen.

This said - it is still SEXIST!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jayne, North Providence, RI — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:42:46 GMT

I see a two consensual adults posing in a photograph. Now if only that was me instead of Gisele! It's a great shot; as well as the others.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Hezi — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:49:09 GMT

I am a black and I mean BLACK man straight from Africa and there is nothing about that picture that remides me of a gorilla!!! Black folks stop being over sensitive about everything!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rain, Temple, PA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:52:19 GMT

The fact that most white people don't seem to have a problem with the cover is very scary. Let's examine the cover carefully: a scary/angry looking black man (many are comparing to giant gorilla King Kong) holding a beautiful, delicate-looking white woman...why wouldn't that be considered offensive? Weren't black men hanged years ago when they were accused of hurting and/or threatening white women? Weren't black people jokingly compared with monkeys on a regular basis?
White people seriously need more sensitivity training; black peoples' gripes are legitimate, whether white people want to acknowledge that or not. Because of the legacy of racism--yes, black people--unlike white people--must be sensitive and protective of how they are portrayed in the media.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jack, LA, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:52:49 GMT

People see what they want to see based on their preconceived notions. Its not racist and its not controversial. The media just wants everyone to believe it is. One person yells "controversy" and then the entire media publish articles and broadcast tv interviews because it creates a buzz and drama. Which in turn creates more web traffic and generates more advertising revenue. Its the britney spears effect and we've all fallen victim by reading this article and posting comments about it. I personally think the picture captures Lebron's intensity and dominance in the game of basketball - NOT an ape or king kong. It also captures Giselle's care free supermodel model-like spirit and its a great contrast of two very powerful figures in two different careers. What would someone expect - a picture of Lebron sipping tea while reading a romance novel?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sharee, Baton Rouge, LA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:53:23 GMT

Why do blacks have to make everything a racial issue? The real question should be why do white people continue to be ignorant of the fact that racism still exists in every aspect of life? When I first looked at this picture it didn't really jump off the page that it was racist but once I looked at the other covers that vogue covered blacks, an outstanding 4, this type of animalistic, crazy look seems to be the trend to portray blacks on vogue covers. It's really easy for whites to dismiss this as nothing but blacks trying to cry racism but then again, whites never have to put up with racism, all you people seem to do is try to tell other minorities that their claims are invalid and then cry victim when you get the blame for the racism culture of america, which you deserve. White america needs to wake up, no wonder every other race can't stand you.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jealous, IN — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:57:31 GMT

I would be glad to look like king kong to put my hand around her waist! The people who think this is bad need to get a life...

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jennifer, Philadelphia, PA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 17:59:12 GMT

People want to find something wrong with anything anymore. Get over it! There is NOTHING racist about this picture so stop trying to take something that is beautiful and make it ugly. We can't seem to appreciate beauty anymore, we want to take it and twist it and make it ugly and I think that is awful. I think the cover is awesome and I think this nonsense is just another way to stir the pot...get over it people, it's a piece of art, that is all it is, stop trying to make it into something else.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sistahgirl, Torrance CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:00:32 GMT

I would love to have been Gisele in this picture. LeBron looks hot in the photo. I'm a black woman and I am defiantly not offended by the picture. I'm offended that people are picking this to make a big deal out of when there is so much more negativity in the world. Lets pick our battles wisely people.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rick, Long Island, NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:00:51 GMT

Reply to Tampa, FL: I agree that "racism exists because black people want it to" is a stupid statement. I DO NOT agree that the cover is racist. The pose LeBron struck is so popular in many sports...watch any football player after a tackle, catch or touchdown, watch any ultimate fighter or boxer after a knockout, they all do the same thing: flex the arms and scream in victory! Black or white, strong males do this. Oh, by the way, we are all descendents of apes, maybe that is why we revert to this posture in times of strong victorious emotion. And I and many others (read the posts) can 'in reality, look at that picture and not see a black man striking a pose similiar to one made famous by Godzilla (Godzilla wasn't the ape) and holding a beautiful white woman.' I like what Brian posted, "It's a star athlete and a supermodel, raw masculine power and true feminine beauty. It's quite a clever picture." If LeBron James were dressed to the nines in an Armani suit, there would be those who would be screaming that he was being the white man's puppet, or something equally stupid as all of this!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

roy tolbert, chicago illinois — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:02:22 GMT

I don't see Kong, but I do see a stereotype image of the black athlete. He grimacing with his game face, and bouncing a basketball. Yes, all athletes are associated with the items of their sport; but would you see Steve Nash grimacing like that? Of course not! Nash, though a NBA all-star like LeBron, has a different game. Thus, a different picture would be shown. This type of magazine cover controversy has happened before. Some years ago, Sports Illustrated had two covers showing different athletes. One issue had Charles Haley in a close-up making a more exaggerated face than Lebron's. In your face and sweating. Another SI cover had Mark Bavarro and he was shown in the foreground serene with his helmet off and carring his shoulder pads. He was looking out in the distance. He was the "noble athlete". Charles Haley was black and Bavarro was white. SI noted the difference and said it was not intentional. But hey, isn't that how we view our athletes? Thus, is this picture any different?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Mel, Moses Lake, WA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:02:26 GMT

At first glance of this cover, it looks like LeBron was dribbling the basketball and in a defensive posistion. Giselle looks like she is having a good time. Where does race come to play in this photo? Oh thats right, its only the racists people who brought this up. Get over yourselves and quit reading into things that aren't there. I think all of us are beautiful regardless of color. For the Black people quit making issues that aren't there, why is it that your always bringing up ridiculous accusations? STOP! We aren't against you. Stop trying to fight a fight that isn't there. Its 2008, really let it go. Can't people just be people without pinning the color of their skin to them?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Curtis Columbia MD — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:03:24 GMT

I think it could by sterotypical racism without intent to harm. They could have showcased this multimillionare in something more conservative without him being a six nine silverback I ment penguine. I don't think that vogu was trying to go out of their way to create a contoversial cover. I don't think it would have been seen this way if it were Yao Ming or Dirk Novitski. Le Bron should always stay on the "Jordan" side of the media opting for a more conservative image. God forbid he ever get accussed of assault by a White Women. The only image that would surface would be this one. Vogue messed up but not intentionally.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

RTURNER, LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:03:27 GMT

I THINK IT LOOKS GOOD. I ONLY WISH THAT IT WAS ME
IN THE PICTURE INSTEAD OF HER.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jason Rosenfeld — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:07:16 GMT

The point is not that there is no difference from the image on the cover of Vogue and Eugene Fremiet's sculpture of a gorilla and a woman and later images of King Kong. Of course there is a difference: associations are quite different from replications. I have showed this cover to many people without comparing it to such images, not just academics like myself who apparently need to relax, and they have all said it it is strangely like King Kong. You can also search the web and find many other people who have come to the same conclusion. The idea was prevalent online, but mainstream media was laying off of it until ABC, and then ESPN and now NBC, took up the issue. My point is to reveal the reference for this type of image in the history of western visual culture.
Damsel in distress or not, there's something offensive about the way Mr. James is portrayed, hinting of the long history of "animality" associated with the black man/athlete. It is not that I think there is a particular way that blacks should be represented in the popular media, but that the accomplished and erudite portrait photographer Annie Leibowitz has made the choice to channel a tradition of racially charged imagery wherein blacks are associated with animality, often simian, and women, light-skinned or not, are shown as powerless victims. This indeed dates back to 19th century imagery such as that remarkably similar sculpture by the French animal sculptor Fremiet:
http://www.wfu.edu/~woodaljn/ant260/gorilla.jpg
At that time, this work participated in the culture of white colonialism by Western cultures, and was then later adapted, on a colossal scale, by the makers of the original "King Kong" in the 1930s.
This is not about blowing things out of proportion. No one is asking anyone to retract an image, or to apologize. This is about revealing the very real visual subtext of such imagery, a subtext clearly not immediately recognizable to everyone. To portray Mr. James in this light is depressing, and indeed it is a source of great sadness that such an image can provoke such an association in me. But that is because I know the history. And, crucially, to me it is off-putting. Such images are no more neutral than an image of a bent over and hunchbacked, old, bearded, man with the suggestion of horns -- a representation that will always bear the mark of anti-semitism. The ultimate problem, for me, in this Vogue cover, is that it does not subvert these animalistic images, it does not present a plausible counter-image to destroy the stereotype. By contrast, for example, Ms. Leibowitz's controversial image of a naked and preganant Demi Moore ("Vanity Fair," 1991), worked to explode female stereotypes and purportedly taboo subjects to present a richly empowered, proud, beautiful and novel conception of a woman. It played off of Ms. Moore's evolving power in Hollywood and her demonstrative nature. In short, it advanced the feminist conversation from which it emerged. Has Mr. James been so well served?
The present image of Mr. James and Ms. Bundchen, whether or not they purportedly had great fun at the photo shoot (and other images of the two seem to say they did, and would have made for an enlightened cover), welcomes and embraces these sad associations of power relations and racial stereotypes. But it does not challenge them, despite her characteristically giddy demeanor and lack of distress. That in itself is not enough of an intervention. She is, indeed, simply doing what she gets paid to do. And he is as well. It is the way that the two are combined here that calls up other associations.
Why is this an issue?
In the specific sports culture of basketball, where august personalities such as the announcer Billy Packer has found himself in hot water, and nearly lost his job, for referring to future NBA superstar Allen Iverson, supposedly affectionately, as a "tough little monkey," such things demand notice. That is one example. There is history here.
Images have power. Controversial images sell magazines. Vogue has every right to print this cover. Mr. James has every right to see himself portrayed as he wants in popular representations. Ms. Bundchen is free to play the gleeful, "sturdy," innocent in his arms. But to see the precursors for such images, and to understand their fraught history, and to be aware of the travails of blacks in Mr. James's profession (and their recent and comprehensive successes), is not to play the race card, it is not even to call it racist, because the picture clearly does not bear that intentionality. But this image in its reference is neither novel nor inert. To be able to recognize this is not to misinterpret it. The point in revealing this is to allow us to understand where we are as a culture and how we have come to this point. It is about advancing the conversation.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Scott, Ft. Lauderdale — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:07:38 GMT

After reading some of the comments on this page, and considering the events of the past couple weeks, ei. minister Wright, it has become apparent to me that racism certainly still exists in this country. Unfortunatly, and as a black man it pains me to say this, it appears that the majority of the racist people in this country are black and racist against white people, not the other way around. Please, let's try and see this photo for what it is: two beautiful, famous people. Not a black man with a white woman. Before I read these comments I stared at this photo for several minutes trying to decifer what exactly was racist about it. I came up with nothing. It's just sad that we are even talking about this. There will always be people in this country who are predjudice against people of one color, race, or religion, or another, but they are certainly in the minority at this point in time. Try and realize that, please.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

JTB — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:11:33 GMT

The reason this is a problem is because so many of you THINK the problem is in pointing it out! I'm a college educated black woman old even to have 3 college-educated children, I don't need somebody else to tell me when to be offended. If we had handled attitudes 100 or even 50 years ago this wouldn't have been a problem today. But I've had 55 years of hidden and overt racism to teach me that everything the majority population does means something and it often hurts me and mine.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ross, Memphis, TN — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:13:24 GMT

Shannon, get real...part of the reason racism still exists is because people like you don't recognize it. I agree with most of the people here that the picture is GREAT...and I agree that most of us didn't see any racism in the picture. As a matter of fact, the pic is really kinda hot. However, with all due respect I think your comments were way off base. "A crutch" and "get out of jail free card to play". Come on Shannon you can do better than that.....I guess.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Brandi Chastain, San Jose, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:18:34 GMT

Everyone is talking about racism, and I didn't immediately see it. As a woman, I immediately saw it from my experience of being a woman who lives and works in a world dominated by men. I saw a woman being held, saved, protected, taken, insert your own word here, on the cover of Vogue. Being an athlete, I saw LeBron as exactly what he is, strong, powerful, talented in his photo. Perhaps these are all the qualities that Gisele possesses but I only saw her physical beauty. The point I'm getting at is that we all will initially see things from our "own" perspective first. After looking at it for a second time, I wasn't taken aback and realized we must have perspective. I agree that there will be some who will be offended, and others that won't, and this is a great moment to share these with one another to find compassion and understanding.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lew, Kansas — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:21:32 GMT

Geez people...the cover says "Shape Issue Secrets of the Best Bodies Gisele & LeBron"...and you the people are seeing nothing but "Race Issue!" Get a Life!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Marie Valley Stream, New York — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:22:07 GMT

This is just a photo of a black man and a white woman. What are we doing? Every thing now has become a racial issue with blacks.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

enemysquirrel chicago illinois — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:24:48 GMT

Most people are missing the big picture. First of all, Giselle is Brazilian, Brazilians come in all colors, hers happens to be white. She has more European in her than say, Pele (obviously) or Sonia Braga (actress). So in reality, Vogue put two ethnic people on their magazine cover. And another point to make is, look at all of the responses in this blog. Most of the people who have responded, I assume white (sorry), don't see anything racial. Does this show progress? Does that mean that if the LeBron and Giselle were a true item, would that bother the same responders? Does LeBron really need the basketball? C'mon people!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jaine Blaize, Phoenix, AZ. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:26:16 GMT

Heather- to answer your question, if Le Bron was photographed with an black model on a white magazine, no one would be upset because there would be no racial overtones. Besides, I think that Bill Gates will go broke before a magazine like Vogue puts TWO obviously black people on their cover like that so therefore your scenario is not likely to happen. Then you asked if Gisele was photographed with a white athlete, would people act like this? Why would they? WHITE men haven't been routinely depicted as aggressive beasts the way black men have so there would be no racial overtones in that scenario either. You also asked,"What if a female black athlete, like Laila Ali, was photographed with a slender, white, male athlete, how would people react?" Again, no one would care because again it isn't white men that are labeled as aggressive beasts. Again, when was the last time you saw a an obviously African American woman being embraced as a damsel in distress by a big white guy ( a la John Cena) on the cover of a white magazine? Yeah...see? Unlikely isn't it.

So you see, all of your other scenarios don’t include the stereotypes that come with a black man being depicted as an aggressive, basketball dribbling protector of all women of non color. What we see is a stereotype. a BLACK man on the cover of a magazine that has NEVER had an African American on it, holding a WHITE WOMAN, while DRIBBLING A BASKETBALL looking ANGRY. You and I both know that they had several shots that they could have chosen from and didn’t have to use THAT particular picture. We also know that it is a FASHION magazine which means that it makes more sense for them to have put him in an Armani suit before they did this. But still, while there are many White people who are reality based and can see this for what it is, I’m starting to see that most people who do not have to deal with racism will minimize the experience as “self victimization” because they don’t have to live it or see it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Libby - Albany, NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:28:14 GMT

If people are willing to get all up in arms about the black/white juxtaposition, then I would expect them to be just as up in arms about the fact that all the other photos the accompany the story depict a man as the athlete and a woman as the beautiful shape.....where's the celebration of the female athlete in this piece?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

dave oxford maine — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:40:14 GMT

Gee, it's just a picture.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Steve C — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:41:28 GMT

Jeez, this is just crazy, but I bet more people will buy the magazine.....

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Grant Hardeway, Jersey City,NJ — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:44:55 GMT

It is interesting to "suggest" racial stereotypes, and to imply the King Kong-Faye Ray connection.
I would not have even made that connection had it not been "pointed out".
But, if I want someone's attention all I need to do is use sensationalism.(BIG BLACK MAN WITH WHITE WOMAN!) Imagine the sensationalism it would have caused 40 years ago!
Race will always be an issue in this country and that is sad.
As for the comments that others have left heaping all black people into one heap...I have nothing to say.
As for the black woman who probably wishes Lebron's hand was around her waist...I have no comment.
Keep in mind that there are those who look for an excuse to be offended.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

DIANNA, HSV., AL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:54:10 GMT

MAYBE, THE CONTROVERSY COMES FROM THE PHOTOS & TRAILER OF THE MOST RECENT "KING KONG" MOVIE.
THE BIG BLACK APE IS HOLDING THE NAOMI WATTS IN THE SAME POSE, UHMMMMMMM, WEARING A SIMILAR DRESS IN THAT UNUSUAL COLOR OF AQUA. SO UNTIL WE START TO RECOGNIZE ISSUES (SUCH AS THE SUBLIMINAL MESSAGE IN THE PHOTO),INSTEAD OF DENYING THEM, THINKING SOMEONE IS SOMEHOW INSINUATING THAT WE ARE FOR EVEN THINKING OF THE SIMILARITIES, BUT IT'S HAPPENING.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

jaij,the bay area,california — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:55:25 GMT

Wow,people have nonething else better to talk about. Its a beautiful photo with two beautiful people. I'm a black woman, and I dont see anything racial and sexual about it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Wendy, San Jose, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:58:35 GMT

My first reaction was, thank God that fashion magazines are portraying black/white couples AT ALL after several centuries of illicit pairings, rape, lynchings, etc. But if some people see stereotypes here, who am I, a white woman, to questions their motives and insult them? How sad that many white people are so sensitive -- the very thing they're accusing blacks of -- that they can't even consider that such a thing as racism MIGHT still exist. Take a look around, folks! Let the one who is without this particular sin throw the first stone.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sara, Seattle, WA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 18:59:23 GMT

When I first saw the cover photo for this issue of Vogue, I was struck by the contrast between the two characters in the image. An athletic, expressive, fun-loving, masculine LeBron James, and the petite, delicate, hyper-feminine Gisele Bundchen. The image struck me as interesting, beautiful, kinetic, and built on the tension between poles of wild masculine beauty and still flower-like femininity. I saw nothing gruesome or bruital in the posture of the man, nor anything victim-like in the dainty curve of the woman. I saw a contrast between the larger-than life world of a man who gets paid handsomely to play a game with passion and motion and verve, and a woman who also gets paid handsomely to create an artistic and aspirational image of elegance and beauty in photos and on runways.

The graceful, muscular pose of LeBron's outstretched arms, expressive features show a powerful, beautiful man in a moment of joy. This photo is a celebration of the broad spectrum of beauty we all occupy, and is tasteful, breath-taking, and full of life.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ran Say — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:04:23 GMT

This is what liberals do. They sit around and create racism even if there is none. They are consumed with race. It's pitiful.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Hera K — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:11:19 GMT

o let's say that Money Magazine was doing an issue about saving money and the value of a dollar. How many of us would be ok with them showing a clearly Jewish man on the cover with a bag of money that he's holding away from everyone else? Let's also say that there's a bar code in the background that could be perceived as a scanner code for a product but..... you can't be sure. Do you think that a Jewish person would accept that this was simply an article about saving money and not about the stereotype that Jewish people are stingy and cheap? The answer is no. No Jewish person in their right mind WOULDN'T be outraged!!! In fact, they would be up in arms and pulling their endorsements left and right because there are many white people who don't understand cultural sensitivity but do understand when their pockets are hit. But then again, you'll never see anyone do this to Jewish people nor will they minimize their plight because 1) Jewish people are for the most part united and won't put up with this nonsense and 2) When white people look at Jewish people they don't have to deal with the guilt associated with them as their holocaust wasn't done on American soil. But the bottom line is that the scenario is still the same and if you flinched at the thought of a Money Magazine cover looking like this then it should be food for thought about the LeBron cover.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Yolanda Albany, NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:12:25 GMT

I am a black woman and I think the cover is beautiful I don't see it as racist, Giselle looks like she is having a great time so is LeBron. People need to stop fueling the fire of racism it's not healthy for any of us Black, White, Red, Green, Brown. I didn't notice the King-Kong thing until I read it in the article. See not all BLACK People are racist or are blaming WHITE people for everything that is not good in their lives.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

EmK, Washington, D.C. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:14:58 GMT

A lot of the people posting here seem ignorant of the very real history behind King Kong and its depiction not only of a European woman and non-human creature characterized as Africans were then characterized, but of the "tribal" villagers of the original movie itself.

Anyone who is aware of this history will see the similarities between it and the cover--I did, almost immediately. My first thought (this was last week when I saw the cover flash briefly on a sports television show promoting the magazine) was "What the heck? Is this a joke?" I now see that it was not my imagination, and that the mainstream media has picked up others' similar reactions.

To the woman in Texas: White people are not "under attack" as you "feel." It is not attacking European-Americans to express dissatisfaction with the way a non-European group is unflatteringly portrayed. An analogy: there is nothing unflattering to the non-disabled in pointing out that a TV show or movie makes caricatures disabled people.

And yes, it is unflattering to pair an agressive, hulking African-ancestry man with a slim, blonde, Euro-ancestry woman. Why? Ask the makers of King Kong--they froze this caricature into the racist canon. Without this history, this mag cover would have much less resonance.

Stop feeling under attack and you will not be so. Start listening to people's concerns with an open mind, and you may realize there is truth to their worries, even if you have not experienced them.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Daniella C., Norwalk, CT — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:16:49 GMT

You have got to be kidding me!! Some people seriously have too much time on their hands. Take it for what it is - Two very in shape and beautiful people - End of story. Take it or leave it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Heather M, Rochester Hills, Michigan — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:19:38 GMT

If you take a look at the caption, it is world's best bodies: A model and an athlete. LeBron is supposed to look muscular and aggresive on the court, so why not off the court as well? What do people want? Him to be huddled in a corner with Gisele's foot on his chest? That would cause another issue in itself. People are looking way too much into things, which makes me wonder if Americans have too much time on their hands to complain about this? Maybe we should focus on things that actually do need to be addressed.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jimi Sanchez, Tacoma, WA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:20:14 GMT

Race never occured to me. What did occur to me was that the ability to bounce a ball guarantees fame, money, beautiful women and the cover of Vogue. That the two people were different colors didn't penetrate until the Today Show segment. Why does the media always seem to focus on the negative?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sue - St Louis, MO — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:21:50 GMT

Why do people ALWAYS have to make EVERYTHING into a racial issue? The majority of people do not see a racial thing. My gosh, it's two beautiful people on the cover of VOGUE! Who is having a problem with this?? .. GET A LIFE!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Cindy Liu, Monterey, California — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:22:01 GMT

Mixed-race female here - upon 1st glance at the cover, I remember thinking cool photo and almost picked up the mag for purchase. Upon 2nd glance, I took in their physiques and vowed to finally abandon my sugar habit. After taking another glance by way of this article. . .I just can't get into agreement with the black v. white logic. Regardless of who proposed it - it's ludicrous.
. .. still think it's a great photo though :)

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kim, Fort Worth, TX — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:28:43 GMT

No racism...this would just be a better picture for inside the mag. If you follow the "better photos" link, there is a much better pic of Giselle and LeBron.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Margie, Richmond, VA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:30:18 GMT

I just can't believe so many people are up in arms over this cover. Hearing that it was a "controversial" cover, I expected something off the wall. When I looked at it, I saw nothing unusual. Just two people who are at the top of their profession. LeBron exudes his athleticism and game face in the photo as does Giselle. She's a model, this is what she does!!! She gets paid to look beautiful and she's doing a great job on the cover with LeBron! For people to compare LeBron to the likeness of King Kong is absurd. Did you ever see King Kong play basketball? Let it go people!!! The picture is not about the color of our skin. It just portrays two people of size and shape (the premise of the issue). Can't we just enjoy the photo and embrace and the beauty? Let's stop making it about race and enjoy what life has given us. Life is way too short!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Amy, Huntington, WV — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:30:20 GMT

I truly don't understand why this is an issue. Nancy Giles is crazy if she thinks this picture is anything but art. It's beautiful. The Lebron you see on the cover is the Lebron you see on the court. He is beautiful, powerful and great at what he does. It's not about race of any kind. It's the celebration of two beautiful people and what they do best. Lebron obviously approved these pictures and I don't believe if he thought for one moment he was to resemble an ape he would have allowed it. People (Nancy Giles) need to stop making something out of nothing. Not everything has to be a black and white issue.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

jennifer, rochester, mi — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:31:32 GMT

why does that woman get to say lebron looks like an ape? if ann said that or thewhite man said they they would be out of a job. the perpetuating of sterotypes comes from african aericans who want to keep the racism alive. no white people are making a big deal out of that photo. the only people who seem to have made a king kong connection, as ridiculous as it is, are the african americans who just can't let it go. stirring the pot is what they strive for.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

COLUMBUS, OHIO — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:35:47 GMT

As I sat and read over ALL of these comments and viewed the picture I can't help to question why so many feel that it was an African American who felt that he was portrayed as a "Gorilla" or we as African Americans are the one's who is stirring up the controversy? There is no mention as to "who" stated that controversy but that "Others" will see it as some sterotype. I agree with with many patrons on here who commented that its just a picture of two Famous people. No More, No Less. And if there was another picture they could have used BUT they didnt this picture doesnt scream "GORILLA" or that WE as African Americans are on a "racism bandwagon". If anything african americans want the RASCISM to STOP! Please AMERICA-quit feeling that African Americans make everything a Issue (sandie in GA/Shannon) We are not trying to make anything an issue of Race.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Gigi, New Orleans, La. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:39:57 GMT

Several people have commented that white people (and especially those from the South!) can't see the racial stereotype in the photograph because white people don't experience racial discrimination against themselves. Well, I've got to disagree with that.

As a white woman, I have been told on two different occasions not to even bother applying for a job because "they" (one was a corporation, the other was a government entity), were only hiring black people.

I went into debt for tens of thousands of dollars for college tuition. A black woman in my class, who was less qualified than me according to the criteria used by the college-ie, she had lower grades and test scores- was given a full scholarship.

Once I walked up to two black people who I didn't know and politely asked for directions. I was completely ignored, as if I didn't exist, even though I was only two feet away.

Once a young black man saw me driving, stopped in front of me in the middle of the street, and looked me in the eye while he spit on the hood of my car. Some might assume that was because of race, but I really don't know.

I could go on with more but there's no point. Those things don't matter because I look at each person as an individual not as a race or a stereotype.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

g miller — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:41:19 GMT

I am so sick of everything becoming a race issue. Why can't it just be what it is, ART?? also if the two models on the cover of the magazine don't have a problem than why should anyone else? This is probably why Vogue does not put African Americans on their cover Look what happens when they do.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Chas — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:46:55 GMT

A cover of a mag people, and all of this? And you wonder why America can't progress past race, and probably never will?!?..

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Laura, Charlotte, NC — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:52:13 GMT

I've read several of the comments made about the Vouge cover with LeBron and Gisele and all it really proves is that we, as americans, are still ignorant when it comes to racial issues. I believe there are a lot of us who are willing to and have cut the racial lines and kept it moving. But because there are a lot more who aren't, you end up with comments like the one made by "Shannon". You point out to me one black person that WANTS racism to continue. You point out to me one black person that has ever HAD a "get out of jail free card" to use. You point out to me one black person that has SUCCESSFULLY used racism as an excuse or crutch and gotten the results they wanted. The reason racism still exist is becasue of that type of ignorant thinking. Racism does not discriminate; it happens within as well as outside of every race. I saw the rest of the pictures they could have used on the cover and honestly, the one they picked was the best. Nobody cares about the cover of this magazine, controversy sells. And they new exactly how to get the ball rolling: "LeBron James is the first African-American male to be on the cover of Vouge".......need I say more?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Joanne Deutch — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:57:29 GMT

It is a beautiful picture. I just don't see the problem. Don't people have bettert hings to fuss over, like people losing their homes, gas prices, can't heat your house, food too expensive, college costs, on & On. I love the contrast in the picture. It is sexual yet playful. I think we all are having heart attacts over the simplest things.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Chas, VA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 19:58:56 GMT

Dave from PA:

I agree with you man.. but I think "African American" is something that others, along with some "uppity" Blacks 'labeled' all Black people as. A part of so-called "Political Correctness"! For the record, most Black People just want to be Black because we AREN'T from Africa..We are Americans..PERIOD. And most of us (And I mean a very large majority here) don't use our race as a crutch.. I said MOST of us!
Please don't get it twisted, and please don't clump all of us together.... OKAY? Thanks.
Now, back to the mag.... It's two PEOPLE! Geez!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Nicole, Buffalo NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:02:17 GMT

It's funny how folks are quick to say it's the media. Well, how do you fix it? My questions is why has such a lovely and well respected magazine such as Vogue have only had 4 african americans on it's cover ? Black women, people of color for that matter are beatuful also. It you think there is no rasicm in the in the world then try this experiment... Put a black doll and a white doll in front of a black or white child... let's say 4 or 5 yrs old. Guess who is prettier, smarter, etc... Yes... I don't thinkg this cover is racist, but the media is a powerful medium. At least folks are talking. Are you listening.... is the quesion!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ally, NY, NY — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:06:16 GMT

I got back from Europe yesterday and was so excited to see my Vogue, not to mention a cover shot that was both intriguing and editorially pleasing. Giselle is a fabulous model and I think more than anything, LeBron James is portrayed as intense, not savage or ape-like. I feel like people are always trying to make eveything about race when it doesn't have to be. To me, I see hard versus soft - a fashion shot in and of itself which represents a long-loved idea in the world of clothing. We've seen countless looks of feminie versus masculine, and what is this if not that? It's a pretty cool shot to me, and until my mom mentioned the news this morning I had no idea that people were so outraged. How can people see hate rather than the beauty Vogue is offering up? And Annie Leibowitz is a photographer who catches interesting and juxtaposing emotion to create a resonse. Unfortunately I don't think this is the response for which she was hoping.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

DEANA SEATTLE WA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:08:13 GMT

PLEASE EVERYONE GET A LIFE.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Elle, Atlanta, GA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:21:48 GMT

You have got to be kidding me! You have two great people on the cover, leave it to some to judge by race.

Get real people, leave it alone!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Shelly — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:23:53 GMT

You can only pull the racism card so many times and for SO MANY YEARS...before it gets old...and I for one am over it. If anything perpetuates racial stereotypes the most...it is a good majority of the black artists (if that is what you can call them) that all they sing about is the degrading of women, call each of the N word, sex and guns.

When I saw the cover, it looked like a successful (yes, black man) having fun and enjoying himself... enjoying his success. Heck I know alot of guys who get that same look when there are intense during any kind of sports game. So what better to have one your arm at the height of your game.... a beautiful woman.

Would it had gotten the same reaction if the woman had been black and not white... I don't think so.. so the real question is what are all these people REALLY upset about?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

John Doe, Nashville, TN — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:24:54 GMT

That photo is outrageous. I am an angry black man and I have this question. Why do we all dance on shells and pretend that the world is a better place then yesterday when we know it's not. In fact, the truth is the world is worse. Because, now what used to be open racism has transformed into hidden racism. And from reading all of those articles, I assume that the majority of Americans think that closet racism is fine as long as noone is hurt. The problem is people do get hurt. Why don't you look at a place as simple as a school cafeteria. We all know what we see, and that's where the truth is. I know it's hard to accept but a hatred still boils in the heart of America, a hatred that has even taken a hold of half of America's black population. This is a Hatred aimed towards impoverished blacks, blacks from the "hood" as stated in popular culture. America's got to open their eyes and first accept that they still have a sense of fear and prejudice towards these types of blacks. What is that fear? The fear any white person is hit with as soon as they cross boundaries into the ghetto. The fear that keeps our kids separate in the cafetaria. That fear is an honest sensation that tells us that "It" is still there. And I am not preaching for racism, but I just hope that people stop prentending, because until a problem is faced, hiding it will only make it worse. And when i say worse my main example is at blacks who have adopted their own sense of fear and prejudice towards the idea of the ghetto. It's a shame but it's true and you know what I'm talking about. The disapating racism that America has grown to see is between whites and the privileged blacks. Let's just remember that not all us blacks are privileged.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

S. Gainous — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:28:18 GMT

This is a great, eye grabbing pic....Isn't that the intent?????

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Southfield, MI — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:29:35 GMT

Before you rush to judgment that it's not racist..

http://www.usatoday.com/life/people/2008-03-24-vogue-controversy_N.htm

But magazine analyst Samir Husni believes the photo was deliberately provocative, adding that it "screams King Kong." Considering Vogue's influential history, he said, covers are not something that the magazine does in a rush.

"So when you have a cover that reminds people of King Kong and brings those stereotypes to the front, black man wanting white woman, it's not innocent," he said.

O'Connell, the Vogue spokesman, declined further comment.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

BJ, Augusta, GA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:30:50 GMT

The people that think this is racist are the ones that are looking for something to talk about. Then again, that is the climate of the world....I am just proud to see two beautiful people on the cover! Get a grip people and PICK YOUR BATTLES in life!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

JaNell, Evans, Ga — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:35:14 GMT

To Sandie in Seattle, please don't group people together because of their similarities...when you said "why do blacks always make it a racial issue"...I am black and offended that this is an issue so don't group me with ignorance...I wouldn't do it to you or anyone. Come on people...realize that WE ARE ONE...we are AMERICANS!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Roxie, Dallas, TX — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:39:12 GMT

As a young black woman I DO NOT see the race issue in this photo. It is a very nice photo of two people at the top of their game!

Don't believe the hype...not everyone see's race in a photo, statement, or gesture...please remember that folks.

Peace

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tamara R., Sacramento, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:39:21 GMT

I think to label the cover photo "racist" is misleading. I think the photo does perpetuate an image of black "animalistic" masculinity and white "virtuous" feminity. I was very disturbed at Ann's interview this morning. Donnie was able to dominate the interview and say "it's not racist. that's crazy" without discussing why some blacks may have a negative reaction to the photo. This is what Nina Giles should have said: within the black community its a running joke about black atheletes and their propensity to date/marry blond women. The joke comes from pain because its rooted our country's history of creating the black male image as animalistic (from slavery to present day), a predator of white women. We don't have to go as far back as slavery to find that image. It was used to justify killing 14 year old Emmett Till in 1955 and the reason TIME magazine darkened OJ's mug shot in 1994. I wont assume that Vogue didnt consider this when choosing Lebron and Giselle for the editorial. I am a black woman and I wasn't offended by the picture, but I was concerned that Vogue chose to glorify this particular image.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Joe, Carmel, IN — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:42:09 GMT

Is it not up to Lebron to choose what he wants to do? I am sure he saw it before it was published and he approved. If you saw the movie 'King Kong' you know that he was the good guy.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Duncan, Atlanta, GA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:42:34 GMT

Shannon writes,

"This story made me chuckle. Part of the reason racism still exists is because black people want it to. It gives them a crutch and an excuse to complain. It also provides them with a get out of jail free card to play. I never would've read into this what others have. King Kong? Black man wanting black woman? Come on....really?"

You made my "chuckled" with your silly perhaps stupid comment. I didn't see the King Kong thing. The whole thing is over-blown. But let's get to your narrow mind. We want racism to continue? Oh really? A crutch and excuse to complain? You must have been around blacks all your life cause you got us figured out (not even close). This black man (meaning me) and most others do not receive "get out of jail free" cards for anything. That was a dumb choice of words. Having said that, I'm not offended by your ignorant remarks as I can discern who is on the outside looking in and those who are culturally seasoned when dealing with people outside of their own race. Grow up and educate yourself beyond your culture.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Abby, Sunnyside, Washington — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:43:27 GMT

When I 1st seen this cover, I thought, "Wow, that's fierce, I like it!" It shows his excitedness & her physique. When I heard the controversy over it, the 1st thing that came to mind was, "Who has that much time to look so deep into pics & cause a stir over it? Some people just want attention." I pride myself on being an embracer of all races, I am Hispanic by the way. When situations arise, I try to look at it from both sides w/out bias. Now that I have had time to really look at the pic. & comments of people, I realize that both sides make a good argument. I can see where other races are not offended because frankly, they don't understand. It's understandable how they think it's just another reason for blacks to complain, because realistically, many people do purposely cause problems for entertainment or because they will find any reason to get a rise. Blacks need to understand that some people don't catch things because they don't notice color, and they realize it after it has been brought to their attention. On the other hand, I could see how blacks would be offended because whether or not he has a players stance & look, it does resemble that of a gorillas, and holding a white woman w/that intimidating look on his face doesn't make it any better. It's always great to see magazines celebrating people, their accomplishments, & then trying to take a picture that captures that essence. It would be lovely to have a pic taken w/no aftereffects, but we live in a world where there is still racism-wanted or unwanted-, & w/people who have a harder time trying to look past things then others. I doubt this pic was taken w/that intent, & it's sad that we still have these kind of controversies (the fact that this has gotten so much hype has made it worse). I do agree w/the fact that if there was diversified staff, someone would have caught it. A better pic could have been taken, one that wouldn't be misinterpreted this way, that way everyone's happy. It's better to be cautious then to cause an uprising because we fail to take into account possible outcomes of an action or pic. By not being understanding, people are fueling racist remarks by upsetting the offended ones, because it makes them seem ignorant to others' feelings. We just need to accept that everyone's diff & diff situations spark diff emotions/actions. Just because something doesn't upset you doesn't mean everyone sees it the same way. I am not taking sides, I am just pointing out the need to be open minded on both ends. It's up to every individual to decide to look past things and see beauty or be offended. Yet, no matter what, there will always be those who have a problem w/something. But if LeBron didn't mind it, then it shouldn't bother anyone else. There are so many bigger things to worry about.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Pam, St. Louis, MO — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:43:32 GMT

I am a black woman and I don't see anything wrong with this picture. Lebron is an aggressive basketball player and I think the picture captures that essence. Gorilla-like didn't even come to mind. If Lebron was on the cover of Sports Illustrated by himself with this same photo, there wouldn't be any controversy.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Brenda Brown, New York — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:47:20 GMT

what annoys me more than the cover controversy are the people who commented african americans are always playing the race card. You are racist because you lump all african americans into the same thought process that the media projects. what makes you think the majority of african american people had no issue and just saw two people on the cover of a magazine and didn't think anything of it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Angela B, Inglewood, California — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:52:41 GMT

Are you serious??? This is "controversial"? It's a picture!!! People have got WAY TOO much time on their hands to let things like this bother them. I'm a white/hispanic woman married 7 years to a black man...Let the "controversy" begin.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

K. Johnson, Alexandria VA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:53:28 GMT

I don't see the picture as racist, however, it is not the best picture. Do I think it serves as an image of what people have been saying it looks like "No", but I don't think it was the best choice in facial images for him up against a woman looking as to move away from an aggresive looking man. I do believe in looking at style.com that their were much better images that could have been placed on the cover. I do not really like the picture, but I do not judge him for the picture nor judge the strength, beauty, and intellect that black people have to offer by images seen in these types of magazines. I am an educated, black woman. We have to put things in perspective and at times wonder what the motive is behind certain imagines, but also the motive behind the media making a story out of something that might not have otherwise been a story. Does it continue a cycle that we should be working to end?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Scott, Bay Area, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:56:26 GMT

I love this picture! LeBron is in awesome shape! He truly is a force to be reckoned w/, both on the court and in the gym. He "screams" power, focus, dedication and intensity. Gisele? Well, what can you say? She is welcome to sidle up alongside and pose w/ me any day... but I doubt a chubby non-athlete like me would make the cover of Vogue. As far as controversy? We all have better things to be doing than posting comments and fueling this story.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Abby, Sunnyside, Washington — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 20:59:26 GMT

I also agree w/the fact that people sometimes do things that seem racist (although the person is not), not consciously realizing it at the moment because of the society we live in, a society that tries so hard to get past race but cannot seem to find a way to do it. Esp because he was the 1st black man, they could have had the chance to take a really appealing pic. I also agree w/the fact that if you like it, buy it, if not, don't. If you don't have an opinion, be quiet. But don't slam down others because they don't feel the way you do, it just separates everyone even more.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Anne, Fernandina Beach, FL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:02:03 GMT

I saw the other photos, and my impression is that, this one had more real, raw LIFE to it than the others...it draws the eye and evokes a visceral response. Not because of race, but because of emotion and passion -- it's awesome. He looks fierce and strong and vital...she looks elated. He's gorgeous...and Giselle appears to share that opinion...look at her 1000-volt smile...he's flaunting raw masculinity...what's the problem? The others are visually appealing, but bland by comparison.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Mireille, Brooklyn, New York — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:02:40 GMT

Fitst of all Lebron is dribbling a basketball which is why I do not see where the refference to King Kong comes in. 2nd Giselle is not a caucasian woman. She is Brazillian, which makes her Latin.
The only people who see this cover as racist, are those who are racist themselves.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jana J. Montclair, NJ — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:06:53 GMT

The world needs to grow up!!! Good grief.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

T Gaugler — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:10:53 GMT

Jared Rohm's picture is more like a King Kong/Fay Wray picture. He is WHITE though so no one mentions that photo which depicts Jared in a hulk like pose, mean looking with a white model flung across his shoulders like he's taking her away like King Kong. This picture with LeBron is making a mountain out of a mole hill. Liberal are OBSESSED WITH RACE!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Julie, Charlotte, NC — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:14:18 GMT

The picture is excellent and certainly ties to the 'best bodies' article. How are things in Iraq? Are we still at war? Seems like a lot more could be covered on a news program.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

DEE Gee — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:16:30 GMT

Hello Sandie I myself am a black man, and find your comments of all blacks making everything a racial issue offensive. I myself don't have a probelm with the cover not because of the images, but because I feel that Lebron had the power to stop this cover from being brought to the pubilc, if he found it offensive, no one put a gun to his head and told him to allow it to be displayed, so I don't have a probelm with Vogue, because Lebron was in the driver seat not Vogue on what images would be displayed to the world. I do have a probelm with anyone black or White painting a group of people with the broad brush of sterotyping, please think before you accuses a whole races of people of something. We all don't think the same.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Janice , Spring Hill, Tennessee — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:19:41 GMT

All I saw was two beautiful, successful people on the cover of a magazine. I am sick of the race card being played everytime I turn around. If the issue of race continues to be brought up, it will continue to be an issue. Let it go already!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Darnelle Los Angeles, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:20:54 GMT

Get a grip, it's a photograph for cryin' out loud!!! It will evoke different responses from every person. If you don't like it look at something else...think of it as a picture assignment.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

chris burton, rock island, IL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:27:13 GMT

I dont fell as there was any racism involed with the process of picking the photo, because if it was he would have never been on the cover, as african american male i like to see more of us.. i love to be on the cover of vogue its a huge honor to us in the fashion world, but as far as the photo i did feel there were better photos that could have been used, but as far as race being a factor i highy doubt it!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Joy, New Orleans — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:27:23 GMT

I can't believe that Shannon would say that racism still exist because black people want it to. But on the contrary I can because she must be a white woman who has not been denied a job, or access to a quality education and much more simply because of the color or her skin. We did not enslave ourselves for over 400 years white people did. We are not responsible for the injustice in the world. But maybe you have forgotten that when my ancestors did protest the unfair and inhuman laws that were created your white ancestors, they were beaten, attacked by people and dogs, lynched and killed. Just the tip of the iceberg and you must remember that it was only 60 years or so that these particular events happened. We are still fighting for rights that some white people feel we don't deserve. Recently, the voting rights act. We are the only race that has to renew is every fifty years or so. Why is that? We did not create this law, your white ancestors did. So before you go placing blame on the entire African American race you need to read more of our history and realize that you would not have a history if it wasn't for my black ancestors. Would you blame a woman if she was raped because she looks nice and has on a short skirt? And by the way, the media knows that it has a major influence on how some of us think and feel, so it is important for them to be responsible. We need to see different images of our men because we so often see them arrested, or put down in many ways. It is just nice to see them in a different light.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Keith Palmer, Boise, Id. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:34:03 GMT

Gee! Where to start?
First off, I suppose I should admit that I'm a 54 year old white guy who can trace my family back to Massachusettes in 1620 on one side, Sweden three generations back on the other. Grew up in the L.A. area before coming to Idaho 15 years ago. I'm certainly not racist, but I do know racism exists,as do all sorts of other prejudices.
Anyway, I think the cover is beautiful, artistic, fun, thought provoking , and just downright brilliant marketing.
But it is NOT RACIST. Annie Liebowitz is a brilliant photographer and this just proves it. She not only produces undeniably beautiful photographs of people of all kinds, but a simple image can evoke so much emotion, views that span the spectrum of ideas and beliefs, and show us more about ourselves.
The contrasts are wonderful. White vs. black, big vs. small(although I think Gesele is close to six feet tall), intense vs. playful, fierce vs. vulnerable. And both these people are absolutely beautiful and fit.
It fascinates me to see the clamor this has caused. Obviously there needs to be a more open dialogue on race in this country. And this picture is not a racist image , but rather a mirror.
I would not have caught the King Kong/Faye Raye inferrence if it had not been pointed out, but it's definitely there. But it is the interpretations we put to these references that shows us who we are.
It's been a while since I saw the movie King Kong, but as I recall it, King Kong was not the beast but a misunderstood gentle soul whose temper only came up after gregious mistreatment. She was not the damsel in distress but the only one who loved and understood the beast. Her fear was not for herself, but for the beast whose actions she knew would be misinterpreted.
I don't know who first raised the cry of racism regarding this cover (yet), but that opinion is uninformed and misguide. They don't get the joke. One can see a predatory black man and a helpless white woman, or one can see a hardworking astute businessman and an airhead pretty face(again I'm sure she isn't- you don't get to the top of any field that way)
What many seem to have missed in this whole discussion is that in the fields of both fashion an sports, people have transcended this issue more than any other parts of our society. Pele and Xuxa, Tiger and Elin, Seal and Heidi Klum, Eva Longoria and Tony Parker. I could go on and on, but the point is that racism is not the issue among these people as it is in the rest of society. Hard work, dedication, persistence, sacrifice are what matters along with truly using god given gifts, whether they be athletic ability or natural beauty. And Annie Lebowitz has shown us that there is beauty in all of us.

I know that racism exists-on both sides. I grew up in an all-white community only a few miles from L.A. It was that way because of real estate redlining back in the 50's and 60's- downright wrong. We had the first black students, 3 of them, my senior year in a school of 2700 students. They were just regular kids like the rest of us. So although there were racial tensions and even riots in places nearby, I didn't experience that and had no racial prejudice, but I remember talking with my friends about the prejudice there was in older generations and not understanding it. When I graduated in '71 and went out into the real world I tied to be open minded, but in driving deliveries around LA I found that no matter how accepting I tried to be there were some blacks who hated me because I was white.
So to the blacks who have commented here, I have experienced reverse racism, and it does no service to the black community. Although it has given Al Sharpton a reason to exist.
And I understand that the is racism against blacks and it does no service to the white community.
Maybe we can take an example from fashion and sports-these people seem to be more enlighted and maybe they actually are worth the money they're paid.
and let me close with a quote of great philosophy from a most unlikely source: in the words of Rodney King, "Can't we all just get along?"

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

M.J. Bridge, Canoga Park, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:40:35 GMT

I have no idea who the people are on the cover and I just thought they must be the top in their field and are being interviewed in the magazine. They just happen to have their pic together. As far as RACE is concerned, I was glad it wasn't yet another white man, non white woman. It's getting OLD.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tyler, San Diego — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:53:06 GMT

JP...how can you say white people are never the victims or racism? Please!! Drive through Harlem at 10pm or Detroit and tell me we wouldn't be the victims or racism!! Double standard? The only people who are complaining about this are the ones who want controversy. Ever think that racism exists because you want it to? I believe we should never forget our past, but do we need to rehash it every day and live today as if the past just happened? Learn from what once was. Abolish the NAACP, United Negro College Fund and all other racist organizations. Or consider that white people have never started the United White College Fund, or NAAWP. As a white person I am always angered when I hear a person of color say something that a white person could never get away with without getting shot! Some...not all....blacks create their own racism! Stop using slavery and racism as a crutch. Live your life...as an AMERICAN!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Andrea Burger Morton, Pennsylvania — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 21:55:02 GMT

So this is the big controversial picture?? I think it looks great!! It captures how he feels on the court as a basketball player. And she does not look like she is in distress. It looks like a fun photo shoot. I'm a black woman married to a white man and personally I think the race card is being pulled a little too much lately. A man like Lebron doesn't not look anything like King Kong!! He is very gorgeous!!! Shame on the critics. They should think and be a little more open minded before they speak.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

J. Frost, Wilmington, NC — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:04:04 GMT

I'm like Jared from San Diego, why do have to put a label in front of American. I am a Black man who happens to be an American. It is a shame that Black people in this country would even consider calling LeBron James a gorilla with all our ancestors had to sacrifice to get to where we are today. Besides when I was in the military, I knew a fellow Airman that was white, but considered himself an African-American because his parents were American missionaries and he was born and reared in Africa. Again, I'm black, maybe of African decent, but I'm American first.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Aaron, Edmond, OK — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:05:13 GMT

You only see racism in that picture if you want to. Some people just need to move on.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Betsy/New York — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:05:37 GMT

Oh please, I didnt see it as racist. I would never of thought that someone called him king kong because of his ethenticity. I do see where they get king kong from, look at the pic, he is huge, and her this little petite thing in his large hands just like the movie,,,,,cmon guys...are you kidding? Is this still going on?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

B.B staten island new york — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:09:21 GMT

It's amazing to see how low the media would sink to make an innocent cover ,photo of two very well known peopleinto something racial,don't they realize the problem we have with racism;why do they always dwell on negatives,try to see the positive in these things and give that to the people,stop dividing us;enough....

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

FrankG~, LA, CA! — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:15:57 GMT

Again, like many others, i would have NEVER compared lebron or anyone of color to an ape. King Kong never came to mind until this Ann lady mentioned it. This is why Stereotypes continue to live, LET IT GO!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

EmK, D.C. — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:17:31 GMT

Jason Rosenfeld made great comments and others would do well to go back and read his post. I value people in academia weighing in. People, they spend the time studying and analyzing our everyday pop/news consumption while we go about our own jobs, and I am personally grateful for their full-time analysis.

Please stop with the "aren't there more important things to worry about?" There is always something "more important" to worry about. Your daughter doesn't medically need braces, but you saved the money to get them for her instead of donating it to UNICEF. Stop denigrating, belittling, and dismissing people's genuine worries and concerns because they do not deal with the meaning of life, war and peace, or the existence of God.
Even small struggles deserve our attention. And you KNOW that you absolutely sweat the small stuff when it comes to your OWN needs and concerns. Get empathy for those of others, hypocrites.

I'm sick to my stomach that people are telling others to shut up about racism and sexism in our media, our images, our art, our lives. Why should I shut my mouth over something that is so easily remedied? Art directors and photags: stop animalizing and over-exoticizing people of African, Arab, Asian, Latin American, and Native ancestry. Stop pairing wafer-thin female models DOING NOTHING BUT SMILE AND "BEING" FEY with active, in-motion, "doing" males. Stop with the feral dark man/angelicized light woman. This is wrong on so many levels.

My biggest concern is over all the posters who here who don't see a problem with the media and pop culture they voraciously consume without second-guessing it, problematizing it, or even examining it at all.

YOU are the ones with a problem, not the thinkers who mull over what is fed them and ask questions...

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Michael, Atlanta, GA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:21:58 GMT

I think it's amazing that everyone is making a big stink of this and forgetting the fact that
Gisele Bundchen is BRAZILIAN!!! It is amazing how everyone jumps to conclusions without knowing the facts. I am a Black male, a LeBron fan, and I love Rio De Janeiro Brazil.... :) Get a grip!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

julie, new york, ny — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:24:05 GMT

This cover is an awesome study of contrasts and similarities. He is the epitome of the Male Athlete, fit and hulking. She is the epitome of the supermodel, fit and wispy. He's got his angry game face. She's ecstatic. He's black, she's white. It's not racism, it's art.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rosheeka Johnson Dallas, TX — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:31:45 GMT

It's because of white people like you, that racism exists, not the reaction of blacks. Blacks are consistently represented in the media as aggressive and "angry". Unlike whites blacks are unfairly judged in this country often times by what is seen in media. Racisism exists because we have people just like the people on this site who won't ever say it's racism. See when it's not happening to you, it's not affecting you. That's why its so easy for you [Whites] to say it's not happening. "Why are we blamed for slavery," blah blah blah. Well it's stereotypes like this that stems from the old womb of racism, slavery, that educated people like myself have to combat everyday. Check your facts, ethnic names get called 50% less than white sounding names on resumes. type it in your search engines. These subliminal messages are part of the system that both blacks and whites are brought up in. By ignoring these things you perpetuate the cycle. Remember no slave owner: Beat Rodney King, called African-Americans (a whole other issue) N's on a comedy stage, or called a group of young black women who are attending college trying to better themselves a bunch of nappy headed hos.
thanks

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

April Hodges Rockville, MD — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:33:40 GMT

I am fearful that so many people are so desensitized to how we are depicted in all forms of media that anything remotely "normal" (A Black man going to work in a suit) is so incomprehensible and so outlandish that it is almost foreign in the mindsets of anyone other than Black men who actually wear suits and actually go to work, per say.

Was it surprising to you that they mentioned past magazine covers where Black male athletes were depicted as aggressive and monster-like. In this case, the models may or may not have seen the undertones in it. Ignorance is bliss...But would it have had the same impact if the basketball player was Caucasian and the actress was either White or Black? Something to think about. Have you seen this scenario? I'd love to.

This is the first time a Black man has been on the cover of Vogue. Period...yeah, and it's 2008! Could they not have been a little more tasteful? I would never go as far to say that the people who did this were racist, however, I do believe that we live in a culture that has ingrained racism so intricately that we sometimes cannot see it even when it is staring us directly in our faces. I can see both sides of the picture, but I would see both more objectively if there was an equal balance of the way the media depicts Black men in general.

I just recently read an article on Tyler Perry's new film. Meeting the Browns. Perry was depicted as a comedian with mediocre talent breaking the box office due to the lack of entertainment geared towards a demographic no one cares about...namely Us.
"...Perry is ideal for making the move to Hollywood, as he has proven to be a nonthreatening black man who has built much of his success by being a transvestite. If there is one thing Hollywood loves, it is a charismatic black man who is willing to trade his masculinity for success by putting on a dress." ~David Walker

Let me tell you something. Black men in the media have either been viewed as nonthreatening or as the aggressive animal to be feared by all.
Want a Gut Check...Check This...The media is Not, I repeat Not on your side.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jaframom, California — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:46:38 GMT

I'm not a mag person anyway. But when I saw this one, it stood out. Was it because it was ' racist' ? no. Those two looked like they were having a blast on that shoot and behind that experession, how much ya wanna bet that Lebron was smiling and sayin to himself' I'm holdin' Giselle, oh yeah ! " I mean , C'mon ! Talk about ' Stike a pose ! " This was a great photo shot and should be viewed as such. Nothing more. No statement here other than " Look at these two great people." People, of any race or color, will always bicker and find ways to heat the flames of racism, no matter what it's based on. That's what our society has grown into. People need to grow up, get on with their lives and worry about what their neighbor needs to eat tonight and what their family needs to be happy than to worry about who's creating the next supreme court arguement that's been heard over and over again for the last 100 years !

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Drew Mclendon — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:49:02 GMT

Racist cover? Lebron is wearing his own clothing line on the cover of the most popular syle magazine in the world! Every designer alive would give their left arm to have that opportunity. You want racist? How many times has a white athlete been on the cover of Ebony, XXL or King? Uh, never I've checked. Keep crying wolf and White America will not listen when it REALLY matters.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ted — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 22:52:00 GMT

Race baiting, plain 'n simple; it's an innocent photo. LeBron James is a super athlete, larger than life figure, and Gisele Bundchen is a size zero supermodel. The picture fits the story of dress for no matter what size: contrast of athletic/big and thin. Should Gisele look like the he-man, and LeBron look like a care-free fluttering butterfly to counter "sterotypes"; I think not. Non-issue.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lynn Smith — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:00:53 GMT

Lest we forget that Giselle is actually Brazilian and not "caucasian." It is a bit racist to refer to all non-black people as caucasian and white. I think it is absolutely ridiculous that this should cause such a firestorm, although I disagree completely with one person's comment that this controversy was exaggerated by black people who want to perpetuate racism because it somehow works in their favor or gives them "get out jail free cards." Ridiculous. Last time I checked, black men make up the majority of prisoners in the US.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

CAB, The DMV — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:01:33 GMT

It always amazes me that some people of color, especially african americans are always portrayed as being "outlandish", "overreactive", and other negative terms. It also bothers me that some european americans would stoop soo low to even state that racism is the responsibility to those who are affected by it. The fact of the matter is stereotypes exist...racism was not the issue at hand. I believe that those who have never experienced the struggle throw the "racism" card out so that it makes the situation more ridiculous to take race relations into consideration.
This picture, in fact had a similarity to the King Kong picture. This fact remains--LeBron didn't have a problem being portrayed in such a light, so the issue is over.

Lets take time to understand other's experiences before we negate them because we ourselves have never experienced such discrimination. That goes for any race. Don't try to hide behind the whole "I don't see color or color doesn't matter" speal...that is a bunch of bull. Color is important; it has to be if God made us all different. It should be celebrated, not taken away. When whites take a stand to end race relations...THEN they will end...not the other day around.

Peace and Blessings

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ina S., Durham, NC — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:04:41 GMT

I agree, it's the fact that someone thought deep enough to pull racial stereotypes out of the photo at all. I'm African-American, and I had to read the whole article to figure out what the "controversy" was all about. It didn't immediately spring to mind on seeing the photo. Why do things have to be so black & white (literally) with people? Why must their always be a issue of race? And who's to say they didn't come up with the pose themselves and the photographer just worked with them? Simply put, people just need a reason to disagree, to argue and to fight for a "cause," whether the disagreement, argument or "cause" is there or not. Someone has too much time on their hands, in my opinion...

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Allison Heath, Virginia Beach — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:17:05 GMT

Personaly I think it is a wonderful state of affairs when we as a society have to invent a racial controversy instead of being able to produce a real one. I am reminded of a time when americans went around thinking everyone was a communist, and now everyone is a racist...give it a rest!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kathy, Rockford IL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:20:54 GMT

Give me a break. This is an issue because the media made it an issue. This is a fun picture nothing more nothing less. These are two powerful successful individuals, if there was a problem with the photo they and their representatives would never have allowed it to be published. Let's see a photo of Hillary and Obama in this pose, now that would be fun.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Y. Berkowitz, Miami, FL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:23:02 GMT

Are you KIDDING me?
A gorgeous recognizable black man and a stunning recognizable white woman portraying their physical superiority and the grace of what they do, i.e. athletics -a physical and aesthetic endeavor; and modeling at its best - a physical and aesthetic endeavor. What's the racial issue? That we keep reading negative things in even the most benign?
Do you believe Lebron and Giselle are being victimized too!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jane Doe, Los Angeles, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:24:30 GMT

4000 men and women have died in a senseless war over the course of five years! LET'S FOCUS PEOPLE! There are real issues in this world that have nothing to do with two, very well paid people, posing on the cover of a posh magazine! Perhaps the issue should be...what are these two people, one of whom was recently called "the next billion dollar man" on the cover of ESPN magazine, doing with their millions of dollars to make this world a better place? LET'S GET SOME PERSPECTIVE HERE PEOPLE!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Joe G — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:39:26 GMT

Guess it all comes down to perspective. Ask ANY child black or white or Hispanic or OTHER from any back ground
then ask them what they see in this photo. What do they say and why?
I see an athlete dribbling a basketball and holding a model. I don't see in color and I wish this would not be given any publicity at all as it is simply ridiculous!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

D. Los Angeles, CA — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:45:06 GMT

Vogue is raising this controversy to boost up sales or is it really the people? That's the real question here. I don't know if anyone has ever bought Vogue or look through their magazine, but it's nothing but a whole bunch of ads. So when you pay $6-7 for Vogue at a grocery store, you're only paying 10 pages of article(s). It's sad but true.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Angel Schultz — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:47:04 GMT

I can see both sides of the story, BUT, people have made things this way.

For one thing, how is this a racially contreversial cover? Just because it shows a rough, built black man, obviously giving the photographer his game face, holding a white woman in a beautiful gown doesn't mean that it was supposed to represent a stereotype, or king kong for that matter.

The racist part that I do see is self created. If you look at alot of famous models, most are white, tall, skinny, blonde women. NOT ALL, mind you, but alot. And alot of famous black men are either, a) football players, b) rappers/ r&b artists, or c) basketball players. Therefore, the "racial" contreversy is pretty much created by our own society. But we don't criticize it until an image that just happens to resemble to some person a King Kong look-a-like picture doesn't mean the Vogue, the photographer, or the readers portray the stereotype of black men as big, rough, slightly menacing looking and all white females as damsels in distress. Give me a break people!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

DT, Orlando, FL — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:52:15 GMT

If he was holding a Barbie doll, not dribbling a basketball, not in sportswear and sneakers, but in a gorilla suit and placed in a jungle-type setting or on the Empire State Building - I may have seen King Kong in there somewhere. I don't though. Not at all. What an absurd comparison.

The photo comes across to me as someone powerful enough to dribble a basketball down the court while carrying a supermodel with him - which makes sense for this shot since Vogue magazine is geared towards fashion and style. The other athletes' photos inside are just as good and interesting.

He looks cool. They both do.

It is intriguing though, all the controversy over this - and laughable over the select few who see themselves as victims over this photograph. Get a life.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tiffany Simone The Bitofluvnhate Boston, Ma — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 23:58:55 GMT

I do think the the pic when she was on his shoulder was the money shot but, I am A young black woman and a part of Lebrons peers and I think that it's all in choices (artistic choices) I want to think that Ann shooting a black man was not thinking lets portray Lebron James as a Gorilla on the cover of Vogue Mag (one of the top fashion mags in history)today. Her pick was her money shot my pick was my money shot bt im not the artist we should learn to respect peoples work and realize that sometime things are what they are and there is nothing in between the lines to be read everything is not subliminal.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Summer, Hayden, CO — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:03:46 GMT

The headline for the picture reads "Shape Issue; Secrets of the Best Bodies. Lebron & Gisselle + the Worlds Top Models and Best Athletes."
Lebron - top BASKETBALL player who is in the photo dribbeling a basketball being enthusiastic and energetic like he is when he PLAYS THE GAME. He's not a model, therefore he is not in a stylie suit. He's an athlete which is why he is in his basketball gear dribbeling a basketball.
Giselle - TOP model at the moment in stylie gear because SHE'S A MODEL (not because Vogue wanted say she has more class as some people have suggested). She looks like she's having a blast; not afraid of Lebron (as some suggest she should be with the whole, ridiculous, King Kong imagery).
I completely agree with those that have stated that the media is bringing negative attention to this beautiful picture.
Why not pick any of the other pictures? If they had put the one with Giselle standing over Lebron, I'm sure that would've caused controversy. And you can't put the one on the cover with Giselle seperately holding a basketball and Lebron doing his thing because that picture demanded not to be covered with magazine captions.
The people that hunted up the King Kong image... try focusing on something real.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kay, Manchester, England — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:08:46 GMT

I came to this page through a link that said it had caused a racial debate and saw the picture and struggled to see the issue. I see a successful athlete and a well known model, forgive me for not knowing the athlete though, I'm from the UK and not up on US sports. But I don't think he looks aggressive or gorilla-like and I certainly dont think she looks damsel in distress. I think she looks like she's having a good time, and I'm jealous! Look around at the build of athletes, white and black who play the type of sport that requires them to be well built. If vogue chose to display a white athlete they would have been criticised for not choosing a successful, influential, healthy, happy black person. Seems to me certain people would only be happy if the pictures represented two down and out white people since white is still 'majority'. Or maybe no human representation at all maybe?. It just sounds like another story spun out of nothing to cause tension and in my opinion does not help society and THAT is what causes racial stereotyping. It happens in the UK too <sigh>.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kay (still manchester, uk) — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:10:04 GMT

can i also add that its not 'blacks' making it a racial issue, its a 'person' or 'people' making it a racial issue.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

jane b, cleveland, ohio — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:17:34 GMT

I am an old movie buff who is very familiar with the films of the 1930s, including the old King Kong. When I saw this photo I was absolutely flabbergasted by its likeness to the iconic poses of King Kong and Fay Wray in that film. If you are unfamiliar with the movie, it would probably go past you without notice.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

G. K. 2 Atlanta, GA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:19:29 GMT

Racism is not a crutch. I know some people try to say it is, but its not. I am a black guy I work hard for everything I get, but when I go into a store and I am stared down because they think I am going to steal thats sad. I don't think most people see things thats all around them. There is Bigtory out there and thats the problem. Shannon take a look at your life, and then way a day with a black man or date one and see how your life changes.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Crystal New York, NY — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:36:19 GMT

It's a good thing someone told me that the pic was racist and that it was an analogy to King Kong. I would never have known. Apparently my IQ is too low to think of it any other way than an asthetically pleasing photo of two beautiful people at the top of their game.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

K. Bonney, Frostburg MD — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:42:30 GMT

Ok, how silly is all of this controversy over a magazine cover? Did either of the participants in the photo have any problems with the final product? Probably not. If they had, it wouldn't have been on the cover of Vogue. I really think that who ever started all of this is the racist one. Did anyone else look at this photo and think "King Kong"? I think it goes back on the one who first started hollering about it. Get over it. Not everything in life revolves around race.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Chicago — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:44:22 GMT

I think everyone should keep in mind that this is too cliche, that's why people have problems with this cover. Too many black people have been seen as an aggressive, wild animal. Now for those who think this is not to be questioned, you never experience the black experience, therefore you can say the all people want to use this a "get out of jail free card. TO GET OUT OF WHAT! The worry of being portrayed in an unacceptable way. Think about the golf-weekly magazine and the whole Tiger Woods lynching incident. And tell me what you think about that, " ohh no! Not again... black people complaining, because it reminds them of the five hundred years of slavery. Brother please... If we do not question these kinds of things we will never get over this whole racist thing.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

kelly gola, brooklyn, ny — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:45:04 GMT

how 'bout the blatant misogynistic ideology splashed all over the cover - "get thin!" "dress right!" "diet smart!" teaching women to dress a size 16 with a woman over 5'8" that's a size 2 on the cover doesn't exactly send a "we live in an egalitarian society" message to women. Let's worry less about subliminal racial overtones and more about the overt and oppressive messages being targeted at women. Annie Leibowitz is disgusting and so is this magazine.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

uju, clemmons, nc — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:45:30 GMT

I am a West African living in America. I am getting really scared and tired of this whole race issue. I saw this as nothing more than a gorgeous photograph. Why does everything have to boil down to racism, and a lot of times the suspicions come from the black community. Why is it so difficult to believe that Vogue made this cover innocently, to be a work of art? God!!! Please let people enjoy their magazine instead of being subjected to this stupid, uneccesary controversy. I worry for Obama if he makes the White House, we will see this topic brought up every time.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sarah La, Rochester, MI — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:49:55 GMT

Do people not have better things to do? Are we saying that black men should be strong and have muscle and that white women should be stick thin and a model? Ummm...NO! Honestly people, grow up. It's a cover. He's made history with his basketball skills and he won't be posing laying down with is legs in a seductive manner like a supermodel. He's an NBA player -helloooo. She won't be wearing a uniform or running around, aka. she's a MODEL, duh. That's my peace. If people need something to whine about, how about getting into politics...maybe even Michigans economy.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

A2, MI — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 00:54:04 GMT

To say that this photo reflects racial stereotypes requires that it be part of a clear pattern of depictions of black men as perpetrators and frightening individuals and white women as victims, controlled by others. This clear pattern is NOT hard to identify if you look at advertisements, magazine covers, music videos and even prime time TV. It's about more than this cover -- it's part of an era of racism that still goes unspoken, yet is prominent in every facet of our society. To those of you who deny its existence, look closer.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kelly D — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 01:12:45 GMT

Beautiful people, beautiful picute. There is nothing more to say. Most impressed with the email comments from all corners of our country denouncing the racist comments and for people to stop it. What color were those two? I didnt notice.. did notice they are beautiful people.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jessica, Washington, NC — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 01:15:20 GMT

I'm black but not racist. I believe the truth is that black women have a problem with the cover because Lebron is with a white woman. Most Black women have a problem with black men dating white women. The reason for this is because they feel that when a black man dates a white woman, he is choosing white beauty over black beauty. Black women get offended and they call this racist. I know because I am a black woman.

I don't feel this way but this is the truth. Another reason it is considered racist is because the way he poses makes him look like a gorilla. Some black people feel this is offensive because back in the old days, racist people would say that blacks are ugly because thay look like monkeys or gorillas.

What people need to keep in mind is that Lebron is the one who chose to pose this way. If he is happy with the pose then everyone should be happy with the pose.

It is only offensive if YOU are one who has problems with black men dating white women or blacks being called monkeys. If YOU have had these experiences then only YOU can see this cover to be racist. You have to be in the shoes of the oppressed to see things the way oppressed people see them. It might not seem fair, but it is the way things are. Sorry.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

JTB — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 01:16:23 GMT

Thank you Keith Palmer, Boise, Id.

One day, maybe in the life time of my future grandchildren, a photo like that will have no meaning except one of beauty. It will not happen until Americans of all colors and races stop saying that talking about race is the problem.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

isabella,chicago Illinois — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 01:42:33 GMT

okay i am in the 8th grade and i see this as a ridiculous remark. we talked about this in my s.s class and it is not the first time this has happened until this argument was brought up all i saw was 2 powerful both beautiful and handsome images in this society these two people wanted to do a great job in this photo-shoot and personally they did they are portraying what they were supposed to which is fitness
but now when i look at it i see how we have truly not changed at all how all the efforts people put into the discrimination problems has pretty much been forgotten we are in the 21 first century for Pete sake and we are still judging people about whether they are black white what if people were purple what then? its all just SO ridiculous again im an 8th grader you as adults should be setting and example for me and the future generations and instead you do this wow im really dissapointed. sorry thats how i feel

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Veeka Benet, Augusta, GA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 02:01:34 GMT

What a load of crap!! I see a basketball star and a supermodel. Where is the controversy? Some people
just can't make it through the day unless they make up some drama over NOTHING!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Shayna, Dubuque, IA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 02:01:51 GMT

This is awful. Lebron is someone that young people can look up to and here people are ripping his amazing, skillful, and brillant career apart just to be picky. He is a basketball player...and a great one at that...leave him alone!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kim, Chicago, IL — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 02:05:15 GMT

Seriously, it is just a picture. If they wanted a picture of him being serious then they would not have had him take a picture in a basketball type outfit. I would not have expected anyting different. He is a hardcore player, who took a hardcore picture. I just can't imagine reading into this that much.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

MaryAnn, Jamestown, NY — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 02:16:41 GMT

I don't really like the photo...didn't think it was racist HOWEVER the comment about King Kong is a bit offensive.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Allan Fuelling, Indianapolis, IN — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 02:33:38 GMT

Does anyone know that Gisele Bundchen is from BRAZIL? Ummm, that's in South America, which would make her Latina. Oh, I forgot wee were only looking at the color of their skin, my bad...

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kareena, Toronto, Ontario — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 03:07:52 GMT

The issue with racism is that the unknowing perpetrators don't learn its history. They just assume that images are natural, harmless and randomly appear when they in fact have a historical context and significance. I think it is hardly the place of a non-black person to dismiss the disdain for this photo when they aren't going to notice the racist stereotype because they are not the target. It's ironic that we don't question the medical expert, the mathematical expert, or the educational expert, but as soon as it comes to social issues, the average individual knows more than the expert. If the social experts on race confirm that there is a legitimate complaint of racial insensitivity in the photo, why can't those who are less knowledgeable on race just accept that? There is so much denial in the other posted comments. This isn't the way to deal with racism, by pretending it's not really there.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ericka S. — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 03:17:01 GMT

Yes this picture is art and art is interpreted through the eyes of the viewer. In this world, a persons viewpoint is determined by their experiences. So when you look at this picture try not to view it through your eyes, but through the eyes of a people who have been second class citizens in this country. Unfortunately most black men aren't viewed with the same adoration of Lebron James. So when you look at this picture look at through the eyes of of the minority in the room. The minority who is looking for equal opportunity and some form of respect without being a rapper or an athlete.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Leigh Horner, Virginia — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 03:18:46 GMT

I love the cover... Gisele has a huge smile on her face and looks like she is having fun. LeBron looks like he is showin everyone, "Hey look, I am awesome at what I do. I am the best on the court, so be afraid. Oh yeah, and I can do all that while holding one dang sexy woman in my arms..." This "King Kong" crap is just that, CRAP. I never once thought he looked like "King Kong". The people who came up with that are the ones with the racial problems. Instead of celebrating with him for being the first African American on the cover, you degrade him, say humiliating things about him, and offend him in the worst way possible... I am a 21 year old, white female, and LeBron can be my "King Kong" any day... I would be honored to be on the cover of any magazine with him, doing the same pose.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

cynthia Miller — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 03:27:38 GMT

This Vogue Cover story on the Today Show was sooooo ridiculous!
Almost more ridiculous than having so called sex experts on last week posing the question "Is it genetically impossible for men not to cheat"? Now THAT was Racist!!! (re Spitzer Scandal)...Vogue is a beautiful, Artistic fashion Magazine. They're job is to create a captivating cover that speaks to you...and boy did they ever! The intention by the Photographer was to show the artistic contrast between a fierce athlete and a delicate beautiful woman.
Was this Intended to show controversy, no not really other than LeBron is the first Male to grace it's cover(how bout focus on that!). Sure Annie took other pics but this by far was the best, as my professional opinion as an Art Director... The thought of this being racist never entered my mind,
until the A.A. lady on the today show started to make something(racist) out of nothing(racist) shame on you! You are the racist for even THINKING this about one of our greatest American Athletes who everyone adores!! More importantly what does Le Bron think?? He looks great and should be proud to be the first male on the cover of Vogue!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Frustrated, Pensacola, FL — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 03:31:51 GMT

A previous comment stated "Lebron must not have taken into consideration the past of blacks being compared to monkeys and the effect it would have on the community". I guess he wasn't dribbling a basketball which is second nature to him. And I also suppose he should think about that history before he dribbles the ball on the court...you know just in case a camera man captures him looking like an ape! Give me a break. I'm Black and did not for one second and still do not think this cover controversial.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Terry G Pittsburgh Pennsylvania — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 03:32:45 GMT

This country "USA" IS racially divided, Black Americans tend to play the race card alot, but white Americans are guilty of stiring the pot. This was a picture of two beautiful individuals at the top of their fields, I love the picture, I hate the fact that americans want to make a racial issue out of it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Dani Beaumont, TX — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 03:37:34 GMT

I do subscribe to Vogue, and when I received my copy this month I didn't think twice about the cover. I was a bit confused when I realized that such a big deal was being made. If people don't notice the "stereotype" (especially white people, who are accused of believing it), then how can it be present? Furthermore, African Americans need to realize that racism applies to all races, not just their own. I've encountered a lot of African Americans who have developed a racist and prejudicial attitude towards whites. In fact, assuming that a general act by a person who is white (not an overt act) is an act of racism is itself prejudicial. I've had someone accuse me of racism because we (my place of employment) were out of a product they desired. This individual assumed I didn't want to give it to her and informed me that "if she were white, she was sure she'd receive the product." This is untrue, as we did not have it. She returned shortly thereafter and spoke to my manager (who had been out at the time), and after he informed her that we were indeed out of the product, she accused him of racism as well. The point is, this photo is clearly not racist. Why would Vogue want Lebron James to look like King Kong? The magazine is so superficial; when did their magazine develop such an indepth analysis of racial stereotypes (which they would have to have to render them in print)?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

P. Reed, Washington, DC — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 04:06:46 GMT

I'm an American woman and I'm Black. Lebron does most certainly not look like an ape and Giselle isn't in distress. I didn't think the photo was a good one because I've seen them both look better. It just wasn't a cute cover but it never crossed my mind (and I supposedly belong to the demographic who might be the most "sensitive" to the image of a black man and a white woman (except for maybe White males, laugh). I could care less about the black man wants white woman thing - HELLO, people, wake up. That theme is tired, tired, tired. White women aren't anything special and Black men aren't either. That's why it's called the HUMAN RACE. Jesus Christ, can someone address the price of gas, utilities, and the war on Iraq? This country is sliding, but I have hope from reading these posts that at least the citizens (if not the media) have a grip. Color isn't the issue, materialism is.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

P. Reed, Washington, DC — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 04:08:03 GMT

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Nathon, Memphis, Tennessee — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 04:31:14 GMT

If Giselle is in distress in this picture, I'd really hate to see someone after her. Who in their right minde decided this was racist. He is a powerful,full-forced basketball player, who plays with emotion. She is a sly bodied supermodel. Gosh... how in the world could that be what I see? Americans need to focus their attention on more important matters... crime, war, poverty, healthcare, disease, I dont' know... presidential elections?!?! Vogue is a magazine... fashion... clothes... people. MOVE ON!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

John Dough — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 04:41:07 GMT

Everybody seems to be in agreement (almost). Media Sensationalism is the root of all this 'racism'. One person makes a gorilla comment and someone takes it to sell some newspapers. This is not much unlike how politics works - you start a rumor and it just catches fire. Unfortunately, America is getting the bad end of this headline starved media machine we have.

Stop the madness. Black people and white people agree...it's just a PICTURE.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Danielle D., Metairie,LA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 04:41:50 GMT

I totally disagree with everyone who says that black people are using racism as some sort of trump card. if anyone is exploiing racism it is the media by fueling these sort of stories. i don't like the photo at all and i think the other photos taken were much more beautiful shots but I don't think that it should be getting the attention that it has gotten. Racism is real regardless of your feeling about the photo. anyone that is unsure about whether racism exist should read some of the other comments. Racism will not disappear just because people decide to look the other way and pretend it doesn't exist. But the more we focus on things like this photo the further we get from coming closer as a people. We need to devote the time spent on this nonsense to real issues like education and developing our young people to have a future and get close to the goal of unifying people. There is still segregation in many places, people are still hanging nooses those are real issues!!!!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ayana G., Fairfax, Virginia — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 04:53:15 GMT

When reading the other comments posted I pondered why is it that a majority of the white people who are commenting on this cover don't understand why this is a "racial" issue? My conclusion is that because when you are white in America you cannot begin to understand what racism is about. If you have not experienced being black in America then you will never understand, and it's nobodys fault. However, it is ignorant to dismiss the feelings of "black people" or the feelings of any person for that matter because feelings come from a lived experience and they are unique to that individual. What amazes me is that Vogue has the audacity to brag about James being the first black man to grace the cover. When the most celebrated magazine in the world for fashion and style has waited until 2008 to give a black man the cover that right there should tell us how little progress America, and the media for that matter, has made on the issue of race and breaking down stereotypes of blacks. In addition, by giving James the cover, an athlete, it only plays into the stereotypes of what defines a black man, and how a black man becomes a success, which is typically in sports or entertainment. Then in turn, when he becomes successful, he must have a woman of "lighter" color on his arm to continue that success. That stereotype discredits a lot of what blacks have worked so hard for, and some even given their life for. What the real focus should be regarding this cover is why in the year 2008, this "milestone" has just happened. For a magazine that has been around 100+ years, that milestone should have happened many many years ago.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tonya B. Silver City, NM — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 05:34:47 GMT

Stop making something of nothing find something better to do with your time then finding negative things about this. There are worse things in this world then the cover of that magazine. Hes an athlete and shes a supermodel. This is what I see a basketball player getting ready to shoot the ball making a face like all other athlete in any sport. He just happens to be holding a supermodel big fleshly deal.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

sara, nashville, tn — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 06:00:23 GMT

I'm appalled that this is even an issue. I mean....are you serious? Why does it always have to be about racism? The day that racism disappears in this country is the day that people stop going out of there way to find it and make an issue. Stop pulling the race card. This country as a whole is not racist. As a white woman, i find it racist that there are black only organizations....if you want to make something a racist issue, lets start with that first. There's just always gotta be something.... why can't we let a cover of a magazine, photographed by a world famous photographer, be a cover. Let it be. If Lebron James is fine with the cover, then why is it even an issue. Get the chip off of your shoulder people, c'mon!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Erin, Seattle, WA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 06:16:40 GMT

I doubt the intent of the photographer, models, and magazine was ever to offend or create an image like King Kong. Because of the underlying racism in this country (and others) any provacative media should spark conversation, even if my opinion is that this is a stretch. I'm also interested if the model identifies as a "white" woman or Brazilian?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Bernard , Inkster, Michigan — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 07:06:53 GMT

It's a shame that people are bringing up a race issue with the photo. The person shot in the photo Is a black man, and has no issue with it being a racial thing, but of couse you do. How is it that Lebron doesnt? The only racist people I see are those complaining about it. Is that what you have been reduced to? Ready to lash out at anything that you see as racist even though the person who shot the picture has no problems with it? You need to meditate, for real.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Anthony, Corvallis, Oregon — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 08:23:49 GMT

This is a good start. We are talking about the issue. It is fine if we do not agree on whether or not the pict is racist or merely insensitive. I believe that our healthy discussion starts to get off track when people start to judge others on their views. When people say that African-Americans are just complaining to complain and that their view is groundless, then we veer into personal attracts. When people say that white people are racists and will never “get it”, then we see resentment start to grow. We all would do well to just stop for a moment and attempt to put ourselves in the position of the other argument. Just try to let go of our view and try to see it another way. I bet if we did we would have a little more clarity and gain the space to actually talk to each other and learn from one another. Maybe we will learn where the questions come from.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

AJ — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 11:51:44 GMT

Hey, I've got an idea. As long as we're all reading deep sociological significance into a magazine cover of a jock posing like a jock and a model posing like a model, why not bring sexual discrimination into it?

After all, this cover is terribly sexist, don't you think? Look at how stereotypically masculine and feminine their stances are! Look at how he's got his feet strongly placed, his facial expression aggressively set, and one beefy arm around the waist of his delicate, smiling property, in her clinging little dress! He dominates the picture and she looks happy about it! Good heavens, this is an affront that reaches all the way back to the early suffragettes and the sacrifices they made to bring ladies the vote!

...or maybe it's just a jock posing like a jock, and a model posing like a model. Who can say for sure? :)

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Parnel , New London CT — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 12:03:53 GMT

Al Sharpton and Jessie Jackson...and let's listen for Rev Wright as well...seems he's big into keeping people in boxes and stirring up racism. What happened to the message of their Jesus, LOVE!
2 Beautiful bodies, nothing more.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Owen, Gilbert, AZ — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:05:18 GMT

are you frickin' kidding me? only racists would think that this photo is the least bit sterotypical. it's just a photo of "two of the world's most recognizable people." get a life!

"And in thinking about this story, I couldn't help but wonder...what's the more racist response to the cover: to see racial stereotypes and object or to not notice race at all?"

WHAT? how would it be racist to NOT notice race? give me a break!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rachel, Akron, Ohio — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:11:39 GMT

If anyone thinks this cover is offensive--KEEP WALKING AND DON'T BUY IT! HELLO!!! This is a free country and we are allowed to express ourselves freely here! Good grief, shame on the media for drawing attention to this.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Liz, Tampa, Florida — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:12:19 GMT

People just need to get OVER IT!!!! It's so stupid!! He's a basketball player (aggressive, but GREAT), the pose resembles him playing basketball and she's a model and the pose resembles her modeling!! I can't stand the ones that always pull the race card on everything little thing....and then turn around and ask you to look at them as a person and not their color! If you stop bringing it up....it wouldn't be an issue!! Once again, GET OVER IT!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

JC in Texas — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:18:15 GMT

i like what mcn Bedford Tx said . "it is only racist if you are." i do not agree with Shannon who said " This story made me chuckle. Part of the reason racism still exists is because black people want it to. It gives them a crutch and an excuse to complain. It also provides them with a get out of jail free card to play. I never would've read into this what others have. King Kong? Black man wanting black woman? Come on....really? " Black people want the same thing white people want. think about that

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Drew — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:19:25 GMT

It's all about the power of suggestion, people. I would think that most people would never think "racist" when looking at the cover. But one person screams it, and suddenly it's all anyone can think about. If people want to see racism in it, then they will. You may call me clueless, insensitive, or whatever else, but I'm a white male who doesn't see anything overtly racist in it. All I see is the glorious athletic intensity of LeBron and the demure sexuality of Gisele.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Brooklyn, NY — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:31:02 GMT

As a young, professional, Black woman I understand why some people of color would be offended by the photo. It does not depict the best attributesof either celebrity. Most people of color do have a bit of a chip on our shoulders and do not see the world as most of you would like us to because it is uncomfortable for you. That chip is the burden we carry because of centuries of outright racism. Those of you who use the word "crutch" and tell us to let go of racism, probably have never been called a gorilla, the n-word or anything similar. Apologies, but we must be critical of the subtleties of racism that unfortunately still do exist.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Katie F, Minneapolis, MN — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:32:49 GMT

My initial reaction was not to make a comparison to King Kong, BUT--I looked up the movie cover/images on google and if you look at the cover for the 1933 film with Fay Wray, the resemblance between poses is striking.(Google King Kong 1933) King Kong was released again just a few years ago and race was a huge part of the discussion of that film. The photographer knows pop culture and cinema. This photo is designed to be controversial. Let's take the opportunity to dialogue in a positive way. Race continues to be an issue in America because it IS an issue still (despite changes and progress). Even if we set race aside for a moment, this image says a lot about how men and women can be successful in America. Respected men are poweful, even angry, athletes. Respected women are dolls. Are we comfortable with this idea?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Brian, Longview,TX — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:33:58 GMT

It's really funny that on T.V. during nearly every you will see an NBA player making that facr after a thunder dunk, or blocked shot. But make that face in a photo with a model, and you look like King Kong. They need to get over themselves, and work out their own issues. That's why they have a problem with this cover.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

robdog, Alexandria, Louisiana — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:35:17 GMT

Magazine covers have one job - sell the magazine! The cover has to be exciting and attention getting. What better way to get attention -- a great athlete and a supermodel. The critics need to get a grip, sometimes a magazine cover is just a magazine cover.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Alisha, Dayton, Ohio — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:37:21 GMT

All I can say is, I am sorry this is happening. I like to try and see everyones points of view. I feel for all parties envolved. I don't think anyone ment any harm, however someone, wants US ALL(any race) to continue to hurt. It really does hurt everyone. We must ALL(any race) OVERCOME!

We all bleed the same

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Karen — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:40:55 GMT

I loved this cover, they truly look like the were having fun. I am a white women, with a daughter who dates a black athelete and I do not see his expression as threating, he was showing a playful game face and making her laugh. What's wrong with that.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

T. James, New York, NY — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:49:10 GMT

I won't even address the cover, because it is what it is. I'm not a vogue reader or buyer. I do think there were better choices inside, but then again I like what I like. Artists/Creatives always get a pass anyway. I'm a writer and a journalist so I understand this.

Wow Shannon, I love how you generalized all black people. Have you been to the pokie lately, I bet those "black (white and brown) people" wished they'd played monopoly some, instead of dice or whatever, then they could really appreciate the value of a get out of jail free card.

Racism in America, come on... really?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Brad M. St. Johns Newfoundland Canada — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 13:55:50 GMT

LeBron is fierce, ripped and smart (did I mention lucky? No?) and Gisele is a beautiful girl...does there need to be any more to it than that? Good choice Vogue.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Robert C, Houston, Texas — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:10:20 GMT

What's most interesting is what people's comments reveal about themselves, perhaps unwittingly. It is dangerous to categorically claim a group is or needs . . . . Really Rain (Temple,PA) imposing "sensitivity training" on "white people" is the solution? Sad, so very sad!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Annette, Fords, New Jersey — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:11:31 GMT

I honestly think people read into things way to much. I am a white woman. I am proud to say that. I would be equally proud if I were a black, brown, or purple woman for that matter. Our skin color is just that - COLOR. Color does not make the man an issue; man makes color an issue.

I respect all people of all color and race, however it irritates me when there are so many seperations amongst the races. In one breath people are asking to be treated as equals and in the next breath they are the ones doing the seperation. Why must there be seperate awards, community programs, etc.?

I see this magazine cover as a perfectly respectful magazine cover. Believe me people there are a lot worse magazine covers out there that should be generating this much talk.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tembi — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:16:31 GMT

If you look at the other photo options for the front cover, they are all beautiful shots! But I think the fact that this is the Vogue "Shape Issue" the cover that they chose makes complete sense. They are both sexy, hot, young and fit - and they are both on top of their respective games. When I first saw the cover my first thought was WOW - and that's not because Lebron looks dangerous or that Gisele looks frightened BECAUSE THEY DON'T. I thought "wow" because it's a very sexy cover & they both look like they are having a blast together.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ronni — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:17:17 GMT

Narrow minded people like Shannon and Sandie are the reason rascism still exists. Bigots like yourself lack the ability to honestly view themselves and the world around them. What you stated was a racist comment, take a honest appraisal of yourself and elevate and educate yourseles, it's not too late to try. As for the picture I was neither offended oor elated but I do think there could have been better photos to choose from. I've seen better photos from Annie Lebowitz.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kirsten, Ramsey, NJ — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:20:50 GMT

I *saw* this cover and *heard* that it was controversial, but had to come here to find out what the issue is. Just looking at it myself, I couldn't find a dang thing wrong with it. And it's nice to see Gisele with all her private parts covered!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

G. W. Westerson, CT — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:24:51 GMT

This is a great piture, taken by a professional, of professionals. The spirit is incredible! It's a cover shot and designed to sell copies. If you see racism in this picture, look inward. The problem is not on the paper, it's in you!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Matt Chesonis High Springs Florida — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:27:14 GMT

You people are idiots. It's two celebrities on a cover of a magazine. Lebron plays wth intensity, and Gishelle is just hot. Plus she sure don't look like she is in gistress. Come on people, grow up.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Clara Phillips — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:30:20 GMT

I see two beautiful people having fun mugging for the camera!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Oracle — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:31:26 GMT

The black man freely posed for this shot. Thus...not racism and not a even a story. GET A LIFE PEOPLE!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lisa, Becket MA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:38:25 GMT

This is the most ridiculous topic in the world. All I saw were two athletes on the cover of a mag. His look appeared to me as someone that was getting ready to make a great shot. Get over it people. It's just a freakin' photo. Why does someone have to ruin it for everyone? This discussion is so stupid!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Stacey, Cincinnati OH — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:42:41 GMT

Ok, seriously. People need to find something better to do with their time than to knit pick at something like this. The cover itself, to me, is stupid! But, if she is supposed to be a damsel in distress she looks pretty dang happy! Get over it people, there is no underlying message with this cover!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Mariah, Jacksonville, FL — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:47:08 GMT

To Ed J: Uncivilized? Lebron and Giselle are both wearing and posing exactly what they do to make every dollar they have. If Lebron or any other player for that matter were concerned about looking uncivilized they would stop getting the prison tattoos and walking onto courts and fields wearing ridiculous amounts of jewlery. That is much more uncivilized and classless. Then again, I'm probably a racist too right?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Mariah, Jacksonville, FL — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:52:12 GMT

Re: Shannon Rebuttal: Atlanta, GA - You are using your race as a crutch right now. When will you stop? There is not a single white person placing any obstacles in your life. That obstacle is yourself. Blacks are not the only people in America who have to deal with racism and inequality. Stop being the victim! Do you not even see the other people around you? People who have to deal with literal hatred just to walk out their front door. Not just being turned down for a job b/c of race or called the proverbial N word. But being beaten, spit on, literally attacked, persecuted, mocked, hated, and demeaned even today in 2008. THIS IS NOT RACISM ~ IF YOU THINK IT IS YOU HAVE NO CLUE WHAT RACISM TRULY IS!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

george,indianapolis, Indiana — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 14:55:13 GMT

Man I can't see any racism in this picture. I don't know where some of these reporters come up with this stuff. It's just another case of news companies and media wanting to make a story bigger than it really is and wanting to just mess with something. Stupid Media.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Brooklyngirl — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 15:15:06 GMT

Three or four commentators and academics (some of whom were NOT black) criticize the cover and suddenly black people are too sensitive?

There is no controversy except for the one all of you are creating by dragging this thing on....

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Chesseley, Raleigh, NC — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 15:16:26 GMT

It is ashamed that people are so dismissive of the concern many people of color have with the photograph. First of all, the shot was probably a half second out of several hours and thousands of shots so I doubt either realized what the picture might look like until the cover was released.

My issue with the cover is that the magazine specifically picked this photograph to get the range of reactions, and hence sales, that it is recieving. People who say the photo is not racist miss the larger point that someone who understood the implications many would take from the photo placed the photo on the cover to drum up this reaction and divisive dialogue to sell magazines...

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

elh — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 15:34:04 GMT

Oh for God's sake people! Does EVERYTHING have to be racial! When did we (myself NOT included) get to be so hyper sensitive to everything! Find something more productive to do with your time

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Regina, Lindenhurst, IL — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 15:39:30 GMT

I cant beleive the media take an image and Blows it out of content... If someone comments Bad on there picture (King Kong) oh my GOD, you obviously have to much time on your hands to evalute the picture with so much negative. People move on in life. There picture together looked very happy and having agreat time taking these photos. STOP reading more in to pictures.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rhonda B., Dallas, Texas — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 15:41:21 GMT

This whole outcry over this GORGEOUS photo is most pathetic! Racism is surely alive and well in this country...because we keep it alive. However, as some of you poster's seem to be mislead and ignorant....it is NOT just our country that see's color. If that were so...there would be no war right now...anywhere! Read the "REAL NEWS" and you will discover the racial issues across the globe.

As a 35 year old white woman raised in a predominantly black "Holy Roller" church (here in Dallas, Texas), I've come to many conclusions on why there is an avoidance of racial injustice. The one that sticks in my mind is because of how we were raised. My mother, the church organist, taught me never to look at another color as being inferior to me. However, there were older black people in the church who told there youngster's that I was to be considered the white devil and to stay away from me. It is ALL in what we're taught as a whole. Black people can cry, "Oh, the white master has us shackled in chains and picking cotton!" The white can claim, "Watch out for that black dude, he's a gangster come to rob, rape, and murder!" Get a freaking life! As long as there are lazy, no-good people out there crying PREJUDICE for simple things such as this photo shoot, there will NEVER be a color-blind society. And for you folks that say that a white person would never know dicrimination....HAHAHA! Come to Dallas. YOUR color is not the minority here. If I go to the local public hospital, I am racially profiled as being non-existent because I am white. Where is MY affirmative action? For you people (white or black), that SEE only the stance of a black man and the frailty of a white woman....open your eyes. That picture IS America! It is WHO we are and portrays WHAT we do! WE...US....Americans!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Dave, West Hartford, CT — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 15:54:49 GMT

Wait. Pardon me a moment. A previous poster commented "Part of the reason racism still exists is because black people want it to." Umm, WHAT?? I need no crutch, nor do I care to carry any sort of "get out of jail free card", thank you very much. It appalls me that people in this day and age even continue to think, let alone voice this kind of drivel. Back to the subject at hand, Gisele and LeBron were chosen for the cover shoot due to the fact that they are the "cream of the crop" of their respective professions. Nothing more, nothing less. Any "controversy" is merely contrived, or as they say, "it's all in your head".

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Margi T Marina CA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 16:14:38 GMT

When is race going to be a thing of the past. to me the picture is awesome - 2 beautiful people - no racism even spews from this picture. I have found that mostly people of color are the ones to scream racism right away - it's time to move into the 21st century and quit blaming something that happened 400/500 years ago - it's destroying lives and the sooner they all grow up and accept everyone regardless of color - the better this world will be

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Margi T Marina Ca — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 16:26:42 GMT

YVETTE DETROIT, MI my question to you then is why are people of color always changing - they were Blacks, then they were Afro Americans now people of color. It's the likes of Jessie Jackson and Al Sharpton and Opra Winfrey (although she does very good for people).. IF you were not born in Africa, you are right - you are not African - just because your ancesters perhaps came from the area doesn't mean you are that way - you are an American - period - regardless of your color and as soon as the race accepts this and the likes of Jessie J and Al S are extinquished, only then can people move on. But when it's thrown in your face on a daily basis and used as an excuse to find faulty and cause alot of tension and mistrust people tend to get defensive.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

T Jones — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 16:43:35 GMT

I'm sure they could have chosen a much more flattering picture for a magazine that's only had 4 african americans on the cover in 100 years. Given the large amount of negative african american imagery in the media that still continues to this day, I can see why people are alarmed.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

ashley, wash, dc. — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 16:45:37 GMT

This can be perceived as rascist is someone wants it to, it can also be perceieved as "Beauty and the Beast" gisele is def. Beautiful and lebron is def. A beast on the basketball court, that's how I see it and to all you ignornant commenters before me gisele is brazilian so stop calling her a white woman fools!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Stevie — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 16:51:27 GMT

*****HELLO EVERYONE*****
The fact of the matter is quite simple and we should be able to put this to rest quickly. To many black people in this country, printing or showing images of an "angry" looking black male has overtones of racism. I am not saying that the photo is racist because that would imply that there was intent when it was to be published, what I am saying is that intent does not diminish the truth.

What really concerns me most of all is that the overwhelming majority of white respondents don't have a clue as to why some black people find this offensive, and then claiming that whomever finds this offensive is racist themselves. This could not be further from the truth.

I went to Europe last year to attended a couple of soccer games and much to my chagrin some fans actually threw bananas at the black players, all the while making monkey chants. This type of behavior comes from centuries of associating blacks with Simians worldwide.

So, next time you comment, make sure you think deeply about why this is issue in the first place. Sometimes one must step outside of himself to see things from a different perspective.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Ann, Seattle, WA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 16:53:19 GMT

The reason people are making a big deal about this cover is that race is a heated issue in this country and people want to read about it. You clicked, you commented, you read, you are interested. If it's really not an issue you wouldn't be here. The media likes to create controversy because controversy = readers = money. They are definitely a big part of the problem, but how can you blame them when they are giving us what we want? Click click.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

F. Dixon, New Jersey — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 16:55:29 GMT

I am a young black woman and take no offense to the photograph other than it being mundane. As far as racism and sexism, it does exist. We can't paint it with a rainbow color brush nor can we blame any one race or sex for keeping it alive. Differences do exist among the races but merely as a result of diverse cultural backgrounds. These differences should not be looked at as reasons to divide ourselves but as reasons to celebrate human distinction.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

LC, College Station, TX. — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 16:58:09 GMT

This is out of control. As a 22 year old, (and part of a hopeful generation that is passionate about color lines being history) I choose not to be concerned about the color of ones skin but what you individually bring to the table. When I looked at this cover I saw a sexy photo of Lebron, a bad A** NBA star with Giselle, a gorgeous Brazilian supermodel (never once did it occur to me that it was a black man and a white woman). It wasn’t brought to my attention until seeing that someone (with too much time on their hands) has hyped it up to be offensive and actually has people supporting his idea! WHAT A JOKE...King Kong!! SERIOUSLY???? I thought the cover was creative, it caught my eye and it looked like the 2 were having fun!! The magazine (in bold letters on the cover) is offering advice about great bodies and being in shape. The way I look at it...Vogue chose Lebron to represent the "best of the best" bodies of men, and Giselle for the women. BOTH of them deserve this!! So don't take that away from them and their fans. I'm now only offended on Lebron’s behalf because someone (who is selfish) took his image on a magazine cover and twisted into a racial issue that portrayed him as King Kong scaring an innocent woman (who is smiling by the way). This is so frustrating. Has anyone asked Lebron or Giselle if either one of them is offended? While I do appreciate art and how one person can interpret it differently than another, in this case, if you look at this photograph and see it as an attack on colored men or maybe NBA stars, or any other negative story you wish to concoct, please try not to ruin it for Vogue, Lebron, Giselle or anyone else. Vogue is not out to get you! America is not out to get you!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Keith, New York City, NY — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 17:04:59 GMT

This "controversy" is just another bunch of tripe cooked up because for some reason in this land of plenty, we have too many people who are eager to be outraged about something....ANYTHING......

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Eri Johnson, Huntington Beach, California — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 17:19:08 GMT

Anyone sitting around worrying about this photo either A, does not understand that Lebron is a basketball player (note the basketball - don't think Kong played with such). He is considered a beast on the court, a large guard who can run, jump, shoot, and do just about everything else on the court. He is a superstar...and anyone comparing him to a guerilla out to visit their local zoo.

Gisele is on another cover, which means she makes even more money. Note she doesnt seem like she is being carried around by a 40 foot tall, make believe monster from New York City.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Chesseley, Raleigh, NC — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 17:20:53 GMT

Margi T Marina Ca, I am no Jesse Jackson or Al Sharpton supporter by any means, but to suggest that if people like them stop talking abut race the issue will go away is completely inaccurate. My father is an american patriot whom, after scoring a 1460/1600 on his SAT's and graduating High School with a 3.9, was rejected by both UNC and NCSU for failing to meet their academic requirements. Fast forward 20 years from 1960 to 2000 and I personally was rejected for a job as a sales clerk for a lack of educational credentials after graduating from NCSU (a school my father could not attend)just to find out that my white brother-in-law, whom I love dearly, was subsequently hired for the same job without either any experience or a high school diploma.

Fortunately I am now a lawyer and happy to have had the opportunities I have had, but to simply think that we can move on without addressing disparities among races, genders, origin, etc. is to in and of itself perpetuate the problem more than this somewhat daft discussion about a silly photograph could ever do.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Marcus, Houston Tx — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 17:29:41 GMT

Analyst out there and ignorant people need to get a .. life. I am an African-American man and I just can't for the life of me see how this image reinforces or even portrays us in a stereotypical manner. I guess those non-African Americans are now the authorities on 'OUR' image. It's amazing that we can be having this discussion about a picture and aren't appalled by really offensive images (most of the stuff on television. THANKS for pointing out our SHORTCOMINGS!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Chantel, Chicago, IL — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 17:30:46 GMT

How many of you have seen the other pictures available for the cover?
How many of you have seen the other photos of black celebrities this photographer has taken?
My only question was: the highlight is supposed to be their body shape, what part of his shape can you see? No ab's, no calf, barely his arm, and his mouth is wide open. On her-- a barely there outline, a skinny arm and one half of a leg. There was a picture IN the mag that could've accentuated this more than him and her looking like their goofy. Doesn't even look genuine, come on!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

LaShaundra T. Ellenwood, GA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 17:36:13 GMT

I usually never do this, but after hearing all the controversy about the Vogue cover I had to respond. I see absolutely nothing wrong with the picture and I never would have likened Lebron James to King Kong. That is absolutely ridiculous. I think the picture shows great contrast between Lebron and Gisele's profiles, personalities and professions.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

John Baker, Cortez, FL — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 17:45:12 GMT

This whole "contraversy" reminds me of the saying "when guns are outlawed, only outlaws will have guns" perhaps a better saying might be " when there is no racism, only racist will point it out". it's a lot like Governer Spitzer - work to shut down prostitution and the like while using their services at the same time.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

searuggs — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 17:54:33 GMT

The cover would have looked better with Lebron James and Naomi Campbell, the real super stars, instead of a white women.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Krissy, Seattle, Washington — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 17:55:36 GMT

Honestly the media puts soooo much emphasis on something that isnt even a BIG deal, Lebron and Gisele are two very BIG faces in the industry and its great that a Rich Black man Is on the cover of a Magazine with a Rich white women, It just shows a different aspect on ewverything.. its not even a BIG deal!!!!!!!!!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Emily, Ohio — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 17:57:26 GMT

I would like to know who started the Idea that this was a racial cover? Black or White we do not know. So the people who say blacks make everything a racial issue in this situation (how do you know that the person was black?) I personally don't find this cover offensive at all. I think its a strong basketball stance for LeBron and a Beautiful model pose for Gisele. I have a multi-racial family and they all do not find this cover offense. We all need to GROW UP!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Greg — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 18:00:51 GMT

Wow!! Is this really news? Are we really this petty? Good Lord, I guess if you look hard enough for something, you're going to find it. People see what they want to see. I saw the Virgin Mary in my toast this morning (WHAT?). All I see in this picture is Lebron James, the basketball player and Giselle Bunchen the supermodel. I don't know, I guess maybe I'd like to see less clothes on her (intentional sexist remark).

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

ms anita, norfolk, va — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 18:03:35 GMT

As a Black woman I'm NOT offended by this picture at all, but i can understand why it can be viewed somewhat stereotypical. Maybe they should of put Labron in a suit or something instead of making him pose like a madman, but other than that, I don't believe there was any intent. If there was intent, it was too show people that this is the world we live in now, and for those of you who don't like it, get to steppin. Race don't matter. and that lead singer from 1 republic is a cutie, i would take a picture with him...lol.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jenna, Florida — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 18:27:21 GMT

I, like many others I now see, think that it is sad that this could be brought up on national television to be discussed as though it were controversial. It's exhausting to have to SEARCH for the racism in things like this, and I almost laughed when Nancy Giles brought up the fact that LeBron was posed like King Kong. Sounds like SHE'S the racist one! I know NO white people who would have said that, or even thought of that. It's ridiculous. That photograph captured their personalities well; showing the two ballroom-dancing together wouldn't have captured their essence at all. Although, it would have kept Nancy Giles quiet, which may have been worth it. But no, it seems as though this country is having a hard time getting past racism NOT because white people are still racist, but because people SEARCH for it, in photographs like this. I am so tired of it. We are not responsible for the actions of our ancestors. We need to move beyond that.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

T Blue, Tampa, Florida — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 18:44:34 GMT

I personally didn't find the photo offensive. I know that some people (regardless of ethnicity) will make an issue of this. People need to wake up! It's just another way for the media to cause some unnecessary "hype" about nothing. I'm more concerned about oil prices, job security, crime, etc. There are more important issues in the world to talk about then this.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sage, Seattle, WA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 18:46:44 GMT

After viewing other choices the magazine could have made, I think the choice of this photos was for the sake of controversy, which would guarantee the issue would be talked about and sell. No mystery here. If LeBron was dumb enough to pose like this, he deserves the controversy he generates. As for Gisele, she's just a prop, albeit a lovely one.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rita, Tacoma, WA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 18:51:31 GMT

Hey people, this is flat out commercialism. We're being manipulated, big time. Vogue won. We've all become so hypersensitve and politically correct to this racial crap that we jump up and down on cue whenever someone puts anything the least bit controversial out there. There were better pictures to choose from, but Vogue clearly went for the one that would generate the best sells.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Harry, Avon Park, FL — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 18:53:19 GMT

Its just a picture for crying out loud. C'mon people get a grip. I do not see anything racist in the picture.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Carol, Reno, Nevada — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 18:58:39 GMT

Personally I think all people are the objecting to this picture because you look at it and question marks float over your head.I still don't think King Kong, I just think it's a weird picture and the the photographer and people at Vogue must have had one hell of a party. Who cares? Life goes on!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

D. Amber, St. Petersburg, FL — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 19:00:22 GMT

Well, first you have to ask yourself - Would LeBron do the cover to begin with if he thought he was being depicted as a "gorilla"? I read an article a few weeks ago celebrating the fact that LeBron James is the 3rd man to EVER be on the cover of Vogue. And now, people are trying to call it racism? Seriously? I mean, SERIOUSLY? Let's not take away from what this says about the status and stature of LeBron James. The 3rd man EVER to be on the cover of Vogue!!!!!

The photo is what it is - two BEAUTIFUL people! And that's what Vogue does - captures the essence of beauty in today's society. It's time to move on people - racism isn't what it once one - people actually see and love people for who they are not WHAT they are.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Britt, Amsterdam, the Netherlands — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 19:01:42 GMT

I think the issue about this cover has been taken way out of proportion. I think it's a beautiful cover with great energy. I am really surprised that some people consider the cover racist.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Phoenix, AZ — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 19:11:38 GMT

People that find this photo offensive are ignorant.
Plain and simple.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Also Black — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 19:19:00 GMT

Does anyone know how LeBron how feels about the picture? I'm sure he's frustrated/mad that their are ignorant people out there thinking that there is something wrong with this cover. Come on people!!!! It's racist cause you make it racist. This country will NEVER EVER move past racism with people like "Ed J" making comments like he did half way down the first comments page. You are making our race and your self weak with the way you think. MOVE ON! It's a great cover, nothing racist about it, no monkey, no nothing JUST A PICTURE. Build a bridge dude!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Diane, Shreveport, La — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 19:20:57 GMT

I'm An African American woman and I honestly don't think that Vogue or the photographer they hired meant to come off as racist.

Why? Because I'm positive that 99.99 percent of the people who work at Vogue have no idea who LeBron James is. Fashion people are notoriously socialy myopic. They probably know of him only as some jock who is kinda famous. They definitely had to be told about him. He is being used as a sports prop for Gisele who is what Vogue is really about.

Vogue also has an extremely narrow view of beauty so I'm not surprised that they view Gisele as the alpha and omega of good looks.

By that I mean, you'd never, ever, EVER see a photo with Tom Brady and Tryra Banks or Naomi Campbell used as one of their covers. Why? Because vogue doesn't think that way. Besides, the world would spin off it's axis.

I think LeBron did the cover becazuse he sees it as a way to get more exposure. But he needs to be careful because the stereotypes of Black guys who can't wait to get at the white women, die hard.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Brandy, Chicago — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 19:50:25 GMT

Why is everyone saying black man with white girl...she's Brazilian. I love the shot and I'm a black female. I see nothing wrong with it. Hell I didn't think about it until I read this.

Now Vanity Fair covers annoy me...but thats a whole nother can of worms,

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jacinda, NYC — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 19:51:41 GMT

The idea that black people want to keep racism alive is not only complete nonsense but rather insulting. Racism is alive well and no amount of talk about colorblindness and diversity will change that. We would rather bury our heads in the sand than address racism head on. I admit that I would not have thought of James a gorilla but all that says is that I've been trained to "look beyond color" while those who control society pay VERY close attention to it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Scott, Corvallis, OR — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 19:54:21 GMT

Stupid,stupid, stupid! Don't people have anything better to do with their time than to analyze a photo and make a controversy out of nothing. Come on people! It is who LeBron is, a firece competitor on the court. What is he supposed to look like.By the way I don't see a damsel in distress. She seems pretty happy to me. Even as I get ready to push the "send" button I might be labeled as a racist for my comment.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Mona C., Pasco WA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 19:56:00 GMT

I'm thinking its not "blacks" making an issue, its the media - once again!!! Anyone can turn a positive into a negative with thought & energy. Let's use the energy for positive thinking. The media should point out the good things about this photo shoot. There are many. I agreed if one is a racist, one may see racism in this photo. I did not! I saw an attractive man and woman posing, earning a living and enjoying life! By the way King Kong was a STORY only! Entertainment only!! Can't a photo shoot just be a picture. Get over it already and enjoy the artfulness of the photographers talent and the joy the models are showing. Don't we have enough in our country to debate about, must we look for more. Note: a little disappointed in the today show and how this presented this particular "news" story. Some things are better left alone.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

AP, Memphis, Tennessee — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 19:58:47 GMT

I think that this photo depicts LeBron and Gisele as who they are - an athlete and a supermodel. However, what is appauling to me is the comments that have been made. We are all entitled to our opinion - something that offends one person may not offend another. We need to learn to value each other's opinion without trying to assasinate who that person represent. The comments about African Americans trying to "pull the racist card" is quite absurd and ignorant. African Americans don't get anything out of racism existing nor are we trying to keep it alive. But for those who close their eyes and say that racism doesn't exist is fooling themselves and living a lie. We cannot ignore the fact that racism exist but must continue to eradicate this ugly creature.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Curtis,Chicago,Illinois — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 20:15:21 GMT

Never heard of her...

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rob S., Portland, OR — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 20:16:37 GMT

Isn't there other things to fret about such as gas prices, recession, upcoming election, etc. The picture expresses exactly the viewer wants it to. I see two well maintained bodies advertising themesleves and their apparel; both of which get paid millions for those reasons. Good for Gisele & Lebron.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sharon — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 20:25:45 GMT

Why couldn't Vogue put Naomi on the cover with LeBron? Would they have put Tom Brady with Naomi? I doubt it!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sojourner Knight, NY, NY — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 20:30:09 GMT

As an African-American woman, I don't think Vogue's intent was to be racist. I simply think that Blacks are thought of in certain ways by society-at-large. And that, sadly, leads to photos and misrepresentations about who we are as people. Many of the people commenting think that we (Blacks) are being overly sensitive, playing the race card or reading too much into it. But let me remind you, historically, we've been seen as mammies and bucks and overly sexualized people, so forgive us if certain images conjure up old feelings and stereotypes that we've tried hard to concur. Images like the Vogue cover remind some of us that even a successful, charming athlete like LeBron can be scene as something other than what he is. Something, someone akin to an ape. Yes, that stings. When you've seen images of your people with exaggerated lips, noses and bugged out eyes and nappy hair--all so that they would be brainwashed into believing that they weren't beautiful or attractive--it's a quite hard to let go. If you look at it from a different perspective, maybe it's not so difficult to understand.

And no, we won't just be glad that LeBron is on the cover. Not when it's still a big deal in 2008 that people of color make it on the cover in the first place. And for those of you who pretend to be colorblind, you are really doing yourself (and others) a disservice--because there is no such thing. You have to SEE color to appreciate the beauty and magnitude of it and revel in the difference of it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

jane doe, fresno — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 20:50:39 GMT

who's LeBron James? To be truthful, I didn't recognize either one of them! I saw the photo, thought, "OK, what's the problem there?" Then I read about this so called "controversy." hmmm interesting, but who cares? why the fuss? it's just a photo on the cover of a famous magazine.. big whoop. Get over it, y'all

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jonothan, Los Angeles, CA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 21:07:20 GMT

The Vogue cover photo is a very accurate mirror... Racists simply look into and see themselves.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

barb smith New castle Indiana — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 21:26:33 GMT

Please if we contune to make something out of everything black and white it well always be a problem. These people are doing something to make money not to say I'll black or I'll white. Tell the news people and some {?} to get a life. Please.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Dv Nguyen — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 21:31:55 GMT

I guarantee nothing will happen if a white male in the same size of lbj is in that foto.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

KC, Ojai, CA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 21:38:34 GMT

Racism truly exists. And if you are any kind of minority you know what I am talking about. It's subtle sometimes and overt other times but it DOES exist. I used to be a long time subscriber to Vogue and honestly I got real excited when I saw Oprah Winfrey on the cover years ago. Vogue's record for having ANY minorities on their cover(I've yet to someone of Asian descent for example) is pretty small. As someone else pointed out, if this was a photo of two white people or two black people, no one would be having this discussion but as soon as you start mixing, everyone seems to get upset. Start educating yourselves because people will continue to mix. Lastly, I don't believe Mr. LeBron looks like an ape (and I have always detested that so-called parallel, it says alot about the people who really believe it), I believe he looks no different than many men I've seen, psyching up for a big game. And quite frankly Ms. Buchen looks like she's having the time of her life. What's the problem again?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rob - Fresno, CA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 21:55:56 GMT

I agree that it is more racist to automatically see racism where it doesn't exist. It never occurred to me that this was a racist photo. I heard about "the controversy" and began looking for the photo online, and thought I was looking at the wrong one. I was shocked people were reading so much into this photo.
Is photo #2 racist and sexist because it shows a white woman as a black man's trophy for being successful? Is photo #5 sexist because the man is a better athlete than the woman? Is photo #8 misogynistic because the man is carrying off the woman like a piece of property? It is very easy to perceive something in a way which reflects your own thoughts and desires. I say if you perceive racism in this photo, it is only because the photo reflects your own racist thoughts.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Scott, San Antonio, TX — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 21:57:38 GMT

Like others, I had to read this article to even find out what the whole "controversy" was. Whatever. I looked at if for several minutes. Never could find anything controversial. I think it is a great photo. For those of you who think this is racist or whatever, get a LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jeremy's Dad., Boiling Springs, SC — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 21:57:39 GMT

If we would stop looking at people as being from different races, this would stop. There is only one created race, The Human Race. We are all just shades of the same color. Share the Love!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Marsha R, Northampton, MA — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 22:00:26 GMT

Why, only in the United States, does everything have to be either racist or too sexual? I have been to other countries and they would not think twice about this picture. They would accept it for what it is, a picture of two beautiful and talented people.

Maybe we should all step back for a moment and value each other for the good things we do and not a picture that is just that, a picture.

Let's get back to basics and focus on what is truly going wrong in this country, such as the evaporation of the middle class, corruption in government, and children and our elderly going hungry and without the proper medical care in one of the richest, most advanced countries in the world.

Oh, and let's not forget the steady and quick decline of our educational system.

We should be spending our time resolving these issues instead of reading something into a picture that just isn't there.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

CLM — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 22:02:05 GMT

Let's stop making everything a racial issue. We need to move on. The past is the past. We need to learn from it and move on.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Stewart, Lehi Utah — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 22:33:02 GMT

Sometimes I wonder if people don't have enough to worry about.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Modi K., Essex, Vermont — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 23:16:46 GMT

Take this with love, people...
I'm not as frustrated with the image as I am with some of the comments on this thread. Those of you saying African Americans are perpetuating racism by calling it out?? Are you serious?? So we should wait for the oppressor to say, "You know what, that might portray (insert marginalized group here) look bad." Maybe you don't see King Kong because you're USED to the stereotype! It doesn't faze you, so of course you wouldn't see it as racist. As a man, I may not know how sexist I'm being until a woman points it out to me. And before we throw "common sense" out there again lets remember that it's not all that common.
Again, as for the image, I think it and the Ohno photo were the best choices for a cover shot. And yes, Giselle looks perfectly happy. But Lebron's pose? Come on ya'll: that's a face you make after a dunk -- NOT while dribbling.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Vinnie, Salem, Oregon — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 23:32:30 GMT

Just seems like people arent happy unless they find something to complain about. This is just a picture or two very famous people, and it needs to be left at that. Whom ever wants to make a big deal about this just needs to realize that not everything is racial or has a sub meaning.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Diana, Ft. Lauderdale — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 23:33:59 GMT

There is nothing racial in this picture. James is dribbling a basketball as if he were in the middle of a game. I am confident that the photographer wanted to capture who both James and Giselle are. I don't see the gorilla pose and Giselle doesn't look the slightest bit afraid if anything she is laughing and looks almost like she is jumping.
As a response to previous comments, yes racism still exists because black people want it to, but also because white people want it to. Ignorant white people are still uneasy around blacks especially those in positions of power, and ignorant black people are quick to pull the racism card. If we want to end racism then we need to give up the stereotypes.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kristine, Bettendorf, Iowa — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 00:05:22 GMT

Why do we have to look at an image and see black and white. That's why there is racism because people are so eager to notice the obvious yet shallow differences. I feel pity for people that must waste their time looking first at color no matter what color they may be.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

SW, Rockville — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 00:17:04 GMT

It's really not a big deal. I was shocked people were making it an issue. I'm a 35 yr old black woman who thinks they both look great. Gisele looks anything but the damsel in distress. It's a great pic.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lee, Los Angeles, CA — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 00:32:36 GMT

Honestly, I do not believe that the similarity to King Kong was coincidental. I would not have seen the resemblance to King Kong but after seeing it and thinking about it, it was probably intentional (think King James vs. King Kong). In saying that, I also do not believe it was intended to be demeaning to LeBron or anybody of any race. Was it a bad comparison if it was intentionally depicting King Kong? Yes. It probably was. Was it insensitive? Some obviously believe it was. Should it be this big an issue with all the intentional racism that is seen on a day-to-day basis? I don’t believe it should.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

J Gardnew, Hollywood, CA — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 00:35:25 GMT

Please, let us take no pictures or make conversations. No matter what is said or done it is wrong.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

JT, Gaithersburg MD — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 01:43:29 GMT

It is incredible to me that this photo has generated the amount of criticism, racism and stupid remarks that we have had to sit and listen to. It's the media folks, they exaggerate anything and everything for that "scoop". I feel bad for LeBron, though I'm not a big fan of his, you cannot deny his athleticism, and that's only what Leibovitz is portraying, his athleticism, pure and simple. Because he is black, and the woman is white, there HAS to be a hidden agenda, and the whites are making it look like a stereotypical Mandingo Warrior (by the way and for the record, I'm a white male, age 50 - and I'm offended by the remarks that have been generated). Get real, this is 2008, no 1918. As John Lennon said - give Peace a chance...Peace.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kristi Gill — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 02:23:10 GMT

i love it, for once in a persons life can they sit back and say lets do something like this without stirring something up, i don't know. can they be less of a black and white issue. i think the photographer did a good job of capturing there peronalities. him being the active and outspoken basketballer and her being a gorgeous model. tombs up!!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sandi, Tucson, AZ — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 02:28:19 GMT

Are you kidding??!!! King Kong?? I didn't think anything, remotely close to that, when I first saw the picture. Who's making this an issue, people who have precious little else to do with their time??? The rest of the educated, thinking, world (who are of all colors and races)have better things to do than even bother to READ a Vogue, nevermind struggle to find some secret agenda in the cover art! Annie Lebowitz is a brilliant, well respected, photographer and, I think that taking her image of two beautiful and talented people and making it out to be a caricature of a lousy monster movie from the LAST century, is what I find TRULY OFFENSIVE. Obviously, LeBron and Giesele didn't find anything offensive to it, or else they wouldn't have agreed...and that should be everyone's Litmus test. Now, stop trying to pick a fight where there isn't one!!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

CNick — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 02:34:42 GMT

To African Americans this does mean something. It truly shows the mentality of Afr.Ame. athletes once they go pro, "get a white/latina/any non-black woman to have as your trophy wife. And there is a picture of it. Why did it have to be Gisele, why not Kim Porter, Halle Berry, Thandi Newton, Naomi Campbell, Traci Ross, why not one of them being shown as a beautiful and happy woman. Or does the Caucasian viewers believe that we (Black-Ame) are so comfortable with Black women being in the shadows to ignore this slap in the face?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tokyo Godfather, Tokyo, Japan — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 02:55:18 GMT

Personally, as a black man who reads the blog http://stuffwhitepeoplelike.wordpress.com, and my own blog, http://blogger2.earthwalkersmag.com , which have agitated white and black commenters all the time, I can see that there is a demographic that reads msnbc.com , namely non-black people who have never heard or seen racial epithets thrown at their black friends. Growing up in a white school, being called Ape or Monkey or Porchmonkey is one of the most common racial epithets given to black men, and I heard it for years. Fortunately, most white people are not racist. Unfortunately, most white people don't see or hear the racism that their racist white peers whisper when the non-racist ones are not around, so they think racism is gone. Long story short, as soon as I saw this picture, I knew why and how it would be interpreted by white people who believed the black man/white woman stereotypes, and I also knew how black people would interpret as well, because we are the ones who HEAR the stereotypes when you're not around. The fact that Lebron had his "game face" (a growl) on but Giselle did not, showed that Annie knew what she was doing. But I also noticed the other key - Giselle was smiling. That's all that mattered to me.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

scott spalding — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 02:58:47 GMT

i think it is a media stero type that a black man has to be shown with a white women when ever possable so i think the media in genral does its best to keep this contraversy alive why dont you ever here a black women point of view on this its the media way of traning white people to accept it and to keep black women shut out because they are stronger and often more out spoken then their white counter parts and frankly if you were to ask a black women how they feel about a black man and a white women you might not like the answer hahaha

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jasen W., Concordia, KS — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 03:50:51 GMT

The ONLY offensive issue here happens if the magazine gives an apology.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

vince Baltimore, Md. — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 04:21:03 GMT

the lady that took the picture is the one at fualt, she just came up with a bad shot for the cover. people cut that race talk out. somebody s bounus will be cut for that picture.( VOGUE ) try again !!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Nick, Phoenix, AZ — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 04:30:21 GMT

This is someone trying to make a story of NOTHING. He is known for INTENSE basketball, she is known for looking good. They are both portrayed as such here. If I were Lebron I'd be bummed it wasn't a "hotter" pic of me, but again he's not making millions off being good looking - he has actual talent.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jay, Indianapolis, Indiana — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 05:02:42 GMT

First of all let me say I am a black male myself and OMG, this is being so blown out of proportion. It is ridiculous that people have taken it this far. Lebron looks like that in many of his shots. That is the high-energy type of expression that is associated with him period! He likes that type of look. People need to relax and find a hobby. Nobody was thinking anything about an ape until someone decided that Lebron had look like an ape holding a white woman. This is really stupid.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

MarcusH, Saint Paul, MN — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 05:09:51 GMT

It's late Thursday night and I just heard about the Vogue cover controversy and so, I rushed to see what's up? What could it be? I took one look at the photo and said, "It's Lebron James and a hot supermodel!"...So, I don't see a controversy here...

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kaylee Griffiths, Columbus, Nebraska — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 05:12:48 GMT

Seems to me there is not enough real news out there for the media, so this cover became a new target for stirring up emotions that would never have been stirred had the term racist not been used. It's just really sad. I see two superstars at the top of their game. LeBron looking agressive (which is how basketball is usually played) and Gisele looking beautiful (which is usually what supermodels look like).

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

ASHLEIGH, BIRMINGHAM — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 07:49:50 GMT

For a magazine as fashion-forward a Vogue, I would have appreciated Lebron being dressed more sophisticated....maybe a tailor-made Italian suit. But, he is in HIS business attire, basketball gear. I'm a black woman and I don't find the picture offensive. I think this is another mole hill to mountain story. Let it go!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Caroline, Alaska — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 08:31:31 GMT

People are saying that "only a racist sees this picture as racist" but really only a racist (and sexist) can look at this photo and see nothing wrong. If what this picture shows is "normal" or "acceptable" in our society, then our society is saying that men (in this case black men) are supposed to be strong and grizzly/unsophisticated and women supposed to be dainty and sophisticated. If I saw this magazine on a news stand, I would be offended, even without hearing all this controversy, and I am not black. It is simply a portrayal of stereotypes, and there is no reason why this can't be avoided.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Dina, Buffalo, NY — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 11:35:12 GMT

I read an Associated Press article with a quote from LeBron James. “Everything my name is on is going to be criticized in a good way or bad way,” James told the paper. “Who cares what anyone says?” If he doesn't care, and he's the one in the picture, why the heck should anyone else? I read that the photo was supposed to look like he was in the middle of an intense game or something, like he was on the court and pumped about it, in which case, I think the photo succeeds quite well. It's the Shape Issue, they look like they're trying to get people excited about that. Well, it's working, albeit probably not in the way they intended, unfortunately...

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

jochen, dracut. ma — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 11:53:41 GMT

the hub bub about this pic really just brings to light that the US is the most racist country in the world. the simple fact that black men are still referred to as gorilla's or any beast is apalling. IMO there has been a resergence of rascism in this country. and one of the reasons why we are coming undone. it is kinda funny that we may have a black president. and can't be portrayed in the media with a white woman. thinking of leaving the states for good.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kendall, Sheboygan, WI — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 12:10:22 GMT

I have so much that I would love to say, but I will keep this short. This is so ridiculous. Who would look at this picture and see what is now being discussed? My answer, is someone who feels the need to keep rasism alive. I am not ignorant enough not to believe that there is no racism. With that said, I strongly believe that people create their own racism. Why can this picture be what it is, a picture. I look at it... no King Kong to me, only a basketball player and a beautiful woman. People need to get a life and stop creating controversy purly to try and prove that racism was a motive behind everything you see. That to me in itself is racism. Let us live for the future as Americans, vs.living in the past.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

LaMonica, Detroit Mi — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 12:36:48 GMT

I am an African American Woman. I think all the people who are turning this cover into a racial issue are just ridiculous and trying to make something into more than what it is.I mean this is an issue dedicated to bodies. And I'm sorry..that's LeBron James. He is exuberant and in your face on the court. Now If LeBron was a Noble Prize winning scientist who had cured cancer , then having him pose with a white woman with a basketball..Then YEAH , it would be racist..but last I checked.. HE PLAYS basketball for a living..And if you look at him on the court..this is what he does and looks like on the court. To all you Politically Correct" cry babies...sometimes a picture is just a picture..and You would probably see ALL Black Men with white women in

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

etta,Albany,GA — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 12:39:08 GMT

What is the big deal about LEBRON,and GISELE,taking a picture together? They are not lovers,just professional friends.I am 62 years young,and I am a product of slavery and segregation. I know that there are some hateful White people out there,because I have experience their hate,but there are some wonderful White people out there I have learned that the masses of socalled black people,donot know and understand the origin of their existence,therefore all that they can say and do is holler racism,and all that does is keep the fighting going on between the whites and the blacks. Allow the young people an opportunity to get alone. I don't believe in interracial marriages,I do believe every body and everything should stay,marry,and live with their own kind,cats with cats,dogs with dogs gnats wth gnat, flies with flies. That is the way the creator planned it Man has taken the way that we are suppose to live out of context,especially the socalled black man because he is dumb,ignorant and without the knowledge of himself.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jane P., Savannah, NY — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 12:40:45 GMT

Those who are making a huge fuss over something that's simply capturing the moment are only KEEPING RACE AN ISSUE. Unless this photographer is known for making subtle racial tactics, there's nothing to be paronoid about.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Claudius, New York,New York — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 13:41:01 GMT

This really is ground breaking photograph it gives us an image of an agressive black athlete and a 'godess'. Our eyes go to that agressive black male - why becuase we don't pity or fear him we celebrate him. We have seen that face and know what it means - it means I've just made an impossible shot look easy. Now I'm **King of The Game**.

It is also is a comic acknowlegement of the type of agression that some people once feared now making us laugh and smile. Not only has Vouge changed white people have changed too. Not sure if Le Bron has any poltical ambitions even if he doesn't he would make a better governor than Arnold S. If he stood he would win. Yes a black president and a black governor of California would be something to celebrate and Americans are making and can make it happen.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Gina, Largo, FL — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 13:57:43 GMT

Are you kidding me? Is this all that people have to worry about? Good heavens people, keep your eye on the ball! We are losing soldiers in a war and you are concerned about a magazine cover. Why should I be amazed. Americans are asleep and continue to prove it with ridiculous drama such as this. Kudos to the photographer because I think the photo is brilliant! Gorgeous black man and stunning white woman. Wake up America....

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Friedrich Muentjes, Germany — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 14:43:13 GMT

Dear all,
I can`t see connection between the picture on the front page and King Kong.
It`s still a nice picture.

All the best for your live broadcast.

I enjoy it all days on my i-pood

Best regards from Munich

Friedrich

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Dan, Savannah, GA — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 14:46:35 GMT

"The picture helps reinforce negative stereotypes about blacks. All Blackmen love to play basketball and be uncivilized. While the Attractive white woman stands there quite civilized!"???????????? LeBron IS a BASKETBALL PLAYER!!!!! Why would they NOT want to show him as one????!!!! Michael Jordan appeared on many a magazine cover in the Bulls uniform...was that racist? NO! THAT IS THEIR JOBS! Apparently people don't know what goes on at a photo shoot and should be educated on how it goes. They are in a studio with the photog and other people and are told to start doing different poses...At some point they will just start to have FUN and goof around, which is OBVIOUSLY what they are doing in this picture. I make this kind of pose all the time (without the bball b/c I suck) just goofing around. Why can't it just be that? Why MUST it be racial? Whether you are black or white...there is no need to ASSUME this was a racial photo to begin with.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Kyle Green — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 16:18:56 GMT

Since when can we rely on the fashion industry to show any sensitivity about anything? What's amusing, and simultaneously dismaying, is the air-brained venality of it all, the pouting snobbery, the "defiant" model with a hip jutted sideways, her thumbs in her belt loops.... The fashion industry plays a sleight-of-hand brilliantly: creating the illusion of trend-making while in fact just recycling the same old things, introducing them to a new generation of consumers. The world of fashion is not the world of ideas of any consequence in this troubled world, but simply an on-going party (with nifty favors) for those able and eager to be part of it. This cover is a perfectly crass and shameless example. But the funny thing is, it shouldn't be shocking: it's fine. Why can't a muscled black athlete cavort in front of a camera with a sleek white female? Pictures don't just make it onto the cover of a magazine, they are reviewed and more-so SCRUTINIZED before making the grade, they knew what they were doing. Considering the srict-ness of the editorial crew, and the fact that he is THE FIRST black male portrayed on THE COVER, it's the magazine that's stuck in racism...think for yourselves

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Suzanne, Long Beach, CA — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 16:23:20 GMT

I also thought this was silly, until I saw an article that juxtaposed the Vogue cover with a WWI recruiting poster. Eerily simiilar.
http://www.jossip.com/somebody-should-tell-lebron-james-he-was-made-to-look-like-an-ape-on-vogue-20080328/

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tracey, Chicago — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 16:32:07 GMT

To the average American, the cover does not seem to be racist. However, the media execs who decided to approve this cover, may have thought otherwise. Media influence can provoke, invoke and evoke racist ideas. It is amazing that this magazine has never had a black male on the cover. Why now? Americans are pondering whether or not America is ready for a black president. The picture says nothing to non-racists, but it scares the hate-filled.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

justin, jackson,nj — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 16:36:36 GMT

"It's the comments that have been made that fuels the racism in this country. I could have looked at that cover and never once even considered the "King Kong" shot but now since it has been made an issue I can't look at it without thinking of it. He is a strong beautiful, talented man who just happens to be of color. How dare anyone compare him to an ape."

I wouldnt have made it an issue. But it is clear that the cover was going after the whole King Kong thing. Just be happy your too ignorant see the meaning behind ads. I honestly dont have a problem with the ad, my problem is with Lebron and the image he puts out.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Guilherme — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 16:44:40 GMT

I'm brazilian and when I first saw the cover (without knowing the "controvewrsy") I saw a strong player and our loved Gisele. That's all. Now, when I'm "learning" to be an "american", I have to stir controversy and accuse people of racism. Now, every time I see the cover I see KING KONG!! ohohoh
No wonder you americans are going to kill each other some day..you guys are nuts.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Anna — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 17:03:38 GMT

You can't change someone. If Lebron happens to look scary to you; the photographer didn't edit his face, he did that pose himself. Giselle is doing her job, modeling. Lebron plays basketball for a living, so of course they'll have him doing that in the photo. Theres a photo of another athlete looking quite similar, only difference is that he is white. I seriously think some black people have a bad self image.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sandra — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 17:04:57 GMT

I love that picture with Lebron! And I am a black woman, and I found nothing offensive with his features, pose or his companion in the pic. In fact i love that they showed his fierceness! Sometimes I think that the media is afraid to show a powerful black man, because they feel it may scare white people. I hated all those commercials with Michael Jordan with him smiling and eating hot dogs! He didn't get that far by smiling, he got that far( and what we admired) by his determination and effort. I also hated when that big guy from the movie "the Green Mile' did those car commercials and was grinning and dancing like an idiot! What made him so interesting was his brute masculinity, why diminish that for some stupid add, so people would think he was approachable? NOOOO! Leave Lebron with his fierceness, his street determination. That's what made him what he is! I love that photo. If anything, that pic screams BLACK POWER!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Anastasia, New York — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 17:09:11 GMT

Seeing this cover, I never once thought it was racist. People really need to get over this and it's only racist if you are. If Lebron and Gisele posed for this picture and one is black and white, then obviously they did not think it was racist. WOW, what is this world coming to?There are much more important issues in this day and age, than to be worrying about whether a magazine cover is racist or not, especially without it being pointed out.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jonathan,brooklyn,new york — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 17:16:07 GMT

One's racial remarks against an individual who happen to be black,shouldn't be excuse due to his lack of information and limited perception of black people because if person in the cover was white they may or may not make such of comments.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lisa S., Madison, WI — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 17:35:05 GMT

Vogue wants to sell copies of it's collectors edition. Why not ride the wave of recent race talks, and use this magazine cover to sell more copies! I don't think it is a matter of black people complaining nor white's being defensive but executives promoting a product.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Michelle, Alpine, TX — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 17:58:44 GMT

I can't believe the comment made by Shannon on March 26th. "Racism still exists because black people want it to." That is the most ignorant and incompetent thing anyone could have made.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Auntie JJ, Cape Cod, MA — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 18:50:55 GMT

I've heard about the cover for several days and just got a look at it and thought "What is the big deal?" Seems to me someone is looking to stir the pot.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

James Gawne, Glendale, AZ — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 18:54:16 GMT

To find this cover controversial is indicative in and of itself of a racist attitude. All I saw here was a supremely talented basketball player and a very attractive supermodel. Skin color is irrelevant. If they'd shot this cover with Dirk Nowitzki in the same pose, nobody would've said a word. End of story.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Claudia Malacrida — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 19:06:06 GMT

To be able to look at something that is subtle yet negative and draw on historical ideas and images to identify racial stereotypes is NOT the same thing as being a racist. Similarly, to be able to look at typical media images of women and understand that they are usually exploitive is NOT the same thing as being a sexist. Quite the contrary. Historically, Black men have been portrayed as animalistic, hypersexual, and dangerous to supposedly-frail White women - Black male power has been seen as a threat rather than a right. This seems like just another example of that kind of stereotype.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Erin, Littleton, CO — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 19:21:36 GMT

Never once would I ever look at this cover and think of King Kong! When you look at Lebron he's displaying the type of energy he uses on the basketball court for those of us who know him and Giselle certainly doesn't look scared of him. This is the exact reason why racism is still alive today and it seems more and more often it's the African-American community who keeps bringing things like this up. We can't even have a cover of magazine with two gorgeous people on it who happen to be white woman with a black man without issues. It makes me wonder if the roles were reversed and they had a white male basketball player with a black woman model, if anyone would be discussing it??? My guess is no!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

jon, st. louis, mo — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 19:24:03 GMT

I hadn't heard the hoopla surrounding this cover, until today. And when I first saw it I thought wow. It does look like a king kong ad. Sorry. It does. Whether James is a good looking man or not is neither here nor there. The imagery is pretty obvious. And I'm an artist. I also happen to be black and my wife is white. And the best man at my wedding was also white. So to Shannon March 26, 2008 9:18 AM... this is no get out of jail free card, and you, ma'am are as benighted as a person can be. It's not the KKK or The Nation of Islam that perpetuate racism. We know where those people stand. It's the people who walk through life with total ignorance of their fellow human being that perpetuate the problem. It's people like you who keep racism alive and well. WWII Germany wasn't full of Nazis. Just full of enough wrong thinking people to allow the rhetoric to fester. If you have children, I hope you make (or have made) the mistake and raise them to be better than you.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Brian, Oklahoma — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 19:53:14 GMT

This shouldnt even be a black and white issue for one major reason that nobody is disgussing. She isnt white. She's Brazilian. It's a good picture. Besides, from what I've read about it, LeBron doesnt think anything is wrong with it. So the whole issue needs to be dropped. It's stupid.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Michelle,Sacramento, CA — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 20:22:01 GMT

Why are people always pulling out the race card?! Any rational person would not see this photograph portraying "King Kong" and a “damsel in distress.” Get over it...seriously! This cover was meant to showcase how successful these two individuals are. Bottom line is that everyone will always have something negative to say about everything. Sometimes I wish that people should be required to take an intelligence test to determine whether you entitled to free speech or not. If you fail, you should have to keep your mouth shut in public. Extreme I know but so are these accusations of this cover being a racial issue. Congrats Lebron and Giselle on your success!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Sam, L.A, Cal — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 20:46:07 GMT

Reading some of the feedback it’s obvious it’s from mainly white people who haven’t experienced racism, and couldn’t see why the picture perpetuates racism even if I hit them over the head with the magazine. As a person of color when I saw the cover I didn’t have to read or hear what’s been said about it to realize it smacks of stereotype and racism.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jeri Myrick, Clerlake, CA. — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 20:51:49 GMT

I have this issue and think people need to read the articles in the god damn magazin before they say anything. They obviously don't understand photo editorials so read in place of your ignorance please.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Mark, Palmdale, Ca. — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 21:40:28 GMT

I see nothing appealing about this photo. Not from the standpoint of raciscm, but from the standpoint of it is not a good photo. Surely there were many other pics taken during their photo shoot. The question that should be asked is why was this one chosen. I dare say that there were better choices than this one for the COVER of VOGUE magazine

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Me, Chicago IL — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 21:42:03 GMT

As a black person, rather than looking at it from race perspective, I looked at it from a fashion point of view, why given the chance to be on the cover of Vogue, a magazine that eptomizes fashion, did he not wear Armani, Hugo Boss or Valentino, he chose workout gear!! Further more the cover was meant to get a reaction, because though Giselle is a tall chick, she is dwarfed completely by this 6'9 260 dude!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Breeze Summers, Riverside, California — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 21:50:42 GMT

This is the worst form of racism, when there isn't any racism of form. This cover shot is a progression of our society, not regressive. As an African American Male, raised in the 60's I cheer Vogue for making such a fashion statement; not a racist one. Its the Rev. Jacksons and Al Sharptons is why this beautful art is turning into racist slant.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

T Mc, Nashville, TN — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 21:54:34 GMT

When I looked at this photograph I laughed because I knew I was above this type of controversy. But, when I read some of the comments from people, it's obvious that racism still exists. You may think you are not a racist, but if you go back and read what you wrote, you will find that there is a little something "hidden" that you've just exposed. People will think what they want to think, but it is up to us to be the bigger person. Not all African Americans pull a race card, Not all Whites are prejudice. A lot of times when we say things out of anger, that's our true selves speaking. You may not agree with the picture being racist, but you just might find out you really are.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Philip 'Wasabi' — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 22:32:48 GMT

Seems everyone is in agreement.. This isnt racism and Annie doesnt have a racist bone in her body... so why do the racist get so much air time? What's in it for them to continue crying racism? The beauty of life escapes them.. for that I am truly sorry. Go make the world more beautiful.... like Annie does.

"Could we change our attitude, we should not only see life differently, but life itself would come to be different."
– Katherine Mansfield

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jim — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 22:48:23 GMT

Doesn't matter what it is. White women can do anything
they like with black men. Personally though I think
it shows bad judgement. Yet another 'in your face'
marketing tactic designed to create controversy. This
is what I resent about it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lisa, Philadelphia, PA — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 23:12:42 GMT

I don't get it. What am I missing? i see a beautiful girl cracking up in a picture. where is the damsel in distress?? I see a tall man with a basketball...where is the king kong? for goodness sakes...move on people. It's a cute picture.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Shea R., Clarkston, Washington — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 23:40:38 GMT

I really wish that America would look at the fact that LeBron is a outstanding basketball player, and from interviews that I have watched, a wonderful person from the inside out. Instead, people try to portray something horrible for everyone to gossip about. The cover looks great, that's his game face, that's him in the moment holding on to someone beautiful. I don't believe she looks scared, who would in his arms, he's amazing!! I really wish that people would stop all of this racist stuff when there isn't a smidge of it there, and focus on the racist things where they really are. The cover is wonderful.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tiffany Brown — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 00:16:16 GMT

It's King Kong-ish for sure. Leibowitz is not an idiot. She knows how to use symbolism and poses and positioning on film. She's a photographer. That's her job. That she's so good at it is what makes her brilliant.

I suspect the cover is both a tweak of the stereotype and a play on LeBron's nickname "King James." Nefarious? Hard to say. There? Absolutely.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Eunice R Westfield,MA — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 00:17:30 GMT

I say this... This is a face that HE chose to make. Which HE states he made to show his enthusiasm towards the game. Soooo if HE isn't offended, NO ONE else should be. lol it's silly and those who are all "omg im sooo offended!!" are just trying to milk the old "omg you're racist" bologna. You're just trying to milk it by making it a huge deal and it's not. Also, by making it a bigger deal than it is, you're just trying to get attention and remind others to feel pity for you. Those that were slaves deserve the pity, but that no longer exists !! Stop being so overly sensitive. The ONLY person who should feel any kind of offense is Mr. James and if he doesn't lol then those who are all "offended" most definately have no grounds to be. I personally am hispanic and I know what it's like to deal with racism. It is hard, but I would NEVER want someone to try to use me as a reason for themselves to be offended by someone's potential racial remark or treatment. lol let me be offended for things that are done to me; dont use me to further continue such negative thinking.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tristan, Madison, WI — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 00:51:34 GMT

I never really saw the King Kong imagery until this article. Reporting on this just makes things worse.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Aaron Allen, Lansing, MI — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 01:28:15 GMT

Being black myself, I would just like to say that I disagree with the statements that blacks are the ones who view this as a racist picture. Personally I don't like the picture, but not for a single racist reason. The main reason I don't like it is because to me it's not as classy as what I would expect from Vogue. I would expect this cover on Sports Illustrated but not Vogue. Be that as it may LeBron simply look as psyched as he does at any game and that's just fine. I didn't even think of King Kong once until the announcer started making comparisons. This picture has nothing to do with race or anything stereotypical. It's the same as taking a statement completely out of context. If you consider that this is just a issue dealing with the human body and fitness, it makes sense that it should be these two on the cover. To put LeBron on the cover with a black woman simply to avoid labeling would have been improper on the part of Vogue and made them no better than all these racists who are calling Vogue racist. I personally feel that the media and these "so called critics" are to blame here. Not black people. Not white people. Just ratings hungry media people. And to all of those who keeps saying this is black people's fault for trying to find racist issues please stop. Yes, some black people look for issues but the vast majority of EDUCATED black people understand that racism should be done away with in all its many forms. I look forward to days when welfare and affirmative action can be a thing of the past, and schools can spend money on books and equipment instead of metal detectors.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Alice B, Lacombe La — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 01:28:24 GMT

Two beautiful people enjoying the beautiful life!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Shannon — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 02:28:26 GMT

First, I said "part of the reason"....which means not all. Second, blacks are making a big deal about this (as well as the media) when it's not a big deal. It's a magazine cover. Anyone who reads racism into this is simply looking for something to complain about. And by the way, OJ is a prime example of someone using his race card. So are the Viking player who had the boat party.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

tim l. — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 02:43:49 GMT

you have got to be kidding me. anyone that sees a race issue in this...you are the racist. you are the ones keeping your own kind down. please wake up and realize the black man today has every chance to succeed in this country as the white man..ie. obama, tiger woods, lebron, shaq, jordan...should i go on..what do you want repairations too. this is an equal country. stop being sheep and break away from the stereotypes that you can't seem to bust down.
this is getting old.

and yes i am voting for obama...so call me racist.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Shannon — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 02:55:45 GMT

So for all the people who are reading racism into a magazine cover, her are some more important things to complain about....the fact that 9/11 was an inside job (thank you "Loose Change")...4,000 troops have died in a war that never should've been...gas prices...Health care (thank you "Sicko")...in 5 years or so we could be eating meat and drinking milk from cows that are lab created...read CNN headlines and learn it's a trend to throw kids off bridges and microwave them...we have elected a retard President for 2 terms...Does a magazine cover still seem so important?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lynn — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 04:15:52 GMT

Wow, the fact that people see anything racist in this picture is pretty funny. I would think it's more sexist, but definitely not racist. I have no idea where anyone would get a king kong image from this.

I hate the way the media makes a big deal out of out of nothing at all.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Bro Terry, Birmingham, Alabama — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 05:04:48 GMT

Vogue magazine has been around for over 100 years and a person with two fingers on one hand and one finger on the other can count the number of times a black man has been on the cover - on one hand! America is what America is. America was founded on race. And as simply as I can put it, America was founded by people who did not want to be told what to do in Europe but wanted everyone in America, if they wanted to be considered a "good" American, to do as they were told. And America succeeded by using humans of a different race as units of free production. Race is the metaphorical elephant in America's living room. Racial slavery happened, the black codes were real, racial segregation and racial descrimination are not theories - they are as much of the fabric of this nation as the proclamation of the emancipation of the slaves in 1862, the civil rights act of 1964 the voting rights act of 1965. And until we begin to acknolowdge and address the psychological trauma characterised by the history of the experience of the "African" American we will not begin to see the end of race as a foundational issue of division in America. It is not just going to just "go away".

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Heather O., Fernley, NV. — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 05:30:15 GMT

The picture appears to me that God has manifested in so many beautiful and different ways-these are 2 of many examples.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

David Lanham, Hattiesburg, MS USA — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 07:10:10 GMT

Leibovitz inserts a threatening, screaming black guy into what is essentially "Birth of Venus", the ultimate depiction of White feminine beauty and virtue, because she (Leibovitz) is a lesbian malcontent who hates strong, White men, and wants to see them replaced.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

candy — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 11:56:08 GMT

obviously the powers that be at vogue and that hack of a photographer annie lebovitz need to pick up a book on semiotics before they procede with their jobs. http://thekrays.wordpress.com

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jennifer, New York, New York — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 12:22:06 GMT

In the words of the great Bill Cosby, Come on people!! Those of you that have decided this is a race issue, literally, need to go away. Far far away. You keep stirring up things that are not even there! This cover is beautiful. She is a model and he is an athlete, both happen to be very good looking people. The End! Stop yourselves, just shut your mouths.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

nolan, los angeles — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 16:02:45 GMT

Hello, I am a white 28 yr. old. To me, it really is King Kong with his damsel in distress. This type of art form, a magazine cover page photograph, needs to appeal to a large mass of people. In order to do this, a reference to a classic image/idea is used and it grasps the attention of the viewer. This is the purpose of the photograph. Grab your interest and have you open the magazine. Is the photograph meant to insult brazilian women or black american men? I really doubt that. It is playing with familiar ideas in american culture in my opinion to grab your attention.

It really disgusts me to read fellow white people deny any resemblance to the king kong idea as well as it does those taking it to another level of racism. It is an image. This one image does not represent anything more than a classic reference which millions of americans can recognize even if they can't put it all together.

smile at your fellow brethren!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Dwayne E., Bronx, New York — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 17:15:42 GMT

Do you think that it is by pure coincidence that of all the beautiful and graceful photos taken, the one which was chosen was a racist depiction of a powerful black man "King James" being belittled by posing like "King Kong" with a damsel in distress in his arms.You mean to tell me that of all the people who reviewed and approved this photo not one saw the racist connotation and controversy that it would bring. This is exactly why racism still exists today. Are people that naive to believe that racism does not still exist in this country? I think not. People who fail to acknowledge racism in this country are usually the racists who do not want to relinquish their only strong hold that they have to oppress minorities. They deny the fact that racism exists with the "sweep the dirt under the rug mentality" Anyone with an open mind and clear heart could see the negative stereotypes of this photo at first glance.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Rebecca, Midlothia, VA — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 17:37:35 GMT

Why is the media creating a new racial frenzy with this cover? Sheer madness... it's a photo of two fit people for the "Shape Issue" of Vogue magazine. Why must there be more just to have a new dialogue of racial relations and assumptions? Damn!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Cat, Anchorage, AK — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 18:03:48 GMT

I like the cover photo the best of all the pictures from the article. Why is it that no one has said anything about the "crouching tiger" photo? To me, the feel of that one is more evocative of King Kong, but I guess since both the athlete and the model are white it doesn't warrant attention.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

LAE Virginia — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 18:49:15 GMT

I looked at the cover and never even considered it to be a racial statement or that the NBA player was "King Kong" like. I saw nothing threatening. I saw a talented NBA player and a beautiful woman. Until the uproar, I didn't even consider that his expression had anything to do with the fact he is black. I figured the photographer told him to get into the game and he did. Get over it.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Greg, Los Angeles, California — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 19:03:54 GMT

The Vogue cover is IDENTICAL to a World War One Army recruiting poster depicting a gorilla holding a white woman. FOLLOW THIS LINK: http://ecosofia.org/2006/03/hijo_perra_insultos_nombres_animales
Annie Leibowitz is a savvy, image conscious artist.
The similarity is a bit too close. I'm a fine art photographer with a love of art and visual history.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Angelique Matheson Clearwater Florida — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 19:40:23 GMT

If the two people on the front of this cover don't seem to mind why is everybody else making such a big deal?

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Art, Youngstown, Ohio — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 20:07:31 GMT

Don't we have better things to worry about? He's a basketball player. That's what he's doing. She's a model. That's what she's doing. Is Vogue trying to sell copy? Gimme a break.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

C Christa, Houston, TX — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 21:09:35 GMT

All these people that think it's just a picture, are probably for, the most part white, - and white folks just don't ever get it!!

You can bet they wanted to send the message of the "Wild Beast" & the oh so "Beautiful and fragile WHITE WOMAN". Vogue barely ever has BLACK FEMALE MODELS on their magazine covers - you can probably use both hands and have fingers left over to count the BLACK FEMALE MODELS they have ever used - So when they brag about the first Black Man to grace their cover - of course it is going to be a picture that is sending a message! Or why didn't they choose to use someone like Tyra Banks who IS on the TOP OF HER GAME!!! or another Black Woman - No, they deliberately wanted someone as white as they come to contrast with the Black Man showing all the characteristics that they wanted amplified. NOTHING THE MEDIA DOES IS WITHOUT REASON!!!! AND VOGUE'S CHOICE WAS TOTALLY A REFLECTION OF THE KIND OF MAGAZINE IT HAS ALWAYS CHOSEN TO BE!

But of course - we're just being "overly sensitive".

And LeBron, like many other Athletes, appears to only cares about the $$s he can make.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Derek, San Bruno CA — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 22:02:49 GMT

If you took their exteriors off and knew them personally, you'd probably recognize the picture truly probably portrays them as being them. Isn't there a famous quote that states "Never judge a book by its cover"? Prejudice only exists when you yourself give a label or cover to it. Read more into the story and content and stop making assumptions based on what you think the cover looks like and all else will seem a whole lot clearer.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lauren, Atlanta, GA — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 02:09:15 GMT

I cannot believe this cover is even being made an issue. It's a photo. I see nothing racist about this picture, but unfortunately many people do apparently and it seems that the vast majority of those that feel that way are black. Of course blacks were treated terribly in the past, but it is time to get past that and the only way that is possible is for crap like this to STOP. Stop reading into everything. I agree with the person who said it exists because people want it to. Of course racism exists in the world, but it seems it's always a problem here in the US and it's always in the news and it's almost always because a "minority" (I live in the south, so blacks/hispanics are hardly minority here in my opinion) make issue with everything. If blacks and hispanics take up most of the jails, it isn't because of racism, it's because they are committing crimes...DUH. I really don't notice any special treatment for whites as jail sentences go...in fact, I personally believe that blacks are let off easier just for the simple fact that things seem to get twisted so much in our society and I feel judges, etc are more apt to go easier on blacks so they aren't criticized and get the famous "It's because he's black" speech.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Tenney Naumer, Vitoria da Conquista, Bahia — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 03:49:17 GMT

Good grief! Don't half you people know anything about art or photography??? This is a fabulous photograph that shows a wonderful contrast between the fluidity of movement of Gisele and the stasis of LeBron (note how his feet appear to be glued to the floor), the contrast between her smile (no damsel in distress) and his growl, between his strength and her delicacy, and yes between her lightness and his darkness. In the meantime, note how your eye has to keep moving all around the photo and doesn't stick to any one thing or go out of the photo (this is called triangulation -- Leonardo da Vinci used it, too). So get a grip and learn something about art for a change. And, by the way, you guys do not give Jesse Jackson enough credit.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

moonboy alexis, Lancaster, NY — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 11:25:14 GMT

Annie Liebovitz probably did not have final say so in choosing the cover, that is up to the editor of this RAGazine. Who for the first time feature an African American male on the cover after over 110 years of publication. WHY now and WHY that picture? That is because VOGUE or VOGUER RAGazine still has the mentality and reprehensible legacy of those cross burning white collar red necks who created it. They should have picked a better picture. If this picture does not Conjure up a King Kong image then perhaps the subliminal cover conveys a “Beauty and the Beast” message. The cover is not in ENVOUGE with respect.............

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Valery Saint Louis, Brockton MA. — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 12:14:13 GMT

I am a black man and i am not/ wasnt offended when i saw Vogue's cover magazine. Why do everything have to involve racism. We are so negative that even when something good happen its so invisible. The cover is fine and portrays both Lebron's and Gisele"s personas.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Jackie D, New York, NY — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 13:39:42 GMT

That cover was designed to be provocative. Lebron and Gisele were meant to resemble King Kong and Fay Wray and to stir up controversy and therefore sales of the magazine. I don't blame anyone as much as Lebron as he is a wealthy man of influence and did not have to do it. However, he is still a relatively young man and may not have realized all of the implications of the cover.

I don't read Vogue, as all it really is is an overpriced collection of pictures and advertisements. At the end of the day it IS just a magazine and not really important. But let's not pretend that the editors did not realize that it was a risky photo and that they didn't publish it to get exactly the reaction they are getting now.

People under the age of 40, white and black, may look at the photo and not see any problem with it. Maybe that is a good thing. They just see a picture of two professional people doing what they do. But believe me Annie Liebovitz saw that photo in a different light. Congratulatins Vogue. No doubt, that issue will sell like hot cakes.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Anthony, Maryland — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 16:48:35 GMT

www.mediatakeout.com/photo/1206797092lebroncover1.jpg

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Christiansburg, Virginia — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 17:53:11 GMT

I am a white woman who is married to a black man and we have seen more racism from black people than white people. When my husband asked me what I thought of this photo, I told him nothing, they are just two people at the top of their game. He also stated the same, but informed me that his family saw the whole "gorilla" issue. This is absurd!! We have better things to worry about in this country and until we start acknowledging the real problems, things will never be better for own children and grandchildren to come in this world.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

indira Khalsa — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 21:15:52 GMT

These are two beautiful, successful, healthy, hardworking professionals who seem very comfortable with one another's race so why should I have a problem with it.It can stir up stereotypes as most images in the media but if you look closer these two are just trying to spread joy not hate.And anyway black and white images are beautiful on all levels. indi

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Anonymous — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 21:46:15 GMT

The image is not offensive in the least and I have to say that if this were Europe there would never have been any controversy.
I am black and I think that this whole thing has been such a waste of time and energy! they were modelling that's it and she was not trying to get away from him, she was smiling and although his face has a lot of intensity, he is not directing it at her.
The fact that this poor guy is being vilified for taking a photograph is ridiculous, perhaps if he had been a bit more like OJ and killed Gisele, his detractors might have liked him a bit more.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Charlotte, NC — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 22:16:29 GMT

I am a black woman which I consider myself very afrocentric. I'm aware of the past and the present stereotype and fears that white america has with the "BBM Syndrome" or "Big Black Man Syndrome". However, In looking at this picture and I don't see the controversy. It looks like Lebron was just having fun at the shoot. All of a sudden a black man is running for president with a good chance of winning, everyone is a little overly sensitive about race. I am not the to turn a blind eye to the possibilities of unfairness and injustice. I just don't see the issue with this one. Save Darfur.....

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

lonestar, tx — Mon, 31 Mar 2008 05:23:50 GMT

has anyone bothered to ask annie liebovitz what response, if any, she was trying to evoke? whereas i didn't see what others were referring to initially, i can see their point. ms. liebovitz is of a generation who is well aware of what such a photo would represent to some in the black community.

the picture is okay with me, i'd love to see this much of an uproar over the misuse of the word/s racist/racism. you've all got a lot to learn. so goes the american education system.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Redd F. DeKalb, IL — Mon, 31 Mar 2008 09:21:20 GMT

Here's the final deal. I am sick and tired of all the people being on their soapbox and henpecking back and forth pretending to understand the photo.Their only objective is to enforce THEIR belief of what it is truly about. It is TRULY about this...............IT'S JUST A PHOTO PEOPLE !!!!....get on with your lives.

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Lori O. Cleveland, OH — Mon, 31 Mar 2008 15:23:42 GMT

These are two beautiful people who are well respected and excel in their careers. I don't see racism, I see professionalism. Best wishes to both of them!!!

LeBron, Gisele and Vogue: The Cover Controversy

Bob, Cleveland, Ohio — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 11:04:43 GMT

Please! I thought the Today show was for NEWS not gossip or publicity stunts. Sher and her parnets are shocked! Get real! Do they really want us to believe they didn't know or think the photos were at all suggestive. Please don't even promote this kind of stunt!