What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Concerned student, Bellingham, WA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 14:45:45 GMT

This was a horrible, ridiculous segment. First of all, who cares, is this really important news? No. Secondly, this young woman who, as repeatadly described by Meredith, is NOT stick then, will not suffer any real negative health from gainging a few pounds; women who become obsessive over their weight due to our culture, with its wonderful little weight centered segments in which a size 4 is made to seem not that thin, however will suffer physically and mentally. Thank you for supporting this trend. ;(

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Linda Thien, St. Louis, Missouri — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 14:52:35 GMT

I think she hit the nail-on-the-head when she
said they wanted her to be more busty; because
she is not too thin anywhere. And good
for her for not giving in to that kind of thinking!
She looks great! She's a natural, self-confident, fit beauty!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Dave, Austin — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:00:30 GMT

I couldn't care less what she does. But after seeing the swimsuit pic of her, she really doesn't have much shape.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Emma, Dayton, OH — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:10:51 GMT

Why don't they stop beating around the bush and just ask her to get a boob job. That's what they really want. Ridiculous.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Anne, Seattle, Washington — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:11:39 GMT

I think she's perfectly fine, when I was her age, I was the same built, tall and slencer, and most girls would envy me I could eat whatever I want and not gain weight. By the end of my 20s I became curvier and now early 30s, I do have to watch a bit what I eat and do some crunches or I would get a belly, but I still have a great body. Girls like us are lucky! Women still envy me! You go Georgia!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Lisa, Denver, Colo — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:14:52 GMT

Will the next winner be asked to get breast implants? Lipo her thighs? Isn't this just another way to inforce the idea that a person is only as good as others judge their bodies to be? How about encouraging people to learn more about current events, world history, or literature? Bluk up on knowledge, ladies, and forget about cup size!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

K HIll - Pocatello, ID — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:14:58 GMT

I think that if she is healthy and positive head on her shoulders then leave her a lone. Life is hard enough then when people hit something that isn't that important. It seems to me that the people who told her that haven't probably check the facts. Is she healthy, is it just her body, but we have other things that are a lot more important than this story. I wish her luck and hope that what ever goals she makes for herself she does well in it. Be your self and try and make it a healthy life.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

jonnie cleveland ohio — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:17:40 GMT

She looks fine, she appears to be at her natural, genetically predisposed weight, which, does,alas include a less than ample bust...Who cares,,,,she is pretty but maybe a beauty pageant isn't the place for her. Maybe we should do away with all beauty pageants! Mixed messages abound.....we want you look healthy and that means bigger boobs???

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Jan Bizjak, Birmingham, AL 35209 — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:18:02 GMT

If swimsuits get any smaller contestants will be judged in the buff....and if weight is such an issue, do what the prizefighters do before each bout - have a weigh in before the press corps. Oh, for the days of the Jantzen one piece suits and the white evening gowns! Jan

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Jeri Bell, St. Louis, Missouri — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:18:44 GMT

St. Louis, you must be out of your mind to believe that a size 4 is not too thin on a woman that is 5'9". That is even thin for some one that is 4'9". We all need to step back and look at what we are presenting to women and girls...a realistic view or media's myopic view.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Rebecca, New York, NY — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:20:04 GMT

Okay, to be completely honest...I think she should lose a little weight.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

ex-contestant and glad to out — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:20:31 GMT

to get the kind of "shape" she's going to need to win that pageant, it'll mean adding 10-15 lbs (American) and total workout to get it to go where it needs to be. Could be more that she's just not old enough yet; at 20 the female body is still developing / changing / shifting.

This, however, presents the argument for these pageants to focus more on the body mass, not weight, and total silhouette that each one presents.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

AP — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:22:42 GMT

WELL I THINK IF SHE WAS "THICK AND HEALTHY" NO ONE WOULD EMBRACE HER WEIGHT AND UNDERSTAND THAT WOMEN COM IN ALL SHAPES AND SIZES. THEY WOULD BE COMPLAINING THAT SHE WAS TOO HEAVY OR SAYING THAT SHE IS FAT. EVERYONE IS NOT SUPPOSED TO BE SUPER THIN AND EVERYONE SHOULD STILL BE TREATED EQUALLY BUT WE ARE NOT. IF YOU ARE NOT THIN AND FIT THEN YOU ARE NOT TREATED THE SAME.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

geglesiasnepa — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:23:40 GMT

"if she puts on more weight; then they'll say she is tooooo Fat.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Sally Field, Nashville, TN — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:25:18 GMT

I support the idea of promoting a healthier body image for women instead of the size zero phenomenon, but some people are naturally thin. I do find it ironic that she describes herself as athletic build. Based on her BMI, I would guess her as an ectomorph. I don't consider ectomorph as an athletic build, this is the body type of most models. For example in tennis probably the smallest player on the women's tour is Justine Henin she weighs the same as Miss England but is two inches shorter, most of the women on the tour are larger than Justine and look great. I don't agree with them asking her to gain, but I also don't agree with her figure assesment as athletic.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

concerned girl, muscat, Oman — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:29:00 GMT

She needs to really not put on weight. It makes no sense. She has her own mind to think and is athletic.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Patrick Sheaffer, York, PA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:32:29 GMT

Unbelievable!! What a beautiful woman and a "wish to have figure". Who knows what wierd judges are thinking? Glad she has more character than those who suggested it.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

GINA MANTI UTAH — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:34:07 GMT

I WOULD LOVE TO BE HER SIZE. SHE IS NOT TOO THIN. I DONT SEE ANY RIBS STICKING OUT OF HER SIDES IR BAGS UNDER HER EYES. LEAVE HER ALONE.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Victor L. Halsig, Garden Grove California — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:34:22 GMT

Unless there is evidence of an eating disorder, how much she weighs is no one's concern except hers and her doctor's. Imbibing high-fat foods to gain weight as she is doing provides insurance that she will have difficulty with obesity and a lot of other medical ills later in life.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

karen dusenberry — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:40:10 GMT

They probably want to her get breast augmentation. Perhaps a butt implant. Stay natural!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

mikeym, Front Royal, va. — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:40:22 GMT

This young woman is fit, trim, and pretty. It sounds like the 'Miss World' people are a bunch of jealous, heavy old women.

I hope Miss England stays fit and trim.

MikeM

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Jess Doe — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:40:47 GMT

While this should not be news worthy nor a segment on The Today Show, the sad truth is that the pageant organizers want her to acquire more of a bust, which they sugar coated, no pun intended, by saying gain weight. Unfortunately they probably meant breast augmentation, since most of the women in that competition now have them. Hopefully she will stay strong and proud of her natural body, despite their urgings.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Stephanie, Dallas — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:42:05 GMT

At least she is thinking healthy about how to do it and living healthy.

I was naturally thin and without a super curvy or busty body at age 20. and even 10 years later when I have gained a few pounds (gotta love aging :) ), being healthy is the way to go.

If only more people thought about the healthy aspect of weight and body image. We are all built different but being healthy can apply to anyone.

I will take Angelina Jolie in Tomb Raider (she got the body by working out and eating right) over Mary Kate Olson anorexic any day.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Donna Quixote — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:42:10 GMT

"weight centered segments in which a size 4 is made to seem not that thin"...the whole idea that a size 4 is not THAT thin is such a TRAVESTY and continues the size/weight assault on women thru the media and entertainment industry. I agree that Ms. England isn't sporting the heroin chic look but at 5'8" and 128 lbs., if you saw her in person, the first thing that would be impressed upon you is how VERY thin she is. If she gained 20 lbs. she'd still be a beauty.

Again though, the problem here is the 24/7 ASSAULT we each face over size/weight (in case you're wondering, I wear a 6 Petite and have for most of my adult life, yet still find myself often feeling not thin enough)and the ramifications on our young girls' self-images especially. We live in a society that values appearance over substance so instead of helping young women to value and develop themselves as PEOPLE, the bar is set at: What size are your jeans?

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Kenny Bartholomew — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:43:29 GMT

She looks fine, no need to gain weight. As Carey Grant said "think thin".

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

BB, Maryland — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:51:23 GMT

To all young women who wish their breasts were larger I say, be happy with what you have. I am in my mid sixties and had breast reduction last year. I am very happy NOT to be in constant pain in my back, shoulders and chest from as my doctor says, the weight pulling on my muscles.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Kathy Jensen, Andover, MN. — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:52:55 GMT

If she had the fake breast implants like most of the other contestants, actresses, models, etc. they would say she looked just fine. Our society is ridiculous the way they expect woman to look so plastic. She looks great the way she is.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Jane Smith, Kingston, ON — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:54:36 GMT

Should she gain weight? Well, there really isn't enough information here for me to answer that. I don't know what her weight is; the story doesn't say how tall she is, how much she weighs or what her bmi is. If she tries to become more curvy, gaining weight will probably add a curve to her belly; that's it.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Jenna, Quincy, MA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:55:28 GMT

Why doesn't she just stuff her top like everyone else? I agree that she doesn't look too thin for Hollywood standards.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Richard Simmons — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:55:28 GMT

The women who are complaining about the size requirements of the beauty pageant on this blog are probably UGLY and FAT; they are just being the typical "catty" women you find everywhere.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Viv McGee, NY — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 15:57:29 GMT

As a nutritionist -I think this is strange? Her BMI = 19.16 in the normal range. I didn't see the entire show. Sounds like something else going on ?

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Anthony Platt, Tulsa, Ok. — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:00:57 GMT

Ladies, some men prefer heavy women for their voluptuousness. I don't; I consider a woman who isn't very "busty" graceful and elegant. And, through the miracle of genetics and the way opposites attract, graceful and elegant women tend to like me more than voluptuous women do.
If you take care of yourself and stay healthy, someone will prefer your type. If you have an open mind and don't choose someone by what someone tells you that you SHOULD like, whether you are male or female, you'll get along fine.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

SS, Georgia — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:01:59 GMT

People would be protesting like crazy if they had asked this girl to lose weight. What people should be focusing on is not what size or weight you are but if you're healthy. I have always, as in from the time I was four, been what people would refer to as "stick skinny". I have always been a size zero. I have always eaten anything and everything I wanted and as much of it as I wanted. I've been to countless Dr's and they all tell me the same thing...I am perfectly healthy and shouldn't worry about it at all. I am just as healthy as someone who wears a size 6 but there are plenty of people who like to make ugly comments and say that people like me give girls an unhealthy body image. Talk about people judging a book by its cover. This girl should stand up for who she is and the fact that what she has and doesn't have is natural.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Susan St. Petersburgh, Florida — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:10:34 GMT

Are they kidding? She has a great shape. The first thing that came to mind was the translation. Gaining more weight meaning getting breast implants. Breast implants are so trailer trash now anyway. These beauty pageants need to get with the times.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

teacher — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:13:37 GMT

Um.....as a health teacher, she is at an unhealthy weight for her height! She has absolutely NO muscle tone. Aren't there enough negative body images for girls out there to see. I'm dealing with girls at school daily who have eating disorders.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

CP, Locust Grove VA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:14:15 GMT

Miss England keeps saying she has an "Athletic" build, while I do not see this I am glad she is sticking to her guns and stating she is happy the way she is. As far as gaining weight in the "inappropriate" places... hey get use to it.. we are women and that is what happens.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Brian B, Gurnee, Illinois — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:18:42 GMT

Why are the pageant orginzers doling out advise to contestants? Isn't it up to her and her handlers to determine what it takes to win? She should play her best hand. Maybe she will have something that sets her apart from the rest of the contestants.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Rachel, Columbus, Ohio — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:18:52 GMT

5'9" and a size 4? She's anorexic! Please someone find her some help before she falls over dead.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Becca, Denver CO — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:21:43 GMT

LOL
I love the "why doesn't she just stuff her top like everyone else" comment. ^_^ Nice reality check! But probably not possible in that bikini.

Rebecca - you think she could stand to *lose* weight? Check yourself in with your doctor immediately for a mental check as I suspect you may be anorexic yourself.

Donna Quixote - absolutely. I would be stunned to have a size 6 figure, but you are still confronted with the idea it's too large? It's definitely a sick social image.

And to everyone going "what the heck is wrong with their standards that they would demand a beautiful woman change?" Beauty pageants are the distilled essence of everything taken too far in our social expectation of women's figures. As the Dove site shows a pretty model being made over, then photo-shopped into a creature of alien dimensions before she is "suitable" for a billboard, so do beauty pageants purely and entirely intend to push their participants through a meat-grinder and re-shape the resulting pap into the figure they prefer, the same unreal creation that advertisers can make electronically. If a surreal level of beauty among contestants is not enough for a pageant industry demanding implants (and wouldn't they just love to demand the contestants get on a torture rack for a while to stretch their legs longer while they're at it) such that even these contestants are forced to be neurotic about whether their stunning beauty is "enough" then it's obvious the pageant industry is a surrealist cake of bizarre and mentally damaged expectations laced with a bit of "and what do you want to be when you grow up and do you love children and puppies" icing.

To say with shock "oh, they're focused on the wrong thing" is naive when looking at an industry that is frankly purely based on shredding any values we have of a standard normal and healthy beauty to replace it with a silicon-based, plastic veneer, and reconstituted-maple-made-from-gasoline flavor. Pageants are a showcase of everything mentally damaged about our view on women's beauty.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Mouse in New Market, VA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:22:24 GMT

Trying to "manage" Miss England is yet another example of obsession with faults - criticizing the good in search of the perfect.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

SRD, Maryland — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:23:09 GMT

Why do we care that a superficial demand has been placed on a participant in a superficial competition? Face it-- If pageants aren't about perfection and ideal body types, why do they parade girls around in bikinis and slutty dresses? It's unavoidable-- body scrutiny and beauty pageants go hand-in-hand (these girls are JUDGED mostly on their appearance for God's sake!). If England really wants to send a message, they should withdraw from the stupid competition! How much would it impact society's attitude towards women if there were a highly publicized worldwide competition to honor young women for their intellect, values, character, accomplishments, and ambition-- not their sex appeal...?

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

JB — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:23:23 GMT

Good lord she's 126 lbs for crying out loud! And on mildly atheletic to non-athletic women that's mostly fat weight. So there's no way she's too thin people!! Look at the top of her thighs. If anything she should exercise and tone them up a bit(though I personally think she looks great as is). Pageant contestants should not look like the average woman. That's not the reason pagents or contests exist- they're for people with extra-ordinary appearance, talent and skills. What's the purpose of having pagents if all of the contestants look like they were just pulled off of the street? And another thing, I train people for a living and she does have a boyish, athletic build, just as she states.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Wendy — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:23:58 GMT

Maybe she should just get a swimsuit that better suits her body.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

smithscape, Blairsvile, Ga — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:25:47 GMT

They just want her to hang out from all sides of her top as if it was a bandaid. She has a great shape and she should keep it that way.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Terra, Arizona — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:28:57 GMT

I'm terribly confused by the people who use the excuse of "promoting a healthy body image" to criticize women who are perfectly fine. People come in different sizes and you can't expect everyone to fit any specific mold; to rail against one image in support of another doesn't HELP girls' esteem, it just moves the anxiety to a different group.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

SRD, Maryland — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:30:15 GMT

Becca- loved your post! Amen!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

AA, NY — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:31:22 GMT

I think she looks fine. If she gains any more weight she might just gain a bigger gut.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Melinda Sacramento, Ca. — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:33:38 GMT

I'll bet the pageant officials meant more "shape" at the top, wanting her to get breast implants. She's fine the way she is.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

S Trent, Morristown, TN — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:35:04 GMT

Some day, probably in the not too distant future, she will join other middle aged women on the diet rollercoaster. So, for now, let her ENJOY being thin. Besides, she's not scrawny! GEEZ!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Lydia, Seattle, WA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:38:17 GMT

She looks fine and doesn't seem too thin to me. It seems like the contest is biased against girls with boyish figures and only want women with big breasts. Not all women are like that. Wish they could just learn to deal with it.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Lisa, NY — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:39:26 GMT

Her body looks great!!!! But look at her teeth....

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

BB, Hackensack,NJ — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:39:48 GMT

I'm 116 lbs and 5'3 at age 23. Am I to believe I have an unhealthy weight? The girl looks fine as she is. Not everyone is naturally overweight.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Julie, Toledo, OH — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:40:27 GMT

Lisa from Denver could not have said it better myself "Bluk up on knowledge, ladies, and forget about cup size!"

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

CAS — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:40:47 GMT

I can't believe that people are judging her health and whether she has an eating disorder by her height and weight. Some people just can't accept the fact that some women are very thin AND healthy. So much has to do with your genetic predisposition to be a certain size, the size of your frame, etc. I'm 5'9 and not too much heavier than she is and I can assure you that all of my adult life I have been around the same size while eating healthily. I find it insulting that people can't imagine that she's that size without being anorexic.

As far as her situation goes, I think she should stay just as she is. As somebody with an "athletic" build - (i.e. not curvy) gaining weight is not necessarily going to give an hourglass figure. Wouldn't it be great if when we gained weight, it all went to our chests!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Christine Wells, Edmonton, Alberta — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:44:17 GMT

I think that this is so utterly silly. She is a healthy weight and looks great. I am her height and I weigh less, I also have become sick and tired of hearing people tell me to put on weight. I am healthy and I can not change my genes. I would love to hear someone say that thin woman who are healthy, and healthy eaters are beautiful and desireable. I would like thin women to represent the image of beauty and not feel that we have to wear padded bra's in order to be considered attractive or healthy. Georgia, you look great, don't change anything!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Mike, Palm Springs CA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:46:25 GMT

Didn't anyone but me notice your vote choices were...add a few pounds... or.. stathin and HEALTHY.. or.. don't care... why did they include the word healthy with the thin comment... are you saying people who aren't thin aren't healthy.. the problem is not really whether she adds pounds or not... the problem is with the media's constant message to our youth of "you have to be bone thin to look good or be healthy"...and by the way.. the beauty pageant is a job... all jobs have qualificaions and restrictions... if she doesn't like the job or its rules get out... if your were the receptionist for a company.. but didn't like talking on the phone..you get my point..

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

maria payan — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:49:04 GMT

This is not about adding or taking off weight. This is about a bunch of lecherous men trying to define and impose their ideal of perfect feminine beauty. In other words, making woman think that unless they conform to these absurd, almost impossible to meet standards, there is something wrong with them. Beauty comes in all shapes and colors. Small, tall, skinny, large, blonde, brown, black or yellow. Who the hell cares, we women are like flowers, different yet all so beautiful. Screw beauty contests and their ridiculous standards. Tell all of these stupid, lecherous, leering perverts to go to hell....

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Joseph South Bend, In — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:51:37 GMT

She also needs some booty and hips -- like the women in brazil !

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Jane Smith — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:56:32 GMT

If her bmi is within the normal range, then I don't see a problem. But she should denitely not lose weight, or she will tip over into the underweight range. It wouldn't hurt her to gain a little. But I think this whole thing is resulting from the problem with underweight models collapsing and dying - there was one anyway, in Spain I think. I think it's a good thing to promote a healthy weight - which she appears to have. All underweight models should be told to gain weight. And overweight models - if there are any - should lose. It's good to find a healthy middle ground for everyone.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

a REAL woman, Los Angeles, CA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 16:58:58 GMT

Hey, Becca? AMEN!!! It's high time to rid the world of "beauty" pagents. We have more pressing issues facing the human race. We don't need that dreck shoved down our throats.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Kathy Jensen, Andover, MN. — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:02:34 GMT

Maria Payan..I love your post..you are so right on!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

v gee, seattle, wa — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:05:47 GMT

wow! i thought only usa was promoting OBESITY.. now the whole world too?!
ps: becka your FAT!
lol

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

joshw — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:07:34 GMT

Ah Becca. Your message is a typical rant from an obvious parentally forced, past your prime, disgruntled pageant contestant. I was waiting for one of you to pop up here.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

X, Richmond, VA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:15:34 GMT

She should stay at her natural body weight. For all those ignorant people who say that 4 is too thin on a person who is 5'9", or even 4'9", you're being a little bit ignorant to the obesity problem. Anywhere from a size 4-10 is pretty healthy; however it's not the average anymore so anyone on the low end of that is considered "unhealthy" or too skinny. I am 5'9, 125-130 pounds, and I have a BMI well into the healthy range. Additionally, I eat a lot and simply can't gain weight. I am not unhealthy, or too skinny.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

barb alliance ohio — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:16:49 GMT

Beauty pageants are insulting to all women. Most of the "beautiful" people are insecure, obsessed with their looks, and miss out on a lot of life worrying about their physical appearance, weight, hair, plump lips, etc. Beauty will always come from within, and the most beautiful people are those that are totally comfortable in their own skin. life is far too short, and i like my desserts.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

G Rogers, San Diego CA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:17:53 GMT

Give me a break. She looks perfectly fine. What they really want is for her to get breast implants so she'll have boobs that are too big for her frame.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

E. Bernice Toronto, Canada — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:18:03 GMT

I am 5'4" and all during my teenage years I weighed 97 llbs, because of my culture I was always told to gain weight. I did when I was in my twenties and went to 130 lbs which was societies perfect weight. In my 40's I started to rapidly gain weight and is now 190 lbs. Oh,how I wish to be 97 lbs again. This young lady if perfectly fine now, she may or may not gain weight later on in life. Lifestyle and genetics will determine this

E Bernice

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Donna,Chicago, Illinois — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:21:23 GMT

Personally, I don't like her figure. I'm not into the "boyish" straight up and down look, but I don't think she looks unhealthy. It is obvious that she is like that naturally, and not starving herself. I think its wrong for her to be asked to gain weight, but I also think its ridiculous when people act suprised when pagents are superfical. That's all they are! The judges and the contestants are equally ridiculous for wanting to be part of such nonsense.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Heidi, Holland MI — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:21:29 GMT

I saw the Today segment this morning and I think Georgia is just gorgeous - exactly the way God made her! If society wants to be concerned over someone, has anyone seen Courtney from Survivor lately? Hello, that girls needs seriously pack on the pounds!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

J. C. in Walla Walla, WA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:22:05 GMT

Looking at her website, she is not "thin." She looks NORMAL. She even has a butt on her that actually sticks out. The only thing that everyone seems to be concerned about is BOOBS. She doesn't have much on top but would help with the "curvy" issue. I'm so glad her ribs, clavicle, and hip bones are not sticking out that a lot of the Miss USA contestants seem to promote with boob jobs. Frankly, Georgia won the contest on other attributes, such as her talent and speaking abilities, not just her ability to be beautiful to what men think is an "ideal" woman appearance.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Jannie Ogg, Winsted, CT — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:22:11 GMT

Marilyn Monroe was a size 8. Nobody told her she had to lose weight! A 4 for someone of her height is very thin, but we are talking about a beauty contest, where there is too much emphasis on how-you-look instead who-you-are. I want to see a contest were everybody wears an enormous sack and we ask what they have done to make the world a better place.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Brian, Greensboro, NC — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:27:41 GMT

The way I see it, this story isn't even about the girl. She is just a pawn in an attempt to rescue beauty pageants from increasing irrelevance. Ratings have been falling for years, and pageant promoters are trying to bring eyeballs back in front of televisions by creating "controversies" like this one.

I offer the trials of a Miss USA contestant (I forget her name) from this year as evidence. The young lady had a substance abuse problem and was threatened with the stripping of her crown - as if that would be a great tragedy. Donald Trump, being the promoter that he is, whipped up a feud with Rosie O'Donnell and brought the issue much more attention than it deserved. As a side note, how long can it be before said pageant is named "Miss Trump USA?" The whole thing was nothing more than a means of bringing Miss USA some attention and rescuing another of Trump's misguided, ego-driven purchases. I'm not sure if more people watched or if it drove them away. At the very least, it got Mr. Trump yet more time if front of the cameras.

The public has figured out that these events are about nothing more than physical beauty. They have nothing to do with talent and skill. Disagree? Name one winner who has gone on to accomplish anything of substance on the world stage.

The beauty pageant as a cultural event is coding. Someone call a time of death.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Happy in WV — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:33:18 GMT

Well, it's about time that this issue was addressed. I have gone through the same thing my whole life. I have always had a thin build and have never struggled with the over-weight issue. Everybody seems to strive for a healthy weight and for those of us that are in that median, being critizied is just a bit of an insecurity for those who do it! I do agree that if someone tells me to gain weight, it's the same as telling an obese person to loose it. A healthy weight takes maintenance either way you look at it and some of us are just born with good genes! Georgia looks just fine and coming from someone in the same boat, she is an inspiration!! Thanks

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Anne, Belgium/Seattle, WA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:38:33 GMT

I agree with Maria to "tell all those stupid, lecherous and leering perverts to go to hell".
Also agreeing with Real Woman "its high time to rid the world of beauty pagents". Our society does have bigger issues that need to be solved than to worry about PERFECT appearence.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Kisha, Los Angeles,Calif. — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:41:23 GMT

How dare Miss World organizers?! I thought beauty pageants was about embracing women of all shapes, sizes and colors?
If I were Miss England, I'd sue their behinds for discriminating against me for being too thin. Fat people do it all the time! People come in all different shapes and sizes! Imagine the outcry if this had been a fat woman told to lose weight. I guess it's O.K. to let skinny women be ashamed of their bodies.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Joanne Deutch — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:46:51 GMT

If she wants to be thin, so be it. As long as she's happy, but if she wants to win, she better start eating hot fudge sundaes, cause most of the world like women with curves and not stick figures. Once you get into modeling, acting, the arts, you must be what the world wants. Good luck to her as Miss England but she will never be Miss World."Real Women Have Curves"

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

kcs, santa barbara, CA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:49:23 GMT

As someone who was very thin naturally during my adolescent years, 20s, and 30s, it was very upsetting to have people tell me you need to gain some weight you are too thin. I ate whatever I wanted and never was able to gain weight. I also was small in the bust but I never caved in and got implants the way too many girls do today - implants are not healthy. People should just mind their own business and let those who are naturally thin stay the way they naturally are just as those who are naturally larger should be left alone. Weight is a personal issue. Obviously if someone is clearly anorexic that person's family should intervene but it is not up to the person on the street to judge others simply by their looks. I personally think that this girl is simply beautiful and I wish that there had been girls like her in the pageants I watched when I was younger - people of all shapes and sizes need to see their body types represented.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Mary, Mountain View, CA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:52:25 GMT

Rachel of Ohio: How is 5'9" and size 4 considered anorexic? How is size 4 at ANY height considered anorexic? It's clearly evident by your comment that you have no idea what constitutes being healthy or what a size 4 means nowadays (due to size inflation). I'm 24 and I have always been a size 0 or 2 (110 lbs), but I am far from anorexic--I exercise 2x weekly and always eat when I'm hungry (which is often). I think I look great in clothes and I am happy with my weight.

If you consider Miss England anorexic, then what does that make me--a skeleton? Please, wake up and smell the coffee. I am really disgusted with people like you who just assume that anyone who is skinny must be anorexic.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

LJM, Detroit, MI — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:54:28 GMT

What we all think about her weight or looks doesn't matter. What matters is that she wants to be in the pageant. That's it! If she wants to play in that game, she needs to follow their rules. Simple!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Joey Smith Sherman Okas, CA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:55:28 GMT

I think she needs more curves she actually needs more of a butt In today's society men are attract3d to women with big butts Remmber the term flat chested well now thats moved to flat butt. Flat butted women are not seemed sexually intriguing as curvy women with a butt especially a bubble butt!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

John D — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:56:43 GMT

JB, love the post. Modeling and beauty pageants are supposed to be for people who are not average. Why does everyone think that the people who do those things should look like "real women". And who are any of you to say who "real women" are. They come in all heights, weights, sizes, and shapes. Just because someone isn't what you think they should be doesn't mean they're not the way God created them to be.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Irene T., Seattle, WA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:56:56 GMT

I am also 20 years old, 5'8", and a size 4, but weigh only 115lb (52 kilo). And, like her, I also "suffer" from a "small chest". I think that Ms. Horsley looks perfectly healthy, and that this debate is ridiculous. At least she's not anorexic or sculpted by surgeons, and has her own body. Stop trying to squish everybody into the same mold... we won't fit!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Mandie,Baltimore, MD — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 17:59:26 GMT

I feel like the argument being put forth is just as damaging to young girls as asking her to lose weight. I'm 5'4", 101 pounds, and very healthy. I eat well, exercise, and just happen to have a small body frame and high metabolism. I have received negative comments my whole life regarding my size, but god forbid I comment on the obesity epidemic in America! That would just be socially unacceptable! Having an open mind includes accepting people of all shapes and sizes, and not making uneducated statements such as claiming someone is anorexic or obese without actually knowing what those terms mean.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Jackie, Atlanta GA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:01:17 GMT

I am pretty much the same size, body frame as Miss London and I am a 36 year old mother of a 10 month old. I was her size at 20 and after having my child I am back to the same size. It's all genetics! I am just naturally thin but healthy thin. Miss London looks great; she said she eats alot and works out so she doesn't seem to have any issues with herself physically.

They need to address the young women in this world that do have eating disorders and issues with their body image. Leave Miss London alone!

Good Luck Georgia!!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Penny Fuller, Portland, Oregon — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:04:29 GMT

I think the message should have been more, "Please feel free to gain, not lose, weight, as the women around the world are perfectly happy with more weight."

She's not "athletic" with those thighs and skinny arms. If she started walking a mile a day--with a long stride--she would lose the weight downstairs, and lift her butt. Then she could lift weights (just 5 pounds each arm would help) and be able to put on weight in her chest and arms without adding it anywhere else. Marilyn Monroe lifted weights for more curvy arms and shoulders. Not only that, she will be strengthening her back and skeleton, for a stronger future!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Tim Souders, Andover, KS — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:07:06 GMT

..heck no; she looks terrific just the way she is; what is going thru the judges' minds???

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Chris Wilder New York, NY — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:20:27 GMT

I think it's horrible that because there are so many fat people that they want the skinny people to be fat too. Perhaps the status quo is cvhanging.. I'm fat and I won't even look at a fat girl so please don't make them all fat, I'll never ever consider reproducing if that's the case.. If anything make them all skinny not fat.. Skinny is more healthy than fat.. Wake up people..

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Lauren, Providence RI — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:28:54 GMT

For those of you who think this story is a waste of time, I don't think you're getting the bigger picture. In the US we have serious issues. We live in a world of extremes. People starving themselves to try and obtain an "ideal body" An epidemic of obesity, most severly in our children. A serious increase in plastic surgery, specifically breast augmentation. We live in a world where what you look like is who you are, how you're judged and how your treated. As frivilous as the story may seem it is just a glimpse at the direction our world is going.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Becky G Tucson, AZ — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:34:23 GMT

As lots of people have pointed out, the issue isn't really her weight or if she is too thin. The issue is that they want her to have bigger boobs on the exact same body she has now! Not exactly a victory for "real women"

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Raphael, New York City, N.Y. — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:35:19 GMT

I think she looks great! She's cute, graceful, and not at all too thin by any stretch of the imagination. She's a natural beauty, and that's that!
If ANYTHING, she could use a bit of muscle tone, but she's young, and that will come!
Well done, and just be yourself!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Natural College Girl, Durant, OK — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:37:54 GMT

I am 5'7" and weigh 110 on a heavy day. I have eat the constantly and never seem to gain any weight. Some people are naturally thinner and some are naturally larger. It is rather upsetting to be told that you are to large or skinny to be pretty or to skinny to be a good role model. If some one is their natural, God given weight, what does that have to do with being a good role model?

By the way, Wendy I agree with your comment. Maybe she does just need to get a swimsuit that better fits her body. I am an A cup and I once had a swimsuit that made my breasts look huge.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Andrea, St. Joe, MO — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:42:04 GMT

She is willing to participate in the pagent and is willing to try to fit a particular ideal of feminine beauty. She has made her choice and it seems to make her happy and she probably wants to win, so why wouldn't she try to be the ideal the judges are looking for? I'm glad she is decisive about what she is willing to do to get what she wants. Just because she is a pagent participant now doesn't mean she will be forever. How many of us wouldn't jump at the chance to do something out of the ordinary with our lives? I think many young women hope to use the pagent system to achieve all sorts of goals. I don't condone the pressure to think that ultra thin is the only beauty. I'm far from thin anymore since my son was born but I think she isn't doing anything that she doesn't want to do and she should be applauded for being goal oriented. She looks fabulous and why shouldn't she try to win? If I were motivated to do the contest I probably would come to the same decision to put on a couple pounds.

I am actually more interested in what she plans on doind with her life after she is done with the pagent circuit. What will all this pagent-life lead to for her? Actress, politician, scientist, professor? What comes next when she isn't a beauty queen? That is more interesting that whether she puts on the weight or where the weight goes.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Gregg Prescott, WI — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:42:21 GMT

This woman is beautiful, sexy, and should not even consider adding weight.

She is perfect the way she is, and very healthy.

Athletic and voluptuous are both beautiful.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Lara, Dive, MT — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:44:33 GMT

When I was 20 years old I was a size ZERO, and five seven. Quit calling her anorexic! I worked at mcdonalds and ate there all the time, never threw up, never starved myself! Some people are just naturaly that size in their youth. Gawd!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

KATHY ,MESA, AZ — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:48:13 GMT

THE TWO PIECE SHE HAS ON DOESN'T HELP. THE TOO LOW
BOTTOM ON THE LONG TORSO MAKES THE TUMMY LOOKS POOCHY, WHICH I MAY BE. THE ONE PIECE JANTZEN ISN'T A BAD IDEA.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Jen, Tampa, FL — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:50:05 GMT

In my twenties I was exactly her build - 5'8", 126lbs, size 4. At 35, I am barely heavier at around 130lbs and still wearing a size 4. I don't starve myself to look this way. For health reasons unrelated to weight, I have had to reduce or eliminate my consumption of wheat products, milk, and sugar. Plain and simple, this is my natural weight on a healthy well-balanced diet. However, I have spent my whole life being told that my breasts are too small, that I looked like a boy, or that I wasn't feminine. All those negative comments resulted in my mild obsession with wanting to look like Catherine Zeta-Jones while knowing I will never have those kinds of curves and have left me with the negative feeling that I will never be womanly enough. Shame on all of you for criticizing someone's natural body type. The effect of this sort of mental abuse on naturally slender women is just as horrible as insulting someone by implying they are fat, obese, overweight, etc. But no one thinks they are insulting a thin woman when they make comments like "You're so skinny. You must never eat." When was the last time you heard a total stranger say to a restaurant patron, "You really shouldn't eat that. You're fat enough already."? And yet, I have had total strangers tell me I should be eating more because I am too skinny!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

RGP Arlington, TX — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:55:54 GMT

Bravo, Lydia, if they want every contestant to be Salma Hayek (nothing wrong with Salma OR Miss England) then vote those as your country's rep in the Miss World.

As a man married to a woman who was size six for twelve and a half years - from the time I met her in college, married and just had our third child - and just cracked the size eight barrier, let me say: LEAVE THE THIN PEOPLE ALONE! Thin body types are not a genetic aberration and having one does not make you an "automatic" eating-disorder person. Get a grip and quit traumatizing those who have no control over the fact that they are thin. My wife, and her sister, both eat and exercise and are healthy. Yet stupid (yes, STUPID) people constantly make their "harmless" comments about being pencil thin, needing a few potatoes, being in need of some extra help up top and innumerable other ridiculous comments. If you are that self-concious that you need to make smarmy comments about another's body to cover your own lack of confidence or self-worth, then go work on yourself and quit talking to/about others.

You have no idea the harm you inflict on others with your words. I am a little plump and have had plenty of verbal abuse, but I can attest that thin people cry just as much and just as hard as anyone else. It is absolutely absurd.

My wife hates her new weight gain and it is not healthy for her, no matter what others may think when they see her fully clothed. She would tell you she is sluggish, wears out quicker than normal and just feels unhealthy with the "stealth" fat rolls and dimples that can only be seen unclothed. We now both have 20 lbs. to lose. We're not trying to get back to our college bodies, we're working to stay healthy. If we get back to our "thin" bodies in the process, so be it. Just shut up when you see us walk by.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

"OliveOil", Fontana, Calif. — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 18:56:22 GMT

Props to Ms. Horsley for having a healthy self-image and being happy with herself. Like she says, she's only trying to gain weight up to the point that she's not doing anything unhealthy or crazy. Don't hate just because she's thin; there'd be an uproar if it were the opposite and people were saying someone was too fat, but somehow it’s okay to criticize someone for being skinny. People come in all kinds of shapes and sizes and this includes thin, skinny people, too. Just because we're thin, it doesn't mean that we're unhealthy, or starving ourselves, or are anorexic, like some people are suggesting here. I'm 5’5”, 100 lbs., and a size 0, and even having had a baby and gaining normal, healthy weight during my pregnancy, I dropped back down to 0 about 2 months or so after giving birth; no, I didn't starve myself or do anything unhealthy (you can't do that and expect to still nurse!), I've just got a fast metabolism. Try calling me anorexic, and I’ll show you how much I can out-eat you (and not binging and purging either). Sure, I’m not stuffing myself with junk food and I eat healthy, but it all really comes down to how my body is built. So to say that this is the media trying to present an unrealistic view by saying that she’s a size 4 but isn’t too thin is simply untrue. A realistic view is not necessarily one where everyone is not skinny.

As for that “health teacher,” I’m so glad I did not have you as my teacher, because if you had tried to present me as a “negative body image,” I would have called you out for trying to have a negative impact on my perfectly healthy self-esteem, and trying to similarly drag down the self-esteem of others who are otherwise healthy but don’t conform to your idea of health. Too bad you’re still a teacher and educator, but at least you’re not a doctor!

Don’t try to blame society for your own self-esteem problems. If you’re a certain size, and society makes you feel like it’s the wrong size to be, but you’re criticizing society for making you feel that way, good for you! Because you already realize that society is wrong in the way it views you or makes you feel about yourself. Now take that progress and go on to the next step: Forget about what society tries to dictate and look in the mirror and tell yourself how you feel about yourself, because only you can control how you feel about yourself. Don’t let other people judge you. If you’re honest with yourself, then you’ll either be happy with the way you are, or you’ll realize that maybe you have some changes to make to get to your happy place. Be brave: Love yourself, “fat”, “normal”, or “skinny”!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Celly, eugene, Or — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:00:41 GMT

Oh pleeeaase. When i first saw her pic I suspected they were telling her to lose 10 pounds. She is curvy. Not EVEN CLOSE to thin yet alone too thin. Everyone else is just fat. Size 4 is NOT thin at ALL. Im same height and size 2 And I eat like a piggy.Same as everyone else my size. So this shouldnt even be a subject.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

A. Flower, Tyler, TX — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:01:07 GMT

I think that if this girl tries to gain weight, she'll just end up with an eating disorder. She should get with a trainer and start lifting weights to add curves and definition where she needs it.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

JJ — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:02:03 GMT

This is about a boob job! It is the only place that this girl needs to put on weight. I have seen a lot skinnier contestants then her (example)present Miss World. The only difference is they have bigger breasts. No way is this girl to skinny. I think she looks great, but could use some toning on her thighs and arms.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Rachel, Chicago, IL — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:04:42 GMT

Even if she gain pounds she is not going to have the curvy shape it is not in her gene. No Offensive to her but the girl does not have an shape at all or I am sorry straight is a shape a guess. But let stop all is these madness askign this girl to gain weight in order to be curvy is like asking apple to give you oragne juice.

Immposible!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

RGP Arlington, TX — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:08:29 GMT

Also, do not confuse an "athletic figure" of an average person with the body of professional athletes and entertainers who train meticulously under the supervision of professional trainers and nutritionists.

If every man looked like a CK model and every woman looked like a goddess then we wouldn't have to put up with marketing campaigns designed around their "bodies", would we? Me? Yeah, I could drop 20-30 and buff up, but I would never look like that with my family & job lifestyle - that's o.k., I'm good with it.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Lisa Willis, Fort Wayne Indiana — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:10:08 GMT

It's just as ridiculous to force someone (who is healthy) to loose weight as it is to gain. Of course, the easiest solution for her is to become a model here in America, where we seem to love stick thin model as opposed to more curvy models.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Elizabeth, Oak Creek, WI — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:11:00 GMT

Personally, I think she could lose, but that's just an opinion, maybe the photo was not a good one. I can wear a size zero, but what is a size zero today, used to be a size three about ten years ago, so she is probably a size eight realistically. As a society, womens sizes keep increasing to make us feel better about the fact tha we're all overweight!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

antoinette, Huntsville, Al — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:14:45 GMT

I think that it is important to care about ALL different kinds of news and keep a broad mind on things however I agree that ppl waste to much time on images and it does effect ppl in a mental and physical way...your either to skinny or to fat as long as someone is healthy and happy why make crude accusations as if a human (all incapable of perfection) could proclaim who is perfect and not and what to do to be perfect...This woman should do whatever she feels will be healthy for her and what makes her happiest...win win situation

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Shirley Hughes, Virginia Beach, Virginia — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:16:42 GMT

To say this young lady is too skinny is very disturbing. I am 58 years old and I weigh 103 lbs. I have 3 adult children, 9 grandchildren and 2 great-grand children. I have never been able to gain weight.Lord knows I've tried and tried. for my Birthday in August, I went to the Beach and had pictures taken of me in a bikini. I look just like Miss England in that swim suit and have gotten rave revues in regards to these pictures. I recently attended my 40th Class Reunion, showed the pictures and everyone was amazed. Some people even told me I should be a Model. If Miss England is like myself, she will not gain weight. Why should she??? I have never really seen a very large person winning that title anyway. So why all the commotion at this particular time?

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

fxs, southern, california — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:19:08 GMT

All she will accomplish is getting fat where she doesn't need it and jack up her cholesterol. She looks just fine as she is.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Angie, Montlake Terrace, WA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:23:32 GMT

First, she looks perfectly fine!

Second, some pagent organizers wants to -
1. get some attention from the new social groups that are trying to make people feel happy about being fat.
2. satisfy his/her own emotional distress over being overweight.
3. see bigger boobs.

Third, how is this helping women anywhere? The longer the debate about weight goes on, the worse it becomes for women who are self-conscious about weight.

Fourth, this is encouraging people to eat unhealthy.

Fifth, why does this Miss England even care. Let the pagent organizers say whatever the hell they want. She looks great and will probably live a good life just being who she is. The pagent winner seem to get stuck in a pathetic rut later in life, pretending to care about world peace and doing things that they do not enjoy deep in their heart.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

tttt tttt, yy NY — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:24:56 GMT

I think she is fine. She is DEFINITELY not anorexic. She is thin but looks healthy.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Steve Gerace, Wallingfford, PA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:33:02 GMT

I'm a 51 yo male. There are too many out of shape women around. She looks great to me.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Gloria Simon-Kuzma, Oshkosh, WI — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:40:47 GMT

She has a small boned athletic build; I agree that the issue is that the pageant wants her to have larger breasts. All I can say is that there is alot more to womanhood than being a giant boob!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

CW Esq., Durham, NC — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:41:28 GMT

At 5'8 126 she's a bit on the smaller side. If according to healthy standards you are to weigh 100 lbs for the first 5 ft and 5 lbs per additional inch she should weigh around 140. She really has no muscle tone, so I wouldn't call her athletic in build...so she may or may not be "fit". "Fit" can't be seen. "Fit" can be tested.

Some people have some really ridiculous ideas as to what weight or size or shape a person should be. She's young and I think there is nothing wrong with her size. But I'd think nothing were wrong with her size if she were a size 14. The size of your clothes can change depending on what store you shop in. What matters is blood pressure, resting heart rate, ability to maneuver through life without healt risks, etc.

And beauty is not the same world round. And reality is...the majority of the world prefers the hour glass figure.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Heather, Somewhere, WA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:41:57 GMT

You know, I am 4' 11" and weigh 96lbs. I did weigh 93lbs. before I gave birth to my first child 3yrs. ago. I have always been told by people (not doctors though) that I am too skinny. The problem is I don't work out and I eat whatever I want and I just don't gain weight. I have a very high metabolism I guess. So, I understand where the girl is coming from. Some people are just built lucky!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Lowel, Wheat Ridge, Colorado — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:46:03 GMT

I'm a male who is 5'7" @ 135 pounds, and a beer belly to boot! People think I'm fat, but in reality I'm right on for a male of my age and size. I look at her and think damn she is perfect. Not to skinny and not to fat! She is right where she needs to be for her age and size! You Go Girl!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Lesa, Russellville, TN — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:53:55 GMT

Too funny, I'm 5'4", 113 lbs and would still love to drop 10 more..I actually have a size zero in my closet (thank you - those clothing manufacturers that blow sunshine up where the sun don't shine) and my size 4's now need a belt to stay up. I thought everyone in the pageants was tiny, they all look a lot smaller than me. Gain weight??? Am I in some alternate reality suddenly?

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Connie, Fort Wayne, IN — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:56:54 GMT

I was thin all my life (size 4-6) and athlectic. Now in midlife with menopause, I have ALL the curves I need and some to spare. Women are beautiful in so many hues, shapes and sizes. I wonder what the judges weight and lifestyle are like? Ummmm...

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

TH Lexington, SC — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 19:59:24 GMT

It appears to me that a lot of folks are threatened by a NATURALLY thin woman. Stop looking at sizes as a way to judge if someone is thin - it is pure marketing deception. Have you noticed that American sizes are getting smaller. When I was in HS, I wore size 5/6 & I was about 10 lbs lighter. Now, I wear a 0, 15 years later. Why can't this culture just eat healthfully, get out & exercise and be who you are? if you are fat - be fat & stop trying to bully women (and men) who are naturally thin. If I were to go up to someone and talk about how fat they are I would get slapped, so why is it socially acceptable to go up to a thin stranger & talk about how thin they are?? This culture is just nuts with its priorities & focus on the wrong issues.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Sharyl, Vancouver, BC — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:06:45 GMT

When I read she was was 5'8" and 126 lbs, I have to say that sounded a bit too thin. However, in the picture included she looks just fine - though she definitely does have a boyish figure.
My conclusion? This has absolutely nothing to do with "promoting a healthy body image" or the fuss over size zero, stick thin models. This is solely about her bustline. And that makes it a really sad (though not surprising) commentary on what is considered attractive in our society.
But here's the really scary part: If she can manage to "fix" that by changing her diet AND manage not to get fat she will be able to make a mint selling that diet plan. (And even scarier would be the number of men buying it for their wives and girlfriends.)

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

JM — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:12:44 GMT

I agree with JB, this is not the average looking woman contest. Its a beauty contest, which is designed to reward great beauty. However, that being said I think we have far more people in the world that are obese, not anorexic. Promoting weight gain on someone that doesn't need to gain weight simply to make other women feel more comfortable about themselves seems selfish and unfair. She's a beautiful girl, leave her alone.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

dc, mesa, az — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:14:01 GMT

"And good
for her for not giving in to that kind of thinking!" Oh for Pete's sake - give me a break - she has given in or else she wouldn't have agreed to try to gain weight.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

geoff — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:14:57 GMT

Lecherous men. That's funny. There are more women involved in running beauty pagents than there are men. So I guess men are twisting the women's arms to make them organize, manage and promote the pagents. Too too funny

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Moira Des Moines IA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:16:20 GMT

There should be no competitions that judge you on how you look! I don't care if they award a scholarship, ask you questions on what would be your wish to save the entire world or whatever. We have enough problems with people not thinking they are good enough because they are too fat,thin, tall, short and every other thing because it doesn't fit some "ideal" that society says it should. Healthy and happy with yourself is what counts. It all needs to stop!!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Frank from Philly — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:17:08 GMT

Sounds like Becca is a disgruntled ex-pageant contestant. Sheesh.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Cindygirl, Nashville TN — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:17:17 GMT

Well, first I think it's crazy the way our society puts so much importance on outward appearance, but that's just the way it is. However, I think no matter how much one weighs, if they are healthy, then they should be who they are. The beauty industry uses computers and airbrushing to make women "perfect" in advertisments that our young boys and girls see everyday.

Our brains process many images from the narrow thinking of the "beauty industry", everday. Unfortunatly, so do the minds of todays youth. The beauty being shown to us today on billboards, tv, magazines, movies, and videos, is a lie. With all the teen suicide, depression, eating disorders, and emotional stress, shouldn't we really show the truth, that there is a wider defination of beauty. The truth is, beauty comes in all races, cultures, genders, sizes, and ages.

Everyday we see those magazine covers, tv commercials, movies, music videos etc. We think it has no impact on how we think. How wrong that is. Especially for youth. Young hearts and minds of guys and girls that just want to be accepted and to fit in. The young minds of boys and girls that see this ONE idea of "perfection" sent out from the media and the beauty industry of this country, this narrow way of thinking and what is considered beautiful everyday many many times, and they seek that "perfection" that doesn't even exist. There are so many young girls and even boys with eating, and emotional disorders as well as depression, simply because they don't fit into the mold of what the media says is acceptable and beautiful.
If we as adults refuse to listen, then how can we protect the world's children and talk to them about what true beauty is. If we turn our heads and pretend that these ideas and images do not impact our minds and the minds of today's youth, how can we help them see the truth about self worth? The video above shows a model and she is basically the same age, size, and with the same made up look as what we in today's society accept as beatiful...It's all about looks...so important that even a beautiful girl must be "corrected" by computers to go onto an advertisement that people walk past and see everyday.
It's disturbing. It's also unbelievable seeing just how accessible Cosmetic surgery is for teens now. It is always an option if one doesn't fall into society's mold of beauty. Look at your statistics, many teenaged girls are having cosmetic surgery from breast implants to nose jobs when their bodies are not even fully developed yet, because they say it makes them feel good about themselves. Looks, apperance, is that the most important thing about someone??? We say no, but our actions say differently. If we keep watching and supporting movies, videos and keep listenin to music that show and depict women only as sexual objects, and makes it seem cool for a girl to go half dressed, or be called "ho" or worse, how can our society expect to teach children, or even truely respect women or others and expect to teach girls to respect themselves if we continue choosing to be blind. Thinking that it doesn't matter. We need to stop and be aware of what the media, music, movies, videos, and magazines are telling us. We need to be aware of what we let into our minds without thinking and begin think about todays youth, sons, daughters, nieces, nephews, sisters, brothers, mothers, cousins etc. It is our responsibility to protect them from this narrow defination of beauty and help them love and accept themselves and be who GOD made them to be, understanding that is what is truely beautiful. We need to make certain that they know their worth and that they deserve to be respected and to treat others with respect. We can teach them early and save them alot of pain they will suffer if we leave them to learn it the hard way. We are all masterpieces of GOD...we are accepted by HIM...we are worth more to GOD than any amount of treasure this earth has or will ever have, combined. We need to know it ourselves and teach it to our youth, so that they can grow up happy in knowing that they are special in every way. May GOD Bless You.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Jaide, California — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:24:48 GMT

They don't want her to just gain weight - they want her to have big boobs and a big butt. She will just get a fat stomach if she tries to gain weight though. I have the same body type and when I was a little heavier it was all around the middle - still a B cup. I hate the obsession with big boobs. Thin girls are not SUPPOSED to have big boobs but all of them get plastic surgery so we think it's the norm to have DDs at size four when that's not at all natural. I know so many girls my age who have those awful fake boobs and a lot of them didn't even realize that those things have to be redone every so often. I can't tell you how many of classmates got those for 18th birthday gifts or graduation gifts from their PARENTS.

I am glad, though, that someone who is a four is actually being called thin. It's a refreshing change from "anything over 0 is too fat" thinking fed to us by Hollywood and magazines.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Eryn Berry, Piedmont, OK — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:32:42 GMT

As a nearly 46 year old woman that is approx 5'4" and weighs only 103lbs and the mother of two - telling her to gain weight is easier said than done. I have tried for years to gain weight - believe me - some people just can't do it no matter what. She does not look unhealthy to me. Leave the poor girl alone. While I appreciate the contest sponsors concern over this, promoting a healthy lifestyle is more important. Some people are just meant to be smaller - don't hate us - shopping is just as much a nighmare for small people as it is larger people. When I purchase pants I have to have them altered - and I am buying size zero - because they are too big. It is not that great to be small.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Patricia hadley, Tennessee Colony, TX — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:34:12 GMT

I cannot believe that she is a size 4 when I am only 5ft 3ins and I am a size 6 to 7. someone has there sizing all wrong. They don't want her to gain weight they want boobs. Why didn't they just say get a boob job like they were thinking

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Cindy, Crossville, TN — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:38:20 GMT

If someone is healthy and happy, no matter what size they are, why should they change for society? I will share this with you...it's so sad...I know a young lady that was in a pageant few years ago...and she is a beautiful girl...well anyway...for like a month she starved herself to death...as did the other girls...if any of you know my friend and knew she was starving you would know how insane that is...as well as the other contestants in the pageant.

And you could say...well... if they don't want to do that then they shouldn't be in it...well come on...look who we as a society give young girls as role models?? Of course they want to be in a pageant and for everyone to think they are beautiful...Doesn't every woman want to feel beautiful?? When you are young in our society...the media and society in general makes it the most important thing...we may not want to admit it...but it is...It shouldn't be...but still it is.

Anyway...back to my point...another young girl in the pageant had also been starving herself for weeks and weeks prior to this event...she was taking diet pills...in her mind I'm sure she wasn't good enough...I'm sure she was aware of what the judges were looking for...the thinner the better...I'm sure as my niece was...this girl was in misery but continued to starve herself thinkin that it would only be a few more days and then it would be ok....well it wasn't for her....she died!!!!

At the pageant all the girls were there in their dresses...all the loved ones were there...excitement and anticipation filled the air...and just before the pageant started a lady steps up to the mic...and says...ladies and gentlemen...may we please have a moment of silence for the young contestant who is no longer with us tonight...a hush falls over the crowd...for like 10 seconds...10 SECONDS!!!!!!!!! 10 little seconds of reverence for a beautiful young lady who died tryin to be what "society" says is perfect...A young girl who just wanted to be accepted and to feel beautiful...gone... and the people at the pageant that she so desperately wanted to be accepted gave her 10 measly lil seconds...how heartbreaking is that.

What a sad day when people closed their eyes to true beauty and closed their minds to the concept that maybe more than just one certain type of woman is beautiful...we see a flower and to us it is beautiful...we see a tree...it is also beautiful...a mountain...the ocean etc...these are all different in shape, size, color, age, etc...but when it comes to human beings...especially women...only one certain type is seen as beautiful...not everyone has that opinion...but most do. A person can't help what he/she is attracted to...but I say make up your own mind...don't let society or the media do it for you...don't have this distorted and impossible standard for others or yourself...open your eyes and your minds to the possibility that our differences are what makes us special...if we embrace differences and choose to learn from each other instead of turn our noses up at it we would be a much happier people...For years I've tortured and hated myself for not being able to conform to what society says is beautiful...I write this in hopes to spare someone the struggles I have gone through inside myself with this issue...I've learned the hard way through much heartache, pain, and finally prayer that I am beautifully and wonderfully made as are you...Thankfully today as I sit here writing this...I am thankful for who I am...for my heart...for the way I think and for the way I look...for my differences and the differences in all of you...we are each unique and different in some way...and when you think about it...isn't it so wonderful??? Yes...I think so...take care and love yourself as well as others...GOD Bless You!!!!

We are GOD'S art...HIS great work...HIS masterpieces...

Psalm 139: 14

"I will praise thee; for I am fearfully and wonderfully made: Marvellous are thy works; and that my soul knoweth right well."

Hugs...

~*Cindygirl*~

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Brenda, HIckory, NC — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:40:31 GMT

At her age I was the same size I'm 5'8" and was about the same weight. I didn't get any real figure until I was in my late 20's. This pagent is supposed to be about more than physical appearance. She looks healthy and seems to have a sensible self image. Will we ever be satisified with the fact that beauty comes in all sizes, shapes, and colors?

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Delena Chico CA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:43:32 GMT

I am 59 years old, weight the same and am the same height. What's the problems? She looks healthy.
Delena, Chico CA

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Erica K, Madison, WI — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:48:08 GMT

I'm sorry. The "curves" they want her to gain will not be obtained naturally by simply eating more. Plastic surgeons would not be driving their flashy cars if that were true. That fat will go anywhere but her bust. But props to the judges of the Miss England pageant for voting for a natural woman who isn't spilling out of her swimsuit top.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Veronica L., Pittsburgh, PA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:49:00 GMT

This is a sad commentary, yet again, on how skewed our societal (yes, even England's!) view of women has become. We are reduced to jeans sizes and the spacial placement of our thighs and breasts.
Even more sad is the fact that grown professionals would tell a young, capable woman that she must reconfigure her body in order to possibly win a contest that is *allegedly* based on the overall picture of a well-rounded, intelligent woman.

After being clinically diagnosed with Anorexia Nervosa, I am sensitive to the scrutiny under which women live. Her response of being willing to gain weight if need be tells me that she does not suffer under the delusions of an eating disorder. However, what of the women that do? How much longer are we willing to let such ignorant judgments of women and men prevail? Let her be who she is...she is obviously a balanced person with so much to anticipate. If she had ribs sticking out, that still is no reason to demand change of her.
When we get to the point that outer appearance is no longer being linked to success, we can say we have finally accomplished something in our society.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Ken Hodges — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:49:13 GMT

Sorry Guys but the woman is actually a little fat. Look at how her legs rub together. She needs to workout and/or lose about 20 pounds.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

BERNADETTE, RATON, NM — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:49:49 GMT

MISS ENGLAND IS THIN BUT SHE IS NOT "SKINNY". THERE IS A BIG DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO. SHE IS PROBABLY NEAR HER IDEAL WEIGHT. BUT INSTEAD OF TARGETING HER SEEMINGLY HEALTHY PHYSIQUE MAYBE THE MEDIA SHOULD BE CONCENTRATING ON THE EMACIATED BUILDS OF RUNWAY AND VICTORIA'S SECRET MODELS AND HOLLYWOOD ACTRESSES. NOW THOSE GIRLS ARE SKINNY. THOSE GIRLS ARE GIVING OUR YOUNG GIRLS UNREALISTIC GOALS AND NEGATIVE BODY IMAGE.DONT GET ME WRONG WE DONT NEED TO BE OBESE WE JUST NEED TO BE HEALTHY.IT IS REFRESHING TO HEAR OF A YOUNG WOMAN WHO IS ACTUALLY HAPPY WITH HERSELF AND HER FIGURE. THAT SHOULD BE COMMENDED. MAYBE MORE GIRLS COULD LEARN FROM HER ATTITUDE AND START IGNORING EVERYONE WHO IS SO CONSUMED WITH THE IDEA THAT TO BE WORTH ANYTHING YOU HAVE TO WEIGH ZERO!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

MK Sometown, Indiana — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:51:00 GMT

Are they really nit picking her for being healthy?!? She is right where she needs to be with her weight if she has a small bone structure. Why on earth would anyone expect her to change that? Isn't this some kind of weird reverse discrimination? I have had struggles all my life with my weight starting with the summer that I spent with my grandparents who decided I was too skinny. They fed me sugary cereals, rich foods and excessive deserts and sweets. I was discouraged from playing in an 'unladylike' fashion. They fattened me up and sent me home. I have never been a healthy weight since. I have recently found out that I have a metabolic disorder that was quite possibly triggered by the unhealthy, extremely rapid weight gain of that summer. Had they not triggered the metabolic response, I might be a healthy weight today! How dare these competition representatives expect her to damage herself with the guise of appealing to more women? Do they really think any educated woman will ever be interested in a competition that demands a woman to fit into the envogue cliche of the day? It may not hurt her. But then again, if she has an underlying health condition that she is unaware of this ridiculous experiment may have devastating results! If she is naturally athletic and trim, good for her! Leave her alone! I sincerely hope that she does not proceed with submitting herself to this misadventure to promote their gross, shortsided, and exploitative marketing ploy!!! SHAME ON THE MISS UNIVERSE COMPETITION FOR BEING SO DISGUSTING!!!!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Pauline Weber, Houston, Mo — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:54:19 GMT

If Miss England were to put on weight it would go to her waist and hips. She needs more bust.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Irene, Seattle, WA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 20:56:40 GMT

It may seem like an irrelevant discussion to some and, yes, there are always more important things going on in this world. But this is more important issue than it seems initially. In now day and age, we tend to accept and/or take advice from our doctors to gain or lose weight. It becomes offensive when people who have no significant knowledge of the physical or psychological aspects trying to tell us that we should gain or lose weight. I am of a very similar “boyish” body type (still in the 20s and have two children). I eat what I want and when I want. I do not starve myself by any stretch of imagination. In fact, I am the first in line for “what’s for dinner?” I do not seem to gain weight even if I double-dip on occasion. However, from my personal experience, if I gain weight (I would really have to try hard), I would gain it in all of the wrong places and feel sick. Therefore, I am glad that Miss England is standing her ground. She is in her natural state and age where any additional changes would be extreme for her and may even be detrimental in the future. More research and consensus has to occur in the medical field in order to determine why some people stay slender while eating any types of foods and others do not. Prior to such consensus, any types of implied comments of such nature have no reasonable ground to stand on, and, therefore, may have ulterior motives or pure ignorance.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Sally Field — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 21:00:34 GMT

jb if you are a trainer, I would never go to your gym if Miss England is your definition of an athletic build. One of the dictionary definitions is mesomorph ie. putting on muscle easily. Miss England may be super fit and I think she is a very attractive young women, but she does not show a great deal of muscle tone in the photo. To me, athletic in a Hollywood tiny way would be someone like Jessica Biel, or Jennifer Garner who have very sculpted muscles.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Steve Barry, Laguna, CA — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 21:26:10 GMT

Right on Miss World Pagent Directors, she needs added weight - specifically boobs. Time to see your plastic specialist

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Joan Fortenbaugh — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 21:49:26 GMT

From the picture you have shown, she looks like she already has belly fat. I think, as others say, that it's all about the bust. The are ways to look bustier. From what I have observed over the years is that the contestants use tape and other materials to give that extra push up that they need for their breasts. So, watch the belly fat, it looks like that is a problem area for you.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Katheline, Topeka, KS — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 22:05:40 GMT

I think Wendy nailed it. She should get a swimsuit that fits her correctly. The picture shown looks terrible. It looks way big on her and is hugging no hips at all. She needs something that is hight at the hips so that one can actually see hips. Same with the top, people never heard of Victoria Secret accross the Atlantic?

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Steph, Orlando, FL — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 22:31:38 GMT

The only way avacados are going to make her gain weight in the desireable area is if they are stuffed directly into her bra.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

jacqueline, canada — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 02:10:12 GMT

WHO. REALLY. CARES?
She's in a beauty pageant! Being "pretty" in the "beauty pageant" way is, you know, her job. If they tell her to gain weight, lose weight, get a boob job or go through total facial reconstructive surgery she HAS to either do it or drop out. I'm not saying it's right, but that's how it is. It wasn't like they told a fifteen year old cheerleader she was too skinny or something. she signed up for this.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Claire H., San Francisco Bay Area, CA — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 05:00:15 GMT

Why doesn't she just choose a more-flattering swimsuit that will create the illusion of curves up top?

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

David-S — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 07:32:46 GMT

What's all the fuss about? Speaking for myself and only for myself. I have found "natural" looking girls to be far more attractive than "augmented girls". Sometimes these natural girls are thin, sometimes they are little heavier. What I dislike intensly is these girls who have artificial breasts when there is no need for it. Just as I also dislike girls who try to make themselves into skin and bone by starving themselves. If she is fit, and healthy then I think the clowns who suggested she gain weight should be fired from the pagent. On the other hand I would also BAN WOMEN who augment their breasts or suffer from eating conditions from the competition. After the pagent is about beauty not plastic surgery and diet plans.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Rose — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 09:42:08 GMT

Stupid rule. Miss England is as beautiful as she is. Hope she knows that. And she looks healthy too, in a world of lollipop girls and stick thin models. That's already enough to stand out.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

tony,kingsto, canada — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 10:41:34 GMT

she loogs good ..leave her alone

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Pamela Smith, Morrisville, North Carolina — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 11:14:12 GMT

We are truly living in a sad time. When organizers have in their mind an idea of what beauty should or should not be. We were all created differently and are unique in that fact. It is truly a sad day when we are being forced to try to all fit in one mould. Instead of trying to pack pounds on, eat right, exercise and have a healthy self image and you will do fine. You will exude confidence which will be projected by your walk, stance and general deportment.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Timothy Huff, Mystic, CT — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 11:31:06 GMT

I agree with evryone and watched this segment yesterday. Miss England is not stick thin and looks fine I thought it was finny though when Meredith asked about where she would like to put on weight? Would she like a bigger top, or a bigger booty? But overall she looks fine.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

anomous,invisaland, mars — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 16:35:15 GMT

Look, the UK has an obsiety problem, size 4 at 5 foot is accually kinda chunky, no offence, unless someone is very athletic and has very large hips, a normal size is around 2, which is around like 120 pounds at that hight, and she is flat, but hey maybe she should excerise a tad more, cause her abbs rnt perfect and if she wants to win work on her best feautes and make them stunning, as opposed to bad features and worsing her good feautrues. Now size 0s are normal for petites, which if they have narrow hips will be around that size at that age, now if we're taking about 40 year olds then size 4 is ok. And for 6 feet tall women, a range would be 2-10 for healthyness, with 10 being very large hips and older, 2 being young and narrow hiped. Many of the runway models are anotheric which is not good, but many are naturally that way. Instead of focusing on what the persons size is, look at their overall health, and if they are within a healthy weight range or just slightly over it which can happen, see if their eating crap and not exerising, or are they eating healthy and exerize and just have an odd bone structure. Shes not too thin, shes normal, maybe needs to exercize more but we all do, and eating fat is not the way to get a bust, maybe she just needs to work on her good features, and less on how much more she needs to eat cause it will all end up on her stomach if she gains it quickly.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Sarah, denver, co — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 17:42:52 GMT

only in america can this be such a controversy. in britian they really don't have an obesity problem because people are moving all the time and eat a lot smaller portions.
for those that say a size 4 is two small.
americans always want to put everyone into a cookie cutter box. the BMI and body fat indexes are the average. that means there is a lot of room for error. and not everyone and mostly likey most people do not fit into those molds.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

TheresaV Brooklyn NY — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 18:26:05 GMT

This is simple. She is small busted. They want her to have bigger breasts.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Dawn Boykin, Jerome, Idaho — Sun, 28 Oct 2007 00:08:14 GMT

I think she looks just fine, but if she realy wants to put on a few pounds she should be smart about it and not eat junk food, instead drink insure's three times a day it will put the weight on but only what you need. and it is healthy, I think the pagents are dum do to the fact they are picky on your looks, my thirteen year old wanted to so pagents and modeling but I said no for this number one reason nobody is perfect enough and they want you to change something about your looks instead of excepting you on who you are

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

kathy, dallas, texas — Sun, 28 Oct 2007 04:19:54 GMT

Many women are size 0, 2, 4, or 6 naturally. Many others have healthy, well rounded eating habits and still have small bodies.
I do not understand the anger and ugliness directed at women who decide to get breast implants. It is (should be) a personal decision that does not deserve the comments often offered. No individual should ever feel pressured to make changes to his/her body just to please others-especialy judgemental strangers.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Dana, Battle Ground, Washington — Sun, 28 Oct 2007 14:44:56 GMT

She looks beautiful and healthy. Of course anorexia isn't heathy (though she doesn't look one bit anorexic to me) but frankly obesity and heart disease kill more people than anorexia. Unbelievable that they claim to be promoting an ideal body image when in fact they're just steering these girls into long term issues with obesity.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Chris Colenso-Dunne, Trinity Beach, Queensland, Australia — Sun, 28 Oct 2007 15:17:09 GMT

It's absurd to describe this girl as anorexic. Forget her dress size: dress sizes are completely meaningless - the fashion industry has been changing them over the years in any case as the average North American, Australian & UK woman gets fatter.

This girl's Body Mass Index (BMI) is just over 19. BMI is easy to calculate which is why it's so widely used by health workers. BMI is equal to one's body mass measured in kg divided by the square of one's height measured in metres. This girl is 68 inches tall. So in metric, she's 68 x2.54 cm tall or about 1.73m. She has a body mass of 57 kg. So her BMI is approximately equal to 57kg/(1.73x1.73m2). Hence, her BMI is about 19.1 kg/m2.

A BMI of just over 19 is ideal for a young, fit athletic female. So stop talking rubbish about this girl being anorexic - any one who thinks this girl is anorexic has clearly never worked with those who suffer from anorexia nervosa and should keep their uninformed opinions to themselves.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Peggy P., Bryan, Texas — Sun, 28 Oct 2007 16:45:14 GMT

Sounds to me like they want her to have a boob job and look out of proportion just like most beauty queens. I hope she stays true to herself and makes the most of her natural beauty. I personally think they should disqualify anyone who has "fake" boobs.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Tam Tam — Mon, 29 Oct 2007 02:16:22 GMT

"Well, real women have curves", maybe she should wait a few years..I doubt that would help. From the looks of it.. she doesn't look so thin, and this not an ATHLETIC body sorry to say, she's just skinny point blank..don't see any muscle tone or any definition there.. she's an ectomorph.. not a mesomorph..she's just flat chested.. I am also a firm beleiver in equal opportunity, but she's not going to win anyways.. why sweat it?

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

ken urbanek, okemos, Michigan — Mon, 29 Oct 2007 10:03:18 GMT

She looks Great as is!!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Meiling, Tianjin, China — Mon, 29 Oct 2007 13:02:03 GMT

As a Canadian living in China... I say that Miss England should stay as she is....Miss China will be a lot thinner than she is!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Heidi, NC — Mon, 29 Oct 2007 14:26:03 GMT

Jeri Bell, St. Louis I don't think you know what you are talking about. I'm a size 1 (juniors), I'm 22 and I weigh about 110 lbs. I'm 5'2. and I like the way I look. I'm not skin and bones. I have curves, and I'm naturally atheltic and healthy. Size four on a 4'9 would definitely more tahn round enough to be healthy. This girl looks more than healthy and I'm proud of her to have made it this far, and not be just another wasting away skin and bones girl.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

LazyCat, NJ — Mon, 29 Oct 2007 14:27:27 GMT

"Put on weight" is code for "get bigger boobs". She looks great. It's amazing how boob obsessed our culture has become.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Janet Kay — Mon, 29 Oct 2007 14:29:23 GMT

I am just waiting for the day when a woman's worth is not determined by her weight..overweight or underweight, makes no difference....it's the same discrimination either way. Aren't there more important things going on in the world????

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Bruce Packard, Dallas — Mon, 29 Oct 2007 21:45:07 GMT

126 lbs is not thin; its normal. Check her BMI. We've gotten too content to allow fat women to get away with character assassination on normal sized young women. Fat behinds and big boobs are not "beautiful" girls, it is ordinary. This is a beauty contest, for beauties. Leave her alone.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

grossed out — Mon, 29 Oct 2007 22:29:22 GMT

I think you all have too much time on your hands to worry or even think about a silly thing like this.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

jane doe Green Bay Wi — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 11:49:34 GMT

I am 5'9 125 lbs(+4 during THAT time of the month) and this is the weight that I think I fit(I get MEAN comments sometimes for being tall etc but there is no surgery for THAT)...I am not obsessive by far, but how do they get a size 4?? I wear a size 9 and sometimes sometimes a belt with my jeans...yeah, I think they ought to tell her to think healthy, not bigger/smaller.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

judge for the right reasons, Vincennes IN — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 14:21:29 GMT

There is an unwritten image for a pageant winner. I learned this “perfect image” requirement years ago while in college. I entered our local pageant (a pre-lim to the Miss America) with the hopes of winning a scholarship to assist me with my education. I thought I was entering a pageant that wanted someone who was out-going, attractive, with good morals, and a strong platform to represent the college and city at our state pageant. What I found was that they wanted an image. I was 5’1” 97 lbs, 34C-24-33. I had the figure, looks, talent, and personality, but was told by the pageant directors that I would never win a pageant because I was to short and there is a “look that they want”. I think the idea of what a pageant represents (positive role models, means for better education, spokesperson for a given platform, etc.) is great, but this has all been lost somewhere along the way. We need to use pageants for the right reasons. Pageant winners should be seen as positive role models, represent important issues, and use their status to present this to America.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

l alabama — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 15:42:42 GMT

she has no hourglass figure for sure. dont see anything sexy about a skinny man or woman!!!!!!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

W. Taylor — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 18:01:55 GMT

This young woman looks slender, but not at all thin. Whenever the word voluptuous is thrown about you can almost bet that it has some indirect correlation to a woman's bust size. What these folks are really asking her to do is to increase her breast measurements. It's very sad that in this day and age women who aren't "well-endowed" are still considered homely are just plain unattractive. Is it any wonder that more than ever we're seeing teenaged girls are getting breast implants.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Tue, 30 Oct 2007 20:23:11 GMT

I think she is beautiful..If she doesn't win the judges are out of their mind.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Kristy, NY — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 20:29:42 GMT

Who exactly told her to put on more weight? She looks fine. Besides, the current trend (as seen in so many fashion magazines)is to have a fit, athletic build. I'd rather see a girl who has a tone body than a body with flab on it just so she has "curves". Besides, isn't the competition about more than just looks, or am I being naive?

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Renee, Seattle — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 20:50:25 GMT

She has been given BAD advice. If you look at her she has a "boyish" body; this means that she cannot attain hips by gaining weight, it will end up around that middle area just above the hips she barely hints at already. She will have a thick middle and it will be awful. Boy-figure (straight-up-and-down types) cannot get hips, or as young adults they'd have them already, no matter how fat or thin. She is built like a stick and she will become just a fatter stick if she gains.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Ellie, Fort Madison, Iowa — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 20:50:49 GMT

I don't think she looks like she's too thin but she definitly doesn't need to lose weight because she IS thin. I'm sure if she gained a few pounds she would still look just fine but she doesn't NEED to. But just to clarify some things, just because someone doesn't LOOK too thin or have an extremely low BMI, they can still have an eating disorder. So everyone who's been assuming that because they think she does look too think she must be anorexic, you have no real proof of that. But I do think this country (and many others) have a horrible view of body image. If the pageant officials were REALLY just trying to promote healthy body image, then I would be saying great for them! But something tells me they just want her to have bigger boobs so if she's healthy and happy with herself then she should not worry about it.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Sasha, St.Kitts & Nevis,Caribbean — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 21:22:29 GMT

To me, she looks great,with a great shape also. Everyone wasn't born to have the same body type or size. But if she puts on about 5lbs,that will be ok also,instand of bein overweight. Being healthy is the way to go,not unhealthy,because she can be at risk by having medical problems. Secondly, Pageants are for Beauty,Showing there talents,and Knowing some kind of Knowlegde of there Country, not by there weight. Not only the voluptuous people has all the talents and can do everything you no!!!!!

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Samuel, Albany, NY — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 21:38:09 GMT

If this girl had won the pageant in England and then been told to gain/lose weight as a personal recommendation, that might be construed as insulting and as promoting unhealthy body image. However, this pageant in Europe is primarily a competition. Her weight and figure are necessarily a professional requirement. When I was told to gain weight for the football team in high school, it was never considered a personal attack, but rather a realistic assessment of what I needed to do. This is the same thing. If she wants to represent England she has an obligation to perform the necessary preparations. If this means losing weight, so be it. As far as the thin vs curvy debate goes, "trendy" body types are created and propagated almost solely by women. There are reasons models look one way and pornstars another.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Kamalani Keka'oha, Honolulu, Hawaii — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 23:11:02 GMT

I think that if they want the Miss World Pageant to represent women from around the world, they should have women of different sizes and different shapes, and not try to change them.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Emily, Wichita Falls, TX — Wed, 31 Oct 2007 01:44:43 GMT

1st of all. SHE IS TO THIN!! Period!! looking at her, and hearing her weight, and height she is technically about 10-15 lbs under weight.

All of you people out there who think she is fine how she is, or thin is better are part of the problem. you are the reason that people in the nutrition industry have jobs, because we have to go around reteaching people about healthy normal eating habits and body images. So thank you for being so ignorant and thinking that she looks perfect, because that lets me keep my job.

For the record, she is not athletic, look at some of the athletic women in this world and compare her to them. She falls way below athletic.

If everyone would get the correct information instead of listening and believing false health facts we would all be better off. The body image in this country is so messed up and backwards it makes it impossible for people to believe all it takes to be healthy is to eat right and exercise.

Anyways, for a model she fits the bill, but as far as health goes, she is underweight and should probably work out and gain a little weight.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Middle of the Road, Nashville TN — Wed, 31 Oct 2007 03:08:47 GMT

The number of whining comments from skinny women who just cannot gain weight is amazing. You are incredibly lucky and should be grateful. My mother was tiny and thin almost her whole life, she has gained a very little now and is thoroughly unhappy about it. I would give almost anything to be as tiny as her, but I have my Father's genetics and have a larger build. I am healthy 20% body fat, but I have larger hips 38'' and nothing is going to change that. I would just love to be tiny and look all petite and lovely, but it just wasn't my lot. It isn't very nice to be called chubby or have people tell you they are certain you would look better if you would drop a few pounds, good luck explaining that muscle weighs more than fat. I guess it is like the straight/curly hair dilemma no one seems happy with what they have. If you ask me, for today's standard of beauty the skinny women should be thanking their lucky stars instead of whining on these blogs.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

utah — Wed, 31 Oct 2007 04:52:01 GMT

Ok. reality check anyone? doesn't "beauty bagent" just scream "make yourself look the way others want you to"? she is perfect, but in a beauty pagent, you have to please others in order to win. if thats what you want to do then gain all the weight you like, but if you are happy with the way you look, don't do beauty pagents.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

rye, Albany, Ga. — Fri, 28 Dec 2007 19:37:13 GMT

If her natural body type is small let her stay that way. If a persons body type is larger, let them stay that way too. As long as it is healthy. The world needs variety. Beauty comes in all shapes, sizes, colors and nationalities. No one body shape should be considered the best look or body type. That is why there are so many people out there with body image issues when there should be none.

What's Really Behind Miss England's Weight?

Frank Eubanks, Columbus, Ohio — Sat, 05 Jan 2008 22:56:24 GMT

Zhang Zi Lin's (Miss World 2007)(Miss China) height is 71.7" or six feet. She weighs 128 lbs. Her measurements are 35"-25.2"-35". Georgia Horsley's height is 5'7.5". Her measurements are 34.5"-25"-34.5". Miss World's weight and measurements and Miss England's weight and measurements are about the same but Miss World is four inches taller, so Meling, Tianjin, China was right about Miss China in comparison to Miss England. It looks like the pageant judges preferred a more stick thin lady and Georgia Horsley for her height might have been too fat compared to Zhang Zi Lin, the winner of the Miss World pageant.
By the way, there is a lady who plays tennis very well in spite of being a stick thin 6'2" and 130 lbs. Her name is Maria Sharapova.
By the way, I ask that John D., Cindy of Crossville TN, and Cindygirl of Nashville TN, pray that God will help me pay all my back tithes with at least 80% deductibility.
It would be an honored privilege if Becca would let me have someone take a picture of me with her on Friday, February 29, 2008, or on Saturday March 1, 2008.
To me, an ideal lady is one who is both, built similar to how Iris Kyle is built, and able to run 5K's in less than 28 minutes. (Then I could do training runs with her.) But I am not worthy of such a woman.