ABOUT allDAY

allDAY is the official TODAY blog, your virtual window to Studio 1A and the people who make America's favorite morning show come alive. Whether it's exchanging views with the anchors and contributors or going behind the scenes with the producers, editors, camera people and more, we'll bring you the buzz here at 30 Rock, and we hope you will make this a regular part of your online routine. We want this to be a conversation, so please respond with your comments and questions directly to the blog, and we'll do our best to post what you have to say.



Natalie Morales: All parents have faced those humbling moments

Posted: Thursday, October 01, 2009 8:09 AM by Jen Brown
Filed Under: ,

From Natalie Morales, TODAY host and national correspondent

On Thursday we talked to Anita Tedaldi, a woman who adopted a child and then gave him up 18 months later.  As horrible as that headline sounds, you realize how just complicated the situation was and how agonizing the decision to give up little “D.” was when you read Anita’s own account.  It’s a piece that will bring you to tears.

When that essay was first published in the New York Time’s Motherlode blog, many people accused Anita of being irresponsible for taking on more than she could handle, for not trying hard enough to make her adoption work (even though she writes about trying everything from months of therapy to bonding sessions with a psychologist, etc.).  Several others, however, applauded Anita for her courage and the strength she showed in making what she felt was ultimately the best decision for the child.
 
No matter how you feel about Anita's decision to terminate her adoption, her story is one almost every mother can relate to on some level. That’s because this is not necessarily about terminating an adoption as it is a story of a woman coming to terms with her emotions and accepting the fact she couldn't be the kind of mom she thought she would be to her adopted child.   As much as we all like to think we can do it all, we’ve all had that humbling moment – or many humbling moments -- when we must recognize our own limitations.  When was the last time you felt like you weren't a good enough parent?  How often have you asked if you are doing the right thing, whether in loving or disciplining your child?   

In her essay, Anita describes struggling to bond with D. the way she bonded with her five biological children.  I know many women who have experienced that with their own flesh and blood.  Upon becoming a parent we are often told that you will experience a love like no other.  All this is very true, but some mothers don’t have that instant bond the second this brand new life is placed into their arms. It doesn't mean they don't become amazing supermoms and love their children more than anything, but we all love differently and some need time to forge that bond.   

So perhaps some of you will still find fault with Anita; others might sympathize with her situation a little more when considering her story through the lens of a parent with their own limitations and shortcomings.  We can all, I think, agree Anita did not fail in giving D. a better life in the end. Where might little D be now?  Perhaps still in an orphanage in a third world country with a variety of health issues.  I asked Anita if she felt she saved little D when he needed saving, and to that she responded with a resounding "yes." 

I hope you read Anita's essay with an open mind and an open heart --  it will make you think, it will make you cry, it will make you question what it means to love as a parent.      

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

My best friend adopted a family of 4. After raising them until the ages of spprox 16, these children NEVER should have been adopted out. They all suffered from Opposition Disorder, ADHD, and several other severe mental issues. It was heartbreaking to see how hard she tried to bond with all four of them. One tried to kill her- and eventually, that is the child she turned back into the state. After deep research- she found in their files- notes saying that these children NEVER SHOULD HAVE BEEN ADOPTED. She spent over $200K in medical and psychological care for them. $100K in damages to her home. She has 4 inch binders of each of them and their stories. Now as adults, they have no contact with her, all have heavy drug habits, have done prison time, and the girls have children. It was heartbreaking to sit and watch. SHE TRIED, SHE STUCK IT OUT. She should have sent them back like Anita but was afraid of what people would have said. Best of luck and love to Anita. She did the right thing.
I believe an old saying is appropriate here: Don't judge until you've walked a mile in my shoes.
I admire this mother who had the courage of her convictions. Her goal was to do the best thing for baby D.
I think she did the right thing if she could not love or take care of the child like her own child. The child should feel loved and not have to question himself later on in life. She was thinking about the childs needs and not her own
I adopted a brother and sister who have Reactive Attachment Disorder,(RAD) and they were my only children.  I lived with these people who were shells rather than loving and accepting of love in return.  One Psychologist likened my experience to putting money in a soda machine over and over and never ever getting the soda.  That is what it's like to live with RAD.  I too considered resinding the adoption but I was told that I would be abondoning my children and would face criminal charges.  Twelve years later, the children are grown and have absolutely no connection to me or anyone else in their very extended family.  It is better for D. to be placed in an environment where he may get the intense therapy he deserves to help him function in society and to help him be an emotionally sound person.
Anita should elaborate on how baby D did not bond with her. All a child needs is love and caring. I think she is cruel. So many couples are childless and would do anything to have a child, Anita has abused that right. She should not be allowed to adopt ever again.
As an adoptive mother, I can relate to her feelings on many levels.
I applaud her honesty.
My heart breaks for this little baby who obviously had a horrible beginning to his life and was dumped on the side of the road. Then to be given away again...I cannot imagine what he must think is wrong with him that no one wants him. Of course she had trouble bonding with him--he had never learned what that meant. I wish she hadn't been so selfish and honored the commitment she made when adopting him in the first place. Many bio moms don't bond for years--do they give their kids away? It makes me so sad.
I applaud Anita for making a decision that was in the best interest of "Baby D" to assure that he could have the best life possible.  It had to be a very difficult choice, and it certainly sounds like she tried her best to bond with him.  
I watched Anita tell her story with Matt this morning and, as a mom, it broke my heart.  It is not anyone's place to judge her.  She was looking out for little "D's" best interest and it had to be a very hard decision for her and her family.  Why are we as a society so quick to judge!!!!
I question whether this lady gave the bonding enough time.  As mentioned in the show sometimes it takes a longer time to bond than eighteen months.  There is also the question of long term damage to the child.  This child now has to deal with both the rejection of the birth parents and the first adoption family who did not feel they were a compatible match.  
Another way of looking at what Anita did for D would be to see that she was the stepping stone for D to get to the right family.  That perhaps he would not have found the right family any other way.  God works in mysterious ways!  Anita also said that she wrote an article about this and judged the family for it.  Now she knows the importance of being true to your heart and listening to that voice within.
I am an adopted child -- now an adult.  I never had a bond with my adoptive parents and judging from their behavior, they never bonded with me.  I believe I would have been far happier if they had realized that and given me a chance to find a loving family.  I spent over a decade in therapy recovering from being their only adopted child who did not meet their expectations.  Blessedly, that therapy was successful. Anita showed great courage to make this decision.
Anita,
My heart is with you. I adopted a baby through international adoption 6 years ago. I read, read, read and learned all I could about the expected challanges, esp attachment disorders. Our baby bonded beautifully but as a result of all the reading I learned that is just not always the case. It sounds like you came to this decision with thoughfulness and love. Baby D probably needed a family where he/she was the sole child for the intense work that will need to be done for the attachment to happen. It is unfortunate but love is not the only answer. For those that will be critical of this decision - this are shoes that you would need to walk in to understand. There are MANY books out there on attachement disorders, Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) being the most serious. Building the Bonds of Attachment is an excellent book to help understand along with The Boy who was raised as a Dog.  Please learn more before you judge. I can assure you that our prisons and jail are full of people with RAD as it often goes undiagnosed.
I have not read the article, but I just saw the Today Show feature on this subject. I have never responded to anything, but I guess I just wanted to say who are any of us to judge? There is not one of us that have walked in THIS woman's shoes, experienced her experiences whatever they may be, and lived her life. And until we have done just that we are not intitled to make any decisions or judgements. And a s Forrest Gump said, "And that is all I have to say about that. "
I am a mother of an adopted child so I think I might have some insight here. Mercy triumphs over judgement. Anita tried. She got a child that had been abused and was not a newborn. A tough situation already. I got my child at 10 days old. He was in a loving foster home for those 10 days and immediately bonded with our family. Though rare, not bonding does happen. It will happen more frequently the older the child is and the harsher the environment they were coming from. To take a child that is not your own and love him/her like your own is to be commended. Not enough people do it. I say 'bravo' to Anita for being big-hearted enough to give her heart to this child. She tried. It didn't work. That can happen. The big thing is that she gave it her all.  
Outrage, I adopted my son at 8 months old, at 3yrs old I was told he had a learning disability. After many years of intervention he is now a high honor roll 10th grader in High School. He is a great kid and as my husband sums it up he is our hero. You don't give up, adoption is like giving birth you get what you give.
I work for a child advocate who represents kids in foster care.
Anita's story was very sad, and I can understand negative reactions to it.
But it sounded like "Baby D" had been severely neglected prior to Anita adopting him, and the truth is that neglected babies often cannot attach normally; it takes a certain kind of person to be able to love a child who may never be able to reciprocate normally.
We too adopted two boys two years apart who were not siblings in 1995 and 1996.  They both were wards of the state of parents who were not able to care for them.  They were failure to thrive children.  We too loved them dearly and we also had three natural children who were almost grown.  We wanted to give back to society because we thought we were so blessed.  

We also went to therapy and counseliing for most of the boys lives.  They are now 16 and 19.  As they grew our lives were turned upside down.  They had so many issues that we were just not able to handle.  The 19 year old is now homeless, we refused to let me torment us any longer.  The 16 year old is now at a youth farm because of his doing.

People so easily judge us because we will not let them come back home.  They have no idea the mental, physical including the financial hardship we are enduring now.

We applaud Anita's decision to let her son go.  We know the anguish she has had to endure.  Anita's being able to sense that there would be good outcome was prophetic!

Alice and Don
Michigan
Hello,  I just say your story on Anita and I have to say I agree with what she did.  I believe that the child if not bonding either way should be placed with a family that is a better fit.  Think about it if your heart is not strong on something especially a relationship you are not going to put your whole self into it.  That is not fair to the child or you.  I am sure this is not what she really wanted or planned but I give her credit for taking baby D's needs first.
This whole story scares me. I am in the process of adopting a baby due in February and this story really makes me stop and think "what if?". I will proceed with the adoption plan in place with the expectant mother. And I will pray that our bond is fast and strong. Anita, I feel for you and your family having to endure the criticism. Baby D, such a rough life at such a young age, my heart breaks for you.
What would she have done if she had given birth to a child she could not bond with. You do not give your children away.
I have heard our society called "Throw Away", this woman, and I cannot call her a mom, just threw this little boy away, again.  What message have we imbedded in this little boy's mind?  He has now been thrown away not once but twice.  Have we created a future psychopath?  Will he ever trust another person?

My question to this women is, "Why did you want to adopt this child if you already had a large biological family? Did it not occur to her that this would be difficult?    
I feel Anita is a very brave woman.  It couldn't have been an easy decision to come to.  And certainly not a "socially acceptable"  decision.  She used her heart and intuition to know that no matter how hard she tried there was just no connection between herself and the baby.  At least she is giving him a chance at another family who may have a stronger connection with him .  Everything happens for a reason.  He is where he is suppose to be. And for those who feel they need to sit in judgement of her decision, maybe they need to have faith in that he is where he needs to be.  
I believe that adoption is very difficult no matter what the age of the child.  I have worked with families that were unable to keep the adopted child in their home and the adoption was terminated.  I think that no one knows what Anita is going through until they have been there and are experiencing it.  I believe that Anita went through a lot of emotional searching before making this decision and it was not easy for her.  
I think she made the right move, there are no books to bond a child with a woman it comes naturally.
I don't have children but at one time considered adoption. It's a wonderful thing to welcome and love a child from the world into your home as a member of your family. The goodness in your heart does not always make this decision a happily everafter story. It seems Anita did everything she could to share her life with this little boy but we all have heard stories of children neglected for whatever reason, who are incapable of connecting with another human being. What we don't hear is how the rest of her family, other children and husband, connected with Baby "D." Was this little wonder unable to bond with them? I  don't judge her because I have not walked in her shoes.
I wish I wasn't subjected to Anita's story about her lack of "attachment" with Baby D. I'd like to know how a child of such a young age would go about showing their attachment. This sounds like some fabricated excuse for someone who didn't fully comprehend the trials of adoption, not worthy of our attention. If your expecting a fairytale, don't adopt. For that matter, don't have kids.
I was a professional babysitter when my children were small. I had no problem bonding with all 'my babies' except for one. I completely understand what Anita is talking about. It was not the child's fault, nor was it mine. The bond just never came. After months of observing the sadness in this child's eyes, I finally told his mother that she needed to find another sitter, as it was not fair to her son to be with me daily. He needed to be with someone he could bond with, attach to, be happy around. I'm sure this mother did not understand my decision, and I'm sure it hurt her feelings and of course put a strain on her to find another sitter, but I had to do this for the sake of the child. I sincerely hope his next sitter bonded with him, and that he had a happy childhood.
There is a part of me that can understand the decision this mother made but as the parent of a child with special needs, I feel that you don't get to pick and choose your children... My daughter is my biological child and she has Autism.  It is difficult to bond with an Autistic child but I don't have the option of "giving her back".. there is no one to give her back to.. She is MY child, and it is my responsibility to do the very best I can for her. Does that mean I get overwhelmed? Yes. Does that mean that it is hard? Yes..BUT, the challenges outweigh the successes and she has made me a better parent and a better human being..... This mother CHOSE this child to be part of family. She already had 5 children.. If it is TOO hard.. oh well.  She would not make the same decision if this had been one of her own biological children..She would stick it out with them and do what needed to be done because she HAS to and she should have stuck it out with the adopted child.  She just decided it was TOO HARD and she did not want to deal with it anymore.. It IS HARD but I deal with it EVERY day and will continue to do so. I would die fighting for my child and I can say that even if it was an adopted child instead of a biological one.  It takes a certain amount of unselfishness and unconditional love. I love my daughter unconditionally even if she cannot love me back......
My husband and I adopted two boys from Ethiopia last year. Our oldest son was 3 and the baby was about 5 months. since that time our baby was idagnosed with a genetic disorder and cancer. Adoption can be a very difficult process, but one that you need to go into with resolve. No child is perfect, whether biological or adopted. They are also not you, which makes it most difficult. You must love them and learn to like them because they come with their own personality and attitudes that do not always reflect the family values, traits, etc. that a biological child may have through nature. I am also a Master level social worker and I believe that Anita needed to do what she did because she obviously was not able to handle these delicate issues that come with adopting. i think it is true that not all parents who adopt, despite screening are prepared for the life adjustments that adoption brings to your family. She would have only been destructive to the childs life. Unfortunately, she has now made it more difficult for the child and new family. Being "passed around" does not ever help a child with attachment issues. Although I would suspect it's more the parents issues here and not those of the child. I just hope that they are not allowed to adopt again in the future and disrupt another child's life.
I'm a foster mother preparing to adopt and I've
often wondered if our bonding process would
be smooth. I know it takes time. I do have a
friend that has struggled with bonding with her
newly adopted baby such that the agency came
and took the baby away from her. She is now
fighting to get the baby back, because she
realizes that what she is experiencing is normal
but it seems as if others are even giving her
the chance to even get bonded. she had the baby
all of about 3 weeks. thanks for running this
story.
I sit and watch the news, I have seen horrible things done to children, baby's because the parent felt no options.  I always say to myself...why??? There are so many options..take the baby to a hospital, a police station, a neighbor..for God's sake leave it on a doorstep and ring the bell....So when this woman is being judged so harshley because she did do the right thing, I think in a few years would they rather be sitting on the sofa listening to a different story?  To a mom who drove car into the bay, or dropped a baby in the dumpster? I say good job!  You did not fail that baby, you gave that baby a chance for a happy life, and for that I congratulate you!
Until you've walked in this mother's shoes, do not pass judgment.  Only she knows what was involved - I've been there and the misperceptions of others absolutely astounded me!  
i would like to know if this were her biollogical child where would she send it......you take a child and giving it back is not an option, it is not a pair of shoes,perhaps the child was not to her perfefection         Pauline fillippis cambridge ohio    .
That's what I was wondering that was not discussed: was D suffering from developmental delays which may have impaired his ability to bond? What did she mean, "he just was not bonding with us?" She already had so many natural children, could it have been possible that another was too much for her? Sounds like a lot of blame for this 16-month old to take on so I'm glad she gave him up for his sake.
I am not a judgemental person, and I can empathize with Anita. That being said, I think that the problem with adoption is that 'pick and choose' mentality of sorts. My child had add and a learning disability. As a single young mother, I was overwhelmed and many times I felt he needed a 'better' mother. I could not do that because I gave birth to him. I think that whether you give birth to a child or adopt a child you take on the responsibilities that come along with that child. Not all children are easy. You don't get to pick and choose the 'happy, easy, loving' ones and throw back the rest. I think what she did was best for the child in the end, because he will hopefully find a family that loves him 'unconditionally'. I feel like she was wrong here. I am sorry. I truly try not to judge but I think 'we could not establish a bond' in 18 months is a sad reason to disrupt his life for a second time.
This is a clear case of a very poor assessment from a social worker . . .lots of warning signs here . . . absent husband, lots of children already (with clear attachment issues themselves!), special needs child, egotistical, emotionally needy mother.  Never heard of an adoption placement occurring in a living room with siblings watching Spongebob . . .hopefully she will not be allowed to adopt again.
I have lived this also and am still struggling to work with a 17 year old I addopted at the age of five.  We have had to do treatment away from home and people just do not understand, that sometimes their is just no other choice.  I say that they did the right thing for thier family.  I now have to other children who are tramitized by having my daughter in the home.
I know of a little girl who was placed with a family when she was about 9 years old, she was with them close to a year.  She loved them very much & we thought they felt the same about her.  They even made the adoption date.  Then suddenly the mother decided she wasn't bonding, that the dad was, but she wasn't.  She said she couldn't live like that if one would bond & the other wouldn't, so they sent the little girl back to social services.  The child was of course heartbroken, because she had been calling them mom & dad for months, & had grown to love them & their extended families.  It was one of the most heartbreaking things I've ever seen.  I think a lot of it is a decision.
How disappointing that you show any sympathy at all for Anita.  She is selfish and heartless.  Adopting children is not a try-before-you-buy transaction.  As an adopted child, I am appalled at this prospect. There is also no mention of the agency.  Why not?  When there are so many people who want their own child without regard to whether they are biological or adopted, why would the agency approve as an adoptive parent, a woman who already has 5 children?  I have no tears for Anita only anger.  I'll save my tears for the child D who now, because of Anita, has to overcome abandonment twice! How dare she leave this child with this legacy.  For shame Anita, for shame.
It takes a bigger person to give the baby back than to oeave the baby in an environment where they can not make a bonding loving relationship with thos ewho are raising them.

Unless you have been in this situation, NO ONE has the right to judge Anita. You don't know what it is like unless you have personally been through.

I applaud her and her family for loving this little boy enough to give him to a family where he can have a bonding loving relationship with those who will raise him.

I wish this little boy nothing but love and happiness in his life as he grows up!
As a birth mother who placed my daughter up for adoption 23 years ago, I can say this story sickens me.  I could not afford to keep my very healthy baby girl.  However, I feel that any woman who takes the role as a mother that has the fiancial ability to care for that child should do just that.  A mother should not decide to throw her baby to society due to any kind of physical problem.  This woman is not worthy to be a mother.  
I commend Anita for having the unslefish corrage to make this decision.  I can't immagine any greater pain than giving up a child that was supposed to be yours biological or adopted. May God Bless you for your decision.
My heart is POUNDING as I write this.  I am outraged at the fact that this adult Anita could return a precious baby because she did not "bond" with him.  Returning him at 18 months is unthinkable....she is the only mother he knows.  With the physical difficulties he already has, he now has even more challenges ahead for him.  As a mother myself, if a child (any child) who needed love and a family, was placed into my life for whatever reason, I would feel HONORED to raise him.  ESPECIALLY if I were pursuing an adoption in the first place.  Anita deserves no pity and no admiration.  She failed a precious gift from God, and doesn't deserve the wonderful honor of being called a mother.
I have perm. custody of a child who is not biologically mine. She has lots of issues and to be honest, it took me a LONG time to bond with her. I found over time she had Aspergers and lots of neglect and abuse issues which kept her from being able to truly bond with anyone. Over time, I learned to accept the fact that she could only bond in her way which isn't the same way I define bonding. After all this you would think I would have bad things to say to Anita but honestly...I don't and I completely understand. The wonderful thing about what Anita did is she helped in finding the right family for "D" which shows her love for him. Anyone who sees you in a bad light has never been through something like this. You made the right decision and I'm sure you will be blessed and so will "D".
This ladies not bonding excuse is absolutely insane. It's an excuse for someone who shouldn't be a mother in the first place, its her job as a mother to make it work. The most important thing is whats best for the child and this women is selfish and ignorant. It's not that she can't bond but that this women can't love something that isn't biologicly related to her, and considering she chose to adopt this baby it was her responsibility to raise it. She should be ashamed of herself.
I definitely feel that Anita made the right decision, both for her, her family, and the baby. I am sure this was not an easy decision for her and I admire her for her courage.
My heart goes out to Anita.  I praise her for having such a compassionate heart and knowing the "right" thing to do.  I can't imagine the pain she has experienced in her decision, but I saw it on her face.  I pray she knows that she is not alone.  I knew someone who adopted a 12 y.o. girl who, in turn, had mental issues to the point of setting fires.  This information was not disclosed to the adoptive parents prior to the adoption.  As a result, the adoptive parents gave her up.  God Bless You Anita.
I think she did give this child a blessing by saving his life from the life he had in a third world country, but I don't think the child had a chance with her because she had a dream child in her head that this child did not compare to and I wish that child the best and that someone appreciate him for himself and not compare him to a dream child in their head.


New comments to this post are disabled

Syndicate This Site

Add allDAY to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google