ABOUT allDAY

allDAY is the official TODAY blog, your virtual window to Studio 1A and the people who make America's favorite morning show come alive. Whether it's exchanging views with the anchors and contributors or going behind the scenes with the producers, editors, camera people and more, we'll bring you the buzz here at 30 Rock, and we hope you will make this a regular part of your online routine. We want this to be a conversation, so please respond with your comments and questions directly to the blog, and we'll do our best to post what you have to say.



Inside an animal hoarder's house

Posted: Thursday, March 13, 2008 4:32 PM by Sarika Dani

(From Josh Weiner, TODAY producer)

Do you like cats? How many do you consider too many to keep as pets?

Imagine being inside a tiny house with over 100 cats. Talk about an unforgettable experience. It was a recent assignment for a segment on animal hoarding where I found myself inside a cat-cramped, tiny home just outside Manhattan.

It was a bitterly cold Friday morning just after sunrise. My colleague Melanie Jackson came along to help film, and we first met the ASPCA folks outside. Their team was ready to go with two mobile surgical trucks. The goal: to spay and neuter all the cats in the house within just one day. Because this case wasn’t wasn't deemed one of animal abuse, this was the way to at least prevent further breeding. A perfect solution? Perhaps not, but it was the best option.

You can't even imagine the stench walking into the home. Absolutely horrendous. Big, small, running wild, hiding in the kitchen cabinets, the bedroom mattress, behind the refrigerator ... cats were everywhere!

Everywhere, including my head. Melanie and I were in the midst of shooting when all of a sudden a cat landed on me.

The ASPCA team was in full gear – professional, comfortable, and whoa were they fast! Within less than 30 minutes, they had captured most of the cats and put them in carrying cases.

I followed around filming – and between the 100 cats and the half-dozen ASPCA folks, this place was chaos. A few confused-looking neighbors passed by the house on their way to work, clearly trying to figure out what the ruckus was all about. It was, after all, just 6:30 AM on a Friday.

I didn’t spend the whole day there. But the ASPCA did. And they were able to perform surgery on all the cats. They returned all of the cats to the home, except for about 40 kittens which they took back to their shelter – hoping that they would find adoptive families.

But there's a tragic paradox to this story. At first glance, one might think that only a sick, malicious person would hoard over 100 cats and keep them locked up inside. After speaking with the owner (or perhaps the "keeper" is a more accurate title), I felt very sympathetic.

This woman, who agreed to speak as long as her anonymity was protected, was really upset and seemingly misguided. Three years ago, she explained, her dog died, and she began to rescue cats from the street. They kept mating ... and mating ... and mating ... all the while she continued to gather more neighborhood cats. Soon it was totally out of control.

The hoarder welcomed the ASPCA, because ultimately this woman wanted to find permanent homes for the cats. Was she doing a service to the animals? I guess it's debatable. But her intentions were always good.

It was a pretty unnerving experience for me. In the end, I think our story about hoarding will help bring attention to the problem, so that animal hoarding cases are reported to authorities before they're completely out of hand.

For more on the psychology behind animal hoarding: The crazy cat lady, explained

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I can sympathize with horders, as I have 14 cats and three dogs. Most I have gotten from the street and three have come a breeder of bengals that had to take them back from owners that decided that a cat was not for them, two had been abused.  I will conceed that I have too many, I added 5 after my son died 4 years ago, there was obviously a need being filled there.  All my pets are spayed or neutered and all but one cat is declawed in the front to preserve my furniture,and to keep them from harming each other when they have the occasional tiff, none of them go outside.  The hardest part is placing them in a new home, I would love to find some of them a new home, but I'm afraid that I couldn't find them a home that would care for them as they well as they are being treated now, and I don't feel that would be fair to them after I have had their trust for so long, they are truly like my children or family.    
I am not just an animal lover but i am also a animal owner.I have 2 dogs and 2 cats all i have bottle fed and raised as part of our family.But i also know that i have  a responsibility to keep them safe and sound.There is not a day goes by i don't see an abondoned animal on the side of the street or go by a shelter and wish i could help every animal in there, but i also know i can't help every animal in the world which keeps me only having my 2 dogs and 2 cats. If we want to help the animals of the worl get your pet spayed or nuetured.keep the pet population down people.And just know you can't save the world by owning more pets than you can take care of...Keep yourself healthy, love god and take care of our animals.
Unfortunately, this situation is all too common, but to a lesser extreme. I am involved in animal rescue and it becomes difficult to say "enough is enough". You want to help every last one of them, why stop at 4???? Who better than me to take care of these poor little creatures?? When you have the will in your heart, you simply cannot turn an animal in need away. It becomes easy to get caught up in it, truly feeling as though you are doing what is right for the animal, but when it becomes a human health risk, as well as an unsafe environment for the animals themselves, it's time to seek out the help of a professional and do what truly is best for the animals.
My heart goes out to this woman, she really did beleive she was making a difference in the lives of these unwanted animals, sacrificing herself and home to provide shelter for them.
How do you report a hoarder? I know a person that has at least 60 or so cats that he has been giving his best care. He gets them spayed etc, but you can't be sure he even notices any new ones popping up. The person is a Vietnam vet with some obvious issues. My seems to collect unusual friends and this person is about the most unusual of them all. I cannot stand within a foot of him even if in the downwind. He smells like an overused litterbox. At one time I went into his house and never made that mistake again. Standing too close made me gag and going in the house was worse. Luckily I made it outside without showing my reactions and recovered before I had to barf.
I mostly worry for him as he smells so bad he has been banned from places he would like to go that would give him some type of social activity.
I don't think his lifestyle with the cats is healthy for him even though the cats seem healthy themselves. I also don't think he could be classified as an animal abuser as the cats seem fairly well taken care of. I just want to know how to get help for him as I am sure the amount of ammonia he breathes with their spraying isn't healthy and I have seen him lose a lot of social interaction that he could have with people due to his cat obsession.
I think that is wrong to have that many cats in your house. Think about the sanitary situation. That must smell terrible. Im sorry, but to have that many animals in one house is absurd. I would love to save all the animals in the world, as would others, but we can only do so much.
People collect cars, clothes, and other material things.  If a person can afford it, they should be able to have as many pets as they wish.  However if then animal collector is not providing a healthy lifestyle for their animal companions, they should be helped not punished.  These people are compassionate individuals with good intentions.  
I don't understand why people find the need to hoard animals.  Cats, dogs, birds, whatever!  Most of them end up starving to death or die of diseases. My husband and I have four dogs and believe me, they eat better then we do.  My house is clean and so are our dogs.  It's a real shame that these hoarders think they are doing the right thing for these poor animals which in fact, they are suffering and slowley dying.
How many is too many?  This would have to take into consideration the location and the facilities.  For an apartment, I would think anything over two would be too many.  For a home with safe outside access, perhaps three, but like children, animals need personal attention and anymore than that is just too many for a person to give adequate care and attention. Having one dog and one cat should suffice any person's love of animals.  I am sorry Marion, but ten cats is a bit much and is over the top eccentric.
  i have frined she has 7 , 8 , 9 cate two dogs n snake birds mice  to feed snake hamsters radits ops one dies neglect out side cage nspider fish tanks n lizard n maybe more i can not count almost 20 total.  i think you are right she has disfuncitional fmaily n marrages past husband was sex offender. in prison long time iowa  know girl 18 has older boy frined sex offender n he is back in prison ex offender. there is law in city4 pets allowed outher wise fined n has to get rid of them. shall one call police n report this hoard of animals?  the house stinks n pets do it ever where it's discusting!!! she can not keep up with the expense of cleaning up after them.
I have had at least 10 cats for most of my life,my oldest died at 21 years of age,all have reached their upper teens and have been spayed and neutered.We have fostered them and taken in at times older cats from the vets office or pound.I even got a group rate once for having 7 done by my vet of 20 years.
I also have 2 dogs and cat sit for my neighbor when she goes on vacation.
Am I crazy?I think not.I belong to the MSPCA and PETA.
My vet has had a member of her staff check out my house before I could adopt a dog,I adopted the dog.
I think the lady was trying to her best ability to help unwanted animals. It got beyound her control, and she needed help, but probably didn't know where to look to get it. I hope all the cats find a good home, and I hope she collects no more, but she probably will.
I don't completely agree with the reasons given in the previous article "Animal hoarding: The crazy cat lady, explained". Not everyone has deep routed childhood issues, etc. I think that many people who end up with so many animals start out with good intentions of trying to help the animals, not realizing how easy it is to become overwhelmed with such a tremendous responsibility. Things also change in peoples lives, like possibly the loss of income or illness which can create these situations. If more people would step up to the plate and adopt and give an animal a loving home, and/or have their pets spayed and neutered, less animals would die in shelters each year and other people wouldn't have to feel that they have to take on so much.  

I also think that the daily question of "How many pets is too many?" is slanted. The choices given are rediculous, choices A. and D. It depends on the person and their circumstances and means to be able to take care of an animal(s). For some people one animal is enough. For others, maybe 5 or more. It just depends. Many people have more than 3 animals. So the results from this vote are stupid.
Aside from the sad truth that it seems most people with such enormous numbers of animals (that are not neutered or immunized for the most part) have some deep-seated psychological problems, it is paramount to continue to try to keep the cat population under control. Most of us that love and try to help in this fashion know all too well how many cats an un-neutered  female can produce in her lifetime.  I wish there were more recources for this specific issue.
I also am a pet lover and have 5 cats at present.  It would be easy to have more as there are so many that need homes.  I also have 4 dogs but that doesn't seem to have the "bad" stigma placed on it that cats have.  If people would take care of there own pets then there wouldn't be the problem.  But too many don't.  It is very hard to not take in all of the animals that need help.
As an animal lover myself it was difficult for me to finally grasp the hard truth that euthanasia for some of these animals is a welcome relief. If an animal is so called "rescued" then subjected to filth and poor living conditions ie, disease, they're not really being rescued in the real sense.
I have much sympathy for any animal horder. My problem is cats. They are my best friends. they talk to me in their own language, listen to them and you will hear them. The problem with horders is not enough money. Shelters are great ,but when you ask for help to spay/neuter , the answer is you can pay so much down and pay the balance in monthly payment.
Please my $260.00 a month does not go to far. Most of the cats I have acquired have been gien to me by someone else or just knocked on my door. A cat gives undenialabe love. Which some people need and get from their cat.
So, that's what a "Cat-House" is!
i feel  for  both this lady who  took in the  cats and the  cats  themselfs ,, people  more  than  not  mean well  and a sickness can soon become  over  wheming ,,,I  hope   anyone  that  knows  of  someone in a cse  like this  will  try to  get that person  some help and not  just  walk away and  call them crazy ... Help is  much better than walking  away ,,
We buy, fix up and resell homes and recently bought one that belonged to a cat hoarder. This house was so bad, after working there 2 days we found that she had housed cats in the attic also and the litter, feces and urine was about 6 inches deep. Our first thought was we have to tear the house down or have it burned but we plugged on and finally finished the job and removed all of the odor. While doing this though I figured out by things I found there that this lady trully did believe she was doing good. My first impression though was that she must have been completely off her rocker. We estimated she must have had around 100+ cats in a small 2 bedroom house. WOW!
I AM MORE PERSONALLY FOND OF THE ANIMALS THAT ADOPT ME. THE STRAYS THAT COME AROUND AND THEN STAY OF THEIR OWN FREE WILL. I DO NOT LOCK UP THE STRAYS, I FEED THEM, BATHE THEM, PUT AN AD IN THE PAPER, SOON THEY WILL EITHER STRAY FROM MY YARD AS WELL, THEIR LONELY PARENT WILL RETRIEVE THEM, OR THEY WILL STAY AND BE MY NEW BEST FREIND.  
I know this lady's heart for cats all too well.She is not crazy.They are God's creatures with feelings like us and and its people like her that saved them and the fact that she welcomed the help from the ASPCA says alot.My two cats that I have , were thrown out by my neighbors .I have  the mom cat of my runt cat Bella.Bella's mum was thrown out of her home because they thought she was flea infested and pregnant.I took her from the woods outside my home.She has been with me for two months and is the best lap cat.Now Hope,the mum cat is reunited with her baby girl Bella age 2 and they get along.Laws should be more enforced for animals that if someone is to have a pet,they get cori checked first.I bathed hope in a flea and tick treatment,no fleas since she been at my home and she is not pregnant,thank goodness.She will be spayed in May.But I said to my neighbor,the little girl age 12 that owned her- Hope was renamed,her old name was Speedy and I said "As you throw your cat away,I want you to think of this,how would you feel if your mum says I'm having a baby bcause your to old and I don't want you no more,how would you feel?" She says 'Jealous,and mad" and I said well that is how your cat feels and why she acted out because you kept her kitten,but not her.Animals have feelings too,just like humans.Age should not be a factor.Its the personality of the animals. All animals need love,thats why animals show aggression to human and because they don't have the same pretense of speaking out for help as we human do.
I agree with Marion. We need as a nation and the government needs to try and get more animals homes and adopted. In a world where pets ar frowned upon, or too much trouble, people who look after these abandoned animals are angels. There are too many that di every year in shelters, on the streets from starvation or injury. People may think that these folks who look aftr the animals, th ons that really car and not neeglct the animals are batty but in actuality they're doing God's work.  
" A righteous Man Looks After the Animals"!
i have taken in many dogs and cats over my adult years.it is so hard to find homes for these animals even after getting their shots and having them spayed or neutered.after exhausting all possible efforts to find a home for them there has to be a limit,the most humane thing is to have them put down.one person can only care for so many,and do the most good to our limits.
Spay and neutered should be an oligation and Animal Hospital should be more reasonable with the fees! There are many good people than want a pet, but can't afford the hight prices!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Syndicate This Site

Add allDAY to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google