ABOUT allDAY

allDAY is the official TODAY blog, your virtual window to Studio 1A and the people who make America's favorite morning show come alive. Whether it's exchanging views with the anchors and contributors or going behind the scenes with the producers, editors, camera people and more, we'll bring you the buzz here at 30 Rock, and we hope you will make this a regular part of your online routine. We want this to be a conversation, so please respond with your comments and questions directly to the blog, and we'll do our best to post what you have to say.



Inside an animal hoarder's house

Posted: Thursday, March 13, 2008 4:32 PM by Sarika Dani

(From Josh Weiner, TODAY producer)

Do you like cats? How many do you consider too many to keep as pets?

Imagine being inside a tiny house with over 100 cats. Talk about an unforgettable experience. It was a recent assignment for a segment on animal hoarding where I found myself inside a cat-cramped, tiny home just outside Manhattan.

It was a bitterly cold Friday morning just after sunrise. My colleague Melanie Jackson came along to help film, and we first met the ASPCA folks outside. Their team was ready to go with two mobile surgical trucks. The goal: to spay and neuter all the cats in the house within just one day. Because this case wasn’t wasn't deemed one of animal abuse, this was the way to at least prevent further breeding. A perfect solution? Perhaps not, but it was the best option.

You can't even imagine the stench walking into the home. Absolutely horrendous. Big, small, running wild, hiding in the kitchen cabinets, the bedroom mattress, behind the refrigerator ... cats were everywhere!

Everywhere, including my head. Melanie and I were in the midst of shooting when all of a sudden a cat landed on me.

The ASPCA team was in full gear – professional, comfortable, and whoa were they fast! Within less than 30 minutes, they had captured most of the cats and put them in carrying cases.

I followed around filming – and between the 100 cats and the half-dozen ASPCA folks, this place was chaos. A few confused-looking neighbors passed by the house on their way to work, clearly trying to figure out what the ruckus was all about. It was, after all, just 6:30 AM on a Friday.

I didn’t spend the whole day there. But the ASPCA did. And they were able to perform surgery on all the cats. They returned all of the cats to the home, except for about 40 kittens which they took back to their shelter – hoping that they would find adoptive families.

But there's a tragic paradox to this story. At first glance, one might think that only a sick, malicious person would hoard over 100 cats and keep them locked up inside. After speaking with the owner (or perhaps the "keeper" is a more accurate title), I felt very sympathetic.

This woman, who agreed to speak as long as her anonymity was protected, was really upset and seemingly misguided. Three years ago, she explained, her dog died, and she began to rescue cats from the street. They kept mating ... and mating ... and mating ... all the while she continued to gather more neighborhood cats. Soon it was totally out of control.

The hoarder welcomed the ASPCA, because ultimately this woman wanted to find permanent homes for the cats. Was she doing a service to the animals? I guess it's debatable. But her intentions were always good.

It was a pretty unnerving experience for me. In the end, I think our story about hoarding will help bring attention to the problem, so that animal hoarding cases are reported to authorities before they're completely out of hand.

For more on the psychology behind animal hoarding: The crazy cat lady, explained

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

How sad that the cats had to be rescued in the first place.  If all pet owners would take responsibility for their animals and always spay and neuter then the pet population could be controlled.  Cases of hoarding are misguided people trying to solve a problem that is real, but with a flawed solution.

Spay and neuter and adopt a resuce animal.  
I commend this women.  I thought I was bad with 10 cats.  Wait till I show this article to my family.  So many people get a pet and when they don't fit in or they can no longer handle the pet, they let them loose on the streets, to fend for themselves.  We need more people who are willing to take in strays and contact the ASPCA, the Humane Society, any no kill organization or their local vet to have them either spayed or neutered. I'm not saying that they have to keep the pet, but at least give them a chance.
What a fascinating story! And I'm glad the producer took the time to look beyond the facade of the story -- that only a crazy person would hoard that many cats -- to get the owner's humanistic perspective.  
Why don't people think "first" about what is causing this woman's behavior and care about her, before the cats.

A mental health care advocate and animal lover and owner.
Why don't people think "first" about what is causing this woman's behavior and care about her, before the cats.

A mental health care advocate and animal lover and owner.
As the devoted care-taker of twenty-three cats, I wince everytime I see an article on "crazy cat-ladies" or animal hoarders.  My husband and I found ourselves with a multi-cat household much as the hoarders do--by taking in the animals that other people abandon.  Often we are painted with the same "crazy" brush that society reserves for the truly trouble and out-of-touch but good-hearted people who take on more pets than they can handle.

I was glad to see that the producers of this segment at least tried to make a distinction between people who have a lot of cats or dogs and those who take on the animals without being able to properly care for them.  If you do a brief web search, you will find that there are many responsible people in the world who do have fifteen or twenty or more pets and manage to provide them with good veterinary care, clean homes and love.  Lisaviolet, Tally, Tik Tok, and Noofies are names familiar to many of us in the cyberspace network of committed multi-pet owners.  Through websites, links, articles and forums, these folks and many others offer help, advice and insight into the complexities of caring properly for multiple cats.  The media reports the hoarders because they are news and the many responsible pet owners with large numbers of pets are not.  Unfortunately, this sort of story often prompts local governments to try and "solve" the problem of hoarding by legislating a limit to the number of animals one is permitted to have.  Laws of this sort will be ignored by the troubled pet-hoarders and penalize the dedicated people quietly investing their time, resources and emotions in caring for unwanted and abandoned companion animals.  

I understand that the city of Houston has passed a ruling that unless a person has a breeder license, ALL animals in their possession MUST be spayed or nutered to be licensed.  And you MUST have a license tag for each animal. No surgery--no tag.
hoarding is hoarding! how can someone not be aware of spaying/neutering? all you have to do is look around and it is everywhere. call the vet and ask them. come on people! if it were a law that you had to register an animal like you do a car, child etc. maybe the wold would be a better place for keeping tract of these pets. out law breeders for one thing, theres way too may homeless animals that need adoption. here is one area the government should get their nose into.
Thank you for this story- I work at a large no-kill animal sanctuary (with a full clinic staff and state of the art equipment!) and see these stories every day.  If only everybody could see spay/neuter is the answer, euthanasia in local shelters would be down and the stray, feral cat population could be contained.  Once again, thank you for the time spent on this story- if only a few people are educated about these situations it totally worked!!
Hoarding is not simply the result of a "misguided" do-gooder getting in over her head. It is a symptom of a larger mental health problem.  The people living with these animals seem oblivious and live with feces and urine covering their furniture, counters, tables, and even their own clothing and bed. Sane people do not collect 100 or more animals and not notice the death, disease, and stench.  Believe me, hoarding does no animal (or human) any favors, even the street cats because it only prolongs the inevitable; lives shortened by disease and injury. Cats that come from hoarding situations are virtually wild and typically cannot be handled. They bite, carry diseases like distemper, feline leukemia and feline infectious virus (FeLv/FIV), suffer from eye and ear diseases, and have ear mites and fleas. This woman and people like her and NOT to be commended for hoarding. And if it wasn't cats, it would be dogs, horses, or some other voiceless animal. Hoarded animals are not healthy nor should they be considered "saved."  Life on the streets is no better but certainly no worse either. Anyone who thinks so has never had to see what these animals live through crammed into a stench-filled house with a crazy human and a jillion other animals. Nor have they helped while 100 plus seized animals get euthanized because they were too wild to adopt out after a mass-seizure from a hoarder's house.
I have a friend who was considered a "crazy cat lady". She took in cats with FIV. When she was arrested years ago, they took her cats off for euthanization. All 80+ of them. It was devastating for her. To this day, if I have any questions about my own cat, I call her. She knows everything there is to know about felines. She is a hyper-intelligent individual who had names and sounds for each of her animals. While the house did smell, the animals, although terminally ill, were well cared for (as best as she was able), happy, well fed, and knew that they had a person who loved them and would do anything for them. I do, however, think that hoarding is a mental illness that people should not take so lightly. These people are not "crazy". My friend is a genuinely caring person who really did just want to save the animals. In the end, her efforts were in vain, but that doesn't make her crazy. She is not allowed, by law, to hoard. She is checked up on regularly, which I can understand. But, to not legally allow someone as caring as she is to take care of cats the way no one else can? That's a tragedy. Maybe not in her home - but, somewhere.
too bad the ASPCA didn't step in when she had a dozen or so.
My township takes care of stray dogs...but not cats. When you find strays, there are usually tens of them! To take them to our shelter would cost $100 each. The local governments should have a hand in helping. I've taken over 20 cats to a low-cost spay/neuter program for wild cats. It's sad to know some of these animals are poisoned by old-timers and younger fed-up families because middle america can't afford to take the problem into their own hands--the right way. Not everyone has the time or resources to find the low-cost alternative that I did.
I, too, am an animal lover, but I have all I can handle with 3 dogs ( 2 left from my children ). The poor woman thought she was doing a good thing saving the cats and it is so good to have the ASPCA step in to assist her.
I hope that the SPCA follows up with this owner, and stays in touch with her, so that she gets help, since hoarding cases have so many dimensions, mental, emotional, social, etc. Since her hoarding started after her dog died, she sounds like she was trying to deal with her grief over her dog's death, by "replacing" the dog with several cats, and, as you saw and heard, it got out of control.
Just because other people do not/cannot/will not understand the reason behind someone's behaviour, is no reason to call them crazy. Read "Dianetics" by L. Ron Hubbard, then maybe you will have more of an understanding of yourself and others.
We certainly have enough animals to qualify as "crazy cat people' or even "crazy dog people".  All our animals are considered our pets and were either abandoned, injured, feral or unadoptable for one reason or another.  They are all neutered and spayed and current on their vacinations and extremely friendly and loving to one another and to people.  They have their own climate controlled space and outside exercise areas.  I feel there is only one reason people find it easy to ignore the needs of either animal or human creatures and that is selfishness.  There are many reasons why people have difficulty turning away needy creatures and needy humans, all of them more commendable than selfishness.  We feel blessed to be able to care for our animals well and to have had them in our lives.      
To the person who has 10 cats of her own and "commends" the woman in the article: I think she missed the point. This woman was not being lauded for amassing 100 cats and then 'having them neutered'.  The ASPCA was there because the woman's original intent to take in a few strays had grown into an unsafe,unsanitary and unmanageable situation. The woman in the article had not called the ASPCA with a plan to neuter her cats. After all, she is the one who stood idly by while (by her own admission) the cats just kept breeding and breeding. She had obviously been reported to the ASPCA by a concerned family member or neighbor. It was the ASPCA's decision to neuter the cats in an effort so somehow stem the flow of the out of control breeding and collection.  Hopefully they will continue to work with her and be able to stem the flow of cats into her home and maybe even get her some mental health assistance.
This is common with dogs as well, Please understand that we do not do this out of any reason other than love for animals. I don't think that compassion is a sign of mental sickness. Understand and offer HELP for the animals instead to TALKing about the care provider.
These types of stories always surprise me. I never think "Oh what a terrible person", but the first thing I do wonder is how the people who allow there homes to fall into the condition where there is feces  and urine piling up everywhere are not severly ill and in just as bad of a condition as the animals. Did they mention what there health was like?
I can understand how a person becomes a hoarder.  It starts with unconditional love for all animals and just gets out of hand.  I have gained 3 cats just because people have moved and left them to run wild. With my doggie door makes it easy for them to move in.  Fortunatly, I have the means to have them neutered or spayed.  But the food cost alone, could drive me to the poor house.  I live a mile from our local shelter which is not a no kill shelter.  It breaks my heart to take them there knowing if they are not adopted, they will be put down.  Will I take the next one who shows up at my door to the shelter??? I don't know -  I may well be on the way to being a hoarder.
I'v lost 3 beautiful cats in my neighborhood. I wonder if we have one of these people living here?
Sometimes the kind heartedness of people blind their ability to take care of one pet let alone a hundred!
If a stray, please spay!
I wish more cities, counties & states would institute  mandatory spay/neuter laws and programs that help people with the costs. It's a shame that we 'put down' thousands each day and spend untold amounts on shelters and these type rescues. Could the money be better spent? We, as americans are all about stretching the 'all mighty dollar' but we refuse to see the BIG PICTURE. And education: People with the best intentions are still buying from breeders.  SHAME ON US. I was appalled when I first moved here that they sell animals on the side of the road.
Animal hoarding is a form of mental illness.  I'm sorry, but someone needs to rescue the owner in this case.  This many animals, kept in this manner, is not only unhealthy for the animals but for the owner as well.  Hopefully she has family that will step in and take care of her, as well as place some of these animals.
I know a hoarder of cats.She will take them from anywhere and try to care for them but space,finanaces and a belief that cats ca take care of themselves creates an unhealthy home for her and the cats.
OUTSTANDING STORY! Not only this lady but all who have several pets ALWAYS have good intentions, but somehow streamline to the worst cases. This story puts people with several pets & the plan to purchase more in perspective! & also to people who purchase pets as "toys/gifts" as kittens & puppies, and leave them out in the streets when they no longer want them!
I CAN'T BELIEVE PEOPLE WOULD HAVE THAT MANY ANIMALS. I HAVE 2 DOGS , 3 CATS, AND 2 HORSES. MY DOGS AND CATS ARE SPAYED. MY HORSES ARE BOTH MARES NOT EXPOSED TO STUDS.  I FIND ALOT OF PEOPLE NOT WANTING TO HAVE THEIR PETS FIXED. PLEASE PEOPLE THINK OF YOUR ANIMALS HEALTH.
This is a mental health issue. The animals need to be cared for and so does the owner. How heart breaking is it for the owner to see objects of his disorder being taken away. We would not punish a bi polar person for his disease or a depressed person for thiers. Other people should not denegriate these hoarders for lack of a better term.  They need love and guidance and the tools to say good bye and let go.
I think people who hard animals see that too many other people don't care about them, and dump them when theyre tired of them, so they go about trying to solve problem greater than they can handle. It gets out of hand when the person is depressed or otherwise suffering themselves and can't stand seeing animals suffer. Instead of judging these people you should do something to help animals yourself.
I forgot to add my city and state
I'm glad to read this story and hear about this woman who was willing to take in cats off the street.  One of my two cats went missing almost a year ago, and while we searched and searched for her, she hasn't been seen since.  I much prefer to think that she was taken in by a well meaning (if misguided) person than hit by a vehicle, tortured by teenagers, or something like that.  While this woman wasn't exactly responsible (ALWAYS spay and neuter your pets!!) she WAS trying, which is more than most people can say.
I rent rooms in a grand old house with a woman who suffers from this. She has dogs in the back yard and cats in the house.None of we tenants (there are 4) use the lush back yard because the dogs are all over you when you walk out the door. In 6 months I've never used the kitchen which is a haven for the cats.
They are on and in cabinets, on tables and even lie on the stove's burners and sink.  And yes, many times I hold my breath from the entry to my space upstairs where the environment is clean and fresh. I like the lady and love the 85 year old house (5 minutes commute) but have worried many times about her mental and physical health. All her expenses come out of her pocket. Vet bills are frequent and food for all the animals must be extraordinary.
How can it be safe to return 100 just-spayed or neutered cats back to that habitat?  Obviously, it's very unhygienic.  Were precautions taken to prevent the dominant animals from endangering the more docile? Many times, animals react to the injury or a weakness of a lesser by becoming aggressive. Has the woman stopped 'rescuing' cats from the outside? If not, this procedure has been a very temporary stopgap measure.
my ex wife with whom i had lost contact, moved back to klamath falls ,oregon and invited me for a visit. when i got there, i found a new titan truck trashed,and three dogs,three turkeys,and two ducks living in the back of the truck. she refused to take the animals to the humane society and when the two ducks got out of the vehicle,we hunted for 6 hours w/o ever finding the ducks.
I have personally been involved with two hoarders, and the sad thing is, if I didn't keep a tight rein on my own impulses, I fear I could become one as well.  I have arned my children that as I age, they should keep an eye out if I start "collecting". When they were small, we had 3 dogs,four cats, 3 horses, assorted budgies, hansters, and one daughter started raising purebred "show rabbits" for a while.  Currently, I "only" have 3 dogs and a horse.  When I see a stray, part of me thinks "Ah, it would only be ONE MORE..."  Fortunately (?) one of my dogs is somewhat aggressive and I talk myself out of adding any others by convincing myself that he would kill any new arrivals...
I am the owner of 8 cats. I understand the desire to save these wonderful creatures, too. Seven of mine came to me as strays. I'm very happy to know that these cats have been spayed & nutured, and that all of the kittens are being given a chance to have a good healthy life.
I feel sorry for the lady, I would like to know when you hoard other animals I went by a place near me and counted 72 horses and there are more than that. they have not been properly taken care of since the people moved here and they have been turned in.
Only a crazy person WOULD hoard cats that way. People like that are not helping the animals. They are still breeding, passing diseases from the common kitty cold to Feline Aids. The cats medical needs are not being met and the filth and stench are just as bad for the cats as the humans. I bet the reporter left out the fact that several had to be euthanized and were probably even some dead or dying without the lady's knowledge. Only if you've worked in a shelter or in the animal field can you understand how horrible a situation that is and how it is absolutely of no service or help to the cats involved.
I have one indoor cat (neutered and declawed) and three outside "feral" babies I am in the process of taming.  The one female, a snowshoe siamese, I captured, took to the vet, had spayed, inoculated and defleaed.  It cost me almost $300 for everything including all the tests necessary because she was wild.  However, she will never have kittens and she is becoming tamer every day.  The boys are too.  As soon as I can recover from my last expense, the boys go in for THEIR neuter.  I don't think 10 cats are too many for some people as long as they are cared for properly.  These 4 are my limit, in fact too many, but they are beautiful and I just love them.
I will never understand this behavior as long as I live. If I had one hundred acres for free roaming and the means for proper care of any stray that came along.  I would welcome them with open arms.  I love animals of all kinds and have raise several wild babies fallen or left behind by the parent in the wild. It warmed my heart to set them free again only with proper care and advice from my Vet. or a licensed rehabilitaion facility.
However I do not and will not agree with people who hoard animals for personal reasons without proper care.

There is a man who has been reported to the local aurthorities on two occasions that I know of, who has dogs inside a mobile home that he has not allowed to see daylight in over five years. This is unhealthy for him as well as the animals.
He lost four adult dogs and three pups in a span of four months. He doesn't seem to understand why that many seemingly healthy animals.... JUST DIED!!!! Not once have these animals had vacinations or seen a vet for preventive care and they lived in their own fecal matter and urine.   That doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out. Yes, I am venting.  Maybe the ASPCA will take notice to this comment and do something about it.  A little help is all I ask.

This man is my sixty nine year old brother.  I don't want him to die as so many of his animals have.  
This woman tried to do her best helping these cats
I don't think she was tryng to put these cats lives in danger, it just got out of hand - there should be
more places who offer spaying and nuetering options at
reasonable prices - this woman did not look like she
could afford for all these cats to go to a Vet - which
would have been too expensive I don't think she is a
crazy cat lady, I think she just wanted to help them
I am also one of those "cat hoarders" however my population is well cared for with yearly vet visits and plenty of food, water, clean litter and warm places to sleep. Yes it is a challenge but I do have a wonderful pet sitter and a daughter who both help with the care. And just for the record, while I have 17 cats all "fixed" except for two and all rescued, these were my unadoptable crew out of the 600+ I took in over the past 8yrs. All of my adopted animals had shots/wormed at adoption--I pd. the cost myself.All were referred to vets and low cost spay clinics or certificates.All were adopted with a one month return policy-only one return.  As a previous reader stated we need to be responsible for our own pets so we don't need rescue groups.
When we bought our house from my husband's aunt, we were left with two female cats, so between the two, 15 cats emerged (they were outside), they were wild and would bite if cornered. It was a job taking care of 15 cats, I commend this women trying to care for all of the cats she had, Bless her heart. She had more work than she could carry. So finally me knowing something had to be done, I rented a Live Cage from our animal shelter to capture them. None of the 15 were sutible for adoption.
I can relate to the "cat collector lady".  I have a sister who has a very debilitating disease.  She chose not to marry or have children so as not to pass on this horrible disease.  To make up for her loss of children she starting taking in cats for something to love, and more and more cats, trying to fill that void because she had wanted children so bad. She just needed to love and be loved back.  But they started breeding.  This went on for years, and the last time I saw these cats, all the cats had turned feral.  She could not even hold any of them and she had scratches all over her. Her apartment was a shock to me, it was beyond anything I have ever seen and the smell was horrible. I was shocked my own sister was living like this.  But I could not reason with her to let go of some of these animals.  As of now, I have no idea what has happened to her as she cut all ties with me because of me wanting to get her into a better place. She knew she would have to give up her cats.  This is so sad of a situation. I could not understand how the tenants on either side of her place did not complain about the odor.  And outside of her door flies were all over the place and the smell was even out into the entry.  I contacted several places and was told that nothing could be done because she chose to live like that, or I could take her to court and claim her unfit.  I could not find it in my heart to do that even though I knew it would be better for her, but did not want to humiliate her either.  I knew I would lose her forever if I did that, but now I have lost her anyway.  I have no idea of where she is.
I have 6 dogs and just recently lost one. That had me at 7. Just because people have several pets doesnt mean that they are trying to be mean or ugly to the animals. I take very good care of my dogs. If they get sick they get medical help, they are love and cared for just like children, however i do know when to quit. I will admit sometimes it is difficult to take care of all of them but me and my husband manage. They always have food even if I might have little to eat myself. People who have several pets just need to learn when enough is enough. I comend those who try to help strays and try to give them loving homes, but everybody needs to realize that pets are expensive and require lots of the same things kids do. If you cant provide the same care you would to a child to your pets because you have too many you need to rethink your situation.
FINE TAKE IN CATS = FED THEM CARE FOR THEM = IT WILL BE A BETTER LIFE THAN THE STREET = but but BUT SPAYING IS ESSENTIAL or YOU ARE COMPOUNDING THE PROBLEM!!!
OWNER OF 10+ CATS AT HOME AND NOT COUNTING....
CARER OF 10+ and definately not counting rest ON HARBOUTR NEAR OUR BOAT.
Interesting commentary about the woman.  How can anyone live in such a house???  I've been helping, since last summer, with a 63 cat rescue from a hoarder/foreclosed house in Cincinnati, where the cats were abandoned to die.  The previous owner(s) were already gone, so we don't know their details - except that these poor cats were very ill, without any previous medical care, and were starving to death.  We pulled together a wonderful grassroots effort to rescue/vet/foster/adopt out all these cats - at this point, we've got about 15 of them that we're still needing to find homes for.
We have 7 cats at home. That's a rather large number, but it's a big house and they all live good lives and have all been spayed and neutered. I recognize that 7 may be too many, but why not? They were all rescue cats and they have been treated far better at our home than out on the street. We love them all and would never want to part with a one of them. Sometimes I think that 7 is too many, but then I look at them one by one, and I can't for the life of me pick one that I would be willing to part with. We both love all of our cats with all of our hearts and they ARE family members. I am an avowed animal lover (not just cats) and the older I get, the more I love animals. I have seen far too many abandoned family pets. I don't understand how any human being with feelings could do that.
We have 7 cats at home. That may seem to be a large number, but it's a large house and they all have good lives and they've all been spayed and neutered. These were all rescue cats and they live much better than they would have on the streets. I love all animals, not just cats, and the older I get the more I love animals. Sometimes I think 7 is too many but then I look at them and I can't for the life of me think of parting with any one of them. We love them all and they are ALL family members. It's unbelievable to me that so many people abandon family pets. Any human being who could do that is beyond my understanding. These animals are precious gifts from God, and I think they deserve better treatment and care than they get many times.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Syndicate This Site

Add allDAY to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google