Roker: Not In My House

Posted: Wednesday, April 11, 2007 11:25 AM by Jaclyn Levin

(From Al Roker)

I don't think I've ever had more response to an online journal than yesterday.

As you may know I called for the firing/resignation of WFAN/MSNBC morning host Don Imus. This after he and his morning "Crew" referred to the Rutgers Women’s basketball team as, among other things, "nappy-headed hos." Ugly racism and sexism at its worst.

Based on the passionate responses we got from people on both sides of the issue, it seems we still, after all this time, have a long way to go in our country when it comes to race.

And, by the way, it's not like I hold a deciding vote at CBS, Inc., Mr. Imus' actual employer, or at NBC Universal, the company that owns MSNBC, and my place of employment, NBC News, as to whether Imus and company stay or go.

I was expressing an opinion, not as a member of NBC News, but as an individual online.

My freedom of speech was questioned. Some of the complaints that came in fell in that same category; I was denying Don Imus his freedom of speech. Far from it. Don Imus has the right to say whatever he wants, however hateful, stupid or uncaring. He DOES NOT have the right to say it on public airwaves or on the cable broadcast of a publicly owned company. That is a privilege, just as you do not have the right to have a license to drive a car. It is a privilege. Privileges can be revoked if certain criteria are not met.

Another point some of my critics raised was that I was holding Don Imus to a different standard than the rappers and African American comedians who traffic in the same kind of language.

Guess what? I think their speech is hateful, too. I don't condone it. Don't allow it in my home. Don't use the words. Don't go to those concerts. Those companies that profit in the demeaning of women via musical lyrics, whether rap or rock, should be put on notice, as should the radio stations that play the music. Others who have used hateful language have recently been fired from prominent radio jobs. They have been held accountable. African-Americans who believe certain elements of rap music, music videos and popular entertainment need to be more respectful toward our own should speak out and repudiate that element. I know I have, and many others have as well.

A slippery slope, to be sure, deciding what should be heard or not heard. But the difference again is, where it is heard and who is saying it and what is their intent.

A team of young women, striving to excel academically and athletically surely does not deserve to have all that they worked for, all that they sacrificed for stripped away in the name of a "comedy show," in the words of Don Imus.

Mr. Imus misspoke when he told Matt that if all we could come up with was a few instances of racial intolerance in the span of a 30-year program, it was, in essence, not that big a deal.

Not so fast, Don. On a regular basis, African-Americans, no matter who they are, were generally portrayed in a "pimp" or "Aunt Jemima" voice. People of color were routinely denigrated. There was an atmosphere of intolerance going under the guise of comedy. Imus would have you believe this is an isolated incident. It is not. Maybe not to the extreme such as was the case last week, but It exists, thanks to Don Imus, Sid Rosenberg and Bernard McGuirk.

People have written in asking why haven't I spoken out against others who have made similar transgressions. The answer is simple; one that I'm not particularly proud of: It wasn't in my "house" and it wasn't so profoundly blatant.

Don Imus broadcasts under the NBC News banner via MSNBC. This is a reflection of my company. I won't stand for the idea that someone who has the privilege of working under the aegis of NBC News could damage this organization with the taint of racism and sexism.

And a word about this organization. There has been a lot of soul searching going on, both publicly and privately. And it is the strength and character off the management of NBC News that gives me a source of pride. Our president, Steve Capus, has been about as transparent in his dealings with this as anyone could be. It visibly pains him, as it does all of us here, both people of color and white, that we are going through this. His support, and the support of Jeff Zucker has meant a lot to the people of this company.

It has been a good process and a necessary one. One that we hope we can help foster both inside and outside of NBC News. This can make us all better people and treat each other with more respect.

No doubt there's going to be more about this in the days and weeks to come. Advertisers are bailing out of the Imus broadcast and the marketplace. In the end, this may decide his fate.

In the meantime, I hope that the debate over this can be civil and meaningful, not one of name-calling and anger.

EMAIL THIS

Comments

It's funny, Chris Rock and Dave Chappelle can degrade the african-american community by saying the N word every other sentence but it's a huge deal now that Imus says it. Rap music has basicly given the term "ho" to describe african-american women. African-americans can't have it both ways. It's deplorable no matter what color the person is. If african-americans would have stood up when Chris Rock made the joke, "There are no african americans. There are blacks and then there are n*****s!" Ya, didn't hear too much from the african-american community on that.

Mike Jones Wabash, Washington (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:15 PM)

Have we become a society that does cruelty to our youth or anyone knowing it is wrong but basing its justification on the fact that we saw someone who looked like him or her or worshipped like them doing it also? No matter who is doing it; it’s wrong and we need to stop using sorry excuses like the ones in some of the comments posted yesterday where other people believe its okay for them to target minorities because they saw it in a rap video. In either situation decent & intelligent individuals like my self and all women, both black and white on that team suffer from a society that already criticizes and belittles us for everything from social class to physical appearance. If you’d all use a little common sense and stop being so hateful you’d realize that there are several minority groups that fight against the use of the “N” word and all other violent & derogatory remarks in “gansta” rap, on urban radio stations and schools. For example, “Star” a jock of a NY urban radio show that we finally got booted off the air due to his racist remarks against woman and his own minority group. The difference is that intelligent blacks can ignore “gansta” rap, and teach their children to not use the “N” word etc. but other people seem to never change and find it easier to use the word and stereotypes against people like us in the work place when we don’t even exibit any likings to that crap anyway. So I know how people like Al Roker feel, therefore, it is NOT ok and IMUS should be FIRED!! and this whole Target on blacks is really old and tired, find a new agenda – Pres. Bush needs to bring our troops home..

Sina P, Orange, NJ (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:26 PM)

Wellll Al, let salso silence Al Sharpton, Jesee Jackson and any other so called black leader who spews their flaming of hate towards white people. Yes, that si what they do. They go around holidng up corporations for so-called offences against white folk, and they get their cut of the funds. Tell the truth Al. Tell the truth about them. It's not only just white folks who are "racist". Thats what makes me sick about all this. Man, lets all get a dose of being real here.

M Carlen (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:26 PM)

I watch Imus almost every day. I don't like the profanity, the racial references, or the promotion of unethical behavior in reference to Sid Rosenburg's appearances. I do appreciate Don's being a champion of what appear to be injustices (e.g.- battling autism). It's also the only place on TV to hear honesty come out of a politician's mouth. His comment of last week, however, was inexcusable and recent "public figure" history would suggest that he should be fired, but what good would that do? Others have been fired and then the issue is again swept under the rug. Judging by the reaction to this incident, this appears to be an opportunity, rather than a problem, to put the black/white issue on the table and initiate a dialogue. If Imus isn't around to provide that platform, who's going to do it? He gets peoples' attention, be it good or bad, and if you can't get the public's attention, you're just spinning your wheels. You've got to bring the debate to where the people are - the kitchen, the bus stop, the office, the social events. He can do that better than anyone I know. Let's see if his repentance is real. This could be the opportunity of our lifetimes

Bob Sandberg, Frewsburg, NY (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:26 PM)

A couple of points, Sir. First, your reference to Cartoon Network issue is grossly incorrect. There is a far cry from an act that people see as someone trying to bomb them and someone saying a racist and sexist remark. These remarks have not shut down any streets or buildings. They also have not had any emergency crews deployed to try and resolve a public panic for their lives. I think you owe your audience an apology for going a bit far with that analogy. Second, I hear you talking about how bad the rappers are, but your most famous people are comedians. Chris Rock, Dave Chappell, etc spew their racial slurs and insults around on the airwaves. What would you do with them? Finally. Calling for Mr Imus's termination puts you in with a group of ministers that do not follow the preaching they claim with the named Reverend in front of their names. They do not forgive. Not calling for it does not necessarily make you a Imus lover either. Why not follow the path of the Rutgers's women's basketball team and work to understand why he said it and then work with the community to make this world a better place. Doing anything else has made you into the same kind of person you're now trying to condemn.

Brian W, OKC, OK (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:27 PM)

His behavior is outrageous and a call-out to any politicians that continue to appear on his show. I hope the up-side is also a call-out to everyone who uses that kind of language. I'll miss Chris Matthews, but I don't think I'll be able to watch MSNBC if Imus is not fired.

mko. Oak Park, IL (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:27 PM)

Mr. Roker, I must say that I wholeheartedly agree with you 100%. As a person whose family background spans to Colombia, Scotland, Germany, and Ireland, it hurts me when I see people make fun of others at their expense, especially when racial slurs are involved. If all of the people in the world could only get along, the world would be a much better place. Tolerance is a key factor in this. For those who love to watch movies, a great example of racial tolerance is the 1965 film starring Sidney Portier titled "A Patch of Blue", which co-starred Elizabeth Hartman as a young blind white girl who fell in love with a young African American man. No one could understand the true love that binded them together. If everyone in the world were blind and we couldn't see the true color of everyone, would people still act this way? I am not sure, but tolerance is the key to success in a situation like this. I agree that Don Imus should be given the boot from CBS and MSNBC. I am a major supporter of the NBC Television Network, and I for one cannot stand the fact that a person of his stature would say the things he said on the national airwaves and not have to take any punishment other than a two week suspension. It is udderly ridiculous. So I say this to the presidents of NBC and CBS.... Take Don Imus off the air NOW!!!

Joshua Hammitt, Cedar Rapids, Iowa (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:31 PM)

What is absolutely hilarious to me is how people will jump on the bandwagon as they circle their kill. That isn't to say I agree with the comments that Mr Imus said. Far from it. But the level of hypocracy is incredible. Two quick comments -- 1. If Howard Stern said this (on free or Satellite radio), no one would say anything. He gets a free pass because of his "shock jock" status. The only difference between the two is that Imus talks politics and makes it part of his show, but the end goal for both is the same - entertainment. 2. Where were all these people when Mel Gibson was spewing his feelings to a police officer? Was Mr Roker, Reverand Al and others calling for Mr Gibson to never get work again? ha... hardly. Not to mention, Gibson used alcohol as his excuse (most normal people people know full well its also a truth serem). Let me get this right - its only ok to comment if its your race involved? The guy made a joke. It was wrong. Dead wrong. Very inappropriate. He isn't running; he isn't hiding. He admits it, and has even gone as far as saying he will revamp his show accordingly. Does anyone have any idea what Imus does when he isn't on the air? Do you have any idea what he does for charities? He screwed up. Give him a chance and see how he deals with this. Ya know...Al is right, we do have a lot to learn

Steve D, Los Angeles (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:32 PM)

Mr Roker, Do you honestly believe Mr. Imus is a racist? I don't see any hard evidence of that being true. This is a man who made a mistake and has apologized. What is happening right now with this whole situation is OVERKILL. Black and White people both are equally as guilty in making inflammatory racial remarks. What was your reaction to Jesse Jackson saying "Hymie town?" Did you publicly write or say that Jesse Jackson should remove himself from the Presidential race? I just think there is sometimes a clear double standard on who does and doesn't pay the price for racial insensitivity.

Steven Schwalbach, Menonomee Falls, WI (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:33 PM)

I am in total agreement with Mr. Roker. Everyone has the right to express their opinion but to use communication airwaves to express racist and sexist remarks is inexcusable. I am truly amazed how some people can justify the comments that were made by Mr. Imus. The man was basically given two weeks vacation and slap he should have been fired.

Janeen L., Cleveland OH (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:33 PM)

Please, Al Roker you are nothing more than a hypocrite. You say you dont agree with what rappers, athletes..etc. say and do, however you have not one time publicly called for them to be fired until a white man says something you think is racially motivated. No matter how wrong what he might said might have been, it is his right to say that and it is your right to not listen to him. At what point are you and the rest of these left wing, America hating, liberals going to realize that you are trying to make this great country a place of intolerance, and not tolerance. You brought, of all people, Whoopi Goldberg, on to your show to comment on this? WTF? Where are you uppity opinions about her and her constant bashing of the president. I forgot, he is "The Man" and he is trying to keep you down. So it is OK to say whatever you want about him on public airwaves. Give me a break, I will now and forever after this, lump you in the same category as Jessie Jackson, and Al Sharpton. I am sure that is something you will be proud of, but to the average human being we know how disgraceful that comparison really is.

tj, seneca sc (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:33 PM)

If Imus were black, this discussion would not be in the news. In response to writer above, on the comparison of 'rap artists and Imus'-- my response to that is, Kristie, have you ever listened to the lyrics of many rap songs? How can an album filled with lyrics that do nothing but express hate, degradation, and violence towards women, be acceptable to us, to the point that many of these so-called artists are rewarded with trophies--yet a white man says one lousy sentence that really didn't say much, and all the world is stepping him into the grave. Where's the logic in this? How is everyone so stinkin morally jumbled up that they can't see that they are accepting of bigotry on one end, but not on the other? I just don't get it. I worked with a man who did nothing but listen to this crap rap, even after I requested for him to stop. It was offensive music to me and all the other women I worked with, but he looked at me and turned it up louder. The thing is, people get subjected to this kind of stuff every day, even if you don't ask for it, even if it's not warrented, and even if you stand up for yourself. It's our job to just learn to toughen ourselves and ignore people who say nasty things. "Turn the other cheek". Otherwise, we will spend our valuable waking hours on constant fighting and nagging, and in the end, really getting nowhere, while all the while, our own lives are passing us by. Why do we give so much attention to a case like this? It's completely ridiculous!

Christina, Chicago, IL (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:33 PM)

This issue illustrates the schizophrenic morality of political correctness. Al, you should be ashamed, climbing on the nanny-state protectionist bandwagon like this. Events like this one make one wonder just how long we have before speech will be regulated. Imus is a racist and misogynist because he is white, but rap music isn’t because...because...because? Grow up people and stop making the obligatory hail marys to the new religion of state. Speech is life. Deal with it.

JHL, Reno NV (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:33 PM)

I have listened to Don in years as I thought that his routine had become stale and boring. Now that it seems like things are being stirred up I think that I will start listening again.

Andrew Smith (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:34 PM)

If you expect any credibility for your stance do you really believe that Woopie Goldberg is the best representative? After her outrageous comments about President Bush at the DNC convention she has no credibility on any subject. I used to Love her work right up until that time I don't watch any of her work and in fact turned off the Today show because she was there. When is she going to apologise? Shouldn't she suffer the same fate as Imus?

D. Chase (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:34 PM)

I believe the (Rev.) Sharpton is nothing more than a publicity seeker, only interested in his self-rightous promotion. Don Imus' comments do not necessarily make him a bigot. I have heard worse comments from black community toward themselves. Like it or not, Imus has a First Amendment right to say what he wants. Remember he is just providing the public with comments that are said and heard by ordinary people everyday. Sharpton should have thick skin by now, he should know not to be so dramatic about what people say. Sharpton should face Imus on his show just as Imus did on Sharpton's show.

Juan Davila, Harker Heights, Tx (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:34 PM)

I agree with everything that Al Roker stated. However, and this is a big however, it seems quite ingenuine to me that folks like Al are only now discovering how this unacceptable behaviour is taking place on the air waves. Where has Steve Capus and the others CEOs of our broadcasting organizations been? Only now, this has become unacceptable?? If any people in the broadcasting orgnizations is serious about this kind of behaviour, then they should be going after everybody -- including Imus -- let him be an example; but only an example of things to come -- not a sacrificial lamb. Just as Imus' apology won't be accepted as too little too late; the firing of only one Don Imus continues to be too little too late -- and could be reduced to only an opportunity for corporations and black civil rights leaders to speak one time with bravura and then let the beast continue to roam on the broadcast airs. Why aren't we all banding together to get something permanently done -- what about these cable video stations -- why have we (broadcast managers/ceos) become so tolerant of this? Surely, it can't be for money!! We need to identifiy additional individuals and organizations that not only put up but support this unacceptable behavior. Rudy Fiorillo, Md.

Rudy Fiorillo (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:35 PM)

For those American citizens that think what Imus said was not so bad. I guess it has to hit your family, or better yet refer to the WHITE race before it's considered wrong and something must be done!

Dawn, Dayton, OH (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:35 PM)

The type of comments Imus made and the context within which he made them are intolerable, made by ANYONE - no matter who they are. Why are we even talking about Sharpton, Jackson, et al? This has nothing to do with them. A paid employee used his professional resources to espouse a hateful, denigrating view of a particular group of people. I don't care what he says in the privacy of his home or anyplace where he is not being PAID to air his vile opinions. Viewing this issue as one of innapropriate workplace behavior may make the gravity of his offense a bit clearer. It might be useful to remember that Congress impeached President Clinton for abusing his position. How many of you objected to that? Al is right and frankly, very brave to risk his position as a beloved television personality to publicly decry Imus' transgression.

Sharon Miller, Austin TX (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:35 PM)

Bye Bye Freedom, sad to see you go. I guess we'll just whine our freedoms away. I hope I didn't offend anyone.

Fred Baroni (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:35 PM)

Because I car pool, I am forced to listen to "Black American Radio" for 45 minutes 3 times a week. You want to hear racist? I have heard caucasians referred to as "hitlers, white supremists whose sole purpose in life is to keep "black folk" down. It turns my stomach. I have never been racist or sexist or any kind of "ist" but listening to Black America Radio has made me realize that black America is totally racist and the targets are "everyone else". Why the big fuss or Imus? I don't hear Latins and Whites foaming at the mouth over Black America Radio. I believe that idiots like Imus need to be ignored and left to self ignite instead of giving them all this press. And everytime people start screaming "racist" at jerks like Imus, it makes the people who are truly not racist get even more fed up with the garbarge that is in the press in this country and realize that the "press" is about sensationalism not news. We need to focus on things that are truly important and truly of value. Shame on all of you.

Judi Richards, Miami, Florida (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:35 PM)

When I found that Imus had the ranch for children I started to listen to his show. I made it maybe 3 days before he so thoroughly disgusted me that I turned him off. His speech is so hateful toward everyone that I wondered what was wrong with him. I have a good sense of humon and miss ethnic humor when it's done right. Imus isn't humorous -- he's crass and mean spirited. Any white person who thinks his comments weren't prejudiced had better look in the mirror so they better understand it when they see it. We can walk on the moon but we can still put up with calling people hateful racist names in the guise of being funny. Maybe we aren't ready to even come out of the trees yet.

Jane Walbridge, New Haven, CT (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:36 PM)

Hypocrites, I've never seen more hypocrites in my life. Imus should be suspended, Sharpton should be banned. Imus raises hundreds of millions of dollars for sick kids, and soldiers. Sharpton once again blindly jumps on any bandwagon he can find. Let the girls from Rutgers help Imus decide what to do. They are the only ones who have made any sense whatsoever

Steve Blandi, Hamilton Square, NJ (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:36 PM)

I dislike Don Imus....I think his show stinks and carries no value. Racist or not, he just needs to be taken off the air. As one other blogger posted...we have bigger issues in this world to concern ourselves about....globalwarming, war in Iraq....just to name two. Lets send Imus to the frontline in Iraq.

Amar, Irvine, CA (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:36 PM)

Words are without doubt powerful: they have the power to start wars, kill or heal. Instead getting upset about this guy, let's practice some discernment about what we listen to instead of forcing people to conform to whatever our version of what's politically correct today. Proverbs 12:18 Reckless words pierce like a sword, but the tongue of the wise brings healing.

Juergen Bach, Billings, MT (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:37 PM)

Al, I have been a fan of yours for several years, and now I see why. I have always found you to present yourself as a caring, loving man and it was so evident in your comments. Imus' disgusting words didn't have anything to do with you personally but you spoke out, good for you. I am not African-American but I am a woman and I found his comments not only embarrassing but deplorable; thank you for expressing yourself publicly for those of us who don't have the avenue to do so. Whether Imus apologizes or not to the Rutgers team, he offended many, many people and I too believe he should suffer the consequences of his actions, he should be fired. Thank you again.

A. Atkins, Orlando, FL (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:37 PM)

Al, I have always loved watching you do the weather and other segments on the Today Show. You have never been "black" to me - just a jolly man with a great smile and personality. PLEASE - don't get sucked in with radicals like Sharpton and Jackson!! They are all about stirring up trouble between races. Imus said a bad thing - he apologized...since when do we not forgive a person??? And really - are we going to believe that these girls are "damaged" because of this? COME ON!! I wish I could sue people for all of my "damage" too. Doesn't work that way - get a tougher skin ladies. Was it a slow news day? Why not cover all the liars in Washington or the many men and women dying for nothing for the "war on terror"...pick a better cause Al - don't make this such a big thing in your life. You were too sad this morning - and not for good reason.

Dawn Marie, Rockford, MN (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:37 PM)

Interesting, I don't remember much outcry from you regarding remarks from Jesse Jackson on "hymie town" or isn't NYC your "house" and wasn't it broadcast on NBC? Look to your actions, Mr. Roker before you go calling for the loss of livelihood for others for their admittedly despicable remarks. I think this incident has uncovered as much hypocrisy as it has racism. And remember this... someday you TOO will make a mistake... perhaps even more egregious,

JEM, Santa Fe, NM (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:37 PM)

If "nappy-headed hos" is "Ugly racism and sexism at its worst" and soooooo offensive, how come you keep repeating it?? The journalist that keep it going should also be fired!

MRoan, Bellefonte, PA (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:37 PM)

This whole business regarding Imus has been blown way out of proportion, not just by you Al, but by every media source on TV, radio, as well as internet blogs. I agree that Imus made some pretty distastful comments about the Rutgers Girls Basketball team, and these comments are intolerable. He is wrong and should be reprimanded. I do, however, question the motives of Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson or anyone else for that matter, that feel that Imus should not be given an opportunity to discuss this situation with the Rutgers team. As political leaders, Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson like many others have questioned President Bush's policy of not talking to countries like Iran and Syria, but Imus should not talk to a basketball team? I say hypocrocy! After the initial outcry of anger, these two leaders should focus not on the Imus comments, but how this very public controversy might begin a real dialogue about race in America. For example, where is the outrage over the administration's underfunding of student loan programs that hurt minority students? Where is the outrage over the volunteer millitary that targets young minroty men and women? Why is Jesse Jacson not picketing in front of greedy, money hungry, record companies that continue to exploit young black rappers with lyrics that belittle Black women for the sake of selling records? You know why Al, that kind of grassroots work that doesn't grab headlines, is usually not noticed and rarely gets thanks, might get the job done! Then where would Al & Jesse be?

E Martin, Utica, New York (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:38 PM)

I am african American and I must admit I have watch Imus in the morning. When you are on a federally funded air ways you have a responsiblity to not offend classes of poeple or genders. Imus did not know these people as critics dont know who Imus is. Imus have done some great work with kids of all races with cancer. I personlly think he had wore his welcome out in this format and need to resign. He will not change, he is too old, he needs to transfer his brand of humor to sirus radio and do what he do, offend people under the protection of humor.

DL Butler (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:38 PM)

Imus should be fired. And everyone else everywhere in entertainment should be held to the same standard. The whole gangsta' thing is a diservice to American blacks, and as long as it is prevalent you cannot expect white entertainers to abstain from mining it for material.

Rick Allan (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:38 PM)

It comes down to respect! Respect of self and others...no matter the color, gender, or religion. The Rutgers women have, obviously, been taught how to treat each other with respect. Kudo's to them!!!Thanks, Al, for standing up for what is right!

Mary, Michigan (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:38 PM)

You make some very interesting points, Al. First, I'm glad to see that you're not the one making the decision whether Mr. Imus should be fired or not. You, like he, are paid to entertain people. Be it television, radio or at the movies, the American public, not the press should dictate where the preverbal lines should be drawn. Although I think Mr. Imus didn’t use his best judgment when he made those statements, I have heard much worse come out of business leaders, politicians, and yes, entertainer’s months in the past few years. If you and the rest of the public figures that are calling on Mr. Imus’s resignation or firing succeed in this witch hunt, I hope you continue to be this countries “moral compass”. Every time a person crosses “the line” I hope you jump onto the bandwagon and demand his/her first amendment rights be silenced. Be it hip-hop music, video games, or just your standard radio or TV programming. You and your supporters must have a better understanding of what the American public will tolerate than they do. The bottom line is this, Al. Companies like CBS and MSNBC are in business to make money. They employee people to entertain the American public. If the public doesn’t like a particular person or show, they don’t listen or watch. If nobody is listening or watching, the company gets rid of the bad entertainers. It’s not rocket science. All of these public bashings and witch hunt like tactics are bad for everybody, including you. I’m glad you have an opinion, but it’s just that, your opinion. Go back to doing the weather and let the American public decide the fate of Mr. Imus.

Dave, Danbury, CT (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:39 PM)

Al: I agree with your comments regarding the Imus issue, I think he was wrong in what he said and how he said it. Being a shock radio show host however, quality control can never be far from the mica phone. Imus big mistake was not going directly to the University and the women basketball team to apologize immediately and ask forgiveness. He thought that he was above having to respond immediately. He forgot when dealing with children, kids and young people who are doing the right thing, this country appreciates that fact. He should never gotten involved with the Rev. Jessie Jackson and Al Sharpton who at the time they were talking to the press, had not spoken to the young ladies on the basketball team. Maybe something good can come from the last few days events, I don’t have much hope, racism is alive and well in America.

Joseph Cooper, Maryland (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:39 PM)

Roker, as usual, reveals himself to be a lightweight when it comes to serious subjects. Freedom of speech trumps everything else. Period. Disturbing speech is the price we pay for that freedom. Suck it up, Roker.

Billy, Planet Earth (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:39 PM)

Wrong place, wrong time equals scapegoat. Was it wrong, was it hurtful? Yes and yes. Did he have the “privilege” to say it? Yes, unlike you, I believe he did. He certainly didn’t violate any FCC rule or regulation. It’s America, vote by not listening. Blast the advertisers with calls, letters and emails but fire a man for the ‘words’ that came out of his mouth when that is what he is paid to do, speak his mind? I think not. I ask you Al, how many others have gone before Imus saying things equally wrong and hurtful without getting fired? Wasted time on one man - Back in the pre-email days I remember being taught that if a negative letter was hand written and mailed to a company (TV. network, sponsor…etc.), that company should take heed because if one person wrote it, another 100 thought it. Here’s the challenge, racism exists in this country. WHAT ARE WE GOING TO DO ABOUT IT? There’s a topic for the Today Show. Imus could retire and become a hermit off in some distant cabin…big deal. Imus isn’t even the tip-of-the-iceberg, he’s just a grain of sand on the beach. Side Note: I’m listening to your two black celebrities and boring white doctor discussing (hardly discussing, more like ranting) this Imus thing and I’m just growing ever so tired. Is that the best the Today Show can come up with to rant about this? - It may just be time to go back to CBS.

MH, AZ (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:39 PM)

Al: You and the Today show have certainly touched a soft spot with me and with the public in general. In my opinion, the problem represented by the Imus incident goes beyond race. We have increasingly found that "comedy" needs to demean someone. If I can demean you and make people laugh, aren't I so much better than you? As a public, we have supported this attitude in our standup comics and our television shows. Through it, I fear we are teaching our children the opposite of respect. Within our crowded society, our most important responsiblty is to respect (which does not necessarly mean to like) our fellow man or woman, wheither black, white, yellow, gay or straght, Muslum, Jewish, or Christian. Only when we stop hating by category will we be able to view peace in the world. Yes, legally Imus has the right to say what he wants. The tragedy is not that he says it. It is that we the public accept hate filled speech by all races and creeds and, even worse, economically reward it .

Bill Butler, Broomfield, Co (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:39 PM)

It is interesting that so many folks who do not get upset with tirades, insults and lies from minority leaders or spokesmen (regardless of group--blacks,muslims etc.) become more emotional about words from Imus than murder by OJ or race hate speech from Farrakan. The double standard grows larger every day.

Jim, Naples , Forida (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:39 PM)

I'm sorry Mr. Roker, while I agree with most of what you say I believe there's a double standard when it comes to the use of this offensive language. Many African-Americans, men AND women, have stated that only THEY can use those words amongst themselves which is why that garbage is still persistent in our culture. Just take listen of what our youth listen on their I-Pods, for instance. If a Caucasian "isn't allowed to use our words"; then NO ONE should be allowed to use them, period! If this is considered universally offensive then the standards of speech should also be considered the same for ALL. Freedom of speech? Well, that should applied to ALL, as well. I know much has been decried over offensive rap lyrics, off-colored remarks by comedians, questionable movie scenes, etc., etc. ,but the outrage over Imus's 2 week suspension instead of a firing is just plain hypocracy by those looking for Imus's 'head on a platter'. They should worry about cleaning up 'their house' before the poison of 'ghetto-speak' becomes more and more part of our American lexicon.

Aldo R. (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:39 PM)

Wow, some interesting reading! I support your views, Al, and hope this will start a dialogue long, LONG overdue. I'm thankful and proud of many black Americans, and a few white ones, who have spoken up over this issue. However, I also agree with some of the other respondents that this dialogue should focus not only on the abomination of racism but also include how insidious sexism in general contributes to the problem. As a matter of fact, I think the tolerance of sexism is the far bigger issue, because that is what allows both the rappers and Imus to think nobody will care. Someone who wouldn't dream of using the n word in public will figure they can get away with nappy-headed or ho. See it for what it is--sexist beliefs allowing racism to go unpunished. How many young (or even older) woman and men in our society even realize how prevalent sexism is? It's almost transparent, and totally acceptable. American Idols are encouraged to wear short skirts to cover their musical inability (and God forbid they need to lose some weight!) while so many think the male Sanjaya is a mystery to be kept on (oh yeah it's the hair--watch out guys, sexism and the beauty culture are after you too!). Hugh Hefner is glorified in our society (don't get me started!), wearing clear stripper shoes is mainstream fashion this year. I could go on and on, but will spare you. Do the majority of people under 40 know that women's rights were added to the civil rights movement to try to defeat it, as a joke? There is room for the outrage against the hypocrisy of Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton, as well as rappers in this discussion we must have as a society about our culture. There is also plenty more room to point out what white, mainstream politicians, media and music do to degrade women. Where is the outrage against THAT? Don't focus only on black rappers! Go forward, and stay brave, my friend...this has the potential to bring light to some critical issues of our time.

The Radical One, Charlotte NC (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:40 PM)

Well said, Mr. Roker. This whole issue just brings to the light the racism that has been so hush hush since the last publicly acknowledged racial event. The reality is that children in America regardless of how prepped they are for a journey in an equal society QUICKLY realize equality is a fascade, as of now. I think Mr. Imus should go because anyone regardless of race, sex, or religion that would have used his exact words in a place of employment would have been terminated IMMEDIATELY. Coach Stringer was right...The color is "Green". Slavery was profitable, Jim Crow only ended because it was decided that it was not profitable and Guess What? People can insult, verbally abuse and attack innocent educated African American women because, ITS PROFITABLE. I just bought a young black male into this world and overall, im grim. How do i prep him for this America?

Nichelle Williams (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:40 PM)

Wow, in reading the posted comments three things stand out: 1- use spell check 2- Imus has been castigated in the past for racially insensitive remarks and promised never to do it (again). 3- Just because most "gangsta rap" is performed by people of color doesn't give license (to everyone) to use derrogitory language. I've heard the comment: Spike Lee used similar language in School Daze, if he can do that, Imus can. Answer to that comment is, watch Lee's movie again, you didn't understand the movie the first time. Think about this, The Rutger's ladies basketball team was playing for the national championship but because two very thoughtless and insensitive people decided to make racial and sexist comments on the air, these fine women will always have an asterisk by their name. What they have accomplised has been obscured by garbage! As for Imus going on satellite so he can contiue spewing racial and sexist jokes (along with Stern), I say fine! All garbage goes to the dump. (Not that satellite radio is a dump but with Stern there, well that doesn't say much about the neighborhood.)

Buzz Opick (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:41 PM)

How exactly has anyone been 'robbed' of anything by a few ignorant and inappropriate words? We have become a nation of belly-aching crybabies, who develop 'mental anguish' or 'trauma' over a joke by a DJ. Time to worry about war, poverty or disease, instead of inflating non-issues in the name of sensationalism.

Jim, Blackwood, NJ (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:41 PM)

Sorry Al, not buying. Personally I think Imus should have been off the air a long time ago. But if you're implying that the public would have been this outraged had it been a white girls team or a black DJ, I refuse to believe it. This double standard has now become ridiculous to the point that people are more focused on the race factor than the gender factor. What he said was demeaning to women in general, yet I don't hear anyone with a microphone commenting on that at all, nor do I believe they would have had the race of both the players and/or the DJ been different. If everyone wants to light a fire under this guy, at least be honest and admit why. Don't hide behind the supposition that everyone would have reacted the same way if the races were reversed, because it's simply not true. If a black comedian had lost his temper in a nightclub and called 3 unruly white audience members "crackers", I doubt there'd be talk of lawsuits and public apologies. Maybe everyone should focus more on the fact that he insulted all WOMEN and not just black women.

Laura (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:42 PM)

Al, for crying out loud, I don't think many people can argue that it was a serious mistake. However, in the context of things I must say that McQuirk was the baiter and Imus was just shooting words...words he didn't even think of, period. As for your stance, it's a shame that you come out now to whip an old white boy when your color has infiltrated and even STARTED the exact words that Imus mimicked. Hands down, the words originated from Black people. "Nappy head" has been around since at least the 30's...was sung by a Black fellow, yada, yada, yada. I believe that Don Imus is not a racist, shot off without thinking and is sincerely sorry for what he did. Now take your cause to your Black people immediately and make some REAL noise. Get all of those terrible words off of the air waves. BTW, get Sharpton the hell out of there. What a fire truck chaser he is. He's also responsible for inciting riots leading to death if you ask my opinion.

Harry Mottola, NH (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:42 PM)

Al, you must be kidding me. Is this your opinion or one you formed after you decided to get on the black self-pitty band-wagon. Get over it. Your committment to this issue makes Ab Lincoln look like a bad decision maker.

John Doe (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:42 PM)

Thank you, Al, for standing up to this dispicable act of racism displayed, ONCE AGAIN, by Don Imus. I am a white American woman who is a published children's book author. My three books all deal with tolerance towards each other, appreciating each others differences, and acceptance and respect of those differences. When we can do these things, then, and only then, can we begin to understand that we also have much in common. I get so tired of hearing people use the excuse that they have the right to freedom of speech. People also have the right to own guns, but does that give them the right to kill someone? We need to keep our Constitution in perspective, and understand that it was a guideline for our country, not a free pass to do as we wish - right or wrong - and come away unscathed if we misuse the privledges allowed us. Thank you for putting yourself out on a limb, Al, and voicing your opinion. I think they should fire Imus, and have you fill that empty seat. I'd listen to you, just as I watch you everyday on the Today Show. Keep up the great work. Janie DeVos, Plantation, Florida

Janie DeVos, Plantation, Florida (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:42 PM)

The media has certainly taken this to new extremes...First of all who would have even known about what Imus said (or for that matter the team that won the women's basketball championship)had the news not blown it up to this proportion. One can certainly tell it's a slow news week when the leading stories are Imus and Dannielynn. Then to bring on Whoopi and Spike Lee??? He says worse things in his movies...Then main point I'd like to make about this is that's the great thing about our country..if you don't like what is being said you don't have to tune in...just like you'll never catch me buying rap music or attending a Spike Lee movie. So folks...just turn off your tubes.

Jane Doe (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:42 PM)

Talk about self rightous hypocracy....where is all the outrage from all the usual self promoting suspects, such as Sharpton, Jackson, etc about pervasive self denigration spewed by Black artists, rapppers etc...just look at BET...it is far more disgusting, embarrasing, insulting, and a horrendous example/role model and it purports to be 'the' network for Blacks by Blacks...how about looking in the mirror.

roger, oregon (Sent Wednesday, April 11, 2007 12:42 PM)

<< Previous

Next >>

SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Your name, city and state (John Doe, Seattle, Wash.):

Your e-mail address (jdoe@msnbc.com):

Your website (it's okay if you don't have one):

Remember me? (We'll keep it private) Remember me?

More allDAY

Recent Posts:

Archives:

Syndicate This Site

Add allDAY to your news reader:

ABOUT allDAY